Some of the bodies at Pompeii were found huddled together in groups, apparent family members embracing each other. Normally would the Romans have found that kind of physical comforting (as a reaction to fear of distress) dignified?

1 Answers 2016-07-07

Use of roads in Early Modern warfare.

This is a multifaceted question on a subject I just want a little more clarification on. I've often heard that in many campaigns or battles that, in a general sense, that "this road junction/crossroad is a vital importance". I've also noticed that the names of a handful of battles in the American Revolution and American Civil War end with either "courthouse". My questions are:

  1. Did most of these "courthouse" named battles occur on major road junctions; hence the name? Were courthouses in colonial America usually built on major road intersections?
  2. What prevented armies from moving off road and avoiding battles at road intersections? Is it becuase supply trains and their ability to maneuver only on roads on not rough terrain?
  3. I don't have any examples for this, but what constitutes the holding of key terrain such as this? What prevents another force from threatening that position yet again? How did armies secure key roads or towns/courthouses to prevent another force from retaking it?

I can re-clarify if my question might seem too vague.

2 Answers 2016-07-07

Why did humans start refining grains? (Brown to white rice; wheat to white flour etc.)

1 Answers 2016-07-07

Why have Sassanids allow their last great war with Rome to go into a stalemate?

Do we know anything about their reasoning at all? It seems that at one point they have conquered pretty much entire Byzantine East. Were they actually convinced they'll be able to conquer the entire Empire? Would Byzantines concede defeat at that point, or were they unyielding?

1 Answers 2016-07-07

Were there any resistance to the occupation of Germany after ww2? How long did it take for the German civilians to accept it?

1 Answers 2016-07-06

After the Zimmerman Telegram was made public, did Mexico have anything to say on the matter?

Or Japan, for that matter?

2 Answers 2016-07-06

Was the average person, in ancient times, who lived in the desert aware of the existence of snow? And vice versa, those who lived in snowy areas aware of deserts?

2 Answers 2016-07-06

British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain is often mocked for declaring "Peace in our time," upon Hitler's promises. What's the truth about how foolish Chamberlain really was?

2 Answers 2016-07-06

What measures did the IJA take during World War 2 to prepare to defend the Home Islands from a US or Soviet Invasion?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-07-06

How did being left handed affect men serving in formation dependent armies like Saxon or Greek shield walls?

1 Answers 2016-07-06

How extensive were american war crimes in Vietnam? is it true that entire villages were placed in 'free fire' zones?

1 Answers 2016-07-06

Tamerlane captured a Sultan of the Ottoman Empire in 1402. A Civil War occupied the Ottomans for another decade. Yet in 1453 Constantinople fell. How did the Byzantines and Christian Europe not capitalize on this moment of weakness?

1 Answers 2016-07-06

Why did the USA develop so much more industry in the 19th and 20th centuries than other European powers?

1 Answers 2016-07-06

Apparently, it is often the case that local variations in language can be very prominent, especially, say in current Europe. If we are to assume such variation in the deserts of 7th century Arabia, what consequences would it have for the specific Arabic dialect used in the Qur'an?

In one of his videos, Noam Chomsky, the famed linguist, mentions that if one were to look at Europe, in a lot of places local variations in language could be so prominent that sometimes even neighbouring villages would be mutually unintelligible. He says that modern socio-political phenomenon like formation of nation-states could lead to homogenizations that we see today. If this linguistic information in transplanted onto 7th century Arabia, would it be right to say that such local variations would have existed in Arabic also? If so, can we tell which dialect the Qur'an was written in, and in particular, what would this mean for the oral transmission and recitations of it? In the context of a nascent religion, would I be right in imagining a far-off Arab tribe reciting God's message in a dialect that they could not understand themselves? Finally, does the existence of Qur'an in a specific dialect mean something for large scale linguistic phenomenon - could the Qur'an be responsible for triggering some sort of homogenization in Arabic by the virtue of its authority?

2 Answers 2016-07-06

Were there any instances of witch hunts, or anything similar, outside of European culture?

Edit: specifically in historic eastern Asia and Japan.

1 Answers 2016-07-06

What terminology would medieval commanders have used to command their armies?

I'm doing some fictional writing, and I was wondering how mediaeval commanders might order the soldiers around. Any lexis they might have been used would be very useful. For e.g I'm already aware of nock, draw, loose.

