Could a child king have been grounded? In general, how would a child who is a king have been disciplined as part of their education?

To clarify, I was thinking about this with particular reference to European monarchies.

1 Answers 2017-05-12

Who is the "Ezra" that the Quran refers to?

Verse 9:30 of the Quran says:

The Jews call 'Uzair a son of Allah, and the Christians call Christ the son of Allah. That is a saying from their mouth; (in this) they but imitate what the unbelievers of old used to say. Allah's curse be on them: how they are deluded away from the Truth! Quran 9:30 - Yusuf Ali translation

The tafsir/exegesis of this verse says:

The Jews say Ezra is the son of God; and the Christians say The Messiah Jesus is the son of God. That is the utterance of their mouths for which they have no support nay imitating the utterances of those who disbelieved before them from among their forefathers mimicking them. God assail curse them! How they are deviated! turned away from the truth despite the proofs having been established. Tafsir Al-Jalalayn

Who is "Ezra?" As far as I'm aware, Judaism is a strictly monotheistic religion and saying a statement like "Ezra is the son of God" would be considered a major blasphemy by Jewish religious authorities. I have asked around and haven't found a single Jewish person who has validated the Quran's claims about Ezra. Is the Quran referring to a certain sect of Jews that lived in the vicinity of the Quran's author(s) or is this an unfounded accusation?

1 Answers 2017-05-12

How much freedom does the American president have to authorize a nuclear strike?

What barriers have existed, both historically and today, to prevent a president from using a nuclear weapon on a whim? How easily could a president authorize a first strike against a power that the United States has not declared war against? How much of this capacity relies on the honor system, assuming that the president behaves reasonably at all times?

1 Answers 2017-05-12

Why was it so important to unify the German states into one German Empire if it the north was just going to Prussia and the south was just going to Austria? Why not just annex the land?

1 Answers 2017-05-12

What are some of the best contemporary texts detailing medieval battles?

Hello all! I'm an undergraduate student with a strong lifelong interest in the medieval time period and military history. After taking a course on warfare throughout history at my university and reading several excerpts from "The Art of War in World History: From Antiquity to the Nuclear Age" by Gérard Chaliand during the course, I have become very keen on finding more works like those found within the book (that is either contemporary, or written shortly after the events described).

In particular, I am interested in those that detail medieval battles or medieval warfare in general. While my main focus is on Medieval Europe, I would be eager to read anything that anyone has to offer. The Middle East and medieval Japan are also regions that I have strong interest in.

I would love to know about other anthologies similar to "The Art of War in World History" that fit this description (at least to some degree) or standalone texts. I'm not particular. Anything that anyone may have to offer is greatly appreciated!

Thank you in advance!

Edit: /u/TheApiary has informed me that the resources I am looking for would be described as "contemporaneous," not "contemporary." I was not aware of the distinction but I appreciate it being pointed out and hope that this makes what I'm looking for more clear.

3 Answers 2017-05-12

Christopher Columbus is documented to be a decently deplorable person—killing indigenous populations, claiming land that wasn't his, and even pedophilia—why do we still celebrate him in the U.S?

2 Answers 2017-05-12

Some people believe that there was contact between mainland Asia and the people's of pre-Columbia South America. Could this be disproved by the fact that the indigenous peoples of pre-Columbia society did not have smallpox until the Spaniards came?

1 Answers 2017-05-12

Was the story of Jonah intended as satire?

1 Answers 2017-05-12

Can anyone explain the system of land ownership in early germanic kingdoms?

Who was the legal owner of the land in Vandal, Visigoth and Frank of conqured land? How was the land split after conquest?

1 Answers 2017-05-12

Did any civilizations (say pre-1800's) discover dinosaur bones? If so, what did they make of them?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-05-12

Trade dispute between Newfoundland, Canada and the United States in the 1890s?

I'm translating a Gaelic Newspaper in date of May 28, 1892, and came across a little article on the aftermath of this dispute, that doesn't spell out the details about what it was about. I'm wanting to know more. (Article is on page 3 of that date's Mac-Talla from Cape Breton, for the scant handful here who might want to read it themselves.)

According to this, Newfoundland is acting more friendly now toward Canada (now being May 1892). They had made an agreement (possibly not an agreement--historical translation, the word used wouldn't mean that now, but it seems to make sense in context) with the United States [about what is the key missing information] that aggravated Canada. So Canada complained to Great Britain, which put a stop to it. Newfoundland was then angry at Canada and closed its ports to Canadian fishermen, while allowing access to American fishermen. Then something or other changed (again missing) and now they've reopened ports to Canadian fishermen and it's looking like a resolution is on the way.

So then, I'm wondering, what's the bigger context for this story, and how was the problem eventually resolved? I'm fairly certain this almost has to do with the cod fishery and the Grand Banks, but other than that, no clue.

1 Answers 2017-05-12

Why does the beginning of "White Town - Your Woman" remind me of a Nazi theme?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HIX2RAHPTsI

2 Answers 2017-05-12

How were new tribes formed in early Europe?

