Geographers Diener and Hagen claim that Pacific Northwest tribes had a concept of property similar to modern Americans' - contrasting common claims that Native Americans had no concept of ownership. Where did the idea that Native Americans had no concept of property emerge?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

How were taxes assessed in empires of the ancient world?

I realize my question is very broad, and not very sexy, but I'm looking for general information about this process. I'd be interested in any given empire's method. I'm interested in the details of how things were run because I believe it can shed light on larger events. Information from anywhere in the world prior to the Industrial Revolution will do. Hopefully, that isn't too vague under the sub's rules.

Below is a full list of my questions. If you can shed light on some but not all, that's plenty. I realize not all of them may be answered today.

  1. How were taxes assessed on a large scale?
  2. How did governments find out how much product was produced, particularly in the case of small, distant villages?
  3. How were taxes transported, particularly when goods were taken instead of coin? Did tax collectors travel in large caravan trains with a heavy guard?
  4. How did people dodge taxes? What were the risks?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

In the Viking Age in Scandinavia, there seem to have been cases of girls being kidnapped for marriage or concubinage. Was this considered legal, and socially acceptable? What justification was given?

The poem Vikingen from Erik Gustaf Geijer is an example of where this practice is mentioned.

1 Answers 2018-01-09

How historically accurate is the idea that Afghanistan is the "graveyard of Empires" or "the place where Empires come to die"?

If not particularly true, why and where did these phrases come about?

2 Answers 2018-01-09

When people think of colonisation, they typically mean the Age of Colonisation. How different was Greek Colonisation, such as Massilia?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

What happened to Early Modern Jesuits of Japanese descent?

I've been doing some reading about 16th and 17th century Jesuits in pretty much two separate areas of study, Jesuit life and scholarship in Western Europe, and Jesuit missions in Asia. A couple of my sources in the former set of readings mention Jesuits who were themselves from Japan, and the latter sometimes mention Japanese Christians who became priests prior to the expulsion of Catholics from Japan. (Mario Scaduto's Catalogo dei Gesuiti d'ltalia, 1540-1565 lists Jesuits with their country of origin as Japan alongside Jesuits from other European nations, for instance.) I'd really like to know more about these guys. Were their career opportunities and geographical spread any different from Jesuits of European descent? Were there still opportunities for Japanese Christians to become Jesuits later than 1565, and when was the cutoff point where Japan's national policies or other factors made this no longer feasible? Basically, sources like Wikipedia can state with reasonable confidence from the historical record that the last (European) Jesuit in Japan "was either killed or reconverted by 1644" -- what about the last Japanese Jesuits abroad?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

Back in the 1900s human zoos were very popular in the West. Oddly it was Hitler who ended the popularity by banning them. What was Hitler's rationale?

Here's an article about human zoos. I'm not interested in being Nazi apologist--we know Nazis are bad. However Hitler's decision to ban colonial practice is strikingly odd. What was his rationale? What was the context?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

What were the reactions of early Jewish leaders to claims that Jesus had risen from the grave? Did they issue any refutations?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

In the film A Knight's Tale, an English squire passes himself off as a German knight. Would this have been plausible, nationality-wise?

Of course the concept of nationality has evolved over time, but it seems strange that no one questions the fact that someone obviously English has the very German name of Ulrich von Liechtenstein and claims to be from Gelderland. Granted, Hollywood tends to play fast and loose with not specifying what language characters are actually meant to be speaking in, but there's no indication of the main characters trying to pretend to be anything but English. Would it have been perfectly normal for someone from one country to have a completely foreign name, along the 14th-century jousting circuit?

Note: I don't mean any criticism of A Knight's Tale, which is of course the second-greatest sports movie ever made, after Major League.

1 Answers 2018-01-09

I'm reading some Sherlock Holmes, and he seems to use a lot of wires for communication. How did the average person send/receive/use wires to communicate?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

In the film Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World, teenage and possibly pre-teen boys are depicted as officers in training on the ship. Was this a realistic age for boys to join the Royal Navy in the 19th century?

