Does Shakespeare’s Richard III have any basis in actual history, ie was he a uniquely oppressive tyrant who was also afflicted with terrible deformities? Or is that depiction of him just a [fictional] product of Tudor propaganda?

Shakespeare apparently got much of his information about Richard III from the Rous Roll whose author John Rous switched allegiance from the Yorkists to the Lancastrians during the Wars of the Roses and seems to have personally despised Richard III, the works of Thomas More who was Henry VIII’s Lord High Chancellor and the Holinshed Chronicles, which was compiled by Reginald Wolfe, who owed his position in society to the patronage of Edward VI, Mary and Elizabeth I, and used the works of John Leland, who was employed by Henry VIII as royal chaplain and antiquary, as his primary historical source.

Although Henry VII technically had a claim to the throne through his mother’s relation to John of Gaunt, and through his wife being the eldest surviving child of Edward IV (though that’s not really relevant since he didn’t marry Elizabeth of York until after he had already taken the throne), his real legitimacy as king came from the fact that his army defeated the Yorkist army at Bosworth Field and killed Richard III. So, the Tudors and their supporters had every reason to portray Richard III as a tyrant who was despicable and repulsive inside and out, that Henry Tudor had to defeat in order to liberate the Kingdom of England and her people from his evil rule, otherwise Henry VII and by extension his heirs were nothing but Welsh aristocrats who usurped the crown. Based on that, I’m very suspicious of how Richard III is portrayed and I question both the extent of his cruelty (compared to other 15th and 14th century monarchs) and his physical deformities. I’m aware that his body was found some time ago and that he appeared to have scoliosis; but there’s a large difference between having a slightly crooked spine and having something akin to a camel’s hump on your back and a deformed leg that made walking without a cane impossible.

2 Answers 2022-03-27

During World War 1, how long did it take to make trenches and fortifications?

I've always wondered how long it took for the Germans to make those concrete forts and the allies to make those trenches. Did no side attack each other while they were making these fortifications?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

Callery Pear trees are infamous for their fishy-smelling blossoms. With that in mind, whose bright idea was it to make them one of the most popular ornamental trees in the US and why did everyone go along with it?

It's springtime, which means that once again you can't walk through a suburban park or a business's courtyard without your senses being assaulted by the distinctive aroma of Pyrus calleryana, ubiquitous throughout the country as an inexpensive ornamental tree despite the fact that its blossoms spend much of the spring emitting the faint but unmistakable smell of rotting fish (among other, more colorful metaphors) and attracting flies. Isn't smelling like stale semen a fairly undesirable trait in a tree deliberately planted in places where people are meant to congregate? Didn't anyone notice before they'd been planted by the thousands from sea to shining sea?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

would Daimyo put bounties on their enemies after a successful battle?

I have been reading the manga series Vagabond by Takehiko Inoue which is set in the late Sengoku Period of Japanese History. One of the defining moments for the characters centers on the Battle of Sekigahara and its aftermath. In one instance in Chapter 164 shows that Tokugawa Ieyasu put a bounty on Ishida Mitsunari. Is there evidence of this specific instance? Are there other instances of this happening during the Sengoku Period?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

In the WW1 the Japanese where lenient towards POWs. Allowing them to take hikes, visit villages and even put on orchestras. In WW2 Japanese POW camps where notoriously brutal (only rivaled by German death camps and Soviet Gulags). What changed between wars ?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

What happened to all the underwater mines placed during WWI to stop German submarines?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

To what extent did 19th century archeologists hold back our understanding of ancient Mesoamerica?

One claim I often hear is that Victorian archeologists and anthropologists in mesoamerica would often destroy or fabricate evidence in order to further their own narratives. To what extent is this true and how has it impacted our understanding of these cultures?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

The Wikipedia page for Sarah "Saartjie" Baartman says that according to African literature professor Natasha Gordon-Chipembere, the fashion for wearing bustles in 19th-century England was derived from the fetishization of Baartman's body type. Can anyone elaborate on this?

The article the page cited also includes this quote from Gordon-Chipembere:

“That whole fashion statement comes out of Baartman’s presence. (...) [White European] women were really anxious that their men were going to be lowered into wanting this sort of exotic, hyper-sexual African woman.”

The Wikipedia page for the bustle says that the garment came into fashion around the mid to late 1800s, while Baartman died in 1815. While Baartman was certainly fetishized and exploited both within her lifetime and afterwards, is it likely that a garment specifically designed to emulate her body would come into fashion decades after she died? If not Baartman's body specifically, is there still evidence that the bustle was designed to emulate the steatogypic body type found in some southern African ethnic groups?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

How are we supposed to understand horse ownership in the middle ages when riders could get fresh horses at regular intervals?

