The Islamic scholar Abu Yusuf wrote that among other groups "the sick and the insane" were exempt from paying jizya tax. Is this true? If so, how were "sick" and "insane" defined?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

Why is right-bank Ukraine and left-bank Ukraine the opposite of what we expect?

Ukraine's main historical geographic areas can be simplified into two regions: right-bank and left-bank. These areas are on opposite sides of the Dnieper River, which runs in a north to south line pretty much directly down the middle of Ukraine. However when looking at Ukraine on a map, the regions of right-bank and left-bank are "opposite" of what we expect. The right-bank is on the west side of the Dnieper, and the left-bank is on the east. Why is this so?

[Map to help explain what I'm talking about.] (https://i.imgur.com/czrzgF8.png)

1 Answers 2018-01-05

Where does the myth originate from that WW2-era US tanks were not meant to fight other tanks, that fighting tanks was the job for tank destroyers?

This definitely was not the case but for some reason, this myth is extremely widespread, to the point that majority of people seem to think that is how it actually was. So where does this myth originate from?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

Friday Free-for-All | January 05, 2018

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

8 Answers 2018-01-05

The biblical Hagar is described as Egyptian and working for a Hebrew family. Are there any records from pre-Achaemenid Egypt of ethnic Egyptians living and working outside of Egypt for foreign peoples?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

2017 in Reading: Share Your Reading List from the Past Year, and Plans for the Next One!

Another year has come and gone, giving us plenty to reflect upon regarding the previous 12 months, not to mention the next 12 to come. As in past years, we like to close things out with a thread devoted specifically to reading, one of the favorite activities of many users here! Whether history or not, fiction or non-fiction, this thread is intended to chat about what you read over the past year, and also what you are hoping to tackle for 2018.

So, fellow Historians, what did you read last year!? What was the best!? What was the worst!? What are you putting on your shelf for the year to come!?

11 Answers 2018-01-05

How did samurai during the Sengoku Jidai sign official documents/treaties?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-01-05

English FA badge and Coat of arms of the Emperor of Bulgaria

FA badge Bulgarian coat of arms Can someone provide a little more info on wether the similarities are just a coincidence or there is more to it? I know lions are rather popular but the resemblance is unusually high. Both have around 3 centuries separating them. Cheers!

1 Answers 2018-01-05

Did america give planes to britain in 1940 by leaving them 1 mile from the Canadian border?

I recently watched the move "darkest hour" and one scene in the middle of the movie had me puzzled of if it was real or Hollywood fiction. in the scene winston churchill is making a desperate plea to rosevelt over the phone for American help as Britain faced what they thought was imminent invasion of germany in may 1940. in the movie rosevelt said he cant do much because of the neutrality acts nor can he deliver britain the planes they ordered with american capital. rosevelt as a stop-gap measure suggests leaving the planes 1 mile from the canadian border and then the canadians can use horses to drag them the rest of the way into canada so britain can get the much needed equipment.

in the movie churchill doesn't really show the audience a clear answer of if he took up Roosevelt on the offer. so i want to know if it in real life america secretly gave planes to Britain in may or june of 1940 by leaving them 1 mile from the Canadian border and having horses drag them across? Or maybe via a similar sneaky method?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

How can I find a certain persons coat of arms from the 1000s?

I’m trying to find Robert “the admiral” Le Blount’s coat of arms. He was a companion of King William the conqueror.

How would I go about finding his coat of arms?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

Why and when did it become "a thing" to blow the smoke from your gun barrel after shooting someone/something?

Also, why did it fade out of existence besides in old westers basically?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

How surprising was the atom bomb to the general public after it was dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Was this a completely alien weapon or did some know it was a possibility?

I've heard the Germans were looking into atomic weapons but how many in the general public knew about the possibility of atomic weapons or what they even were?

Also was Germany the only other country looking into atomic weapons or was it only the USA?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

It’s no secret that medieval/renaissance kings had many mistresses and consorts, but how did their wives- the queens-react? Did they know about it?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

We know that in the pre-Civil War US, white male plantation owners raped slave women. Are there any reports of white women raping male slaves?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-01-05

How accurate is the Broadway Play Hamilton?

I think this might be the best subreddit for this question. I've been listening to the Hamilton soundtrack lately and wondered how accurate it actually is to history?

2 Answers 2018-01-05

When did African slaves stop speaking there native langues

there have been Arabic texts found written by slaves

1 Answers 2018-01-05

What problems was fascism intended to solve?

Or to put it differently, what account did the fascists give of their policies? To clarify, I'm referring to the Italian political movement, not the Nazis; and their specific policies, the nuts-and-bolts of their administration, not their overarching goal of "make the nation strong". What problems did they identify in contemporary politics or economics, and how did they intend to fix them?

2 Answers 2018-01-05

Hitler survived WW2?

I recently saw documentary portraying that Hitler was somehow taken to Argentina, like many Nazis. Is there any dilemma to the way Hitler died?(suicide with Eva, then burned outside the bunker)

2 Answers 2018-01-05

What are the best first-hand sources/accounts for the life of Anne Boleyn and the reign of Henry VIII?

This question came up a few minutes ago as I noticed I have a lot of first hand sources for the history of other famous leaders - for example the complete works of Josephus , the works of Lucy Mack Smith, a book of first hand accounts from the American Revolution etc - but nothing on the history of Anne boleyn and .Henry VIII.

Boleyn is a fascinating figure for me but one who also feels a bit inaccessible. Whilst I have read some good books on her - most notably The Creation of Anne Boleyn - I have yet to find any first hand sources. The same goes for her husband Henry VIII.

What accounts and sources would you historians recommend?

2 Answers 2018-01-05

Hopeful Future Historian Internship Problems?

Hi there! I'm an undergrad studying history right now with the hopes of becoming a historian and/or professor. Does anyone have any suggestions as to what sort of internships I should look for that would build a resume for this kind of career? I'm sort of lost and need to start planning for the summer, so any advice would be extremely helpful. Thanks so much!

4 Answers 2018-01-05

Why Germans during WWII didn't use wood for airframes ?

Wood has a great weight/strength ratio (like CRP ), it's cheap, easy to work with, saves metals for something else, you can use furniture factories. British and Russians did it in Mosquito and La-5/7 production. Why Germans didn't do the same ?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

Atatürk reformed and secularized Turkey. He changed many things to differentiate the new Turkish republic from the fallen Ottoman empire. He, for example, changed the alphabet, abolished the Caliphate, etc. Why did he stick with the obviously non-secular Ottoman flag, then?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

How did the Manchus manage to enforce the queue on the large populations they conquered and ruled especially given the population growth during the Qing Dynasty itself?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

The Kansas-Nebraska act set up popular sovereignty in each new state, which led to the violent conflict Bleeding Kansas. Did any violence or conflict of the same type occur in Nebraska?

I know that Nebraska was further away from other states, making the trip from another state longer and more arduous, but did nothing happen in Nebraska while people were killing each other in Kansas?

1 Answers 2018-01-05

How accurate to the Roman Empire is Caesar’s Legion in Fallout: New Vegas?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-01-05

⯇ 2903 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start