799,455 people were executed in the USSR during Stalin's tenure. How many of these did he approve of? How many did he personally order?

Political deaths in the USSR are often attributed to Stalin as an individual, rather than the Stalinist system of governance. This is common among both communist and anti-communist critiques. Is such a vision of the USSR accurate? What involvement did Stalin have in the many, many executions during his rule?

3 Answers 2016-07-18

Has there ever been a historical equivalent to James Bond?

Gadgets and explosions aside, has there ever been a highly trained 'superspy' that could show up places and basically announce, "I'm James Bond, I'm spying on you, deal with it"?

1 Answers 2016-07-18

Did Stalin ever express sadness or guilt with regards to the fate of one or more of his subjects?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-07-18

If being a Gladiator was so intense, life expectancy was so short - why did so many people become one ?

1 Answers 2016-07-18

I just opened a saloon in a frontier town in the mid 1800s. How do I stock it?

4 Answers 2016-07-18

Is there any evidence that pagan religions added Christ to their pantheon of gods?

I've always wondered whether or not other pagan religions adopted Jesus as a deity.

4 Answers 2016-07-18

What is the connection between victorian Irish pubs and undertaking?

I was watching the documentary "The Irish Pub" on Netflix and several people mentioned a connection between the pub and undertaking as professions, which in some cases continues into the modern day from what seems to be the Victorian era. Why the connection? I assume its more than the bereaved simply needing a pint and it being convenient.

1 Answers 2016-07-18

Why didn't Spain keep its republic like Portugal after fascism?

Why and how did Spain manage to restore its monarchy after the Franco era? And why did Portugal stay as a republic after the Carnation Revolution?

1 Answers 2016-07-18

What was Allies' reactions to the July 20th Plot?

1 Answers 2016-07-18

What evidence is there that the battle of Zama occurred?

1 Answers 2016-07-18

The Emperor of China was believed to be the ruler of all under heaven. If so, what were their opinions of foreign rulers?

Is my understanding correct that the Chinese emperor is believed to be the ruler of the world, or was my understanding too literal?

I've also read here that the Han Dynasty was aware of the Roman Empire and vice versa, but I was also wondering about other neighboring realms (i.e. Japan, Korea, Indochina region, Malayan peninsula). Did they believe them to be pretenders?

Also, if possible, how would a Chinese peasant react upon hearing that there are other empires beside their own?

1 Answers 2016-07-18

How did captain become a rank in both the land and sea armed forces whereas other ranks are only found in one or the other?

2 Answers 2016-07-18

Who first settled in mainland Britain (Specifically Scotland)

I'm wondering what 'people' first settled in Scotland permanently. Most history books and articles seem to stop at the Pictish tribe - who settled before them?

1 Answers 2016-07-18

Was the American Revolution a coup?

As a non-American, I had always imagined that the popular view of the American War of Independence had probably exaggerated the level of popular support. But over in the TIL subreddit, today I learned that there is an apparently common view that the American Revolution was a coup and lacked popular support.

Is this a widespread view, or is it just a handful of ignorant redditors sprouting nonsense? Given that the war of independence involved thirteen states (by memory), multiple fixed battles, sieges, etc over the space of a number of years, is there any justification for considering it a coup? To me, it seems absurd, but I'm not an expert on the American Revolution.

Edit: I should say, if it had just been one person claiming the revolution was a coup, I'd just dismiss it as a weird fringe belief that one person has. But there were at least four redditors sprouting the same belief, as if it were common knowledge.

1 Answers 2016-07-18

Memoirs of WWI by those who "enjoyed" the experience

I'm curious what memoirs (other than Storm of Steel) have a different perspective than the meaningless tragedy.

2 Answers 2016-07-18

Was the United States winning the cold war in the 1950s?

I'm learning about consumerism and was curious if it was truly the be all end all to communism fears in the United States. Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-07-18

What is the reputation of the Journal of Late Antiquity like?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-07-18

Was it true that Hitler was Christian?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-07-18

How much is it feasible for one person to learn about History?

I sent the mods a message before posting this question because I know how serious moderation is around here.

As of late, I've been very interested in current events. I spend hours researching what is going around all over the world in terms of politics, government, etc.

However, once I start, questions come by the dozens. I end up having to learn current and old history in order to feel like I have a realistic grasp of things.

I'll look at it from all relative perspectives. Religion, economic, ethics, politics, geography. Basically, I have to know everything about a country/'s before I can move on to actually thinking about the initial thing.

My question is, how much can one person actually learn about all the things I mentioned? How many of these things can one person call themselves a "master" in?

I know it's a bit of an odd question but I'm wondering whether or not it's even reasonable for me to try.

Again, thanks for reading and I hope no one finds issues with my post.

1 Answers 2016-07-18

Was there any blame aimed at Socrates and/or Pericles for the character flaws in Alcibiades?

After reading much on the Peloponnesian wars and learning of the significant blow to the Athenian cause with the 'exile' of Alcibiades, I find my self holding Socrates, and to a lesser extent Pericles, at least partially to blame for the loss of the Peloponnesian wars.

Alcibiades seems to me the perfect opportunity for a philosopher king, and his close relationship to Socrates in his early manhood would almost seem the ideal pairing. However, the character flaws in Alcibiades undid him in the Athenian democracy and robbed Athens of his immense talents. His resulting 'exile' or flight seems to me a critical straw that helped break the back of the Athenian empire.

I know Socrates was charged with corruption the Athenian youth and this charge eventually lead to his suicide, but was there any contemporary or more modern criticism leveled at Socrates or even Pericles for their role in the upbringing of Alcibiades and his character flaws?

Also, what do we know about the relationships between these famous Athenians? Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-07-18

At what point did doctors discover the real reason women have periods?

I tried researching the answer on my own but the only information I could find is that there's evidence of our ancestors using cloth during their periods which suggests that they knew about it, but I couldn't discover when society discovered "Oh, periods are caused by the lining of a woman's womb being shed". Does anyone know or at least have a general idea on when this information became known?

1 Answers 2016-07-18

I've heard several times that the Nazis were working on an atomic bomb. How close were they to completing one for use during the war?

2 Answers 2016-07-18

Why didn't sports teams in the US develop like soccer clubs in England?

London alone has 10 clubs in the Premier League and Championship combined. Many of these came about as company teams or extensions of already existing clubs.

Yet at roughly the same time in the US, having just two teams per league in a city is rare.

Why?

1 Answers 2016-07-18

Around when did people start calling it World War II? Was it pretty soon after the war began or did it take some time for people to equate this war with the previous one?

1 Answers 2016-07-17

This Vice article from 2005 appears to have a lot of bad revisionist history regarding slavery in the US. Is there a problem with the data or how it's presented?

The article in question.

I don't doubt the facts and figures (although there are no sources), but I suspect the author is using them manipulatively.

1 Answers 2016-07-17

⯇ 4110 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start