There is a myth that Hitler respected Swiss neutrality due to the high levels to which Swiss citizens were armed. To what extent, if any, is this true?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

When military commanders in middle ages were making strategies and decisions, would they really consider chivalry as a important thing?

For example, would they really refuse to ambush enemies or attack enemies in retreat just because of honour?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

Where was the Christian god as we know it during Ancient Greece, Sophocles and the like?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-01-15

What was the Persian strategy at Cunaxa, and what is the scholarly debate about it?

What it says on the tin. I asked about the scholarly consensus on Cunaxa here, and I am particularly interested in the Tissaphernes' decision to avoid engaging the hoplite force, and the scholarly traditions around it.

1 Answers 2017-01-15

What was governmental rule like during Jesus' time?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-01-15

A bayonet from a WW1 field barber

I recently inherited this bayonet. I was always told this story about how it ended up in my family:

It supposedly belonged to my great grandfather, who served in the German army during World War 1. He was Danish, but came from ’Sønderjylland’(Southern Jutland), a region of Denmark that was part of the German Reich from 1864 to 1920. Since he had little sympathy for the German government that had pressed him into service, he sought a way to not serve at the front lines. He found himself a position as some sort of field barber.

So the bayonet was never actually used in combat, and supposedly it was something he received at the end of his service as a sort of ceremonial memento. It has been in my father’s family ever since.

I have these questions regarding the bayonet:

  1. Is this an actual German bayonet from WW1?

  2. Were there such a position as ’field barber’ or something similar in the German army?

  3. Was awarding servicemen with a ceremonial bayonet something that happened?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

People don't stop hating over night. What was life in Germany like for Jewish, handicapped, gays after WWII?

We hear stories about the allies finding the concentration camps and usually the movie ends and we are left to assume a happy Disney ending.

Did they get their homes or businesses back? Was there any kind of compensation for victims? I don't imagine they just went home and back to work on Monday morning.

What about the less desirables like mentally challenged, what happened to them post war? Were hospitals built and people hired to care for them or was this system pre-existing anyway before the Nazis?

Finally, about gays. I watched the Alan Turing movie on Netflix so of course am an expert now. Aside from the Nazis, it was not a good thing to be out back then in Germany either. Were they just moved from the camps to prisons?

Sorry for the wall of text, just wanted to give a few examples so that I don't just get answers from a Jewish victims perspective. As we know, many group were victims and that's what I am curious about.

Thanks for your time.

2 Answers 2017-01-15

Why did Ba'athist Syria under Assad support Iran during Iran Iraq War even though Iraq was also led by Ba'th party?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

What was popular opinion on why America joined World War II?

I was told we didn't know about the concentration camps until after we were involved and went overseas, but then I hear "If we weren't fighting for democracy and righteousness, what were we fighting for anyway?"

1 Answers 2017-01-15

Why do we have a 24 hour day, 7 day week, 52 week year?

My assumption was that since Europeans colonized much of the world, they forced the locals to adopt their customs/standards when it came to time-keeping.

Did other areas of the world have other units for tracking the passage of time, be it hours, days, weeks?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

If Henry Tudor had been killed alongside Richard III at the battle of Bosworth, who would be next in the line of succession?

I had always assumed it would be Elizabeth of York but if her brothers had been declared illegitimate that meant she was as well. If not her, who?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

Did Magellan know Columbus, either by reputation or personally? Was he inspired by Columbus?

Magellan was born in 1480, making him 11 or 12 when Columbus made his expedition and discovered the new world (yes I know about the Vikings but that's beyond the scope of my question)

I'm just imagining a teenage Magellan in his bedroom with a Christopher Columbus poster nestled between charts and maps, mad at his parents for something because he's a teenager and saying "one day I'll be a great explorer just like Colubus, you wait and see!"

1 Answers 2017-01-15

In the NJ portion of the New Netherland colony, what did the settlers think of Peter Stuyvesant's administration when the colony was taken over by the English in 1664?

Hi all,

I'm a resident of the state of NJ and am trying to learn more about the early history of the state and region. I've been reading a couple of books on the subject like The Barbarous Years by Bernard Bailyn and A History of Middlesex County: 1664 - 1920 by John Wall, and I am a bit confused about something.

