I've seen Christians claim Hitler was atheist while atheists claim he was Christian. I haven't found a definitive answer to this so I was hoping someone could give some insight.

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Why did Peru-Bolivia and Gran Colombia fall apart to internal divisions and yet the United States didn't?

I know all three had separate regional interests and political divisions, but only the US held together despite a civil war. Was it just because in the American Civil War the two sides were so unequal? Could the South American states have held together somehow?

If someone knows more about the First Mexican Empire or the Federal Republic of Central America, feel free to contribute.

2 Answers 2015-12-10

What happened to WWII veterans with PTSD?

We hear a lot nowadays about PTSD in members of the military who served in Iraq and Afghanistan. I've even learned a little bit about how little support Vietnam veterans got. What happened to WWII vets after the war? Such a large part of the population was involved, but you never hear about people who weren't able to transition back.

1 Answers 2015-12-10

[NSFW] Story about nuns+priests secretly meeting in tunnels, then later people find the tunnels filled with baby skeletons. Did this really happen?

I was talking to my therapist about my sexual anxieties, which are largely a result of being raised in a Catholic Church. To help me feel better about how difficult it can be to suppress natural urges, she told me a story about a Church or seminary or some Catholic institution, where the nuns lived in one building and the priests lived in another some distance away. Apparently, after a while somebody discovered a tunnel connecting the two buildings, and tons of baby skeletons in the tunnel. This is where the nuns and priests had come to secretly fornicate, and this is where they disposed of the resultant babies.

I had this conversation a few years ago, so I might be sketchy on the details, but does anybody know of anything like this actually happening? Where can I read more about it?

1 Answers 2015-12-10

In stories of Prometheus giving fire to mankind, he is punished by having his liver eaten each day and regrown each night (because of his immortality). However, we now know that the liver does actually regenerate, from as little as 25% of its mass. Did the ancient Greeks know this?

I was thinking about Prometheus the other day, and this occurred to me. I knew both of these facts, but I had never made the connection before.

Is there a chance the Greeks were aware of the regenerative capacity of the liver, or was this a coincidence? What's the significance of Prometheus having his liver eaten, anyway (as opposed to other body parts)?

3 Answers 2015-12-10

How efficient was the Soviet planned economy?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Were Italians, Germans and Japanese barred from immigrating to America during WW2?

I'm seeing a meme on Facebook that says the above.

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Why does Babylon seem to have in Modern Western culture a connotation towards sex and eroticism?

1 Answers 2015-12-10

The Rome-Berlin Axis - When Hitler and Mussolini became allies. - Could you explain this for me.

hello there /r/AskHistorians For quite some hours now i've been researching something about the Rome-Berlin Axis, but i can't quite seem to understand it fully. So far i've learned that this Agreement between these 2 fascist countries were made in 1936/1938? and were broken in 1943, when the allies invaded SouthItaly.

but for me this seems a bit weird that Mussolini would agree to be Allied with Adolf Hitler, as Mussolini declared during a conversation with Nahoum Goldman, that he were a Zionist.

My question for you clever guys is, can you explain this important event in Italy and Germany's History for me.

If you are able to explain this to me, i would like the source where you gathered your information from.

Thank you.

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Were there any memoirs relating to Hitler's service in WWI?

My aunt's father was a soldier in Hitler's unit during the first world war. She had pictures of the two of them together, but they were lost in a house fire when I was a kid. I'd like to know if there's any sort of first hand reports or biographical/autobiographical work about Hitler during that period of time which might also mention/comment about his unit mates in the war, that I could pass on to her. I just checked Mein Kampf, and it's somewhat self-centered to say the least and doesn't mention a single other soldier. Any suggestions?

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Is there any history of major agency conflict in the U.S. government?

In modern popular culture, there are numerous depictions of different government agencies in conflict. The reasons for this range from competition over funding, conflicting goals, ect.

