Hello, I am currently writing an essay on the influence of Domino Theory in Vietnam and to counter it I have been using Quagmire Theory as my example. However I am running low on secondary sources, I am wondering if anyone has a good way of finding legitimate opinions of professional historians on the topic that I could quote, such as A.Schlesinger or L.Gelb. Thank you for helping
1 Answers 2022-04-06
This question was inspired by my love for Google Books. It's brilliant to go back and see the old typefaces and decorations from th 1800s, and to have access to a whole different world.
I imagined that what I saw on the screeen was essentially an image of the book that had been copied. But in downloading and playing around with the images, I discovered that there were multiple layers, some acting as a mask, some sharpening the letters and lines, and so on. Some layers seemed smeared, which I assume has something to do with the scanning process.
In short, what I'm looking at online is not a simple picture of the original page. So what is actually going on when an old book is made digital? And in what ways does that process obscure (or clarify!) our understanding of the historical text?
1 Answers 2022-04-06
I'm writing a fiction book about a Spanish family who are one of many sent to settle a new uninhabited land in the 16th century. I've found lots of information about medieval villages, but this is too early a period. I've also found information about 16th century European villages, but these are too advanced for settlers who will be working with their immediate woodland surroundings (I think).
I'd particularly like to know how their homes were constructed, and how individuals (including children) spent their time.
Book suggestions would be welcome, particularly of first-hand accounts. Thank you
1 Answers 2022-04-06
As I understand it, the popular “self destruction” story of the people of Rapa Nui doesn’t hold much water, at least on its own. Rather, later events such as abduction by slavers, infectious diseases and “cultural extermination” by missionaries lead to cultural decline/change and loss of knowledge. Of course, all cultures change and knowledge is lost over time but, as I understand it, no one can even decipher the written language (whether it is proto- or true writing) and it’s not that long ago that people presumably could.
1 Answers 2022-04-06
While there are stories about children telling jokes and stories at the expense of their abusers, is there any evidence of them fighting back physically? There was undoubtedly an incredible degree of fear these children felt, but what about the older children? I can imagine that after years of abuse there was probably a significant amount of hate towards the staff and likely violent tendencies caused by said abuse, has there ever been any instances of students ganging up on staff and fighting back in that sense? Given that the staff were mostly preists and nuns, I find it hard to believe they were able to control dozens of teenagers who hated them enough to consider physical violence.
I am currently writing a paper about the experiences in residential schools and the affects caused by them (generational trauma, etc) and I'd like to touch on the possibility of "rebellion" in the schools and how that might have made things better/worse during their time there and afterwards once they left.
1 Answers 2022-04-06
On a quick search I couldn't find any sources to back it up, but I also couldn't find any to refute it.
Considering around 24,000,000 Soviets died during the war, it doesn't seem implausible, so how true is my friend's claim?
1 Answers 2022-04-06
3 Answers 2022-04-06
I was listening to a podcast about the war in the pacific and the narrator would talk about MacArthur as if he was already some sort of military genius that was a household name before the onset of WW2. His defense of the Philippines doesn't strike me (the very definition of an armchair critic lol) as particularly brilliant. The success of the pacific campaign always seemed more down to the Admirals and the Navy than anything MacArthur did. Please forgive my ignorance, I am not American, just a fan of history.
So basically, apart from being born into a very distinguished military family, and coming top at west point, what was so special about MacArthur? What were his greatest triumphs, and why was he so famous?
2 Answers 2022-04-06
I have always believed they left the red army with no leadership, and that the replacement of competent officers with politically convenient individuals did nothing but harm the soviet performance in the war. Pretty much everywhere I look that is the narrative, but I have seen stated more than once that the purges helped the soviets win the war. I didn't give it much credibility(as it is coming mainly from stalinists and communists), and I can't find much information about where this could come from. But I have seen it enough times, and from people who are minimally serious to consider it. So the question is: Is there any truth to this? If so, why is it so hard to find about it? If it isn't true, why is it claimed relatively often?
1 Answers 2022-04-06
Based on what I've read, it seems chattel slavery was basically non-existent in West Africa prior to Portuguese contact. Some regions had no form of slavery at all, like Upper Guinea, and in other regions like the Ashanti Empire, most slaves were domestic servants who enjoyed considerable rights. That seems to be mainstream view here - that slavery was not endemic in West Africa but rather expanded by European demand. However, you also have regions like Benin which seem to be very well acquainted with slavery prior to European contact, engaging in slave raids as early as 1500 AD. So my question is, what really was the state of slavery in West Africa before European merchants arrived? Any links for further reading would be appreciated.
2 Answers 2022-04-06
Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.
Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.
Here are the ground rules:
55 Answers 2022-04-06
The Ukrainian electorate, in March 1991, voted 82% to stay Soviet. 9 months later, in December, a second referendum was held (the USSR was still around at this point, it wouldn't collapse until 3 weeks later) but Ukraine was independent (had been since 1st August), this referendum's result being 92.2% in favour of independence. Even in Crimea, it was still a majority of voters who backed it (but not as many).
What caused such a huge shift in a few months? Did the penny drop as to just how bad Soviet life was?
(Obviously I am not trying to discuss current, tragic events or spread an agenda, I just want to know why there was such a shift in voter behaviour).
