When reporting rule breaking posts or comments is it more helpful to be specific in the report?

Looking for a bit of clarification on the Rules Roundtable XXIV: What Can a Non-Flair Do to Help?

Sometimes they cross more than one line so it isn’t clear what to actually report them for, does this actually matter to the mods?

2 Answers 2022-12-07

How much credence should I put in the "Santa Claus = Siberian mushroom shaman" story I hear every year?

I'm friends with hippies and I hear it every year, this year is no exception. Mushroom growing shamans going house to house with their reindeer, dropping off psychedelic gifts for the happy Siberians.

As awesome as that sounds, I heard it from hippies so of course my woo detector is going boop boop.

2 Answers 2022-12-07

The persistence of Jim Crow was because the U.S. is a historically majority-white nation. How did a minority-white population in South Africa institute apartheid?

I ask this in good faith. Thanks.

2 Answers 2022-12-07

Why did Clovis 1 convert to Christianity?

I read on wikipedia that he converted because of a miracle that happened at battle of Tolbiac?

Is it true?

Also, how did the Alemanni lose if they were winning in the beginning?

1 Answers 2022-12-07

Is there credible evidence that Japan offered surrender to the Roosevelt Government?

No links, but I found a 1945 article by Walter Trohan stating that terms of surrender were offered through MacArthur in January 1945.

Is there veracity to this claim?

1 Answers 2022-12-07

Why did Alfred of Wessex not claim the title of Emperor of England?

My growing understanding of the title "King" was that it was originally an ethno-tribal appelation, given to the chief ruler of a folk-nation or People (i.e. King of the Lombards, King of the Franks, etc). I understand, in that way, Charlemagne who was King of the Franks in his own right made other kings his vassals and is therefore an Emperor. Why then did King Alfred of Wessex, who sought to unite the various Saxon kingdoms of England under his crown, not claim the title of an Emperor? Was it because he sought to unite the Kingdoms into one royal realm, under a single King?

1 Answers 2022-12-07

What is the "resolution" of the historical record when it comes to evidence, texts, etc as we go backwards through time?

The phrasing is odd, I know but it's the only way I can think to ask the question.

When looking at the modern era you have video, photos, and tweets the let you understand our time down to the level of what people ate at that moment in time.

As we travel further and further back through time, that evidence shrinks exponentially. It'd be difficult to have the same "resolution" regarding the state of affairs in let's say 867AD...after all, there are no photos, no videos, physical texts decay or are destroyed, etc.

At what point does the historical record become more inference and theory than "fact" per say?

As another example to illustrate my question, I thoroughly enjoy a game called Crusader Kings III and it features a map of Europe, North Africa, Scandinavia, the Mideast, and India. As you zoom in you can see who rules what counties, duchies, kingdoms, empires, etc. But the developers have stated that some of the counts and dukes are made up as they couldn't find anything to suggest who was ruling these areas or what their personalities were like. In my humble understanding of history as a whole I would have though that going back as "recently" as 867AD would have more evidence to know these sorts of things.

1 Answers 2022-12-07

I read that my family’s Hungarian surname, Balla, stems from Italy in the 1300s-1400s. How did this name or other surnames make its way from Italy, when I read that Hungarians come from the Urals and Iran?

I could very well be misunderstanding something or misplacing dates, but I understood the present Hungarian population to come from the Indo-European influence on Ugrian hunters from the Ural Mountains.

I read that the surname, Balla, comes from Italy, and is an occupational surname coming from merchants. A Balla surname website says that the Balla surname likely wasn’t around in Hungary until 1300s-1400s, and I can track the Balla name in my village (and family, with church/birth/marriage records to back it up) in far northeast Hungary to the early late 1600s-1700s. Additionally, the surname is prevalent in the Budapest area, not especially so at that time in Zemplen county, where the village is.

My question : if this is all true, the Balla name must have come into Hungary within 300-400 years of its earliest recorded presence in Northeast Hungary. If the population of Hungary was so influenced by Iran and the Ural areas centuries before this, how did an Italian surname come into an area closer to the Urals than most of Hungary?

I understand there was lots of history between this, like fighting the Pechenegs and such and this history is closer to the area, but I’m still confused.

What historical events would put Italians or Hungarian influenced Italians come into this area, creating the Balla name?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2022-12-06

Historians, what made you decide to focus on your specific area of history?