How were new tribes formed in early Europe? Is this process something that occurs unintentionally or is it done on purpose? How does the same group of people end up being two or more distinct groups of people? I am particularly curious about how this occurred with the various Germanic tribes specifically the Angles and the Saxons. Where did these peoples come from, presumably at on point they were the same tribe, what was that tribe, did it exist in the stone age? When and what happened and that caused them turn to into the Saxons and the Angles?

Also how closely related would the two most distantly related members of the same tribe be?

1 Answers 2017-05-12

Can anyone please tell me the model of train in the silent film "Arrival of a Train at La Ciotat"? (The Lumière Brothers, 1895)

1 Answers 2017-05-12

Did the hippy counter-culture movement of the late sixties evolve directly from the beat generation?

Is there an ongoing continuum of counter-culture that can be traced from the hippies to the beats and back through the 40s, 30s and even earlier? If so, how far back can this be traced? Are there issues or themes that are consistent threads through this continuum?

1 Answers 2017-05-11

With 400,000 available men, how were the French and British not able to push the Germans back from Dunkirk?

Seems like you could accomplish a lot with such a large force. Was this simply a calculation by the British to live to fight another day? We know it worked out later but wouldn't an invasion have been much more costly and risky then making a stand in France?

1 Answers 2017-05-11

What are good books on the history of economic thought?

1 Answers 2017-05-11

How come tall ships were being built with ridiculously thin sails after the mid-19th century? How is this practical for sailing in the wind?

Example 1

Example 2

I don't know how different it would be to sail in the wind with sails like this versus the other two examples I've shown above. Wouldn't the wider, taller sails of this ship be able to capture more wind than one like this?

1 Answers 2017-05-11

A few questions about indentured servants in the early 18th century

Where would a European indentured servant in the American colonies live and what were the living conditions like? Would they be treated differently if they were Catholic? I'm pretty sure they weren't allowed to get married, but what if they were already married and had a family at the time they came over to the colonies? Would just the head of the household work, or would everyone have a job, including young children? Would any of this be different in the Carolinas?

If you just want to recommend a source that answers these questions (preferably a primary source), that should be fine. Thanks so much!

1 Answers 2017-05-11

Historians of Reddit, What has happened in the years after a Political Party dies and where does the replacing party rise from?

Please no shitty Prequel Senate Memes.

Also this is in reference to USA political parties.

1 Answers 2017-05-11

What was Baktria?

I've been playing a game called Total War: Rome 2 lately with a faction called Baktria located in modern day Pakistan. I know there was a kingdom with that name in the 4th century BC and that they were succesors of the Alexandrian conquests. I imagine they had relations with people from India, but I want to know more about them.

1 Answers 2017-05-11

One-handed weapons with full plate armor

In the 15-16th century in late medieval England, full plate armor was at its highest use. From my understanding, this led to the decline of a sword-and-shield combo on the battlefield in favor of polearms and weapons to defeat armor (ie picks, warhammers, maces, maybe the two-handed longsword). Did this essentially eliminate the use of shields such as heater shields amongst armored infantry? What if you decided to use a one-handed weapon, or would there be no reason for that as a primary choice for a battle?

1 Answers 2017-05-11

Why were there so many general elections in 1920s UK?

So I was looking at some historian online and at the bottom of his page it said he ran for general elections in three consecutive years 1923/4/5 and I was wondering what on Earth was happening at the time to warrant it

I tried searching online and I couldn't find anything on it so any help would be appreciated

1 Answers 2017-05-11

Why was Bill Clinton's approval rating so low in the first few months of his presidency?

According to Gallup Trump is currently enjoying a 42% approval rating, and his approval ratings have been called historically low among modern presidents. And indeed, the average approval rating for a President in May (from Ike to Obama) is about 62%. However, we have had one President who polled within a margin of error of Trump - William Jefferson Clinton, at 45%.

So here's the question - what were the circumstances of Clinton's first 100 days that led to such low ratings?

3 Answers 2017-05-11

Why does Japan have such a stronger communist party than any other developed nation?

For fear of violating the 20-year rule, while I going to use existing statistics, I am interested in long-term factors which could contribute to the strength of the Japanese communist movement. I am sure that these factors, whatever they are, were in place prior to 1997.

The Japanese Communist Party boasts more than 300,000 members and appears to be surging. Though nowhere near dominant, it is more than a third of the size of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party. After the Democratic Party (not to be confused with the LD), the Japanese communists are the second-largest opposition party. Why is this the case?

I understand that Japan has a very old and rich communist tradition, but so do Germany and France. In Germany, there is no substantial communist party. The closest would be the hard-left Linke, a medium sized party which is declining in membership. France, the nation which arguably birthed the socialist movement, has approximately 70,000 dues paying communists. The only non-ruling communist parties with more numbers than Japan are those in Russia and India, countries with entirely different economic circumstances and entirely different histories with communist ideology.

Did Japan never have a red scare? Japan is an industrialized country and also a capitalist country in Asia. These two factors are generally not conducive to the strength of left-wing movements, as they have usually declined in the former and been suppressed in the latter. So how do the Japanese communists survive and prosper, despite the odds?

1 Answers 2017-05-11

⯇ 3413 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start