Were the Nuremberg Trials a real trial or just a show?

The world was already aware of the horrible things the third reich had done, war crimes and holocaust and everything, Germany had already lost the war, pretty much the whole world wanted Germany to be held accountable. So, were the trials a real trial where the defendants had a chance or was the outcome pretty much decided from the get go and the appearance of a trial was just to try and show the world the righteousness of the allied forces even when dealing with such a horrible regime?

1 Answers 2021-11-03

Books on Kanem Bornu

Where can I find information about Kanem Bornu, especially in the economic and military areas?

1 Answers 2021-11-03

What was lost at the burning of the library of Alexandria?

We hear that lots of ancient texts and information was lost when the Alexandria library was burned down. Is there any information as to the general topics that were destroyed? Lots of people allude to conspiracies, e.i. ancient aliens, Atlantis, magic etc. realistically is there any way of knowing the general topics and subjects of the scrolls that were destroyed?

1 Answers 2021-11-03

Why did migration era German tribes institute separate laws

I may be operating under incorrect assumptions but my impression is that the migration era Germanic tribes (Frank’s, Visigoths, etc.) kept a separate legal system for the Germanic people alongside the remnants of the Roman legal system.

Firstly is this correct? More broadly was there a legal distinction made between the tribal people and the pre-existing Roman populations of these states?

Secondly, if this distinction existed, why did it exist? The Roman Empire had emperors of a variety of different origins but those emperors do not seem to have changed the legal status of their ethnic groups. I am wondering why the Germanic kings felt more distinct from the Roman population than the Roman generals who often usurped the Roman state.

1 Answers 2021-11-03

Did any Chinese dynasty ever decided to colonize outside of southeast Asia?

I've read about some peoples on the island of Madagascar having a striking amount of Chinese DNA and I'm curious if that had happened anywhere else in the world.

1 Answers 2021-11-03

Short Answers to Simple Questions | November 03, 2021

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.
  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.
  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.
  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.
  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.
  • Academic secondary sources are prefered. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).
  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

62 Answers 2021-11-03

How did punk rock music become so intertwined with Left Wing politics?

1 Answers 2021-11-03

Why are US state capitals often smaller towns?

As a non-American, it's easy to make assumptions about what state capitals are in the US based off the largest and most famous cities there: surely, one might assume, NY is NYC, California is LA, Washington is Seattle, Florida is Miami, Oregan is Portland, Louisiana is New Orleans, Illinois is Chicago, etc.

However I was shocked to discover that in almost every state the capital is often a much smaller town that I've rarely, if ever, heard of (NY is actually Albany, California is Sacremento, Washington is Olympia, Florida is Tallahassee, etc.)

Now, there are some rare exceptions (Phoenix, Arizona and Salt Lake City, Utah notably) and I'm sure every state has their specific reasons for choosing their state capitals, but are there any general trends or overarching historical reasons why big, notable cities seem to be spurned for the capital status?

2 Answers 2021-11-03

Does the character of Achilles predate the Iliad? Was he an existing mythological character that Homer incorporated in his works or could he be Homer's creation altogether?

1 Answers 2021-11-03

In 1971, the U.S. Emergency Broadcast System was accidentally activated for 40 minutes. Are there any studies about the public's reactions? Did people commonly believe a nuclear war had started, and how did it feel like?

What I'm referring to is the Feb 20 1971 incident where the teletype operator inadvertently inserted a real Emergency Action Notification tape instead of a test tape. The message ordered radio and TV stations to cease regular programming immediately, and notify the public that regular programming had been interrupted at the request of the U.S. government due to national emergency. The mix-up was not cleared until after 40 minutes.

Here's one recording I was able to find:

http://historyofwowo.com/audio/WOWO-Bob%20SieversEBS_02-20-1971_scoped.mp3

Are there oral histories or the like that have studied how did it feel to hear a message like that during the Cold War, when - I believe - the most likely explanation that would spring into my mind at least would've been that nuclear war had finally started? What did people do upon hearing the announcement?

