Steve King & the contributions of Western Civ

Last night at the RNC, Rep. Steve King created a bit of a stir when he said in an interview:

"I'd ask you to go back through history and figure out, where are these contributions that have been made by these other categories of people that you're talking about, where did any other subgroup of people contribute more to civilization [than western civilization/white people]."

From a historical method standpoint, is this kind of scorekeeping of contributions actually a thing? If so, how is it done? If not, what's a better way to look at the contributions of different groups of people and how they impact our lives today?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Historically speaking, what do the death throes of an American political party look like?

The original Republicans, the Federalists, the National Republican Party, the Democratic-Republican Party, Torries, Whigs, Southern and Northern Democrats, there's easily a dozen political parties that have put candidates into the Presidency but no longer exist.

My question has 3 main parts:

  1. To the general public what did the final years of these parties look like?

  2. What were their final candidates like?

  3. What happened in the years between the death of one party and a return to the equilibrium of a 2-party system?

Edit: In the interest of answers feel free to cherry pick which particular question you'd like to answer

2 Answers 2016-07-19

Were there classical musicians/composers that were considered too musically progressive for their time?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Did beer taste the same 1000 years ago?

What is the oldest known recipe still being brewed?

4 Answers 2016-07-19

How "socially conservative" was the common peasant in medieval europe? Did the aristocracy contrast this with a more "socially liberal" view?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Did Latin supplant native languages during the Roman occupation of Britain?

I should have added, "as the language of ordinary people".

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Did the rural population of Western Europe push back against increasing secularism in the Renaissance period?

Today, a lot of countries have rural populations that are socially conservative and religious contrasted with a relatively secular minded urban population. For example Turkey, Iran and Pakistan. The conservative populace living in villages or small towns pushes back against secularism and liberal thought from prevailing especially if they outnumber the people living in large, cosmopolitan cities.

I'm assuming that the population in Western Europe during the period from 1500-1800 was also comprised of people living mostly in rural areas. Therefore were there similar problems of rural pushback against urban secularism and decreased religiosity as in the present day?

Did the proliferation of books help? Were the books coming off the newly invented printing press, making their way to the small towns and villages?

Or were the demographics such that maybe the rural population wasn't as large a majority?

Did the people in the small villages even realise the changes that were occurring and and how the culture was changing towards rationalism and liberalism and away from superstition and religion?

Were there any rabble rousing priests ala today's village Mullahs who sensed the move away from religion and try to stop it?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

How is the "four folkways" theory advanced by Albion's Seed typically viewed by modern historians?

And for that matter, the similarly themed "The Eleven Nations of North America"?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

How probable was the Communist victory in the Chinese Civil War?

The Communist victory against overwhelming numbers and overwhelming odds always struck me as a very improbable occurence. But was its occurence really such a "fragile" thing that depended on many circumstances to be tuned exactly in its favour? Or was it a certainty that was largely impervious to changes of circumstance? And if so, beyond what point was it so certain?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

How did Josip Broz Tito view Croatia, and vice versa?

Recently I found out that over 70% of generals in the Yugoslav Army were either Serb or Montenegrin. How did Tito, as an ethnic Croat, reconcile this bias?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

What's the deal with the pyramids in bosnia?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bosnian_pyramid_claims

Can anyone shed some light on this?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Were vikings really taller than Saxons?

I know vikings were on average only 170cm tall but wasn't that the standard height for people in middle ages to begin with?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Was Hillary Clinton, in 1996, the first spouse of a candidate to speak at a national convention of a US political party?

[deleted]

3 Answers 2016-07-19

How come muslim rulers often have their dominion transverse natural civilization boundaries as opposed to christian/ancient rulers?

I am specifically referencing that when I look at maps, I often see that phenomenon happening.

For example:

The Roman Empire often just held control of the coast of North Africa, but muslims seem to go well beyond that. Also and especially true for Morrocco where different rulers often went well beyond the border, you'd see marked as southern border of the Roman Empire. The Arabian Peninsula is also a good example. As well as Persia, and the steppe areas east of the caspian sea. Or north of the caucasian mountains.

