Why did the French Revolution devolve into such violence and blood letting?

1 Answers 2015-12-01

Given the recent refuge crisis in Europe, is there any historical precedent for such a quick migration in so short of time?

3 Answers 2015-12-01

Where do the concepts of ethnicity vs. race come from, and why are some groups of people (latinos/arabs/Indians) only considered an ethnicity and not races?

Hopefully this is enough of a "history" question for this sub, also I'm talking about this from a US perspective. I'm of mixed race (mestizo and white), and have always had trouble with surveys/polls/census asking me my racial identity. The main reason is that these surveys always have white/black/asian/native/other as options for race, and then hispanic/latino as a separate question.

In my experience, this isn't just for latinos though...I don't really see options for "arab" or any of the various races/ethnicities of the indian subcontinent on surveys or the census.

I guess my question is really what has given rise to our current understanding of what constitutes a "race", and why is it generally only broken down along black vs white vs asian vs native? Additionally, you get sub-categories for races such as Asian (Vietnamese vs Korean vs Japanese, etc), but for latinos there really isn't recognition for racial difference between, say, Dominican vs Mexican vs Peruvian.

I'm guessing that the answer has something to do with linguistics and social history more than anything (why should US census differentiate various races on the Indian subcontinent), but Latinos seem much more prevalent in US society than other "foreign" races. Wouldn't it be more important to racially separate the peoples of central/south america, or am I just being biased by recent increases in latino populations in the US?

Probably enough/too many questions at this point. Any guidance would be much appreciated.

1 Answers 2015-12-01

Did roman cavalry dismount ?

So i read somewhere where it said that roman cavalry would dismount before engaging enemy. Because horses were smaller back than and fighting from horse was hard.How true is this ?

2 Answers 2015-12-01

How did the crossword become a newspaper fixture?

While doing the New York Times crossword today, I wondered about the crossword's origins in print. As a follow-up, how did the modern newspaper puzzle section (i.e. Sudoku, Kenken, etc.) come into being? This question is a bit obscure, but my curiosity is piqued. Hopefully someone can answer!

2 Answers 2015-12-01

In the Jewish bible god reviles himself infront all the people. Is there any other religion where God reviels himself in front of thousands of people?

I.e. doesn't speak via prophets, or small groups.

1 Answers 2015-12-01

Were the Crusades really in response to Muslim aggression?

Some people will tell me that they were started because of Muslim incursions into North Africa.

2 Answers 2015-12-01

What were the police like in the USSR?

Where they professional or were they bent to a certain outcome (such as certain crimes could not take place in the Soviet Union - such as murder - and so they did not happen and another cause was found)?

I have not found much in terms of historical records of Soviet era police history.

2 Answers 2015-11-30

When and how did Boston, Massachusetts first become so heavily associated with Ireland and Irish culture?

From the Boston Celtics, to the stereotypical Irish cop on the streets, to the countless movies and TV shows portraying Irish Bostonians with their typical Southie accents and shamrock tattoos, to the many Celtic Rock bands from the Boston area, it seems this phenomenon is well understood. Does Boston simply have an extremely high proportion of Irish Americans? If so, when did this immigration occur, and why Boston, as opposed to any other major American city?

If this is a phenomenon that has occurred within the past 20 years, please feel free to remove this question.

1 Answers 2015-11-30

How common was it for Roman men to marry one of their female slaves in his house?

While in an archaeology museum, I recently came across a grave marker for a woman who married her former master and had two sons with him. I was under the impression that the master could take the slave as a lover but wouldn't marry her, this marker seems to contradict that. Any information would be immensely helpful.

1 Answers 2015-11-30

Would anyone be able to tell me what Mike Duncan got wrong in his History of Rome podcast?

I've heard that he got some facts wrong. If possible, would you be able to list them for me?

1 Answers 2015-11-30

How did vikings eat while they were on ships?

And in tandem with that question, what did they eat?

4 Answers 2015-11-30

How long would it take a Viking longship to get from Norway to the shores of England?

2 Answers 2015-11-30

Why wasn't Holocaust more effective?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-11-30

Why did some people receive news of World War 1 enthusiastically when it broke out?

I have to write a paper on this topic, and I am finding a hard time coming up with talking points. The spirit of the question is not asking why war broke out (what caused it), but why some people (intellectuals and artists) thought it would be a good thing. Here is the full question:

It has been said that Europeans both dreaded and hoped for war leading up to 1914. Why did some intellectuals and artists receive news of the war enthusiastically when it broke out?

This is for a second-year university paper (2500 words) in a European history course. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2015-11-30

Need Helping Researching Sauk Tribes, Chief Black Hawk, and the Fur Trade in the Midwest during Pioneer Times.

