What does /r/Askhistorians think of Dan Carlin's "Hardcore History" podcast?

Several close friends swear by Dan Carlin as a great place for a historical podcast. I'm not asking to refute or support his general claims. My question is more based around how reputable he is as a historian and are there any red flags I should be careful of?

I realize this is a fairly broad question. I apologize if it breaks the subs rules.

1 Answers 2017-05-14

Were the Indo-Greeks a significant influence on the development of India, or a historical footnote?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

The remaining Melanesian population in Maluku Islands.

As I was reading some pages of Native Peoples of the World: An Encylopedia of Groups, Cultures and Contemporary Issues by Steven L. Danver, I came to this passage.

The Maluku Islands (also known as the Moluccas or the Moluccan Islands) are famous as the Spice Islands. Originally, the population was Melanesian; however, many people were killed during the Spice Wars of 1600s. During the Dutch colonization of Indonesia, a significant number of Austronesian immigrated to the Maluku Islands.

Exactly how did the Dutch colonial authority replace the original Melanesian population with outsiders and are there any original Melanese population today in Maluku Islands?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

What were the motivations of foreigners who joined the International Brigades during the Spanish Civil War?

While the famous International Brigades were obviously on the side of the Spanish Republicans, the Wikipedia page says they also had an allegiance to Comintern. Were the members, whether they were American, German, or whatever else, all leftists, or was it more of an anti-Fascist sentiment? Or did they just want to fight? At war's end, what happened to them, both in Spain and if/when they returned home? Also, were there similar Brigades of foreigners (excluding the Condor Legion) that fought on the side of the Spanish Nationalists?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

How were the extensive German retreats in the last years of the Second World War covered in German media?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

Is slavery mentioned in the ordinances of secession?

If yes, how? If no, why?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

When and where did the 21 gun salute originate?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

Why did the sultan of Oman start living in Zanzibar?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

Prior to the October Revolution, American media and politicians seem preoccupied with "anarchists" more so than any other kind of socialist. Why did this change?

Prior to the collapse of the Russian monarchy and ascension of the Bolshevik party, it would appear that anarchists were treated as the primary scapegoat of Red Scares, and a good deal of conversation from "bourgeois" papers revolved around dissuading people from anarchism. They were targeted in the first Immigration Exclusion Acts, and subsequent Exclusion Acts as well.

Theodore Roosevelt seemed to hold a special contempt for anarchists:

“When compared with the suppression of anarchy every other question sinks into insignificance. The anarchist is the enemy of humanity, the enemy of all mankind, and his is a deeper degree of criminality than any other. No immigrant is allowed to come to our shores if he is an anarchist; and no paper published here or abroad should be permitted circulation in this country if it propagates anarchist opinions.”

-- (April 9, 1908)

The better distribution of property is desirable, but it is not to be brought about by the anarchic form of Socialism which would destroy all private capital and tend to destroy all private wealth. It represents not progress, but retrogression, to propose to destroy capital because the power of unrestrained capital is abused.

-- (September 3, 1910]

What I'd specifically like to know is:

  • Was there a widespread belief that anarchism and anarchists posed a significant threat to the capitalist order before the Russian Revolution?
  • If so, did the emphasis on anarchism as the threat to the existing order shift as a result of the events and outcome in Russia towards a belief that Marxist-Leninist/vanguard-party elements posed the greater threat?
  • Was there ever an articulated concern in the media or by politicians that an authoritarian socialist order like that in Russia would rise to power in the West in the three decades leading up to the Russian Revolution of 1917?
  • Did Theodore Roosevelt's contempt for anarchists stem from the nature of his coming to office, or was this an attitude generally held by other bourgeois figures at the time?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

If I attended the University of Pavia, Italy in 1370 and studied medicine there, what would I learn and how long would it take me to graduate?

I am doing some research for a character in a story I'm writing and for the life of me I cannot find the answer to this question.

1 Answers 2017-05-14

How would have intermarriage between Greek city-states have been perceived?