Or crimea. Before the byzantine Empire was replaced by the Ottomans it held crimea, but often not even the whole island, but just the southern coastal strip. The Ottomans on the other hand often went well beyond that and held huge areas of modern ukraine.

1 Answers 2016-07-19

How long would I have been able to flee Prague and Czechoslovakia on March 15, 1939?

The german Wikipedia says the Wehrmacht entered Czechoslovakian borders at six and Prague at nine o'clock. As an inhabitant of Prague, when could I have taken the last plane/ car/ train out of the city and would that have been advertised as that? Also, where would I go? Poland?

2 Answers 2016-07-19

What so impressed Julius Caesar about Octavian?

I'm reading through everything I can find about Octavian before he landed in Italy to determine his inheritance and all I can come up with is the funeral oration of Caesar's sister, what did he do that was so impressive to the imperator of the Gallic wars? And there are continuous references to him becoming ill, repeatedly, so my impression is that he was physically quite frail (the battle of forum gallorum, not that I can blame his propaganda team, how do you sell yourself as god-emperor if you've got a chronic disease?), not a skilled strategos, but a skilled dictator of tasks to appropriately skilled persons within his sphere of influence. Plz halp

1 Answers 2016-07-19

In what way did Genghis Khan's Mongol army differ from the traditional nomadic army?

2 Answers 2016-07-19

How were the cities of Nagasaki and Hiroshima able to be rebuilt immediately following the atomic bombs?

I've done some research, and there are many great books about the rebuilding efforts post WWII.

My question is, wouldn't there be nuclear fallout and radiation that would prevent rebuilding for many many years?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

I'm cook for an English Lord in the high middle ages. What does my menu look like for the week?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Documentary claimed Nazi soldiers were hooked on methamphetamine's to make them feel invincible in the face of battle. How true was the level of use among soldiers, and who or what types of soldiers was the use more rampant if at all?

It also went into Hitlers "feel good" doctor who kept him on his supposed even kneel.

It made a very blunt claim as to attribute the success of their blitzkrieg tactics on some level to the use of drugs, to allow soldiers to cope with it.

I forget the documentary.

3 Answers 2016-07-19

I'm a Puritan teenager in New England, 1655. Is there anything close to naughty I can get my hands on and read/see to satisfy the devil within me? (NSFW)

3 Answers 2016-07-19

Why does the United States have term limits for president?

If someone does such a good job as president as to gain the votes of the majority of citizens democratically multiple times why shouldn't they be able to go more than two terms? What reasons or justifications did congress have when creating the 22nd amendment?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Was smoking marijuana relatively common in the early 1900's?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

"The Soviet Bloc dissolved because Gorbachev let it." How accurate is this statement?

So I just finished reading Tony Judt's Postwar (If anybody has any opinions on that, I'd be glad to read them). In it, Judt argues that although various Eastern European anti-communist movements provided the spur for dissolution, the primary reason behind it was Gorbachev's refusal to enforce the Brezhnev doctrine and intervene militarily, which Judt believes would crush any of the independence movements with ease. Should his argument considered accurate and/or valid?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

A question regarding writing technology in 1790s America, or a question regarding early congressional procedures. (I'm not sure).

I'm reading Empire of Liberty by Gordon Wood, and a sentence in it has left me confused.

"Fearful of being overawed by Hamilton's expertise, Congress requested that Hamilton's Report on the Public Credit be submitted in writing."

Clearly I'm missing something here, because I don't see how this is out of the ordinary. They didn't have typewriters then, so he would have to submit it in writing. The printing press doesn't make much sense either, due to it being a government report meant only for congress. Either there's some obscure congressional procedure I'm ignorant of, or my perceptions of the writing technology of the decade are wildly off! (Or I'm missing something obvious, as I sometimes do).

Sorry if this question is too specific, or if I didn't give enough context. Trust me, I gave as much context as the book did.

1 Answers 2016-07-19

⯇ 4107 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start