Hello /r/AskHistorians! I need help researching Native Americans in the Plains. Since I'm from the Rock Island area, I was curious to learn more about the Sauk Tribes and Chief BlackHawk. I'm working on a screenplay that has two half brothers (one 1/2 Native Am, one full) join together to fight a common enemy that controls much of the fur trade. I want to know where I should look for information on early White settlers in the 1800s Midwest, and the Natives during this time period. Although I may take some liberties historically, I would like the Native Americans be authentic and accurate.

So here's a background. Thank you all in advance, anything will help!

Screenplay Background:

    Setting: "Pioneer Times" in the Midwest.
    Protagonists: Same Native mother, different fathers.
    Premise: Brothers team-up to find a common enemy.

Writer Goals:


    Cinematic like a classic western
    Honest portrayal of the Natives
   Accurate portrayal of Fur Trade 
    Characters: well rounded, dynamic, and most importantly, authentic.

1 Answers 2015-11-30

In Rome if a slave annoyed it's owner could they kill it without fear of repercussions?

What where the repercussions of slave murder?

2 Answers 2015-11-30

Scottish Stone Carved Rabbit Dish. Xpost from r/whatisthisthing

Scottish Rabbit In December 2004 I went on a Christmas trip with my company at the time to a hotel on the banks of Loch Lomond. On the first morning with a raging hangover me and a mate went for a walk around the Loch to clear our heads.

In a densely-wooded, muddy part of the shoreline I found myself looking down (mainly because the marshy ground was difficult to negotiate) and I saw something odd sticking partially out of the mud. I dug it out, washed it a little bit and took it back down to London with me after the weekend finished.

Since then to now I've not done anything with it but it's always intrigued me. It's made of stone of some kind, appears old (to me, at least) and apart from the carvings and wear is unmarked, oh, and is a rabbit.

Anyone got any suggestions on possible age or potential next steps?

Location was roughly here: https://www.google.co.uk/maps/place/56%C2%B000'47.3%22N+4%C2%B036'15.0%22W/@56.0131522,-4.6050616,295m/data=!3m2!1e3!4b1!4m2!3m1!1s0x0:0x0

Xpost from https://www.reddit.com/r/whatisthisthing/comments/3upspv/scottish_rabbit/

2 Answers 2015-11-30

How did Calvinism influence Lutheranism in the Americas (specifically re: crucifixes)?

I know, this is a super specific question, but hopefully someone can answer it! I'm a Lutheran myself. My church (in New York) does not use the crucifix displaying the body of Christ, just a plain cross. The Wikipedia article says:

Martin Luther did not object to [crucifixes], and this was among his differences with Andreas Karlstadt as early as 1525. Luther at the time of the Reformation retained the crucifix in the Lutheran Church. Only in America, where Lutheranism came under the influence of Calvinism, was the plain cross used.

But the article cited for this paragraph (which is on a church website) just says the same thing verbatim.

So two questions:

  1. What sort of "influence" did Calvinism have on Lutheran settlers in the Americas?

  2. Is this changing in Europe today? A quick Google search shows a lot of European Lutheran churches using the plain cross.

1 Answers 2015-11-30

What are the evidences used for dating the construction of the Great Pyramid of Giza to 2580–2560 BC?

1 Answers 2015-11-30

I'm confused as to how Eratosthenes was able to calculate the circumference of the Earth

[deleted]

3 Answers 2015-11-30

I'm Looking to Research Korean Culture From the Past Century or So. Where Can I Find Resources For That?

For personal reasons, I've become very invested in Korean history and culture. I have quite a bit of information in regards to the Sejong Era of Korean history, but I can find little in the way of more modern history, especially for the past century. For the stuff I do find, it's invariably A) More about North Korea and its relation to South Korea and inevitably B) The Korean War. It's as if that's all Western historians care about in regards to Korea, which I find somewhat depressing.

I want to know how Korea turned from what was essentially a backwater at the turn of the 20th century, literally cut in half by a war, and in 50 short years became one of the most advanced, richest countries on the planet. And I believe this can be attributed to its history, particularly its history in the 19th and 20th centuries. I know in regards to the 20th century the Korean War had something to do with that, but that simply can't be the only thing.

So I'm looking for anything and everything that can help me out here. Books, documentaries, podcasts, you name it, I want it. My google-fu has failed me in this regard, and although there's some information I can find by perusing Korean texts, my Hangul isn't good enough to make reading them not a chore.

1 Answers 2015-11-30

What were the most important cities in the newly formed US?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-11-30

Did any factory ever exist before the industrial revolution? Were "ancient factories" a thing? Could the mass production line have been discovered independently before the 19th century?

1 Answers 2015-11-30

How do historians feel about Graham Hancock? I just discovered his books and they seem interesting, is he a kook or does his theories hold weight?

1 Answers 2015-11-30

4756 / 7255

Back to start