For example, if a Spartan and an Athenian would be wed, what would the general perception be of that marriage?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

Did the German people know about the Holocaust whilst it was going on?

I'm at a LAN party and we're having an argument about it. Did German people in general ever know about it whilst it was occurring? Were they aware that there were concentration camps?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

Were there any "Byzantines" before Heraclius who contemplated changing the imperial language to Greek?

It just seems odd that well over a century passed between 476 and when Heraclius made the change. Even considering Justinians' reconquests. I mean educated Romans favored Greek over Latin since the late republican era anyways. Why didnt an emperor before Heraclius do it?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

How rare was cheese before modern farming? Would ancient to early-modern peoples have had much cheese in their diets?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

Where can I find British East India Company papers online

Not sure if this is the right place to ask. I'm after the papers/documents in digital format for a research project that I'm working on. Thanks

1 Answers 2017-05-14

How extensive was religious learning in Hellenistic and Roman Jewish society? Might someone like Jesus actually go around quoting the Septuagint, or would he have used a targum? And where would he have learned all that Scripture in the first place?

I know the fact that stories composed in Greek have Jesus quoting the Septuagint doesn't mean he actually did, but since I've also never seen anyone say Jesus wouldn't have been likely to know Greek, I'm at a loss to guess what version of the Bible would have been most familiar in his social milieu. Partly I'm wondering if popular religious values already included scholarship before the Temple was destroyed (I imagine the traditional answer is no, but I'd like some more context), but I'm also just curious about the state of literacy and multilingual proficiency in the Levant in late antiquity.

I asked this question before without getting a response, but I haven't given up hope. (Shavua tov, everyone!)

1 Answers 2017-05-14

Were ancient soldiers taught individual fighting techniques or just how to fight in a unit formation?

I was wondering basically what the difference would be between individual melee combat styles and unit formation melee fighting styles in medieval and ancient times.

Was there any kind of technique in large scale melee combat like there was in individual combat or was it mostly just stabbing and slashing over your shield at opposing troops? Sorry if this is confusing I wasn't sure how to word it.

1 Answers 2017-05-14

How did clapping as a form of crowd approval start and where did it originate from?

2 Answers 2017-05-14

Were treasure maps a real thing?

If they were, wouldn't that just invite people to steal your treasure?

1 Answers 2017-05-14

What is the history of makeup? When did women start wearing it and what was it made out of?

1 Answers 2017-05-13

Re: Using interviews in an undergraduate dissertation.

Hi all,

I am a second year undergraduate student studying history. Although it is early days yet, I am beginning to think of concepts and ideas for a potential topic for my fourth year dissertation. The dissertation (if it is going to be on the subject I currently want it to be on) will be covering a relatively modern era, which means many of its survivors/inhabitants are still alive.

My question is this: is it acceptable to conduct interviews with these people (whilst recognising their biases etc.) for said dissertation? Or is it too academically unprofessional (for lack of a better term)?

Many thanks, and apologies id this question is tedious.

2 Answers 2017-05-13

Do we have any evidence that US Japanese interment camps were effective at preventing or reducing Japanese counterintelligence during WW2?

1 Answers 2017-05-13

How far back in time would we have to go to not understand "English" in a conversation?

Could I effectively communicate with a person in the 1850s? 1710s? 1640s?

How far back in time do old English dialects start to sound like a foreign language?

1 Answers 2017-05-13

Was there an event that brought in the use of time delays on live television

Watching mad men and it shows John Ruby shoot Lee Harvey Oswald on live television. Was it an event like this that caused the delay to be brought in?

1 Answers 2017-05-13

Has anyone done good comparative work on the Ottoman Empire, Austria-Hungary, and the Russian Empire using Empire as an analytic category?

I think the title explains it, but I'm curious if anyone has analyzed all three states as empires (by which I mean multinational, multilingual, multiconfessional political entities) all of which were attempting to modernize and all of which were somewhat peripheral to Europe, with the analysis focusing on comparing the three empires and how they responded to these pressures.

1 Answers 2017-05-13

⯇ 3409 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start