9 Answers 2022-12-06

What did the ancient Chinese know about Siberia and its inhabitants?

I am especially interested in the time between the Qin and Tang dynasties

1 Answers 2022-12-06

What happened to gay individuals under Antonio Salazar's regime in Portugal? Please I need answers.

I posted this question yesterday - I really need an answer

My grandfather served his mandatory military service plus a few extra years during the middle-ish of Salazar's regime. The family left the country a few years before the revolution. Yesterday I heard a family rumor that my grandfather participated in raids to find gay people. The people they found were shot immediately or sent to prison. I heard that my grandfather and the other soldiers would beat and assault the people they found for the fun of it. Only recently did my grandfather stop using the f-slur, the rumor does not seem too far fetched to me. I need to know if this is real. I'm gay and very much not out to my family, I don't know how to process this. I really need an answer - I've looked everywhere online and I can't find anything. Any information would be helpful.

1 Answers 2022-12-06

Why did Stalin win control against others such as Lenin and Trotsky?

1 Answers 2022-12-06

How difficult is it to get a Master's in Public History?

Sorry if this is the wrong subreddit for this, but I'm just wondering how difficult it is to complete a public history program. I'm currently working on a bachelor's in history, and I'm thinking about getting a master's in public history, but I'd like to get some insight as to how difficult it is, and what it involves. How did it compare to getting a bachelor's?

1 Answers 2022-12-06

In popular Russian cultural memory today Лихие 90-е (the hard 90s) is discussed as an almost apocalyptic era of decline. But did Russians of the time actually perceive it as such, especially compared to the crises of the late Soviet Union?

As terrible as life could be for some people in 1990s Russia, with the political upheaval, violence in some regions, the beginnings of the demographic crisis, etc... weren't the late 80s in the USSR much worse? Didn't the 90s improve quality of life for the vast majority of Russian people?

And, if it's a safe with regards to the 20-year rule: when did the 1990s start being characterized as a catastrophe?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2022-12-06

Before the age of mass consumerism and large amounts of spending money for average people (roughly the late 19th century) what where some "typical" Christmas gifts given ?

1 Answers 2022-12-06

Can someone identify these WW2 Cap Badges?

Hello hello all, this is my first time making a reddit post so please bear with me.

Ive come to you all here because Ive heard many a great thing about this community from some of my favourite history channels and figured you may be able to help.

My great grandfather served in WW2 fighting with the Maori battlion. He faught all over europe with them. However recently, my family has sort of "rediscovered" a box of possesions from him, in which was a belt covered in cap badges from WW2. At least I believe they are, as they were found with a whole load of photos Id never seen before from italy, dated 15-3-44. Captured German 88s, shot down aircraft, damaged buildings, an abbey of some kind etc etc.

Below I have included an imgur link (didnt know how else to share em, not sure what the norm here is lol) that shows the belt and cap badges in question.

We believe theyre mostly british from some quick reverse image searching, however Im not sure where theyre all from. Some may be british, south afrian, german etc etc.

Would anyone have a better idea of the history of each of these than me and the power of 5 minutes on the internet? Im not interested in what theyre worth, more interested in putting together his story for my mother who was recently diagnosed with breast cancer, as she didnt know much about her own grandad herself. So sheading some light on this would really be a cool thing Id like to do for her.

Imgur link below,

Many thanks

ELE

Edit: No idea how I tagged this with "dance" my bad team lmao

https://imgur.com/a/QzQHBkn

2 Answers 2022-12-06

What led America to being the most obese country in the world?

I'm wondering from a historical perspective what attributed to this. Like what decade rang in the era of bad dietary habits and why? Can it mainly be attributed to junk food marketing? Is it a cultural thing that caused it? Etc etc

Are there any books on this too?

1 Answers 2022-12-06

If guns were available in the Middle Ages, why doesn’t the collective imagination of “Middle Ages” include them? Same with samurais

If you Google “middle age drawing” or ask a person to describe them, few will mention guns. Most will picture knights, prince was and swords, but the collective imagination of Middle Ages doesn’t include guns.

Same with samurai’s. Ask someone to cosplay, describe or draw a samurai and very few would include a gun

1 Answers 2022-12-06

Before European arrival in South America, why didn't potatoes seem to travel far from Peru?

Here in Maryland the natives had the "three sister" crops - Corn, beans, and squash. From what I can tell, corn's original plant originated in what is now Mexico, beans from somewhere in Central or maybe South America, and squash was also from somewhere around the same region.