We see a number of officers in training (that's what I assume they are anyway, but I would appreciate clarification on that too!) who seem to range in age from 10 to 18. Were boys really joining the Royal Navy at those young ages? How did one go about becoming an officer at that time?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

The JFK assassination is shrouded in conspiracy theories in the popular imagination. Do any of these have academic credibility? What is the historical consensus on the assassination?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

In HBOs "The Deuce" the characters are able to establish a essentially legalized brothel near Times Square with help from the mafia and the corrupt NYC cops. Did this work in real 1980s New York? What was the real-life Deuce like?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

You’re a 44 year old Mormon man, and a toy store owner/manager in a suburban town near Salt Lake City. the year is 1964, What are the odds you self identify as a republican? What are the odds you self identify as a democrat?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

Accurate fiction set in Ancient Greece/Rome/Egypt?

I love historical fiction, but primarily read Tudor works. I'm looking to branch out into other areas of history that I enjoy.

Can anyone here recommend good historical fiction on the above or just authors in general and I can check out their work myself? Thank you!

I did google, but it's like needle in a haystack, so many indie authors writing "historically", but forgetting the history haha

2 Answers 2018-01-09

How come, despite the lack of certainty of historical evidence from the Middle Ages, we know the exact year of the Norman Invasion of England in 1066?

Most historical evidence during the 400s to about the 1600s doesn't seem well documented nor reliable.

So why can we pinpoint the year of the Norman Invasion?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

Is modern "total war" really different from medieaval (or earlier) war?

I have read about the beginnings of modern "total war" in which civilians and civilian infrastructure are regarded as legitimate targets. There was Sherman's March to the Sea, British policy in the Boer Wars, unrestricted U-boat attacks, etc. all culminating in the Second World War.

The suggestion seems to be that, before this modern development, warfare was somehow more civilized. But this does not fit with what I know of medieval warfare, which appears to be full of massacres, bloody sieges and razing.

Is "total war" really a modern invention?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

In the early 1800s and prior, how "Indian" did Indians feel?

Did Bengalis, Tamils and Gujeratis see themselves as something different from European traders? Or, to a Gujerati, was a Bengali as foreign as the British or Portugese?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

What was the state of Christianity in England between the Anglo-Saxon migrations and the subsequent Christianization?

During the days of the Roman Empire, many Christians practiced in secret despite the threat of death for doing so, and that included Britain. When Constantine converted to Christianity and legalized it throughout the Roman Empire, many people in Britain converted to Christianity.

However, after Hengist and Horsa arrived and conquered, England was ruled by pagans in the various kingdoms established. A century-ish later, roughly in 600, a Kentish monarch (I forget which one off the top of my head) married a Christian princess and allowed her to bring over some missionaries to convert the people, and himself. That eventually led to more missionaries going throughout England to convert the various Anglo-Saxon kingdoms.

However, was there already a Christian presence within England by the time the missionaries arrived? If the Romans had changed the religion of the native Britons to Christianity prior to leaving, and Christians are historically good at hiding their Christianity, would it not stand to reason that there would have already been a Christian presence within England? The particular king that I referenced had married his Christian wife prior to converting as well, so evidently pagans don't seem to hate Christians as much as Christians hate pagans.

1 Answers 2018-01-09

Was China's influence on southeast Asia ever comparable to European influence in Africa and the Americas in the age of colonization?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

Bad middle ages art

If people (monks) spent all their time writing and drawing funny pictures in the margins, why are they not that great at drawing?

3 Answers 2018-01-09

How true is the account of St Thomas having come to India and him having convert sections of the local population to Christianity?

Many such communities of Christians exist in the state of Kerala and claim to be the descendants of those converts. Is their historical validity to these claims.

2 Answers 2018-01-09

How did the money transfer for the Louisiana Purchase happen in practice? Did Americans load a bunch of money in ships and send it to France?

2 Answers 2018-01-09

How much did led lease assist the Soviet Union during Barborossa

What materials were supplied and how much did they help the red army?

2 Answers 2018-01-09

How long did it take for distinct linguistic identities to develop in India like we see today?

How did linguistic identities like Tamils, Malayalis, Kannadigas, Bengalis, Gujaratis, Punjabis etc develop.Were these shaped by colonisation or did they exist before?

1 Answers 2018-01-09

⯇ 2895 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start