Did people in the 19th century talked as pompous as the letters they wrote?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

What rights did slaves have in the United States prior to abolition?

We have all been taught about the atrocious treatmeant of slaves in the American south with regards to their basic human rights. I recently learned about the treatmeant of slaves in ancient Rome, where a slave could be killed by their master with no questions asked. Considering slavery continued in the United States well into the post-englightenment age, were black slaves granted any sort of rights "guaranteed" by law or even common social norms?

P.S. it's "guaranteed" because I doubt an 1854 South Carolina jury would give a fair and honest trial to a slave.

1 Answers 2021-10-28

What were the political positions of the Democratic and Republican Parties excluding their positions on slavery during the Civil War and Reconstruction?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Was Leclerc acting Independently or Under Direction from the French Government?

I'm watching a documentary series on al-Jazeera about the end of the French empire and it featured a meeting between then-president de Gaulle and then-insurgent Ho Chi Minh in Paris. Whilst this meeting was going on, general Leclerc declared independence for Vietnam. Ho Chi Minh returned and it seems he felt like he'd been double-crossed.

My question, and the reason for this post is, whether there is any conclusion as to whether General Leclerc was acting on his own or under direction from Paris? Many thanks for addressing this question.

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Was having a tan considered an ugly "working class" trait in the Victorian era?

Going through school, I was told by many a literature teacher that - in the Victorian era - the gentry were careful to stay out of the sun. This was because having a tan was a very "working class" thing to have.

However, it seems to me that all the famous explorers - some of whom were upper class - would almost definitely have had a tan right?

Is there any truth to this at all?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

How accurate is Wikipedia's article on Roman slavery?

I read the part where it says Nero gave slaves the right to sue their masters, how Antoninus Pius made it homicide to murder a slave without cause etc.

The only source for these claims is a book that is only indirectly related to slavery, i.e. "Prostitution, sexuality, and the law in ancient Rome" by Thomas A.J. McGinn

It doesn't seem particularly credible to me. Did these things actually happen? How well was this enforced if it did?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Did 1930-1940s Germany ever ban or discourage drinking beer?

I know that Germany banned smoking and hard spirits during the 30s and 40s, but considering how culturally significant beer is in Germany and them being extremely nationalized was it ever considered to be banned or discouraged from drinking.

One part of me is it would during world war II for food shortage reasons but not cultural reasons. But other part of me thinks that because beer is so significant to Germany they would pride themselves on still having it.

I'm sure there's some exact answer to this question and I'm just not wording this the best way I can. This is my first time posting here so I hope you guys can answer some of my questions. Thank you.

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Brief explanation of the Battle of Kursk?

Hello,

I am making a small website and I want to write a very small and brief article (about 100 words) about the Battle of Kursk. The problem is that it's very expensive topic and I don't know how to shortly explain it.

Could you please help me?

Thank you in advance!

Wish you nice day!

1 Answers 2021-10-28

How do historians working in one language account for work in their subfield written in another language? Is it common for historians to disagree with one another without even knowing on account of language barriers?

Even though English is the de facto academic lingua franca in the West, I'm sure there is still ample amounts of history written in other Western languages, let alone nonwestern ones. The vast majority of this history goes untranslated, whether its in Italian, Arabic, or Mandarin, and is therefore inaccessible for most historians who do not speak those languages. Do historians who only speak one language go out of their way to examine historiographical developments?

7 Answers 2021-10-28

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | October 28, 2021

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

9 Answers 2021-10-28

I'm a soapmaker by trade and I was wondering how were soapmakers viewed in the past? Was it a lowly profession or a respectable one?

I know that Yardley is the official soap provider to the English royal family and has been for ages, so some soapmakers must have been respected at least somewhat.

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Why didn't they use ceramic armor in the renaissance / gunpowder age?

Today ballistic vest plates are offered in two materials: steel or ceramic. If historical knight's armor would get penetrated by muskets, why couldn't they just wear a ceramic plate underneath some linen plate carrier? Wouldn't this be effective at stopping musket shots, even if it's just one time use? Why didn't Napoleon think of this?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Help finding credible factual resources

I'm writing an argumentative speech titled "black history month is still relevant". I'm struggling to find any actual factual evidence to support my arguments for why black history month is still valid. Can you suggest any sources that can be used as evidence?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Questions about this sub

whenever I open a post, it only shows me the bot answer, and many of the Words are in red. Although it says there are 9 or more responses, I don’t get them except the bot.
Im new to Reddit, what’s going on?

thanks.

