European rules and Roman democracy.

I read once that European medieval rulers would use the collapse of Rome as a justification that democracy/republicanism didn't work, thereby further legitimizing their autocratic rule. Is there any truth to this? How much might the average citizenry and the nobility know about Roman or Greek democracy, or rule by an elected body?

1 Answers 2016-08-26

Why is the Protestant Reformation so important to the history of Western Civilization?

I of course believe its important, but seem to have trouble wrapping my head around it. How did the Protestant Reformation change Western Civilization and the world?

2 Answers 2016-08-26

Where did the tradition of European Explorers presenting gifts of scientific value, such as telescopes or fireworks displays, to non-European people come from? E.g. The voyages of Captain Cook, European trade missions to China and Japan, etc.

1 Answers 2016-08-26

How did the police communicated before the telegraph and the radio?

How did they communicated when they needed back up, medical assistance or needed to ask for instructions or give instructions?

1 Answers 2016-08-26

I'm a slave living in the Confederate States. The word just got to my plantation that the war is over and I'm now free. Now what?

Am I free that very instant? Do I start working for the same family but for a wage now? Is there any reasonable enforcement of the new laws that prevents the same people from just continuing to enslave me? Can my owners just up and kick me off the land I'd at least tacitly been allowed to live on in exchange for labor my whole life if they don't think I'm good enough to earn a wage? Are there enough protection laws in place to prevent my former master from now arguing that he's paying me more than enough by putting a roof over my head and food in my stomach? Are there any legitimate opportunities for me? Are there any dedicated government or charity structures around to help me hit the ground running?

6 Answers 2016-08-26

Why were there so many small German states?

What was the reason for so many small German states such as Hanover, Schaumburg-Lippe, Waldeck and Pyrmont and so on...

1 Answers 2016-08-26

Helicopters in battle.

What's the earliest example of helicopters in warfare and how did they change the battles were fought?

2 Answers 2016-08-26

Were there any substantive differences between Carthaginian and Greek warship design at the time of the 1st Punic War?

I'm reading Polybius' history, and he describes the Romans' initial attempts to build a navy as being troubled because they had no craftsmen familiar with quinquereme design.

They apparently solve this problem by using a beached Carthaginian design, but Polybius mentions that in their initial expedition to Sicily they "borrowed quinqueremes and triremes from Tarentum and Locri, and even from Elea and Neapolis; and having thus collected a fleet, boldly sent their men across upon it."

Why wouldn't the romans just copy these ships?

Were there any differences between the punic and the italian/greek quinqueremes that would lead the romans to prefer using the punic design?

Or is this whole section just mildly nonsensical? Or possibly just a poorly thought out parable about the crafty romans and their adaptability/gumption?

1 Answers 2016-08-26

Is the Right of Revolution guaranteed in the US Constitution?

Recently I'v heard people say things along the lines of 'the constitution gives me the right to rebel'. I was wondering if this is actually true. I know in some countries that is the case, but I can't find any references to the US. Thank you.

2 Answers 2016-08-26

In the 19th century, Western observers regarded the Japanese as "lazy". Where did the modern "workaholic" culture come from, and why the change?

I originally posted this in /r/japan but was advised to try here for better answers

This is a quote from the paper "The Japanese Nation: An Imagined Community" by Paul Doyon I found on www.academia.edu (registration required)

He mainly talks about nihonjinron and the emergence of the Japanese nation-state, but he also made this interesting point:

One presumably essentialist trait that the Japanese have been deemed to possess is one of workaholism. Kato Tetsuro, in his paper "Workaholism: It's Not in the Blood" provides evidence against this and the nihonjinron theory by using Linhart's (1988) study on Japanese leisure habits:

To Western observers in the Meiji Period, the best adjective to describe Japanese workers was not "diligent" but "lazy." In the Journal of Japanese Studies (Vol. 14, No. 2. 1988) Austrian born Japanologist Sepp Linhart has this to say: "To Western observers of the Meiji Period, the Japanese exhibited none of today's stereotypical characteristics of a diligent, hard-working people. Karl Scherzer, a member of the first Austro-Hungarian delegation to the Far East, wrote in his diary shortly after the Meiji Restoration that the Japanese seemed much more cheerful, pleasure-seeking, and given to drink and showed more aversion to work than the Chinese he had observed. (1995)

Is the Japanese image of workaholism and diligence a post-WWII phenomenon? Does anyone have any other sources on this topic? I'm pretty sure that in Japan it is widely believed that this has always been a feature of the national character, so I'd be really interested to hear more on this.

