Why do historians favor the term "Partisans" in reference to resistance/rebel/independence movements during and after World War II?

It seems the use of the term "Partisans" for a rebel/resistance/guerrilla/patriot/independence movement is most common in reference to the Eastern Front in WW2, Yugoslavia, and also the Ukrainian rebels in the Soviet Union after WWII from 1945-1955.

Also, it seems that "resistance movement" is used more often for the Western Europeans under German rule during WWII. For Eastern Europeans under German rule during WWII, "partisans" is more likely to be said. Is this a correct assessment?

Why is the term "Partisan" favored for these times and regions, but in other times and regions, historians usually say "rebels", "guerrilla", "independence", "patriots", "resistance", "separatists", etc.?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Which came first, jails or police, and how did this unfold? Did the answer vary from culture to culture?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Why were there no big Germanic cities during the Roman period?

It is my understanding there were certainly a lot of them. Why did they never settle in big cities? Or did they, and i just don't know.

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Isn't there a contradiction between descriptions of medieval archers and contemporary battles?

A typical legend describing a prominent archer, like Robin Hood or other, says that those men could shoot arrows with incredible accuracy, hitting arrow with another arrow or shooting through a ring. However, a typical description of a battle involving archers suggests mass shooting without aim ("arrows covered the sky" or "the Sun could not be seen because of flying arrows"). Isn't there a contradiction? Which was the real archery tactic - to take aim precisely or to shoot as many arrows as possible?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Did Raphael, Michelangelo and Leonardo da Vinci ever meet in person?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Weimar Germany experienced a period of hyperinflation - what happened to the currency after it stabilized? Did Germans who sat on billions of worthless Marks become "actual" billionaires when it regained its value?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

One of today's top reddit posts suggests the Dutch East India company was worth nearly 7.9 trillion dollars, more than the value of 20 of the world's most valuable companies today. Is this the largest private accumulation of wealth in history, and what assets made the company so valuable?

4 Answers 2017-12-12

Went through the Wikipedia rabbit-hole and was reading about ancient Phoenicia. How are they different from the invasive "Sea Peoples" of ancient mystery, given they both seemed to be prevalent within the Mediterranean during the same period? Or are they thought to be the same entity?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Lawrence of Arabia historical context with no prior knowledge

I finished Lawrence of Arabia tonight and had trouble keeping up with the politics. There was a decent grasp through the duration of the film but my knowledge still feels shallow.

I don’t know much history, let alone much about World Wars.

Thanks for reading and or writing.

1 Answers 2017-12-12

What's the consensus on the acceptability (or lack thereof) of using the term "Victorian" for the history of non-British countries from 1837 to 1901? Is it considered bad practice to speak of "the Victorian U.S."? What about, say, "Victorian Spain" or "Victorian France"?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Looking for a good primer on the rise of the Third Reich.

Hello Looking for a good place to begin as stated above. The less biased the better please. I realize I know a little bit but not enough to hold a serious conversation. Any good book recommendations appreciated. Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Did the Vatican ask Israel to re-try and exonerate Jesus in 1948?

One for the ecclesiastical historians out there — I’m currently reading Gideon’s Spies, Gordon Thomas’ history of the Mossad. There are no shortage of deeply dubious claims and implications (not to mention outright factual errors) in the book, but this one is by far the strangest and least plausible-sounding I’ve encountered yet, from a chapter on Vatican-Israeli relations:

The chilly relationship on both sides stemmed partly from a bizarre incident following the creation of Israel in 1948. The then Secretary of State [of the Vatican] had sent an emissary to Israel’s attorney general, Haim Cohen, carrying a request that Israel should restage the trial of Christ and, of course, reverse the original verdict. Once that was done, the Vatican would formally recognize Israel.

My google-fu has failed me on this one — so help me, /r/AskHistorians, you’re my only hope...

2 Answers 2017-12-12

What is the explanation for the switch - or the lack thereof - between republican and democratic parties in the 1900s?

Every time I look for information on this, I don’t find any satisfactory answers. They all tend to be speculative with no specific mention of cause

1 Answers 2017-12-12

How did the other Nuremberg Trial defendants treat/react to Rudolph Hess?

