How do we know that early human civilizations primarily used stone arrow heads as opposed to sharpened wooden shafts, and that the reason that we see so many stone arrow heads is because the wooden ones have rotten away?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

Why did Napoleon refuse the Frankfurt proposal?

He was vastly out numbered by this point, and all Europe was marching against him. Did he believe he could still win? Did he believe he could get better terms than France's natural borders and retaining his throne?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

During U.S. slavery, were black families primarily matriarchy?

Is that were we get the 'Mammy' archetype?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

Why were early Christian texts written in Greek, instead of Aramaic?

Aramaic was the language Jesus and his disciples spoke; and it was the primary language of the Levant at the time. Why would the texts of a religion that originates from the Levant be written in Greek? A regular Jew or Syrian would not be able to read or understand Greek.

1 Answers 2015-11-25

Role of malaria in depopulation of Roman Italy?

I'm currently reading John Norwich's history of Byzantinum, and he mentions the spread of malaria in Italy and the subsequent population decline as being a factor in Constantine's decision to move the capital east. Why did malaria suddenly become worse around this time? And was malaria a factor in the long term decline of Roman Italy?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

Did Vietnam have a policy of trying to dominate or bring in its sphere of influence Laos and Cambodia? If so what happened?

I read a little bit about this only when looking at Chinese history. I wanted to see if anyone had more information on this.

1 Answers 2015-11-25

Native Americans and thanksgiving

I've married into a small native American tribe, the Lumbee tribe. With thanksgiving right around the corner it has me wishing I knew more about the history of my wife's people (and my future children's history). Anyone have insight on the history of the Lumbee's and other small eastern tribes. What was their culture like? Have a great reference? I've become very interested in the smaller tribes as they aren't well known and often overlooked. Thanks!

1 Answers 2015-11-25

Why is the black Egyptians hypothesis not accepted?

I have a lot of friends who've become black nationalists recently and they talk a lot about the Egyptians being black. I've looked it up and there doesn't seem to be much written on it. What I have read basically says that it is impossible to attach modern motions of race to an ancient peoples but that seems like a cop out to me. If that is true, then why? What makes it impossible?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

How far into WWII did the involved parties realize/accept that they were indeed in the midst of a second world war?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

The website Geacron, which offers year-by-year maps of the world from 3000 BC to present, shows a massive change in the shape of the Persian Gulf between 609 and 608 BC. Is this at all accurate? And if so, what the heck happened?

These two images show what happens when you click over from -609 to -608.

http://imgur.com/a/ueqSO

I discovered it by accident, and was quite surprised. Nothing I could find about those years indicated any kind of large-scale public works project or ecological event that could have caused the entire gulf to recede so far.

Did something like this really happen? What might have been the cause?

3 Answers 2015-11-25

Is there any similarities to the Protestant Reformation and the current wars in the middle east?

Both have poli-religious groups trying to gain territory and impose religious rule in some way. Is there any similarities?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

What were the career trends before Wall Street?

I'm wondering what the "hot" sectors were historically in the U.S., prior to the rise of Wall Street (and now Silicon Valley). What kind of jobs did the top talent gravitate towards?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

Before the Iranian Revolution, was there ever interest from either side for Iran to join NATO?

I know Iran and West were fairly close before the revolution, and probably US's closest ally in the region besides Israel. As far as I understand they even had exclusive access to some US military equipment that even other allies didn't have access to (F14).

So my question is this, Was there every any interest/attempt from either side to have Iran join NATO?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

To what extent is Western colonialism responsible for the current conflict in the Middle East? Is it the sole/major cause?

Hello all,

A friend of mine (who is a teacher) recently posted a link to the Sykes-Picot agreement, with the comment: "The West is to blame for all the chaos in the Middle East, here's more proof". As an amateur historian, I know that conflicts are almost never this black and white, but I don't feel confident enough in my grasp of Middle Eastern history to answer this myself. Perhaps I am completely wrong, but I feel that the conflicts in question are much more complicated than this.

Just to clarify, I'm asking about the modern day consequences of actions taken by Western powers from the colonial era to the end of decolonization (around the time that most Middle Eastern states achieved independence). Thank you in advance!

2 Answers 2015-11-25

What is the historical origin and significance behind the direction of fabric folds in clothing?

So here's a multi-part question I'd love to get some more information on, from both the Eastern and Western perspective.

  1. In general Western clothing, men's clothing goes left over right, and women's clothing right over left. When and why did this become a thing?

  2. In traditional Eastern clothing, robe-like clothing is worn left over right regardless of gender. I have read sources that say that this is to accommodate things being stored in the robe that could be easily accessed with the right hand. Is this correct? As I understand it, in Japanese culture, wearing the robe in the other manner signifies funeral wear. My parents (Chinese-Taiwanese) have told me that the direction of the robe is irrelevant in Chinese culture, and I've had some Vietnamese friends tell me the same as well. Is there any reason that the Japanese have a different view of the direction of fabric folds, or was this a common mentality in East Asia that has slowly faded everywhere but Japan, etc. etc. etc.?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

In the ancient/ medieval world, How common was it for Kings/ Princes/ Generals to join in on the front lines of battle during war, not out of necessity but solely because they enjoyed fighting?

