How accurate is this wikipedia page outlining casualties in WWII?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_II_casualties

If these numbers are accurate, the implications are incredible. I'd never realised how comparatively miniscule the contribution of the western allies was towards the eventual victory in Europe. The sheer size of the human toll in Eastern Europe absolutely dwarfs any atrocities the Nazis may have committed against their own citizens.

Also, what on earth were the Germans doing to consistently kill 2-3 soviet soldiers for every one of their own dead?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

History of Italy during WWII?

So having Italian heritage makes me very interested in Italian history, particularly during WWII where my grandpa fought and my nonna grew up. However my grandpa died before I was born so I never got the chance to get answers.

How did Mussolini and his fascist regime get into power and what was the general reaction of the public? How did they transition from the Axis to the Allies? What significant battles were fought by the Italians? What happened after Mussolini was ousted?

If anyone could answer any of these questions or provide further info it would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!

1 Answers 2016-08-19

What are the real origins of the Medusa myth ?

So Ive read in quite a few places. That Medusa was once a part of a three part goddess with Athena in North Africa. And that she had temples and priestesses that worshipped her and wore the gorgon masks. Saying that she represented death,rebirth and sexuality. This is until the greeks came and with a more patriarchal society took her down and killed her within the Perseus myth. Now this sounds like it makes sense (but I know that it doesnt necessarily make it so). Where ive read this has come from feminist,astrology, and Wiccan websites that dont list sources. I get the feeling theyre patching together different facts (and maybe some, not so much facts) to make a narrative that is appealing. So does anyone know if there is any truth to this ? Is there any substantial evidence of Medusa's origin ?

4 Answers 2016-08-19

Native American Bead identification?

I read the rules, and it seems this kind of post is allowed, all apologies if I am reading that wrong. Anyway...

Found in Central New York, maybe a 1/4 mile from the shore of Oneida Lake (maybe less) by a friend digging in his backyard garden. Could this be a Native American bead? Years before, when building the house, same friend found what was very obviously a well worn pestle (he even went to the local museum to verify).

2 Answers 2016-08-19

Considering the amount of materiel and the scale of the conflict, why did the German Reich wait until 1943 to transition to a full war economy?

3 Answers 2016-08-19

How did anti-Semitism become a feature of both far right and far left politics?

So in the UK there has been a review of anti-Semitism in the Labour party and plenty of suggestions that the far left in British politics has been tainted by anti-Semitism especially in anti-Zionist support for the Palestinian cause. By contrast the far right has, amongst many other things, characterised Bolshevism, and by extension Communism, as a Jewish conspiracy.

Considering how opposed these two political ideologies are, how did they both develop similar anti-Semitic elements?

3 Answers 2016-08-19

Why is the Mona Lisa so world renown? What differentiates it from all other portraits of the Renaissance?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

During the Ottoman period, would foreigners have referred to ethnic Greeks as "Turks"?

Today Greece and Turkey have quite a heated national rivalry, not least because of the Cyprus issue, but to the best of my knowledge, Greece was one of the most stable and loyal taxpaying regions of the Ottoman Empire for more than three hundred years of its apex of power.

I know that the term "Turk" took on a religious significance during this period, but it also seems, from contemporary European texts, that foreign powers took a relatively monolithic view of the Ottoman behemoth before it started to fall apart. So I'm curious if a Greek in that period would be liable to be described as a Turk, or Turkish.

As a side question, I'm also curious whether North African, Egyptian and Levantine religious minorities would have been referred to as Arabs or an equivalent term equating them to other Arabic speakers between the period of early Islamic "Arabization" and the 19th century rise of modern ethnic and racial identities.

No agenda in asking this potentially controversial question, it just popped into my head that it would be interesting to know how medieval and early modern people used these words. Thanks!

2 Answers 2016-08-19

Foreign Media covering French Revolution?

How did the world get information about events in Paris during the Revolution and Reign of Terror? Was it all thru embassies or was there a press system reporting events?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

In WWII, did any Russian soldiers fight on the western front in France, and did any Americans, Brits or French fight on the eastern front?

3 Answers 2016-08-19

Overview / Recommendation Vietnam War Books? The Book List is sadly rather empty

I am looking for a multi-volume work on the Vietnam War and/or a collection of various articles by experts on specific topics of the Vietnam War, e.g., the Air War, the Naval War, POWs, etc.

I already posted a similar question a while ago. But no response, also your Wiki is pretty empty in that regard

no entry: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/books/coldwar#wiki_asia

2 entries: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/books/southasia#wiki_vietnam

one that deals mostly with war crimes and one that deals mostly with the South Vietnamese Army...

1 Answers 2016-08-19

Why is so much ancient buddhist philosophy written in verse ?

From early buddhist sutras like the dhammapada to later, more elaborated phiolosophical texts like nagarjuna's Mūla-madhyamaka-kārikā verse is very often used in buddhist text. Whats the reason for this?Have any authors written explaining why they write in verse instead of prose? I can immagine oral transmission and ritual recitation as the reason for certain sutras being in verse, but what about more analytical works?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

What exactly was the influence of The Beatles on the long-term?