After reading about Rudolph Hess' failed efforts to strike a war-ending deal by flying to Scotland to meet with the Duke of Hamilton, it got me thinking. We all know that his whole plan fell through but it was interesting to learn that apparently he had come up with this whole idea on his own. Supposedly, Hitler was furious after hearing about it and even declared Hess a traitor. Hess was stripped of all his titles, ranks, and Hitler even ordered him shot on sight if he ever returned to Germany.

Based on that decree, it got me thinking when i was recently watching a documentary on the Nuremberg Trials. There are several scenes in the trial footage that show Hess sitting right next to some of the other big name Nazis such as Herman Goering. There's moments where they seem to be laughing and joking with one another.

My question is how did the other defendants view/react to Hess? If Hitler declared Hess a traitor, it would be safe to assume that the other big name Nazis viewed him in the same light right? I can't imagine they would go back to being buddies with him after years of him being outcasted. Is it possible that some of these other Nazis agreed with his plan to broker peace? Since Hitler was dead at this point, maybe they just didn't feel the need to go along with Hitler's wishes? Does anyone know if there are stories or documents out there examining the interactions between these trial defendants? I just find it interesting that they seemed to look so jovial with a man who was declared a traitor to Germany by the Furher.

Ps. I've also read some stories that discussed the possibility that the Nazi hierarchy, including Hitler, knew about or even encouraged Hess' plan. If you know about that and would like to expand I would appreciate that too.

-Sorry for any typos, currently writing this on my phone on the go.

1 Answers 2017-12-12

How did blue ink become the norm, and not black?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Why was Mormonism not accepted in America (specifically the South)?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

As a drafted soldier, am I more likely to return from war unharmed during the Civil War, WWI, WWII, Korea, or Vietnam?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

What fighter aircraft saw the most use by the United States from 1941-1944

I am under the impression that the P-51 was very powerful in the last years of the war. I want to know what fighter plane was used the most both in carrier based combat in the Pacific and bomber escort in Europe. I have been told it was the P-38 by a friend, but I'm looking for evidence that would support or contradict that claim.

I'm not talking specifically kills attributed to pilots of these aircraft, but more in the sense of production. Which plane was produced the most and as a result used the most as a fighter plane during the war?

2 Answers 2017-12-12

On July 31st, 1985, Chase Manhattan Bank stopped lending to Apartheid South Africa. A days earlier report by Citibank said that the country's finances were in chaos. What caused this chaos?

Inspired by this article:

http://www.theworldin.com/edition/2018/article/14442/south-africas-coming-political-crisis

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Suppose I'm a Roman slave who's just escaped my wealthy master after stabbing him in the abdomen with a sharp stick. Do I have a chance of making a successful escape, and if so, where can I go?

Bonus question: what about for slaves in other environments, who aren't personally serving wealthy Romans? If I'm a slave, say, on a large plantation or in the mines, what are the security arrangements like, and do I have a chance of escaping? Where to?

Edit: a commenter suggested specifiying where in Rome and in what period I'm asking about, so I'm going to say during Augustus's reign, after the end of the civil wars. But if you want to answer for any other period I'll take that as well.

2 Answers 2017-12-12

How much more efficient did the Continental Army become as the American War for Independence progressed? What were some major differences between the army which left New York City and the one which fought during the Battle/Siege of Yorktown?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Why was Alexander III so conservative and reactionary compared to Alexander II

Alexander II emancipated the serfs and was on his way to making a constitution when he died, while his son proceeded to return to complete autocracy what caused this rift in views between the two monarchs?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

Why did Portugal become an independent country (both from the Kingdom of Leon and again during the Portuguese Restoration) but Catalonia did not?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

When did Mutually Assured Destruction become a reality? Was it an explicit policy goal of the U.S. or U.S.S.R. or was it just a natural consequence of the nuclear arms race?

1 Answers 2017-12-12

What grasp would Sir Issac Newton have on our mondern day calculus? How much has it progressed since he first started coming up with the discipline?

2 Answers 2017-12-12

⯇ 2950 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start