Is the origin of western monasticism based in Stoic philosophy? (3rd ask)

This is not part of high school or college class, nor job related. It's more of a hobby of mine. I study philosophy in my free time, and I came across a reference that I haven't been able to verify. Specifically I'm interested in the Hellenistic school of philosophy Stoicism.

The reference in question is that ‘monasteries’ in the west were firstly a Stoic development. I chased down the following lineage of this info, but ran into a wall. If anyone is interested, please feel free to help.

Dr. Olson, in her book “Daily life in a Medieval Monastery” makes this claim:

“Monasterium is the Latinized version of a Greek word (monos, alone; monachos, one who dwells alone, whence the word “monk”) that was coined by pre-Christian Stoic philosophers to denote a place set apart where the lover of wisdom could retreat from worldly distractions to study and meditate.”

But, there was no source. So I wrote her. Much to my surprise, she responded to me, and referred me to her immediate source for that statement which was Maxwell Staniforth’s introduction to his translation of Marcus Aurelius’ ‘Meditations’ (Penguin Classics, translation first published 1964), p. 26, which reads:

“A notable Stoic contribution, too, to the manners of the Church, and one which has had a lasting influence, was the practice of asceticism. Christians who desired to follow counsels of perfection took the Stoic sage and his way of life as their formal exemplar. The coarse garment, the untrimmed locks and beard, were adopted as the badges of aspiration to sanctity. Just as the Stoic professor was accustomed to withdraw from society and meditate in solitude, his Christina imitators not only followed his example but appropriated his terminology. In the Stoic vocabulary one who went into retreat was an ‘anchorite’; one who practiced self-discipline was an ‘ascetic’, those who lived apart from their fellows were ‘monachi’, and the place of their retreat was a ‘monasterium’. Each of these borrowed expressions has retained its place and significance in the language of the Church to this day.”

But there the trail ends, as that is also not cited. It's not common for citations in the introduction of books, and that's where both of these references occur. The common understanding is that western monasticism is based in the lifeways of the Desert Fathers, but this hint suggests that their practice might be the descendant of an older tradition which would be interesting if true.

So, any further help would be great If anyone has any additional information or suggestions which wold help support or refute that assertion, I would surely appreciate it. Either way, support or a refutation would be helpful, I'm not heavily invested in either result; I'm just looking for the origin of this information that I've seen, and if it's true or not.

Thanks!

2 Answers 2016-05-02

Why did the Khazars convert to Judaism? Why did they later abandon it?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

1000 naked Rough Riders at the invasion of Cuba? When else have so many naked men been on the front line?

According to the PBS documentary, "Crucible of Empire", during the landing in Cuba at the start of the Spanish American war, the Rough Riders stripped naked and finished the landing wearing only their cowboy hats, after their uniforms had been soaked in the surf. When else have so many naked men been on the front line?

Here's a link to the documentary, they discuss the landing at around 1:00, with photos and witness accounts. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EiMRo8CBLCY

2 Answers 2016-05-02

How and why were the Germanic people of the late Classical Age so successful at spreading themselves far and wide?

German tribes spread as far as modern day Tunisia, the UK, Spain, Crimea, Anatolia, etc. defeating Roman, Gallo-Romans, Ibero-Romans, Slavs, Celtic, even Hunnic (or Steppe) armies (on occasions) on their way

1 Answers 2016-05-02

If the attacks on Taranto and Pear Harbor were so effective in WW2, then why where there no other attacks like them?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

When did the convention of chairs and tables having four legs get started and why?

2 Answers 2016-05-02

Why don't Jews, Christian and Muslims agree on the resting day?

Jews are not supposed to work on Saturdays, Christians on Sundays and Muslims on Friday, and this is all derived from the Ten Commandments. But then how come they have different days for the seventh day? Was it a conscious decision by Christians and the Muslim leaders to differentiate themselves from the other faiths? Did the specific day of the week commemorate some other event? Can it be tracked down to a clerical error early in those religions' history?

Also has there been any cases of different (geographically separate) sects of the same broader religion disagreeing on which day they should not work?

3 Answers 2016-05-02

Best of April Voting Thread

Another month gone, another round of recognizing the best of the month.

Submit answers you feel are deserving, upvote those already here that you really enjoyed.

13 Answers 2016-05-02

Why didn't Judaism spread more?

Christianity and Islam both started in the same area as Judaism and they have massive followings and had large ears of conversions, not always on their own free will but I digress. Judaism had a long head start and yet there wasn't many Jewish converts and their religion didn't spread very far, even after the diaspora towns didn't start converting to this new religion that got dropped into their city.
Is there a historical reason for this?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

Recommended history of financial markets?