I remember reading an account of an English King who enjoyed fighting in battle so much that he disguised himself as a knight in order to get his hands dirty amongst his soldiers (I unfortunately don't remember his name). How often did this happen? Were there any famous accounts of such things happening and are there any factual accounts /stories that are available to research or read about? Are there any great stories of victory on the battlefield because of brave Kings or Generals taking part or alternately any famous stories of mishaps that resulted in the loss of elite/ royal lives or toppling of kingdoms or empires due to certain overzealous leaders galloping down from the hillsides to their unnecessary deaths because they liked to fight?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

How did European 'knights' of the middle ages reconcile their supposed devotion to the God of the Bible with the fact that they slew fellow Christians in battle?

I am aware that in most battles, knights would typically avoid conflict with one another for reasons along these lines. Even if a knight is on the other side of the field from you, he is still your 'brother' and fellow Christian, and thus slaying him is of little appeal. Yet why would knights so readily slay peasants and mercenaries, when they too were fellow Christians?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

Why did St. Thomas Aquinas find it necessary to prove the existence of God? Were not most people theists?

3 Answers 2015-11-25

Paleography

Does anyone have a good resource for learning more on this subject?

1 Answers 2015-11-25

How did europeans know of lions?

We often see Lions on european coat of arms, and even as far back as the Mycynae civilization with the lion gates of Mycynae, and the ancient greek myth of the nemean lion. My question is, how did these europeans know of how lions looked like? Were there any lions in Europe/Greece that went extinct? And even if there were, how did Scandinavians adopt that said symbol?

1 Answers 2015-11-24

I have my great uncle's POW journal from stalag 17b with incredible artwork and poetry from all the prisoners. How should I go about sharing it?

So as the title says, I have my great uncle's red cross POW diary/journal from while was in Stalag 17b for 2 years during WW2. He was a radio man on a flying fortress that got shot down. The journal contains typical journal entries about life in the stalag, a few pages of etchings of quite a lot of dog tags of other prisoners, some newspaper clippings, even a preserved flower on one page taped in, but mainly a lot of artwork and poetry. It got passed around and many different prisoners contributed to it. It is in very, very, very good shape.

Along with the journal I have all the original western union telegrams to his family, including notification of MIA, POW, etc. along with all his various medals.

So now down to brass tacks, how to go about sharing this with the world?

I've very carefully taken high quality (in a light box) photographs of every page. The artwork and poetry is truly astounding and it's all in very good shape. It also has day to day life stuff, such as the food menu (note this was a quick bad photo not one from the light box)

It's the only journal of its type i've ever seen. I've asked WW2 museums about it before and none had one nor really knew much about them. It seems very few of them survived intact to modern times.

I really do want to share all the artwork and poetry with the world, i'm just debating how. It really is almost publishable. E-book? actual book? Imgur album? Make an actual website with sections for poetry, artwork, and day to day life?

I've been planning on at the least sending a good copy of it to the 8th air force museum/historian (he was a radio man on a flying fortress in the 8th). They have been very helpful in my research, providing me with info about his plane, the crash report, etc. I'd like to someday track down the families of his fellow crew members and share this all with them.

This is not something i'll ever sell, though I have been told the collection as a whole could be worth a lot, but i'm truly not interested in that. I do just want to share it with the world, as corny as that sounds. However, as of now I don't believe my family is willing to give it up to a museum, someday maybe, but not yet.

Any thoughts or advice? Thanks and apologies for the long post.

4 Answers 2015-11-24

The Death of Fascism: How did Fascism "evaporate" so quickly while "The Socialist Movement" still exists today?

Long title, I know, and it may not explain my question the best.

So, for a while Fascism existed as a kind of legitimate ideology; at least in the sense that it did have a major impact in multiple countries and gave birth to parties striving to put fascist ideals into practice. After the horrors it unleashed in WWII for the most part Fascism as an ideology kind of just... well, died off. There exists far-right nationalist groups, of course, but as any kind of "legitimate" ideology it has been thoroughly discredit by the wider world and ultimately rejected.

Even today many "fascist" groups generally place an emphasis on racial politics and nativism rather than the other aspects of Fascism such as national fraternity, radical change, opposition to Marxism, so on.

The Socialist movement, comparatively, has managed to survive the fall of the Soviet Union, even if it's been bloodied. You still have some openly Socialist politicians making waves with people, some nations openly aligning themselves based off of "Socialist" economic models, heck you even have a few very light "Socialist" works and views gaining popularity.

What I want to ask is why, by comparison, does it seem like Fascism just up and died as any significant ideology after WWII when Socialism is doing comparatively alright? Both sides horrifying acts committed in their name and both sides suffered a large blow when the major nations pushing "Socialism/Fascism" up and died. Can any Historians point to an exact time where Fascism as an ideology just up and dropped out of relevance? Did any kind of openly Fascist groups anywhere see a light revival during the cold war because of their opposition to Marxism?

I'm intrigued.

4 Answers 2015-11-24

Were there ruins of earlier civilizations that the Greeks puzzled over and wondered about?

1 Answers 2015-11-24

How did America gain its artillery fire data in World War II?

The most recent episode of the AskHistorians podcast has the special guest(who's name I have shamefully forgotten) claim that American doctirine was developed from French techniques of pre-testing fire locations and then applying that technique on a much greater geographical scale starting in 1941, implied to be data from across Europe. But what exactly were the logistics of such pre-fire study? Was it tested out before the war? How did they update that data as the war went on?

1 Answers 2015-11-24

Was Stalin really a Tsarist informer?

I'm listening to the audiobook "Bridge of Spies" while I pretend to work and the author makes this claim. I'm aware that it isn't really an academic book though. I did some googling and couldn't find much.

What do historians think about this?

1 Answers 2015-11-24

4771 / 7255

Back to start