From what I can tell those crops spread out both north and south, being essential crops to a number of cultures in the Americas. Potatoes, in spite of similar usefulness, did not ever seem to travel very far from Peru, however.

From my understanding trade up from Central/South America existed, as the Chief of the Powhatan evidently had a South American parrot as a pet when the English arrived in Virginia. One would think that over the centuries such a durable and useful crop would have "grown some legs", even before the Inka empire began its expansion.

Potatoes definitely grow at least up here - I've done that myself, even.

My best guess is that maybe potatoes don't grow as well as other crops further south and thus there was a dearth of land that could support the cultivars available at the time (thus there's no "land bridge" for them to creep along). This is a stretch to me.

Is there any formal speculation as to why potatoes seem to be so region bound compared to other staple crops?

2 Answers 2022-12-06

I just realized I’ve never seen Maori, Polynesians, or Hawaiians depicted with bows and arrows, why is this the case?

They’re practically one of the few indigenous groups who I’ve never seen depicted or heard of using the bow and arrow. Is my assumption correct?

2 Answers 2022-12-06

[1980s-Early 1990s] Did the Eastern Bloc Satellite states of the Soviet Union exploit the policies of Glasnost and Perestroika, introduced by Mikhail Gorbachev, to vouch for their independence?

1 Answers 2022-12-06

“Water water everywhere, but not a drop to drink?” (The Rime of the Ancient Mariner) Did pre-industrial ships not have a still or some other system to desalinate ocean water on board? A distillery system would have been pretty compact and low tech, right?

1 Answers 2022-12-06

Did women in the past really faint from seeing mice? Did people get frightened into permanent institutionalization by seeing criminals? Why was everyone so sensitive?

I was listening to this here episode of the Histocrat on Spring Heeled Jack, and this made me realize that accounts and fiction of the time before, say, roughly the 1960s constantly portrays people as sensitive and psychologically fragile in the face of fear that would be considered very excessive today. At the extreme end, the stereotypical depiction is the woman fainting or screaming and climbing a chair at the sight of a mouse. This motif seems to have been very common in the 1950s. Was this really a common behaviour then? Or did media just pick out the few women who do act that way (there's got to be one or two in every town even today) and depicted those with preference?

But the psychological issue is more widespread when we look at accounts from even earlier times. If we are to believe novels and even newspaper articles from the 19th century, people, both men and women, get frightened into permanent institutionalization, "never regaining their wits", from seeing a spooky figure in a lane, wearing a cloak, carrying what is possibly a real live dagger twinkling in the moonlight.

Today, some people live in da hood where shootings are daily (e.g. Oakland, CA, or the Atlanta metropolitan area now - not to insult those places, but to give you an idea of what I mean). Sometimes, people witness mass shootings. Those people are surely shaken, but the psychological impact witnessing these horrible events rarely attains the heights that a shadowy figure in cloak and dagger could impress upon people's minds in 1850s London.

What's going on here? Were people really more sensitive? Why? Childhood trauma? Environmental toxins? Were they just not used to the sight of an actual violent criminal? As for the case Of Mice and Women, did they act that way because they felt it was good and proper and socially desirable to be a woman who goes through the effort of screeching and climbing onto a chair because that's cute? Or was this always just a big fat misdepiction in the media at the time?

edit: Now that I think about this more, it's possibly not only fright. Psychosomatic responses to negative emotions in general seem to have been a problem before roughly the interwar period to a degree that would make Freudianism seem plausible. For example, routinely, people come down with nonspecified "fevers" and remain bedridden for days after hearing shocking news about dark family secrets, maidens die of heartbreak when their beau is lost at sea, and so forth. Authors used to take things like this for granted. Were they the reality of people in that era? Just how is that possible that "snowflakes" were such a common phenomenon?

1 Answers 2022-12-06

George Washington is known for warning about the pernicious influence of political parties and polarization. But given how few democracies or republics there were in his day, what examples would Washington have been thinking of?

Not a lot to add - what would have been in Washington's mind as he warned about the influence of factions and political parties? There were very few democracies or republics in the world at the time, and even the UK hardly had strong party politics.

1 Answers 2022-12-06

Why is the Holodomor considered a genocide, but the Irish and Bengali famines are not?

4 Answers 2022-12-06

29 / 7255

Back to start