1 Answers 2021-10-28

If the one of the leading causes of anti-Umayyad sentiment leading up to the Abbasid revolution was the Umayyads continuing to levy the jizya on converts, how did the Abbasids make up the difference in receipts? Did they institute new taxes or was their tax income lower compared to the Umayyads?

I read In God's Path: The Arab Conquests and the Creation of an Islamic Empire by Robert Hoyland a few years ago and he ends with the Abbasid Revolution. One of the letters he quoted is an Umayyad governor complaining about people converting leaving him without money to pay his garrison (I think, at least, my memory is a bit foggy on exactly what it was). But the argument Hoyland was making was that the Umayyads needed to continue taxing converts because their expenditures were calibrated to tax revenues prior to the population converting.

So that makes me wonder how the Abbasids afforded to run their empire if they abolished taxes on converts without having instituted anything new, so I presume they did have some newer forms of taxation, but I don't know so I'm asking here!

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Is there any sort of modern day equivalent to the library of Alexandria?

Recently I’ve learned about the library of Alexandria and love the idea of people in ancient times having a central hub of general knowledge that could be used for the betterment of everybody. What surprised me was how they sent people out to the corners of the known world to try and find anything they could get their hands on. Even people who would pass through the city by land or port would have all their books and stuff copied and were given the copied version while the original stayed in the library.

Now I know Wikipedia is a thing obviously, but is there anything else that has a system similar to the library where it’s a vast system of archived knowledge while also actively looking for more knowledge to add, so much so that people who wanted to access books would have to submit their own? I guess Wikipedia might be the closest we can come in today’s world, I just really like the idea of it in ancient times.

1 Answers 2021-10-28

By the time of the Muslim conquest of Egypt, what religion did most Egyptians practice?

Was Ancient Egyptian religion still widely practiced? Was Christianity more prevalent?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Why did all of civilization just happen in the last 10000 years?

Anatomically, we haven't changed much in the last 300000 years, we've lived in North Africa and the Near East for at least 100000, so why did we seemingly sit around for 90 thousand years and then suddenly, invent farming and found egypt?

AND seemingly independently, on the other side of the world, they Maya seem to do the same thing, roughly at the same time?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

When defeated by his foe Yuan Shao, Three Kingdoms-era general Gongsun Zan committed suicide by setting himself on fire after killing nearly his entire family. Was this jaw-dropping act a sign of insanity or does this have some precedent or meaning behind it?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Why aren't there more sources from the Spanish perspective about the Arab conquest of Spain in 711-720?

I'm researching the fall of the Visigoth Kingdom and I can't really find much information about it outside of a single source from an Egyptian scholar who wrote about it from the perspective of the Umayyads. Why is there no documentation about this event from any European historians? All I can come across is work about the Reconquista and Charlemagne's exploits, but nothing about the initial invasion or the deposition of the visigoth throne

1 Answers 2021-10-28

How did Nelson Mandela go from being seen as a terrorist to being seen as an inspirational figure similar to Gandhi and MLK?

I want to preface this by saying that I personally don't see Nelson Mandela as a terrorist.

I'm referring more to the perception of him. Margaret Thatcher called him a terrorist, and Apartheid South Africa was a Western ally throughout the Cold War. So when and how did he begin to be viewed (in the West) as this heroic leader like MLK.

Also, I feel like his image was heavily sanitized; he supported Castro and opposed Israel, but Obama gave a speech at his funeral. How did this happen?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

The United Nations is famous for gridlock and doing nothing controversial. But the "American," side of the Korean war was actually under the auspices of The United Nations. So how did the UN get behind a major "side," in an Asian land war in 1950? How did it escape the battery of vetoes?

2 Answers 2021-10-28

How did America elect Senators?

From what I’ve read, until around 1912, American Senators were chosen by State legislatures. How did that work and how were State Senators chosen? Do you have any recommendations on early America’s system of government? Sorry if my question isn’t clear.

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Why did Nazi-Germany attack the USSR and therefore opening up a second front without first defeating the UK and her allies? A war on two fronts is exactly what led to the defeat of Germany in WW1.

It would've made sense to take out the UK first as Germany already had a non-agression pact with the USSR. My thinking was Germany first defeats the UK and get her to sign an armistice giving Germany a "free hand" in continental Europe. Then Germany turns their entire war machine to the USSR.

1 Answers 2021-10-28

Martin Luther King is seen as a hero by almost everyone, but how popular was he during his major campaigns and at the end of his life?

1 Answers 2021-10-28

480 / 7255

Back to start