1 Answers 2022-04-07
I know very little about religion, theology, or religious history, nor do I know much about the specific teachings or scriptures of any modern descendant or branches of the three Abrahamic religions (namely Christianity, Judaism, and Islam). However, I do know that most religious followings belonging to these groups have negative views on LGBTQ+ people, and specific teachings against same-sex romantic and sexual behaviors listed in their holy texts and taught in their faiths, at least in the current era.
Are their any historical reasons why all three major branches of the Abrahamic religions and their offshoots regard same-sex behavior as wrong? Either from when they were first forming and their holy texts were first being by written in ancient times, or from later subsequent events in history that caused these views to develop? I’ve heard people mention both trying to stop pagans as well as something to do with ritual warfare, but if either of those are the case I’d like to hear an in depth explanation as well as sources. I’ve asked this question here multiple times before and it has yet to be answered, so I really do appreciate any answers.
2 Answers 2022-04-07
It has struck me while reading about the British conquest of the world that their conquest of India was almost comically easy. No matter how many soldiers the Indians threw at them, no matter how lopsided the numbers, the British rarely had any trouble defeating them. Even some of the more stubborn foes like Mysore and the Sikhs were rarely able to last once the British seriously went at them. And even they lost rather decisively.
What is the reason for this structural weakness in the Mughal Imperial army and its descendants that it could not contend the British Army? Was it due to promotion based purely on caste and tribe affiliations, no industrial base, lack of morale in the common lower caste soldiers to die for their overlords, or simply that the British were just that good?
1 Answers 2022-04-07
1 Answers 2022-04-07
Here is the TikTok, although it appears to be taken from a thread on Reddit. (I don't actually subscribe to this channel, it came up on my For You Page.)
1 Answers 2022-04-07
I'm especially interested in the mechanics, if the information arrived to us.
1 Answers 2022-04-07
Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:
Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.
5 Answers 2022-04-07
AskHistorians Podcast Episode 197 is live!
The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. If there is another index you'd like the podcast listed on, let us know!
This Episode
In this episode, Morgan Lewin (/u/aquatermain) speaks with Stefan Aguirre Quiroga (/u/bernardito) about his new book, White Mythic Space: Racism, the First World War, and Battlefield 1, and about the construction of idealized representations of whiteness in the histories of Argentina and Chile. 1 hour.
1 Answers 2022-04-07
When reading about the US role in the Vietnam war I often see it painted as a 'mistake', a 'tragedy' or an action taken because of false assumptions. To me this looks like incredibly even handed and generous terminology to use when talking about what the US did in Vietnam. Am I missing something or has orthodoxy mellowed somewhat since the anti-war movement in the 60s and 70s?
1 Answers 2022-04-07
I know Cao Cao and other warlords have their own ambitions, but since Liu Bei had the legitimacy, why didn't they recognize him as the next Han emperor? Did anyone even know at that time?
1 Answers 2022-04-07
How did the Soviets go from losing land at a massive rate to betting back the Germans to Berlin. The t34s and kvs were on mass on day one, as we're some of the Soviets best units. As I understand t34s weren't equipped with radios, before and after the soviet push to Berlin so how did they communicate in battle? When the Soviets pushed back, I understand the logistical issues were fixed but that doesn't explain how the kvs and t34s were able to perform much better after this. The British curriculum focuses mainly on the fact that the nazis weren't prepared for a winter war and thier tanks couldn't stand the cold, but from what I understand niether could the soviet tanks. The curriculum also focuses on the arrival of the siberian units that were trained for winter combat, but this doesn't explain how the counter carried on well into the summer with no stalling.
1 Answers 2022-04-07
I will need to do a school project and the theme chosen for me was this. I will have to talk about the evolution that the world, the countries involved, had militarily.
It's a very interesting topic since before the need for a war, I think the world's army was kind of "archaic".
The problem is that I don't find any good sources to use as a reference.
Does anyone here have a good book or article about it?