In our modern world, people who own horses own them like pets. But it must have been different in the middle ages, yes? I will read things where "such and such got fresh horses and continued on their journey." Does that mean the horse they were using is now the stables' horse? Were there transactions? Or were horses seen as a communal resource the be shared?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

How did the Nazis accurately identify the Jews? Is it possible they mistook many Germans for Jews? How did they verify Jewish ancestry to make sure they didn’t kill a random German?

2 Answers 2022-03-27

Was there any connection between anti-Masonic and abolitionist movements in antebellum USA?

I know this has some political relevance today, so it's a difficult one to ask or answer properly, so, sorry in advance if it doesn't pass the muster.

I've read all kinds of assessments, from the two being largely one and the same to just something a few notable abolitionist congressmen ran on earlier in their political career but repudiated by the 1850s. It's kind of difficult to see the logic connecting the two movements (except, perhaps, certain churches in the North having strong opinions on both) and as I said, anything I could find on it seems to be influenced by the modern-day soapboxing, so what's the actual facts are and if there was indeed a strong connection, what was the logic behind it?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

I have seen many people bring up memes/articles during debate on Libya that claim that under Gadaffi the government gave free housing to newly weds, carried the largest irrigation project, implemented universal healthcare etc. Was Libya really a successful welfarist state?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | March 27, 2022

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

2 Answers 2022-03-27

How and when did the Belarusian identity emerge?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

In the video game Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood based in 16th century Rome it shows people are living in the Colosseum in rooms made of makeshift wooden walls and using old pillars to hang dry their clothes. Is this just fiction or did people actually live in the ruins?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

A popular conspiracy theory says that the 1969 moon landing wasn’t real. Was this theory prevalent at the time the landing happened? If not, when and how did it gain traction?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

Why are the Qing and Yuan dynasties viewed as Chinese dynasties and not occupation by a foreign power?

Basically exactly what the question says on the tin.

Were they always considered Chinese? Was the history repurposed to make China look stronger? Is it something as simple as they won the mandate of heaven so are therefore Chinese?

Also very curious as to when the shift happened if they started out as foreign powers and later came to be regarded as Chinese, especially if that happened during their reigns

1 Answers 2022-03-27

How were body parts used after sacrifices ?

I’m creating a DND world and I’ve got a culture of people who do human sacrifices (of volunteers if that makes it feel better)

I wanted to put great emphasis on the idea that they dissect and use the entire body - bones, blood, and organs - but any and all searches for information on that just leads to articles of people being trafficked or talking about the Viking Blood Eagle method which is a gory punishment and I was going for more solemn.

The only thing I could find is one sentence saying people did and do eat human kidneys(nothing on why) but surely in all of history there’s gotta be documented uses of organs for something!

Any information you’ve got I’d love to hear it :)

1 Answers 2022-03-27

How did the French Monarchy justify having royal mistress be an official acknowledged position given the fact that Christianity was such an important part of its ideology?

Apparently, the position of chief royal Mistress was an official one in the French court.

The French Monarchs regarded Christianity as important enough that they had the title of "Most Christian King". Needless to say Christianity in general does not look kindly on mistresses.

It doesn't really surprise me, of course, that powerful Monarchs should be a little morally flexible in this regard and take mistresses anyway. But it does strike me as odd that they could have Royal Mistresses be officially acknowledged. Once you have royal mistress as an official position it seems to me you are basically keeping a royal harem. How was this officially justified? Did the position of Maîtresse-en-titre involve less scandalous official duties? Did the whole thing ever get condemned by the more religious? Wasn't it seen as a problem for the King to be living in officially acknowledged sin?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

Is there any strong evidence of ancient civilisations discovering dinosaur fossils?

2 Answers 2022-03-27

Why didn't non-whites in America bleach their skin to avoid racial discrimination ?

I recently saw a photo of Sammy Sosa, Dominican baseball player, who bleached his skin and transformed from black to being completely white ?

It was also common practice in the Dominican Republic to lighten skin in the 1940s-1950s

Why wasn't there widespread skin bleaching and ethnic plastic surgery in the Jim Crow South as well as other areas of the country where there was racial discrimination i.e. Sundown towns in the North and Midwest ?

1 Answers 2022-03-27

How literate was Ancient China?

It has always made me wonder when reading about the vibrant Song economy, the widespread imperial exams and cases of rags-to-riches social mobility, about how many people (especially common folk) back then were able to read and write Hanzi and to what extent, as literacy seems to always have been so crucial in China.

1 Answers 2022-03-27

National participation in the holocaust varied, but Romania seems to be among the worst, frightening even SS officers, and Bulgaria among the best, inspiring SS officers to reject their orders — Why did these two nations alike in history, religion, and position have such antithetical responses?

1 Answers 2022-03-26

I would like to know why the last Chinese dynasty had their male hair style , shaved with long hair. I understand the long hair part but why shave the forehead ?

1 Answers 2022-03-26

Did any large groups successfully resist the Mongols during Genghis Khan’s reign?

1 Answers 2022-03-26

308 / 7255

Back to start