Why in this sub (and not any other) can I not see the answers even though multiple posts have already been made? I can see a thread with 30 answers but when I click on it, I only see the auto-mod reply text and nothing else.

2 Answers 2021-12-05

How did American citizens handle garbage in 1929?

Hello,

How did American citizens handle garbage in 1929, especially in New York? Did they just throw the garbage in the street, or did they have a trash can area near their building?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2021-12-05

Why did pre-marital sex become a taboo concept in Abrahamic religions? Was it just a way of shunning pagan religions?

3 Answers 2021-12-05

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | December 05, 2021

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2021-12-05

About the movie "The Last Duel", how historically accurate is the movie?

I saw in the trailer that the woman would be burned alive if her husband lost the duel, is that true?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

Help with beginner books on the Tudor Era/Dynasty.

Hello,

I’ve recently been getting into Tudor history, by watching or reading an article or two here and there, so I wanted to ask if anyone had good entry level books on the Tudor dynasty. I want a book that can help me get a good picture of the events that happened during that time, something that can help me get the broader strokes of it all.

1 Answers 2021-12-05

In "Marie Antoinette: The Journey" by Antonia Fraser, it is said that after Marie Antoinette was betrothed to the future Louis XVI, Austrian girls were "abandoning their curls in favor of a style a la Dauphine." How would a teen in Vienna circa 1768 have kept up with the Dauphine's latest trends?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

We consider older generations to be more religious. However when the British conquered Jerusalem they played it as a secular conquest. Is this really true? and if its is, Why was this not a religious triumph? Did people simply not care about the Holy Land? What was the stance of the Anglican Church?

Was post WW1 Europe already an atheist and agnostic society or atleast more than we believe?
Or was this secularism simply official policy disguising a de facto religious nature?

Considering the crusades and the more recent push to make colonial subjects in Africa christian why was Jerusalem not more significant?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

How are we to deal with a primary source that contradicts itself?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

How true is the claim that lots and lots (millions) of people today are somehow descendants of Genghis Khan? And how did we know about this?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

Is it true that it was Alexander the great who indirectly helped Chandragupta Maurya conquer most Indian kingdoms?

I read somewhere that Chandragupta Maurya managed to conquer Indian lands and unite India partly because Alexander the Great had already destroyed the power of many smaller rulers and kingdoms of India. How true is it?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

Sorry if this breaks the rules

As the title says, sorry if the question breaks the rules as this is more of a question about the sub than a question of history. But I joined the sub a few weeks ago with the hope of reading some interesting historical stuff. But every time I click on a post it will say there are 10-50 comments on the post. But then when I go in to look, I don't see anything but a post by a mod talking about how if the comment isn't good it will be deleted. Is this an issue on my end or has all those comments just been deleted?

4 Answers 2021-12-05

How easy would it have been for one of Rome's enemies to just clog up the aqueducts?

I was reading about Rome's aqueducts and the thought occurred to me that it must've been very easy to "clog" the aqueducts way upstream and limit the water leading into the city. A few days or maybe even weeks without all the expected water could really cause some damage to Rome.

Did none of Rome's enemies ever think to do this? Would it have been easy to fix and as such no longer a strong tactic? I can't imagine the aqueducts were guarded. Did this happen and we just never hear about it?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

How did plaid/tartan become the default for Catholic school jumpers/skirts in the United States?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

Why is the US extermination and removal of the Native Americans not considered a “genocide”? Is this not labeled as a genocide because of a true consensus of historians on the historical record, or is this purely ignored due to political reasons?

The actions of the US Government against the indigenous Native American tribes seem pretty clearly consistent with the accepted definition genocide (there is a great description by u/dhowlett1692 here ). Is there a true consensus on this topic among historians? I imagine political pressure is a major factor why this would be an unpopular label to brand the US government with, but is it a label that is deserved?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

Lincoln considered having the federal government buy all US slaves from their owners and then free them. It would have been expensive, but not compared to a civil war. Was the buy-them-and-free-them solution realistic?

1 Answers 2021-12-05

Best of November 2021 Voting Thread!

Come one, come all to cast your vote for the BEST answer of November!

15 Answers 2021-12-04

How did the interpretation of US(?) Law change, so that the CIA was able to engage in targeted killings?

I'm aware this likely crosses the 20 year boundary in regards to post 9/11 changes in the interpretations of the law. I'm still posting it because I figure the change might be rooted in the 2001 AUMF which could be covered by the scope of this subreddit.

In Ghost Wars Steve Kolls claims that in the 90s the targeted killing of Osama bin Laden - possibly with a Predator drone predecessor - was considered but ultimately rejected as an option because of questions of legality, instead the CIA opted for attempting to capture him with the help of local fighters (which had a far smaller chance of success and ultimately led nowhere).

But at a later point the CIA obviously started doing such targeted killings, including with drones.

I wonder: How did that change came to be?

1 Answers 2021-12-04

African History

Recently I needed to do some research on african history for school and I got into it. Do you have any recomendations on what and where I can read or watch to learn more? Right now I'm reading "Old Africa Rediscovered" by Basil Davidson and "African Religions and Philosophy" by John Mbiti

1 Answers 2021-12-04

In Greek mythology, many of the important places (such as Mount Olympus) exist in the real world. Can the same be said about places in for e.g. Norse Mythology? Was Asgard inspired by any real-life location?

1 Answers 2021-12-04

Benito Mussolini studied in University of Lausanne in Switzerland

How much money did he spend on this education and where did he get the money?

1 Answers 2021-12-04

The unified Kingdom of England was only around 140 years old by the time William of Normandy beat the Anglo-Saxons; Was there a threat of dissolution back into the petty kingdoms?

I always knew there were various Anglo-Saxon kingdoms throughout the early medieval period but I didn't realize that it became the kingdom of England for a relatively short period before the Normans came.

It seems like the Anglo-Saxon kingdom of England didn't really get to mature into its own identity.

I know William the Conqueror faced rebellions and crushed the North but was there a threat of Northumbria, Mercia, Wessex, etc returning into independent realms?

1 Answers 2021-12-04

Where did pop Christianity get the idea that people become angels when they die, when this isn’t suggested anywhere in the Bible?

1 Answers 2021-12-04

The cambodian genocide

Why is the murder of more than one million cambodians is considered a genocide if it was done by cambodians?

1 Answers 2021-12-04

Historical Context of Russia and Ukraine, Please.

One of the things I hate about the news is they seldom, if ever, provide historical context for global conflicts, especially when actual violence is involved. Be it Israel and Palestine, Iran and the U.S., or more recently, Russia and Ukraine, the historical context of said conflict is often ignored when it could provide the public with a deeper understanding of its significance, consequences, and pragmatic solution. That being said, I am extremely curious about the historical context and origins of Russia/Putin's interest in Ukraine. Could anyone explain the historical context of this modern conflict to me, or provide a link to an article that would?

1 Answers 2021-12-04

439 / 7255

Back to start