Peter Stuyvesant was director of the colony for 17 years (since 1647) and from what I understand, he was responsible for expanding the settlement of New Amsterdam and improving its economy and aesthetic after the disastrous tenure of Willem Kieft, but had a lot of controversial social and religious policies and was a bit of an authoritarian. I've also read that in the 4 years between the Stuart Restoration and the take-over of New Netherland by the British, Stuyvesant intentionally settled English from Long Island and the New Haven colony in what is now NJ as those colonists were not fans of Charles II and had enjoyed extensive freedoms under the Protectorate; they were more republican-minded than they were fans of the English monarchy and Stuyvesant thought it advantageous to populate the areas under his control with residents who were not so politically different from the Dutch.

So I'm wondering, what was the general opinion of Stuyvesant's administration when he was forced to step down in 1664 in the eyes of these English settlers? Was it a positive one, or relatively more positive than the opinion these settlers would have had of Charles at the time, or did they care all that much? Are my sources total bullshit? Sorry if this is a bit of a rambling question...

1 Answers 2017-01-15

Was Charles V's title Emperor or King of Spain? Why was he not king of Hungary-Croatia and Bohemia?

My two questions elaborated:

  1. Charles V abdicated in ~1550. The titles of King of Hungary and Croatia,& Bohemia do not appear in his titles but appear in his brothers'. Why is it so?

  2. Were Spain and Portugal ever officially declared as Empires? Charles V and his son Philip have only king of Spain and Portugal(only for the latter) in their titles whereas they are called empires in general. My understanding was that HRE and Russia were the only Empires in Christian Europe until Napoleon, and they claimed legitimacy from west and east Rome respectively.

 

The person in question's wiki page: Charles V

1 Answers 2017-01-15

How did the U.S. Army decide to standardize the .30-06 cartridge for their weapons in WW2?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2017-01-15

This week's theme: Corruption

3 Answers 2017-01-15

Read about the recent death of the creator of the Pinyin system and was curious - how long did it take for non-Chinese academics to use Pinyin more than Wade-Giles? Is Wade-Giles used much at all today?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

To what extent did ideological differences between the U.S.S.R and the U.S result in the development of the Cold War?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2017-01-15

Do we have physical remains of any Roman emperor or senator with extractable DNA?

Fascinating concept

1 Answers 2017-01-15

A person who knows next to nothing about history here. Is there a specific kind of book that gives brief introduction/overview of all the important, "must know" stuff in history?

I started reading more than ever before this year and the more I read the more I realize how uninformed I am about the world. I'm looking for something to introduce me into studying history, Something that gives brief, but informative enough information from earliest civilizations to modern ones. After which, whenever particular subjects interest me more than others, I'll delve into them separately.

Consider that I know literally nothing about history and I want to chronologically study it. Is there a book that would fit the description? Is this a correct way to go about educating myself on history?

3 Answers 2017-01-15

Medieval and Early Modern breastplate sizes?

According to this video breastplates were generally a bit shorter than people today assume. Coming down to about the bottom of the ribcage or natural waist. I'm wondering how universal that was.

According to this chart it seems that some breastplates in the 16th and 17th century were relatively long. For instance the sides of this brestplate seem to stretch down quite a bit farther than the sides of this one. Am I correct that the plate in the first image ends closer to the hip? and if so why were some breastplates longer than others?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

Why did Caesar cover his face as he lay dying?

When Julius Caesar lay dying after receiving multiple stab wounds why did he try to cover his face with his robe? Out of decency? Out of shame? Out of sadness? Out of disgust? Out of disdain?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

In his History of Rome podcast, Mike Duncan mentions that Hadrian was mocked for his accent, which was a combination of Spanish and "military pronunciations." What do we know about Roman military pronunciation?

It was in episode 81 - The Greekling. What does "military pronunciation" refer to? Was legionaries' speech distinctly different from normal Latin?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

Old Testament Laws

Historically speaking, have Christians ever followed the laws of the Old Testament (the laws involving stoning, burning, cutting of people's hands, etc) or was the idea that there was a 'New Covenant' they had to follow there since the earliest days of Christianity?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

How do historians define or quantify the ability of less "civilized" people to engage in violence?

As an example, the prodigious war capacity of Romans in the peninsula have way to administrative roles while the provincials did the fighting. Then the provincials were administrative and Germans did the fighting. Or take the ability of Afgans to resist the Soviets. Or the Vietcong. I don't think this phenomenon is questioned.

Have historians reached a consensus on a "cause"? Are urban civilized less exposed to violence in daily life and this less capable in battle? Or is life in urban civilized environments just that much better in comparison to war that war less desirable an option?

Does this tie into the general decrease in rioting in the US over the last 100 years?

1 Answers 2017-01-15

⯇ 3675 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start