In one scene particularly an army is retreating, then reinforcements arrive and begin attacking the enemy from a separate direction. What might the commander say to negate the retreat, get his men back into formation, and advance once more?

2 Answers 2016-07-06

when the Romans took new territory how did they go about dividing it up among themselves? how much did they typically take themselves (as in for roman estates) and how much (if any) did they leave to tribute paying locals?

Like when they took southern britain in the 40s, how did Claudius (or who ever he delegated the task to) go about dividing up the province afterwards

1 Answers 2016-07-06

So is the typical classical score we see today the only standard notation of music or were there other civilizations prior who had their own?

2 Answers 2016-07-06

How did the Arabic word "alcohol" come into usage in Europe rather than the Latin word "vocatus?"

2 Answers 2016-07-06

What were the fatal faults of the Bismarck-class battleships during WWII?

Listening to some music on Youtube, I came across this fun little diddy. After delving a bit into the history and r/Askhistorians, I found out that both the Bismarck and Tirpitz were sunk relatively quickly in their deployments, but were the largest ships built by Germany during WWII. I know that they were meant to help make up the deficiency compared to the Royal Navy, but weren't to be "superior" and rule the seas due to the lack of Germany production for Naval warfare.

Why were the Bismarck and Tirpitz so easily sunk? I don't mean 'easily' in the general nomenclature, but comparatively to their expensive and expansive nature. Was there a design flaw? Did the German fleet provide inadequate support fleets which left them on their own? Was the era the end of the battleship and beginning of the aircraft carrier which resulted in the best battleships being obsolete? It just seems that both ships were too easily destroyed/incapacitated for their power.

Thanks!

3 Answers 2016-07-06

"Best of June" Winners

The votes are in, and the winners for the 'Best of June' award are decided.

There is no "User's Choice" or "Flair's Choice" award this month, simply a first and second place!

Sitting at the top for both as the unanimous winner was /u/CrossyNZ's response in the WWI AMA regarding "the complex (and somewhat appalling) appropriation of historical war wounds in Bioshock".

And close the heels, and equally unanimous as the second awardee, was /u/brigantus's answer to the question "Why is the Fertile Crescent now desert?"

As always, a big congratulations to the winners, and a big thanks to everyone who contributed to the subreddit in the past month! Also a reminder, if you want to nominate answers for the monthly awards, the best way to do so is to submit your favorite posts every week to the Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check out this Wiki page!

1 Answers 2016-07-06

Why did Alsace in France never become a country while smaller and nearby entities managed to, e.g. Liechtenstein, Monaco and Luxembourg?

Alsace is culturally, ethnically and linguistically distinct from the rest of France, and seems to have a strong sense of Germanic identity. Why couldn't it manage to become an independent country? Smaller areas that were nearby and neighboured France managed to become independent countries, e.g. Liechtenstein, Monaco and Luxembourg.

1 Answers 2016-07-06

Why did the UK stop using Capital Punishment as a form of crime control?

I remember back in my History classes being told that Capital Punishment in the UK was stopped because it was ineffectual. It didn't lower the crime rate, so they stopped using it.

Now that I am older I am more hesitant to believe this. What was the reason for the end of Capital Punishment?

1 Answers 2016-07-06

Why do people say North America was stolen from the Native Americans, and not that it was "won" by means of conquering land from a militarily inferior foe?

I've pondered this question for a while. A lot of people insist that we're immigrants in a country that our forefathers claimed, fought, and killed to control. Why is this considered different than any other scenario where a militarily superior country invades and conquers land?

1 Answers 2016-07-06

What companies profited the most from US stockpiling of nuclear arms?

It does not seem corporate lobbying was necessary to induce the stockpiling of tactical and strategic nuclear arms during the Cold War. Still, this should be an interesting topic.

Was the actual process of manufacture privatized? Was it completed under military control after a certain point? Did anyone make their fortune on the way? Which companies we would still recognize were involved?

Two previous threads on nuclear arms stockpiling:

Also, I was unable to find a section in the FAQ for nuclear arms in a brief search but searching the sub revealed this may be a good thing to add.

1 Answers 2016-07-06

⯇ 4137 / 7255 ⯈

Back to start