2 Answers 2021-11-03

What was the role of the pumpkin in pre-Columbian American agriculture?

Having grown my own pumpkins, I know that there a robust plant, capable of producing enormous vegetables. The flesh is delicious, the seeds can be roasted and eaten, and they mature late in the autumn, making an excellent crop. If the skin is left intact, they can last literally weeks outdoors in a cool autumn.

So why haven't I heard about First Nations living off of pumpkin all winter? Were there other, more productive crops? What role did the pumpkin play in their agricultural complex?

1 Answers 2021-11-03

Did the Nazis ever write/say anything about Charles Darwin and his works?

I am wonndering if there are any specific references to Darwin, evolution, and his works. It would be interesting to see an explicit mention if Darwin’s name.

1 Answers 2021-11-03

Did people back in the day experience or describe aurora borealis?

1 Answers 2021-11-03

Why was the USA adamant for Japan to surrender unconditionally? Why did they drop the atomic bombs even when they knew that Japan was ready to surrender with a few guarantees?

1 Answers 2021-11-03

I’m looking to write some historical fiction based in Scotland and would like some books about 17th or 18th century daily life on the Isle of Skye

I’d love anything about daily life, more information on clan structure, religious beliefs, etc. I’m looking for pre-Jacobite uprising, please.

Articles are also fine!

1 Answers 2021-11-03

Spanish Civil War Causes

Hi there, could anyone explain the causes of the Spanish Civil War? I've tried reading/researching and now I'm all confused. Thanks!

1 Answers 2021-11-03

What accent would Fagin have had?

Recently I read Will Eisner's graphic novel Fagin the Jew, an alternative retelling of the life of the character of the same name from Dickens's Oliver Twist. Eisner (logically) places Fagin as the descendant of Ashkenazi immigrants to England during the late 18th and early 19th centuries, as many lower-class British Jews of the time would have been. When I, a 21st-century American Jew of Sephardic descent, imagine first- or second-generation Ashki immigrants speaking English, a very specific accent comes to mind, of the sort one sees in old movies, occasionally in the older relatives of my friends, or in the modern day is mostly associated with the likes of Dr. Zoidberg. But that accent emerged in America-- did British influence produce a distinct Yiddish-British accent from the Yiddish-American one I'm familiar with? And did this accent survive long enough to be recorded, either in writing or by phonograph? What did it sound like?

1 Answers 2021-11-03

How much of China could Japan realistically occupy in WW2

As we know Japan occupied much of coastal China during world war 2. I doubt they would be able to take over china in it's entirety but I also doubt would be impossible for Japan to advance further into china if things went differently. This isn't supposed to be asking what if Japan won ww2 I'm wondering how what parts of China could they have taken over if they focused more on China rather than South east asia and the pacific ocean. A better way to put my question would be what parts of china that Japan would be best suited to japanese expansion given their logistical restraints

1 Answers 2021-11-02

How was the relationship between Qing China and the Mughal Empire? What did the Chinese think of the Mughal Emperor?

So, I know that, for a time, the Mughal Empire was the richest polity in the world. It had a rich economy, advanced technology, a large urban population, and a powerful military.

How were the Qing's dealings with the Mughals? A country so powerful would not, I assume, be treated just like any other "tributary state" or "rebel tributary" under Heaven.

Besides, I know that the Chinese notion of Mandate of Heaven had a large influence in East and Southeast Asia, with many rulers from Japan to Korea to Vietnam recognizing China as the "Middle Kingdom" (though not always) and legitimizing their rule at home by being recognized by China. They would even call themselves Emperors in their nations but never equal to the Chinese Emperor (except Japan). How was India positioned in relation to all of it?

1 Answers 2021-11-02

Why did democracy start in ancient greece?

The first known democracy in the world was in Athens. Athenian democracy developed around the fifth century B.C.E. But why did it start in Athens. ?onsidering that other city states had other ways of governing.

1 Answers 2021-11-02

Did H.H. Holmes really build a murder labyrinth, or was he just a terrible architect?