1 Answers 2016-08-26

Would the man who wrote the oldest surviving version of Beowulf have been able to write Latin? If yes why did he choose to write the poem in old English?

Did the pre-Norman Saxons buy into the idea that their own vernacular was more barbarous that the Church's preferred language?

1 Answers 2016-08-26

How did cavalry engagements usually play out?

I'm assuming when two sets of cavalry met they would both charge at each other, and the guys who got dismounted would end up fighting dismounted enemy troops, kind of similar to how the Battle of Bastards started in GoT.

EDIT: I'm thinking of cavalry engagements during the Punic Wars if it matters.

1 Answers 2016-08-26

When did people start smiling in photographs?

It's a common observation that people in old photographs aren't smiling. And I've often heard that the story about "it took 30 mins to take a picture" is an oversimplification of the reason why no one was smiling. But somewhere between daguerreotypes and polaroids, everyone decided that smiling was to be the done thing. How come?

2 Answers 2016-08-25

In the game Crusader Kings 2, each ruler has a council which wields powers over what decisions are made in the country, but how much power did medieval councils actually hold throughout history?

What examples are there where councils made rulers into their puppets, or the rulers obeyed the will of a council, or any instance where the council was the real power behind the throne and had the final say within a decision making capacity?

1 Answers 2016-08-25

How did the Kingdom of Mali come into being even though it's so far inland and far from any ocean navigation?

1 Answers 2016-08-25

You know the Haudenosaunee foundation myth. Is there any particular evidence of extensive warfare in New England 900 years ago?

1 Answers 2016-08-25

Why out of all the prestigious universities in America did Harvard become the stereotypical school for the most intelligent people in the country to go to.

1 Answers 2016-08-25

How certain is that Constantine the Great was a Christian?

Sorry if this question was asked before but I could not see any post directly questioning the conversion of Constantine to Christianity. As a start, one might delve into what Christianity meant and how one could become a Christian at Constantine's time. How realiable are the accounts telling that Constantine converted to Christianity?

1 Answers 2016-08-25

The U.S. National Park Service turns 100 today. In light of this, what led to the NPS's creation in 1916, and why wasn't it created earlier?

1 Answers 2016-08-25

Why is Scandinavia sparsely populated?

1 Answers 2016-08-25

Why were winter campaigns so commonly avoided?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-08-25

In her speech tonight Hillary Clinton claimed (in reference to Trump's Muslim ban) that since the pilgrims, America has been associated with religious freedom. I'm skeptical, didn't the pilgrims and other early colonists ban other religions / sects in their colonies?

3 Answers 2016-08-25

During the Vietnam War there is a disproportional number of "massacres" carried out by South Korean troops in comparison to other Anti-Communist forces. What is the reasoning for this?

Phong Nhi, Phong Nhat, Ha My, Binh Hoa, Binh Tai, Binh An, Tay Vin... And the list goes on.

Only major incidents for the United States I can find are My Lai and Thang Phong. Why were South Korean troops serving in the country more likely to commit such events?

1 Answers 2016-08-25

How extensive were intelligence services in medieval Europe? Did medieval states have extensive foreign and domestic services?

1 Answers 2016-08-25

Was it Ben Franklin or someone else who penned "an enormous proportion of property vested in a few individuals is dangerous to the rights, and destructive of the common happiness, of mankind"

1 Answers 2016-08-25

⯇ 4012 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start