Did the medical community learn anything significantly beneficial from the atrocious experiments performed on live prisoners during WWII?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-01-05

Why was slavery prevalent with black people rather than other races?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2018-01-05

Why do the clothes at the Smithsonian look so small?

This might seem like a silly question and it might be the wrong thread for it, but I recently visited the National Museum of American History and I kept getting this weird feeling that all the period garments on display, with the exception of George Washington's suit, looked smaller than they should. Is it just me? Were people smaller back in the day? Did the clothes shrink during the preservation process? Did the clothes on display just come from smaller people rather than larger people?

This also kinda goes for the museum of Natural History in the taxidermy and bone exhibits, but presumably that's because either the specimens are just smaller animals (size of animals varies a lot), or I'm used to large than lofe presentations of these animals in films and on TV.

2 Answers 2018-01-05

After the Christmas Truces of World War I, were soldiers on both sides hesitant to fight?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Was Ancient Troy based in a dim memory of a Luwian Confederation?

Zangger seems to believe so. How are taken his views in the current scholarship?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Did they bombard the beaches with battleships before the soldiers made it to shore on D-Day?

I was reading about the paratroopers flying into Normandy, and recounting all of the battleships and transports crossing the channel, and I began to wonder if they bombarded the beaches with the battleships before they landed the transports.

It seems like a waste of a lot of lives if they could have destroyed many of the defenses on the beaches before the soldiers landed on shore.

Anyone have any information on this?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Mestizos Living in Spain in the 1700s?

Hello! First, some background: I have been doing research for a historical fiction book set in the early 1700s, and though most of what I've been looking for has been available online or in books, information on this particular topic has not been easy to find. I know that, when Spain settled South America, many Spanish men had children with Native American women, and those children were commonly called mestizos.

My question is: did mestizos ever end up moving to/living in Spain? If so, how? Why would they want to move in the first place? How were they regarded within Spain's social structure as opposed to Latin America's? If you have any additional information or sources regarding this topic, I would love to see it.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Why is it a commonly held belief that Oswald didn’t act alone in the assassination of JFK?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Why did the US military stop using water cooled .50 machine guns before ww2?

I was reading about the history of the M2 Browning, Basically the military originally adopted the water cooled M1921 BMG. Think a M1917 scaled up to .50, wheras the air cooled M2 would be a M1919 scaled up. but until the introduction of the M60 the Army and Marines use the water cooled M1917 instead of switching over entirely to air cooled machine guns. So it doesn't seem like they had a problem using water cooled machine guns.

1 Answers 2018-01-04

[historical method] When you can't access a resource online/in person, what do you do?

I'm a high school student doing a research paper over 1811 German Coast Rebellion. For the past 2 hours or so I have been trying to find a version of John S. Kendall's “Shadow over the City” from Louisiana Historical Quarterly vol. 22 online. The one that I found online is under copyright protections (https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/pt?id=uva.x000988045), and the only other hopes of getting this article is to go to University of Virginia.

As historians, what do you do to get a resource that's seemingly inaccessible?

2 Answers 2018-01-04

Question about the holocaust

Hi there,

This is my first post here so if I do something wrong, please correct me.

I'm highly interested in anything about the second world war and anything that has to do with it. The last few week I've been reading/watching a lot about the holocaust and thought to myself there would be a subreddit about it. I searched r/holocaust only to discover that the place is filled with holocaust deniers/critics. There is absolutely no arguing with these people and it makes me pretty sad that such a terrible event is disgraced in that way. Now my question: how do you deal with these people and what do you think about holocaust deniers/critics?

I like a good discussion about certain historic happenings, but the Holocaust is a deeply tragic event that shouldnt be doubted.

P.S. English is my second language, as you might have guessed.

1 Answers 2018-01-04

In the play, The King and I, the King of Thailand offers to send President Lincoln war elephants to help in the Civil War. Was such an offer ever made?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Rex Anglorum

Why did the first kings of england to claim dominion of the island title themselves as rex anglorum instead of rex saxonum when they were west saxons?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Announcing the Best of December Winners

The votes are in!

This month we return again to the consensus 'One-Two' punch, with /u/dandan_noodles taking a well deserved top nod from both the flairs and the users for their answer to "What specific battle tactics did Napoleon employ for people to consider him a military mastermind?", and /u/400-rabbits nipping close on the heels with the respobse to "How did Herman Cortez unite many of the Mesoamerican tribes with him against the Aztecs?"

The non-flair taking the Dark Horse Award is /u/bodark43, who tackled "How were the tiny parts in mechanical watches machined and made with such precision at a small size in the era between the 1500s and the early 1800s?".

