Flaming Naval Trebuchets - did that really ever happen? (Game of Thrones related)

This question is more for Game of Thrones fans. (No Spoilers) Last Sunday's episode featured a visually stunning scene where there were dozens (hundreds?) of ships launching flaming shot into a costal city that was being bombarded. Each ship had a trebuchet on the front deck that was launching a flaming load hundreds of yards into the city center. However, from a practical perspective this strategy seems like.....a remarkably terrible idea - taking a bundled load, dipping it in pitch/tar/unrefined oil, igniting it, slinging it from a wooden trebuchet on the deck of a wooden boat would most likely be a disaster. It just seems like an elaborate way of burning your own fleet to ash. My question is this: is there a real life historical context for this? Was this a real Greek/Roman/[somebody else] strategy in actual naval history? I do recall this being an effective strategy on land, but I've never heard of a naval application. If, yes, there were flaming naval trebuchets, how did they work, how did they control accidental fires and how effective was it given how dangerous it was for the attackers? Thanks!

2 Answers 2016-06-16

Did Nazi Germany plot with Japan the attacks on Pearl Harbor?

In finishing up my Bachelor's, I read Robert H. Jackson's "Report to the President on Atrocities and War Crimes, June 7, 1945." At one point he mentions: "They [Nazi leaders, SS, and Gestapo] did not hesitate to instigate the Japanese to treacherous attack on the United States" (Jackson, found in The Holocaust: A Reader by Simone Gigliotti and Berel Lang).

I was under the assumption that, while they were allies, Germany and Japan had little contact between one another. Did Nazi party leaders actively work with Japan to plan and execute the attacks on Pearl Harbor?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

How effective were infantry anti tank weapons in WWII?

Things like the PIAT, the M1 Bazooka, Panzerfaust, Panzerschreck or even the PTRS-41.

2 Answers 2016-06-16

Did the Israeli royal house die out? Or does it still exist?

When Rome destroyed Israel in the first century, did the royal family die out there? Did it survive around a bit before going away?

7 Answers 2016-06-16

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in June 16 2016:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2016-06-16

How plausible is it that Geoffrey Chaucer intended for The Wife of Bath to be a proto-feminist, as some literary critics have claimed?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

Was there ever a big problem with people yelling fire in a crowded theater?

It seems like anytime anyone talks about the first amendment this is the example they give. Was there a specific instance where this happened, or just a fear of it?

3 Answers 2016-06-16

Do any of the Viking Sagas describe the weapons, tools & dress of the natives they encountered in North America? If “yes” are these descriptions consistent with what later (post-Columbian) European explorers would find in (what is now) Eastern Canada?

are there any seeming anachronisms in the Norse descriptions of the new world?

EDIT: Can anyone answer the second part, that's what I'm most interested in?

4 Answers 2016-06-16

Was Charlemagne religious motivated in his dealings with the Vikings?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-06-16

What happened for the troops Napoleon abandoned in the Levant?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

Why was the scientific method developed in Europe and not somewhere else?

What are the factors and the contributing reasons of why the modern scientific method we know today have mostly originated in Europe?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

[WW2] Was there (if any) a "plan b" for allied forces in case of a German victory?

I wonder if there was any "plan b" for USA, France, GB, etc... In case of German/Japanese "strategic victories" during WW2.

Is there any historical evidence of procedures, plans, whatever to be applied in case, for example, GB was completely invaded and defeated? What was the plan in the case of a defeat in the Pacific war?

Where can I read more about this?

Hope the question is clear.

2 Answers 2016-06-16

How was time kept aboard a ship in Napoleonic times (1790-1825)?

I figure hour glasses were used - how would you make sure to turn them? Was this the same for English and French ships alike? What happened if someone forgot to turn them in the midst of a battle - where and how would they be "reset"?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

How often did plantation mistresses have sex with black slaves?

With the amount of slave-owning men having sex with female slaves, surely their wives would have snuck around sometimes too? The resentment these women must have had towards their husbands for having sex with female slaves (plus these men not even being home often) would probably drive some of them to have affairs themselves? Whether it be for the thrill of it, for romance, or good old fashioned casual sex. This is my layman's justification for this, anyway.

http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/747/sexual-relations-between-elite-white-women-and-enslaved-men-in-the-antebellum-south-a-socio-historical-analysis

This is the only article I've found with some information and it's a couple years old. Can anyone chime in here?

3 Answers 2016-06-16

Where did the swastika symbol come from?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

Was there ever any sort of neo-Carthaginian group during classical or medieval Europe?

By neo-Carthaginian group i mean any sort of group that claimed to be the descendants of the Carthaginians or are somehow inheritors of the Carthaginian title like the Holy Roman Empire or Medieval Russia with Rome. Or maybe a group in Rome similar to modern day neo-Nazis that would idolize Hannibal, and possibly commit violent acts in the hope of tearing down and remaking the social order into something closer to Carthaginian traditions.

1 Answers 2016-06-16

As a politician how was Adolf Hitler?

Ignoring the obvious. As a politician, did he keep his promises? What did he do for Germany?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

How much text do we have from different ancient languages?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-06-16

How were Roma people treated by republican and anarchist Spain?

In the Spanish Civil War AMA I came across this quote of Orwell (about Barcelona):

There was no unemployment, and the price of living was still extremely low; you saw very few conspicuously destitute people, and no beggars except the gypsies.

Which seems to imply that the Catalan revolution did not extend to that ethnic group.

2 Answers 2016-06-16

What was the maximum population of native Americans throughout North America?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

Why would Thomas Jefferson write in, and founding fathers put their signatures on, the 2nd amendment after Shays rebellion?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

Medieval fairs

Did fairs in medieval Europe implicitly encourage the wider use of money? It seems that local markets allowed simple bartering, but big fairs were more likely to use money for purchases because the fair was temporary and required debts to be settled quickly. So did these fairs (such as the Champagne fairs in France) lead to more use of government-minted money?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

How good of an investment was stock in the British East India Company?

Let's say I bought $10,000 USD in today's money of stock in 1650, 1750 and 1850: what sort of returns would I have today? Would I have done better by cashing out before Great Britain dissolved the Company?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

How common was it for women to develop a mental illness in the American West? What would have happened to these women?

My boyfriend and I just watched The Homesman. If you're not familiar with this movie here's the IMDB. Basically, the setup is that three women are driven insane by frontier life and have to be taken away to (presumably?) an asylum. It's horribly sad. Can't say I recommend it for a date.

My boyfriend is convinced that there is some record of something like this happening, but I can't find anything that says this really happened. Do we know if it was common for women (or people in general) to be driven insane by the harshness of life on the frontier? Would they have been transported long distances to an asylum of some kind or would they have stayed with their families? If you've seen the movie, how accurate is this depiction?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

When designing Second World War era tanks how much consideration went into crew survival once the tank was hit?

Looking at pictures of tanks from that era a lot of them must have been an absolute nightmare to escape from. Hatches that could be blocked by the gun, for instance.

Obviously there were many different designers and manufacturers of tanks in that era but how much thought did they put into crew survival?

1 Answers 2016-06-16

4187 / 7255

Back to start