The more colorful version of this 19th Century serial killer's life is that he had a "murder castle" created; a hotel with confusing architecture, rooms designed to kill their occupants, trapdoors to drop corpses down into the cellar, and so on. Another version I've heard is that Holmes just wasn't much of an architect, and that he contracted one builder after another, so he could cheat them out of payment, and that this also played into the weird and messy layout. I've also heard that he greatly exaggerated his killings.

Was there actually a murder castle? And did Holmes actually use it to kill people?

1 Answers 2021-11-02

"There is a surviving snatch of Ennius' epic poem on the history of Rome that refers explicitly to 'the Second Punic War' in which he had fought as a Roman ally; it was written even before the third had happened." - SPQR by Mary Beard. What is the significance of this?

In Chapter 5, after noting that Romans typically define their history in terms of war, there is the excerpt from the title. What is the point being made? What is the significance?

In particular "it was written before the third had happened" seemed to imply to me that it was significant they called the war the "Second" before the third had even occurred. But this seems fairly logical after two wars; it would have been surprising to find references to the "First Punic War" in the records before the occurrence of the second.

Is there something I'm missing?

1 Answers 2021-11-02

Why did the Western Roman Empire fall? Throughout my life I have heard all sorts of reasons, ranging from economics to politics to "cultural decline" and "barbaric jnvasions" to repeat military failures and lastly climate change. So why did it fall?

Boris Johnson, current prime minister of the UK, recently claimed that the Roman Empire fell due to large amounts of uncontrolled immigration.

Now I am aware that this, probably false, claim was made to further his anti-immigration stance in politics. The claim obviously refers to the migrating Germanic tribes that entered the Roman Empire throughout its late period.

Said "barbaric invasions" combined with a "cultural decline" has long since been a favourite in pop history, a theory popularized by the British historian Edward Gibbon in his magnum opus "The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire".

However, I am aware that most contemporary historians have long since debunked this theory.

Another reason I have heard of is that the economic circumstances of the late Empire with vast and expanding inequality, worsening economic output and a corrupt bureaucracy and state lead to its fall. This is a theory I have heard espoused a few times by left-wing politicians comparing the current rising inequality in the contemporary USA (and West in general) to the late Western Roman Empire. I have to admit that due to my political biases that is one of the theories I find the most likely, but there are other theories still.

So another, more recent, theory holds that it's decline was a result of climate change. The Mediterranean climate cooled down, leading to harvest failures and widespread famine. I don't know much about the validity of this theory, but I am aware that supposedly the climate shifted a lot during the late Empire.

The last reason I have heard of is that it was a simple result of repeated military failures against external foes, compounded by internal strife (the late Empire had many civil wars and emperors who got that position through assassination and military victory as former generals) and an overstretched empire.

Of course, I have also heard all sorts of combinations of the above factors.

So the question then is: Why did the Western Roman Empire truly fell?

Source for the claim made at the beginning:

https://www.newstatesman.com/culture/history/2021/11/boris-johnsons-claim-that-the-roman-empire-fell-due-to-uncontrolled-immigration-is-wrong-and-dangerous

1 Answers 2021-11-02

Did medieval armies feature any sort of uniformity or standardization?

Would there have been any expectations or requirements as to how the nobility or soldiery were equipped or dressed, beyond simply what they could afford? Did the soldiery in any way replicate their lord’s heraldry, once that became a thing? Were there weapons exclusively meant for one tier of fighter vs. another?

1 Answers 2021-11-02

What would enslaved peoples do throughout the day when they were brought to serve a student in college in early America?

I was reading a biography on James Madison and it mentioned that he brought an enslaved person to college with him that he had inherited. I know Jefferson also brought an enslaved person to college with him. That got me wondering what exactly the enslaved person would do all day in relation to the student. Would they accompany them to class and sit next to them to be at their beck and call? Or would they be sort of imprisoned in the student's dorm room while the student had class and then serve the student when they came back? Were they permitted to leave the college campus at all? I'm interested mostly in the lives and experiences the enslaved peoples went through if any such testimony survives.

1 Answers 2021-11-02

474 / 7255

Back to start