1 Answers 2022-04-07
Did the Mongols have, for lack of a better term, a specialised 'genocide' or 'extermination' department? Where did they acquire enough manpower to carry out these genocides?
1 Answers 2022-04-07
Minamata https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minamata_disease
Itai-itai https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Itai-itai_disease
I suspect that similar incidents happened in the West too especially in the 19th century and early 20th century?
What are the examples of heavy metal poisoning in the West similar to Minamata disease or Itai-itai disease?
1 Answers 2022-04-07
1 Answers 2022-04-07
Though the community was undoubtedly very small, surely there were some American businessmen or other non-military personnel living in Japan at the time who chose not to return or simply were not able to when the war started. Was there official policy regarding treatment of them? Were they largely detained?
1 Answers 2022-04-07
Hi! I'm really curious about ancient civilizations and was wondering if there are any books that anyone would recommend about their daily lives. I'm interested in Ancient India and Ancient Greece specifically but would love to more about any civilizations in general. I want to know more about their customs, what they did every day, myths that were passed down to them, and really just get a sense of what it would've been like to live there.
Thanks!
1 Answers 2022-04-07
“Behind the scenes, high-ranking Air Force officers are soberly concerned about the UFOs. But through official secrecy and ridicule, many citizens are led to believe the unknown flying objects are nonsense. To hide the facts, the Air Force has silenced its personnel.”
Supposedly he made the above statement to congress in 1960. I saw it in Leslie Kean's UFOs: Generals, Pilots, and Government Officials Go on the Record, who attributes it to a New York Times article. I also saw it presented without a source in The New Yorker article "How the Pentagon Started Taking U.F.O.s Seriously." I want to know if there's a credible source for the above statement, or if someone just made it up wholecloth and falsely attributed it to our first CIA director.
As a follow up, if the statement was indeed made by him, why would the first Director of Central Intelligence ever make such a statement? What sort of context do I need to understand why this statement was made? How do historians tend to treat seemingly incredible statements like this from seemingly credible public officials?
1 Answers 2022-04-07
Not sure how “legit” of a question this is, but I’ve been listening to Mike Duncan’s podcast “Revolutions” for a little while, and one of my big takeaways are how fragile post-revolutionary regimes can be. It seems to me that most of the revolutions he covers see a large amount of (often violent) leadership turnover both during and after periods of revolution (eg. French, Mexican, and Russian revolutions). Is there an explanation for why the United States didn’t see similar kinds of instability after seceding from Great Britain? I recognize that my premise may also be false, and I just have a bad understanding of post-revolutionary history so feel free to just tell me to read more.
1 Answers 2022-04-07
I know Hindenburg disaster had a great impact in the industry, but we had horrific airplane disasters and they didn't stop people from flying in them. But the zeppelins also know that the USA used zeppelins during World War II and they had a important role in it.
1 Answers 2022-04-06
I have been looking online to see if their are any followers of Hongs Religion/Cult in the modern day and I have not been able to find anything. Considering how many people where dedicated to his religion I would have thought there would be offshoots or remnants at least for a short while after his rebellion was crushed. What happened to believers of the supposed brother of Jesus Christ after his death, and does anybody still believe in him today?
1 Answers 2022-04-06
What made it so unique and why was it a tragedy that it was destroyed?
2 Answers 2022-04-06
1 Answers 2022-04-06
I'd love to learn more about my heritage and history, but all the pop sources I can find are either quite dubious or just focus on the Vietnam war.
My family isn't much help either. None of them are historians and all sources they give me seem to have a very nationalist slant or strange credentials.
For example, I've been constantly recommended to watch Professor Stephen Young's lectures on the History of Vietnam.. Looking at his credentials, though, he has background in law, not history. And he starts kind of ranting about Communism and the Vietnamese social character and that all makes me very suspicious about some kind of Victor Davis Hanson-esque attempt to connect political sensibilities of modern day peoples with ancient history. But, at the same time, I have no idea how to verify any of this, because he could be correct!
Does anyone know any sources I can take a look at?
1 Answers 2022-04-06