So I've listened to a lot of Beatles music and I've always been told they're probably the most influential band in history. But how exactly did they influence music and social-economic issues? Can we still see their influence today and if so, how?

4 Answers 2016-08-19

Why didn't Poland and Czechoslovakia have mutual defense pacts to defend against Germany prior to 1938.

2 Answers 2016-08-19

Why didn't Aramaic become an important language in Christianity?

This is something I've been thinking about for a while now. I realise that in the the eastern half of the Mediterranean Greek was the lingua franca, and in the west this was Latin, and that the first Christian manuscripts were in Greek, but still.

Considering Christians believe Jesus is the son of god, and that Jesus spoke Aramaic, why didn't Aramaic become an important language in Christianity? Do we have any Christian manuscripts in Aramaic, and is there an explanation why the holy book of the Christians was first written down in Greek rather than the language the book's main character spoke?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-08-19

Using the word 'Dynasty' as a name for a state/realm

Hi!

I'm always confused by the use of the word Dynasty for the official (or historiographical) name for a state or realm.

Is this purely a Historian's Convention and used because we have the benefit of hindsight to see Dynastic Unions or Personal Unions?

The most egregious example would be the historical China, where we use the word dynasty not only to refer to the ruling family, but also the period, and the state which the family governed (and I guess the subsequent culture). Does this mean that the one dynasty's state was that vastly different politically and socio-organisationally that we have to use the word 'Dynasty' to refer to the different state and society that emerged under each ruling family?

One of the most obvious examples I can take from European history is the Hapsburg Dynasty. Would you honestly consider the various realms (united under the head of the dynasty) a single state? And if so, is "Hapsburg Dynasty" truly the best name we can use to call the state itself (although some sources 'Hapsburg Monarchy' or 'Hapsburg Empire' or 'Danubian Monarchy') as well?

Anyone who can shed some light or give a good primer on this? When do we use the word 'Dynasty' to refer to a state, and when do we use any of the other words (such as Empire, Monarchy, Kingdom, etc.) Basically, I'm confused by the nomenclature we use for various states/realms as a whole.

1 Answers 2016-08-19

Why are the Jews seemingly the butt of everyone's hatred, seemingly from the birth of the religion to even now there are still masses of people that hate them. Why?

I've always wondered about that. Did they do something 3500 years ago that just kinda snowballed into them being Europe's scapegoat? Even today they are the main source of all of the world's problems according to many, many conspiracy theorists. My question is: Why?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

What Mediterranean cultures (beside the Egyptians) were devoted to their cats?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

Why did 10x as many Chinese die in the Korean War as Americans/U.N. troops?

I was watching a BBC documentary on the topic and it claimed that there were 50 000 American/U.N. casualties and half a million Chinese casualties. I looked it up but found no answers. (I found figures for Chinese deaths ranging from 100 000-500 000) What I did glean was that the Chinese military was heavily underequipped, even compared to the initial American invasion forces previously stationed in Japan, but were there other reasons? The documentary made it seem as if the Chinese strategy was of a much more potent nature than the Americans expected, yet the Chinese lost many more. Thank you!

1 Answers 2016-08-19

Did Muslim Africans brought to America as slaves keep their faith?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

What was Hannibal's race

I heard there was some controversy when a black man portrayed Hanibal in barbarians rising on the history channel, and that he actually wasn't black. Do we know for sure what race he is?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

Why do people rarely smile in old photographs?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

How did Switzerland manage to remain neutral and mostly unaffected during WWII considering their location?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

How prevalent were airborne radars in WWII?

I was reading about night fighters and Airborne Interceptors in the Battle of Britain, and I was wondering about their wider use during the war.

  • I know radar was mostly a new technology, was it mainly the Allies that employed it?
  • Did most planes by the end of the war have some type of radar?
  • Finally, how important were they in directing fighters to enemy planes? Was it mainly ground radar, scouting and communication, or the airborne radar that identified targets?

1 Answers 2016-08-19

Can you suggest a single-volume WW2 overview?

I find WW2 fascinating, but I feel as though I have a lack of formal knowledge about the overall structure of the conflict. I'd like to read a single work as starting point for future reading. I'd prefer it covered the entire conflict, in all theaters and across the various economic, political, and military contexts. I know this is a difficult question. I've done some research and found:

I'm not sure the Shirer book is really a contender for what I'm looking for. I'm excited about his first-person take on things, but I've read that his account is considered dated and doesn't include much outside of Europe.

I've heard Weinberg is a bit dry, but it ultimately seems like what I'm looking for in terms of a comprehensive, largely objective telling of the war across all contexts.

I've heard great things about Gilbert and Hastings too, but not enough to know where they excel.

Is one of these the best to start with? Are there any others? Thank you for your suggestions!

2 Answers 2016-08-19

⯇ 4030 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start