1 Answers 2022-04-06
So the story goes, find a new history channel, their delivery seems great and enthralling, but at a certain point (as I am asking the historians and am not one myself) you realize a little too late you haven’t checked how reliable they are before watching. Pete Kelly on his channel History Time makes these great hour+ long videos with collaborators and although for some vids apparently a bibliography exists somewhere I haven’t found it and I haven’t seen anyone talk in favor of his reliability, so I’m worried. Is History Time a source of misinformation?
Edit: here’s a link to the specific vid I watched: https://youtu.be/sXBgNNtEJ6M
1 Answers 2022-04-06
A very random question but can find no information on it, if anyone could help out it will be greatly appreciated.
1 Answers 2022-04-06
I know the modern name comes from the name given by the ancient Greeks, "Aegyptus", but why did the Greeks call it that? The "ancient Egyptians" actually referred to their own land as Kemet, so why did they, and we today, not call it ancient Kemet, and its people Kemetians?
I always found it odd, from my understanding most other major ancient civilizations, and their people, have always been referred to by the names that they gave themselves. Why not them, though?
P.S - this is my third attempt at asking about this... I am honestly not sure what is so wrong with this question? I have already been called an idiot and told to get lost with this in two other subs.
edit: The rude messages about what a colossal moron I am can stop. Thanks.
1 Answers 2022-04-06
1 Answers 2022-04-06
1 Answers 2022-04-06
What's the history behind stealing a base? It seems like an strange thing to allow? Was it a deliberate inclusion and if so what does it add to the game?
Or did it evolve from an oversight in the rules that they decided to make an official part of the game?
It just seems so random to me and I'm not sure what it contributes to the sport and I'm interested in how exactly it came to be
1 Answers 2022-04-06
1 Answers 2022-04-06
Another month down, and thus time to recognize some of the best content of the past month (and due to a lot of travel and scheduling... also catch up on a month prior).
First up is the "Flairs Choice Award", with the award going to /u/kaiser_matias, and "Fighting has been an integral part of North American hockey. Has this been the the case in other countries? How was fighting treated in Soviet hockey?. For the February Award which we're only now getting around to answer, the Flair's were enthralled by /u/mikedash's post addressing ""In 1927 Chiang Kai-Shek boiled hundreds of Communists alive," claimed George Orwell. Is this actually true? If not, where could he have heard such a report from?".
Meanwhile, the "Users' Choice Award" for March suggests our readership is a bunch of lushes, gravitating to /u/Daztur's answer to "Has the taste of beer changed over the centuries?". Meanwhile for the belated February award, they were also quite attuned to relevant events, giving the nod to /u/Kochevnik81 and their response regarding "Vladimir Putin has just claimed that modern Ukraine was entirely created by communist Russia (specifically Lenin) and that Ukraine never had the tradition of having its own state. Is any of this accurate or true?".
For the "Dark Horse Award", with a non-flair winning outright in March, it is only February where we're recognizing the combined top-voted non-flair user's answer, with the honor going to with /u/LXT130J, who addressed "To what extent were the Dahomey a tribe of slavers, and to what extent did they fight against the institution of slavery? Were they slavers before Europeans 'showed up'? Is there room for nuance in the story of the Dahomey Amazons, or were the Dahomey the 'bad guys' of West Africa?".
For this month's 'Greatest Question', voted on by the mods, after getting over the first impulse to remove because it clearly can't be 20 years old, the second impulse to ban them for making us feel old, the mod collective conceded that the winner was clearly /u/jelvinjs7 for their question ""Sk8er Boi" (A. Lavigne 2002) argues that in high school dynamics, the so-called 'skaters' were low on the social pecking order. How accurately does this work represent turn-of-the-century teenage social order (at least in North American city/suburban schools)?". Doesn't hurt that /u/noelparisian and /u/NoBrakes58 both provided some excellent responses! Meanwhile for February, things took a slightly different tack with "Were medieval Ethiopians interested in learning about the rest of the Christian world?", asked by /u/Revolution_TV, and with a response by /u/larkvi.
As always, congrats to our very worthy winners, and thank you to everyone else who has contributed here, whether with thought-provoking questions or fascinating answers. And if this month you want to flag some stand-out posts that you read here for potential nomination, don't forget to post them in our Sunday Digest!
For a list of past winners, check them out here!
8 Answers 2022-04-05
A question a little bit outside of the box, hopefully it won't be deleted. What is the current controversial discussion happening in academia, over your different fields of study. For example, in Linguistics, the recursion debate rages on, but the average Joe isn't particularly aware of it. Perhaps there was a recent archaeological finding? A new interpretation of primary sources? A breakthrough in deciphering an artifact?
11 Answers 2022-04-05
If there was a period of general consensus, was a lot accomplished and was the an attempt to merge parties?
1 Answers 2022-04-05
I know how Janus had significance to the Romans and January is the first month for this reason but it seems odd that there's no real difference between January and December from a weather standpoint so wouldn't it have made more sense to make March the first month of the year since that's when spring starts? I know Julius Caesar borrowed a lot from the Egyptian Calendar when designing his so was this just a holdover from the Egyptian calendar being better suited to their climate or was it just completely arbitrary?
2 Answers 2022-04-05