Finally, the "Excellence in Flairdom" award, which recognizes the contributions of a user in the past month that went beyond a single, standout answer, goes to /u/klesk_vs_xaero. Since October, Klesk has been walking us through Italy "100 years before this week" in Friday Free-for-All. Since "World War I" and "Italian history" are two areas people tend to think we know about but when confronted actually don't, this has been an absolute masterclass for a lot of us following along. Thanks for all the time and effort you've put in, Klesk!

So as always, a big congratulations to the winners, and a big thanks to everyone who contributed to the subreddit in the past month! Also a reminder, if you want to nominate answers for the monthly awards, the best way to do so is to submit your favorite posts every week to the Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check out this Wiki page!.

Additionally, stay tuned for the Best of 2017 vote coming to you shortly!

2 Answers 2018-01-04

Can anybody recommend two different books on the Arab-Israeli conflict that present each side of the argument?

I'm currently studying History and Politics. I'm trying to understand the Arab-Israeli conflict and form my own opinions. However, obviously, no source on it is impartial and it's such a detailed subject that's its hard to understand it well enough to form opinions.

Can anybody suggest two different history books on the Arab Israeli-Conflict? One from an Israeli/Right Wing/Zionist point of view, or that is written by somebody with Israeli sympathies, but is still a factual and reasonable book. And one from a Palestinian/Left Wing/Anti-Israel point of view, or that is written by somebody with Palestinian sympathies, but is still a factual and reasonable book. Obviously, I understand the issue is slightly more complicated that that, but you probably understand what I'm asking.

Thanks.

2 Answers 2018-01-04

How did Greeks see reincarnation and how does it compare to the Indian concept? What other Indo-European descendants shared this idea?

Did this idea make its way from one people to the other or is it rooted in their ancestors(Proto-indo-european)?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

How did bread/cheese making cultures of antiquity get their hands on ingredients such as yeast and rennet?

Even now the only way for one to obtain Renner or yeast is to purchase it. There is no east home recipe for these, so where did the ancient bakers get yeast and cheese makers rennet? This might include any other ingredient they obtained through outdated ways (not export/import).

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Is there evidence that the founders included cannons and bombs in defending the 2nd Amendment?

Essentially what I am asking is: did the founders believe the 2nd Amendment have limits? Would a constitutional originalist be in favor of allowing unrestricted use of nuclear weapons to the public?

2 Answers 2018-01-04

What was the impact of the Seven Years War on the American War of Independenc?

This question came to mind as I am a massive fan of the Assasisns Creed franchise and have recently been replaying "Rogue" which is set in the Seven Years War, with this game acting as a prequel to ACIII which is set in the American Revolution.

So I've become curious.

With the historical Seven Years War what was their impact on the American colonies and how much did this impact tie in, or not tie in, to the events which would later occur during the Revolution?

Were there any particular sentiments that arose in the Seven Years War which helped contribute to the Revolution?

Did the alliances with Native Americans built in the Wars affect the Revolution?

We're there any significant progresses made for the rights of colonists and Natives during the Wars?

Were key battles in the Wars necessary to the eventual Revolution?

Or did the Seven Years War ultimately have little affect on the American War of Independence?

Hope this question isn't to broad or to specific and I look forwards to your replies.

2 Answers 2018-01-04

Were the Great Pyramids ever used as a vantage point during a war?

The Great Pyramids in Egypt being colossal rock structures would act as great vantage points, so I am wondering as to whether or not there were ever wars where the pyramids were a critical point. I am mainly wondering about wars that have taken place in the last 200 years.

1 Answers 2018-01-04

What is the origin of Hamburger + French Fries + Soft Drink combo that is the foundation of all Fast Food today?

A dish with supposedly German influences with a side of supposedly Franco-Belgian influences with an American drink seems normal now, but was it always considered normal?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

When and why did people stop worshipping gods from the norse, egyptian, and greek mythologies?

Gods such as odin, sobek, anubis, poseidon etc...

also sorry for my bad english, not my first language

1 Answers 2018-01-04

A contractor told me that most American homes from the 1950s and 1960s have wood floors because FHA was the most common mortgage provider at the time and FHA required wood floors. Is this true?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Why dont we view the Ottoman Empire as a continuation of the Roman Empire

It is largely uncontroversial to treat the later Byzantine Empire as a direct continuation of the Roman Empire, despite it having a different religion, language, territorial center, culture, and administration than the image generally thought of in it's namesake. You might even get a pass for rolling the Latin Empire into the larger Roman story.

By all the rules that let you conflate the Byzantine Empire with the Roman Empire, the Ottomans have a much stronger claim than the Holy Roman empire ever did (not that anyone pretends they were). This includes the leader having the title of Cesar recognized by a major church body.

Has this question been addressed by minds in the early modern period or by historians since? Have there been instances of reluctant or willing acceptance of this fact by the powers that be?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

Were there attempts at a diplomatic resolution to avoid the American Revolution? What happened?

1 Answers 2018-01-04

⯇ 2904 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start