A few examples (some spoilers if you watch/play these):

  • In the X Files where there is conflict over whether or not the existence of Aliens should be public knowledge

  • In the Grand Theft Auto video games series, two fictional government organizations called The Agency (likely the CIA) and the FIB (likely the FBI) are constantly in conflict over funding, taking credit for cases, and controlling witnesses

  • In the show Sons of Anarchy, the Federal case against a motorcycle gang is not brought up because leaders of a drug cartel they're selling weapons too work for the CIA.

My questions are the following:

  1. While these are all fiction, is there any basis in fact?

  2. What are other moments in the post-WWII era in which U.S. governmental agencies were in conflict with each other.

1 Answers 2015-12-10

How did Crimean Greeks and Jews survive two thousand years of invasions and conquests with their cultures intact?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Does Islam descend from Nestorianism? Is there any relationship there?

I found this family tree of religion circulating on Facebook, and while it's a beautiful, "we're all one big family" kind of sentiment, is there any truth to the connections and relationships? I thought I'd ask about the big one, where they graft Islam onto the Nestorian branch of Christianity.

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Did the village used to raise the child?

As the father of a 2 year old with no family for thousands of miles, I often fantasize about having a village to help raise my child as this study: https://www.reddit.com/r/science/comments/3w7sbf/lack_of_sleep_found_to_impair_the_brains_ability/ rings all too true for me.

My question to you wonderful historians is: historically, did the village help raise the child? Or is my fantasy of the elderly in the village watching the child in the morning while the parents go off and pass out for a couple extra hours just that, a fantasy?

Thank you.

2 Answers 2015-12-10

How did the French Revolution turn into the reign of terror? Who was killed and who was doing the killing? What was the military's role in all of this?

I know there seem to have been a lot France questions today, but I've been sittin on this one for a while.

3 Answers 2015-12-10

I understand that in the medieval period of plate armor, the effectiveness of swords was limited. How often were arming swords and long swords used in this period?

Many medieval tapestries and paintings show armies on horseback on foot mostly armed with long sword or arming sword and shield. Is this true? Wouldn't most men have an axe or pole axe or mace to counter armor? Or were there still dedicated swordsmen during this period?

2 Answers 2015-12-10

When did the earliest non-rhyming poetry come into being?

2 Answers 2015-12-10

I like all kinds of beer (good, bad, hoppy, sour, stout,ect). If I were to time travel to pre-prohibition, what could expect to drink around the country?

3 Answers 2015-12-10

Why did the European powers agree to Swiss neutrality?

I know that after Switzerland was turned into the Helvetic Republic by Napoleon, they convinced the great powers of Europe to grant them neutrality. Why did the great powers agree? Wouldn't France or Austria desire Switzerland?

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in December 10 2015:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Was there much public debate about the dangers of Hitler's ideology prior to his rise?

We often cite Hitler as a clear example of the dangers of certain type of rhetoric in modern politics, but were there any examples of outspoken critics of the dangers of Nazism before the Nazis had managed to gain enough power to silence them?

1 Answers 2015-12-10

How did the sword come to be the staple, "default" weapon of soldiers during the middle ages (as opposed to axes, blunt weapons, etc.)?

Maybe it's just a construct of movies and video games, but it seems like the sword is the bread and butter weapon of soldiers during the middle ages, and that other weapons, such as axes, were far less commonly used. Is there any truth to this? And if there is, how did the sword rise in popularity?

1 Answers 2015-12-10

Why is Basque an isolated language even though it's surrounded by Romance languages? Why didn't the Indo-Europeans assimilate them like they did everyone else?

1 Answers 2015-12-10

How were Jews identified by Nazis? What happens if a Jew didn't wear the Star of David while walking on the streets in a Nazi-occupied town/city?

2 Answers 2015-12-10

[Meta] Where do you historians go for some history-themed humour?

Any good subreddits/websites/blogs you guys frequent?

I just came across this post on /r/me_irl and, as a history buff, found it really amusing. (even though the comments are filled with bad history)

sometimes /int/ and /r/polandball has some nice stuff but I would love to see more history themed humour in higher concentrations.

3 Answers 2015-12-10

4727 / 7255

Back to start