Can anyone recommend to me a history of financial markets and products?

I'm studying their current use at the moment for a professional qualification but they seem ripe for a historical study (who doesn't want to know the context in which the first zero-coupon bond was issued as opposed to all the other options? ).

I've had a look down the master book list and can't see anything that may be relevant but I may have missed it.

Edit: clarity

1 Answers 2016-05-02

Did Iran really use child soldiers to clear minefields etc in the Iraq War?

I know there were certainly people in their mid-teens in their army, but how true are the claims that they deliberately amassed groups of younger children and used them on the front lines/as fodder basically, as I've heard alleged? For instance, this post

I found another thread here saying the key story from the top comment is just propaganda, but the poster has provided sources, I get that different people probably disagree on this. But I would be extremely interested if anyone could provide some guidance; I live between the west and Iran and like so many things it's hard to know who is telling how much of the truth about this.

1 Answers 2016-05-02

Did French hussars actually engage in, and win, a naval battle with the dutch fleet at Den Helder in 1795?

I came across this wikipedia article that describes a dutch fleet frozen at anchor at Den Helder being stormed and captured by French Hussars. I found the article in a different post on reddit and someone in that thread said that this is almost certainly false, stating that there are no good primary sources that corroborate that version of the story. The truth, according to the person saying it was false, is that the fleet did surrender to the French but there was no battle or surprise ambush and that the hussars were merely the regiment sent to accept the surrender. So historians of /r/AskHistorians, can anyone enlighten me about this?

Follow up if anyone has any knowledge, are there other credible and interesting instances of a "naval" battle between land units and sea units, particularly where the land combatants won?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

How was homosexuality treated in Imperial Japan (1868–1947)?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

While watching CNN's "The Sixties" documentary, I noticed that a soldier in Vietnam had several grenade pins hanging off his helmet. Was/is this a common practice, and why would it be done?

Any insight into this would be appreciated. I noticed it when they ran film from the Vietnam war and it made me very curious as to why it would've been done. I tried to google it for more info but had no luck. Does anyone have any idea whether this was a cosmetic choice by the soldier on film, or if there was an actual reason for it? Just to keep track of the grenades thrown? Someone watching with me suggested that maybe it was in case they had an opportunity to re-pin an incoming grenade, but that seems crazy to me.

Any insight you may have is appreciated, seeing it made me curious, and not being able to find any information at all was very frustrating. Thanks for reading this long post, and for any information you might have.

2 Answers 2016-05-02

What was it like to be a woman in Sparta (or otherwise in Ancient Greece)?

I remember reading somewhere that Spartan women were considered repulsive by nature which is why the men engaged in same sex relationships and viewed their wives as a means to an end to create sons, but now I can't remember where I saw it and I can't find any sources corroborating this. What was it like as a woman in Ancient Greece? What rights did I have? How was my worth viewed compared to freed men, slaves, or livestock?

2 Answers 2016-05-02

Was Julius Caesar a reformist, a conservative, or just an opportunist?

Or a bit of all three?

2 Answers 2016-05-02

Why were galleys used for naval combat in the mediterranean for much longer than anywhere else and why did nations suddenly stop using them?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

Why was American industrial production so much greater than all the other nations during World War 2?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-05-02

Was AIDS a concern during medieval battles?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

Did any villages/towns ever sucessfully repel a viking raid by themselves?

3 Answers 2016-05-02

What foods would a Medieval "Adventurer" eat?

I use the word adventurer mainly because my love for fantasy is what has me asking this question but to be more realistic im talking about a normal traveler. Someone on a pilgrimage, a group of mercenaries on the move, vagabonds, travelling wise men, stuff like that.

What kinds of food would they make if they set up camp? What would be common if they stopped at an Inn or tavern for the night. What kind of snacks would be eaten while they walked or rode?

EDIT: Noticed after I posted the theme is "Cooking and Baking" so I'm relevant!

1 Answers 2016-05-02

Were there any exceptions to the fact that ancient cities were usually built on or near a water source?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

When did american settlers realize that they weren't in India? Why did the term "Indian" stick?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

Has there ever been a president in office that had no political experience?

How did a candidate with no political experience have the ability to convince voters and become president? Did any significant programs/legislation pass(for better or worse). Was he able to win reelection? Did he cause more damage or beneficial things economically, socially, or politically? What kind of leadership background he have?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

Did the settlers of the American south (or any arid land) know they were moving to good farmland, or did they just stay there because it was working well?

1 Answers 2016-05-02

4307 / 7255

Back to start