When the cracking of the Enigma was announced in '73 and publicized in '74, what was the reaction of the surviving members of the German military?

While the cracking was announced in '73, I know that is was Winterbotham's book The Ultra Secret in 1974 that enabled the fact that Enigma had been cracked to become widely known. What I would like to know is what reaction there was from the German military, if any.

2 Answers 2016-07-19

Why was Neil Armstrong selected over Buzz and Michael to be the first to step foot on the moon?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

What colour were lamp posts in the 1930's?

2 Answers 2016-07-19

/r/AskHistorians has just hit 500,000 Subscribers! To celebrate this momentous occasion, you may be mirthful in this thread.

This afternoon the subscriber count of the subreddit ticked over 500,000! All of us here on the modteam would like to use this occasion to thank each and every one of you for helping to make this subreddit into the amazing community that it has grown to be, whether it is by writing answers, asking questions, reporting clutter, or simply being a reader.

As we do once in a blue moon, we're celebrating this milestone with a META thread where (almost) everything goes! Please be excellent to each other, but otherwise, post all those rules breaking jokes and memes you've been suppressing for the past four years!

81 Answers 2016-07-19

What was Monaco like in terms of governance pre modern era?

A long time ago I saw a map of Greek colonies around the Mediterranean, the one that stood out to me was Monaco.

So from what I gather, it was Greek, then Roman, but what after the fall of Rome. Did Charlemagne conquer it? When did it gain it's independent status or have they had it since essentially Rome fell?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

What did students memorize of Cicero's writings?

I just started reading Founding Brothers by Joseph J. Ellis. The first chapter describes the duel between Hamilton and Burr. One of Hamilton's insults to Burr was that Burr was like Catiline. The author briefly tells us that students of the time regularly memorized Cicero's Virtues and would have understood the reference. I can look up Catiline easily but I can't seem to find exactly what students used to memorize. I found a brief explanation of his thoughts here but I imagine students would memorize ~10 lines of text.

Any ideas? Thank you.

1 Answers 2016-07-19

A question about defensive pacts vs. military alliances

I am doing a personal project and was attempting to find information on defensive pacts throughout history. From wikipedia, one gets the impression that the first defensive pact was the Dreikaiserbund.

In popular game titles like Civilization 5 and the Total War series, defensive pacts appear long before recent history. In the same titles, a defensive pact differs from a military alliance in that defense pact bound countries will automatically declare war only if the other member of the pact has war declared on them, whereas a military alliance works as either the aggressor or defender.

When did these alliances begin and what is the earliest example, if not the Dreikaiserbund?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Are the Norse gods and Roman gods at all related mythologies?

I know the Romans tended to treat the Norse Gods as if they were, to the point that they use to call Odin Mercury when ever they wrote about northern religions

2 Answers 2016-07-19

What was the social structure like in Achaemenid Persia?

I always hear it was feudalistic, but it is never elaborated on.

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Was Hiroshima and Nagasaki necessary?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

"It is the stated position of the U.S. Air Force that their safeguards would prevent the occurrence of such events as are depicted in this film." What were their safeguards? What about the other branches and other nuclear arsenals?

The events depicted in "Dr. Strangelove," to be clear.

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Did Stalin have plans to start a new nation-wide pogrom against the Jews of the USSR before his death in 1953 (the 'Purim Miracle' story)?

I have heard/read over the years that before his death, Stalin planned on deporting millions of Jews in the USSR to gulags, and that his death during the week of Purim prevented this from happening. Is there any historical evidence/basis to this story?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Between France, Great Britain, and The U.S.- how have working-class pants evolved since the beginning of the 18th Century?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

What was the first article of clothing(shoes, underwear, etc.) that early people wore? Was the first article different depending on where the civilization was located?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Why is Augustus considered the first emperor rather than Caesar?

It seems to me that Caesar was the first person to gain and maintain "emperor" levels of control over the empire, so I'm curious as to why he isn't considered the first emperor? From what I've seen every emperor looked to Augustus as the father of the imperial system and tried to emulate him, with barely any mention of Caesar at all. How did Caesar come to be less revered than Augustus, and why don't we consider him an emperor?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Why relied the late Roman Empire so heavily on "barbarians" to man it's armies?

This summer I have grown an interest for Roman history, especially anything regarding the Late Empire(s) and ERE after the fall of the WRE.

From what I have gathered the Late Empire (both halves) increasingly became dependent on "barbarians" manning their armies, either as auxilia/legionaries or foederati and that in addition it had a hard time recruiting ordinary citizens (especially those from the "heartlands") to serve.

Am I correct here? In that case why was it so? It seems that this trend was reversed around Justinian, is this correct?

Plus a small bonus question, as you can see I separated auxilia/legionaries and foederati as I am under the impression that foederati was more or less armed by themselves and the others was armed by the Roman state. Correct?

Thanks in advance for any answers!

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Renaissance Northern Italy Richest Place on Earth?

Apologies if this doesn't fit with this week's theme but in various histories on Venice and some economic literature I've heard it said that Venice was the richest place on Earth per capita, I've also heard that said about the Northern/Central Italian republics generally during their golden ages.

The only problem is I haven't been able to find anything tangible to substantiate the claim and I've been looking around. Although the decline narrative seems to be emphasized by many historians, I wonder if the wealth attained by Italian city-states in this period is the reason why a wealth divergence continues between northern and southern Italy today.

I'm new here so to fit in with this week's theme, what would be the difference in marriage and courtship practices between workers, peasants, the middle classes and the aristocracy? Is it true that male fidelity was not expected in marriage in this time?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

When did hydraulic machinery gain popularity in construction and factory work?

My dad was wondering if you guys could tell me when hydraulic machinery started becoming more commonplace in work environments, not when it was invented/conceptualized.

1 Answers 2016-07-19

During the baroque and classical era, who were the type of people that made up an orchestra?

I imagine that to learn classical music, a person would have to be in a family wealthy enough to afford lessons and custom made equipment. Yet, I don't imagine being a violinist in an orchestra as being a well paying profession. Where did these people come from?

2 Answers 2016-07-19

[meta] what got YOU into history?

9 Answers 2016-07-19

What exactly caused the area known today as the Czech Republic to change hands so many times throughout history?

I've only just started learning about the Czech Republic recently because I found out I had ancestors from there. I know it spent some time called Bohemia, and it also spent some time being owned by different groups (Duchy of Bohemia in the Moravian Empire, Kingdom of Bohemia in the Holy Roman Empire, etc) and I'm trying my best to learn about it. Wikipedia seems to talk about what names it took as it switched hands or came into its own, but none of the Wiki articles seem to go into why.

2 Answers 2016-07-19

We tend to use Hitler as a go-to example of extremes nowadays. Prior to the Nazis, what filled that rhetorical role?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

How long have classical Roman first names been as popular as they are in the black community? And why?

Marcus, Cornelius, Cassius, are a few names of people I know or have heard of who have Roman names. Along with modern derivations like quentavius (the -ius ending) Why do you think they became relatively common, and how long ago did it start?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

After the death of Julius Caesar Marc Antony and Octavian formed the triumvirate with another man named Lepidus. Who was Lepidus, and why is he so overlooked by historians?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

Tuesday Trivia | Black Widows & Other Dastardly Women

Today, Tuesday Trivia is a not a place for nuance, for reading through sources to redeem those women who were unfairly maligned for acting against gender stereotypes or simply for political motivations of the author.

Not today.

Tell me about the evil women of the past. Who are they, and what did they do to earn a place in this thread?

1 Answers 2016-07-19

⯇ 4106 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start