Was White Man Runs Him’s name considered an insult?

While reading Stephen Ambrose’s Crazy Horse and Custer, the Crow scout White Man Runs Him’s name stands out as an insulting nickname - but was it? Wikipedia says he was also known as White Buffalo Who Turns Around, bugg the unclear when. Were Crow or other tribes given to re-naming people based on events or characteristics, and was this neutral, a joke, or an insult?

1 Answers 2021-10-27

Why wouldn’t have western culture/Europeans have at least suspected that there might be a huge landmass across the Atlantic? Were there never any rumors or myths? Did it seriously take until the 1490s until someone in Europe decided to go take a look?

1 Answers 2021-10-27

Do we have a general idea of how many people participated in the Holocaust?

As in: people who worked in death camps (excluding forced labor, of course), rounded up people for the death camps, or knowingly played a part in the supply chain, bureaucracy or planning of the Holocaust.

1 Answers 2021-10-27

Reading recommendations: Druids, Boudicca and Iceni..

Obv doesn’t have to be same book. Just looking for an up to date book on Boudicca, not a modern translation of Tacitus. Also, a book on the druids. Source material would be fine, but Romans being Romans, probably not accurate. Druidic culture, practices…though again, non written material culture, I’m sure it’s hard to find accurate reporting.

1 Answers 2021-10-27

Could Harold Bluetooth have been secretly pagan?

1 Answers 2021-10-26

How and when did salt became something so coomon in cooking ?

EDIT: Salt has been used for quite a long time, but during the Antiquity, the Middle-Age etc ... it was quite expensive, like a luxury. Nowadays, salt is really common and cheap, when did it became that way ? And how ?

2 Answers 2021-10-26

Did kids actually have to kill their frogs before dissecting them in the 80s?

Was watching ET and at one part Elliot is in biology while ET is getting hammered and watching tv, and the scene involves all the kids giving live frogs chloroform cotton balls and suffocating them or whatever before dissecting. Was that actually standard practice in public school biology in the 80s and earlier?

In my biology class in 2001 or 2002 or whenever they brought in already dead and preserved/bloodless refrigerated frogs. There was clearly an entire industry dedicated to providing dead and easy to dissect frog cadavers to public schools. Did that service not exist 40 years ago? They just brought in dozens of live frogs and had the kids passively kill them and watch them slowly die before dissecting their fresh bloody corpse like little Jeffrey Dahmers?

Also did they really do that when kids where 10 like Elliot was? That’s like elementary school age. Pretty sure we were all like 13-14 when we did it 20 years later.

1 Answers 2021-10-26

Was Queen Elizabeth I really a virgin?

Publicly she was known as the virgin queen but was this really true? I just cannot imagine someone living to 69 and never having any interest in sex.

1 Answers 2021-10-26

I want to form an comprehensive opinion on the Soviet Union. What sources of information can you recommend?

I‘ve heared a lot said about the Soviet Union and how bad / great it was. I live in Germany, so my school education has been very negative in regard to Socialism in general and the Soviet Union and Eastern Bloc in particular, but we rarely actually talked in detail about anything. Now, online I‘ve heared more diverse voices, with some not only highlighting successes, but even suggesting that it was a great place to live, actually.

I think it‘s safe to say that a lot of the (especially non-scientific) discourse on the topic is unsurprisingly incredibly biased. So, I‘ve decided I‘m done with that. I actually want to learn, in detail and from a reliable, scientific and unbiased (as much as it gets, at least) source about the political structure, economic organization, history and culture of the Soviet Union.

My goal is to use the information I gain to understand the successes and shortcomings of the Soviet Union so I‘m able to form a political opinion about Soviet-style socialism and to learn the lessons of what things could be useful and what should be avoided if one doesn‘t want to repeat the mistakes of the past.

I know that achieving this will take lots of time, but for now I‘d just like some beginner-literature with maybe an overview of the most important matters for a start.

I‘m very much a beginner to this topic, but I do have a roughly above-average historical knowledge of the 21st century. I‘m familiar with philosophy, political philosophy and leftist ideas (including Marx), but nothing from Lenin, Trotsky, Salin etc if that helps.

Thanks in advance!:)

1 Answers 2021-10-26

At what point did Napoleon's French Imperial Eagles become a tool to demoralize French troops rather than inspire esprit de corps amongst them?

As I'm listening through Andrew Roberts' Napoleon: A Life, I continue to see a recurring theme where capturing Imperial Eagles becomes a measure of defeat for Napoleon especially past 1812. For example,

Krasnoi in 1812:

The Russians claimed 13,000 killed, 26,500 captured, 133 guns and fifteen colours, standards and eagles taken, as well as Marshal Davout's baton

Leipzig in 1813:

The Allies captured 15,000 able-bodied Frenchmen, 21,000 wounded or sick, 325 guns,[4] 28 eagles, standards, or colours, and most of the French supply trains. Six French generals were killed, 12 wounded, and 36 captured including Lauriston and Reynier[4]

Waterloo in 1815:

The Greys captured the eagle of the 45th Ligne and overwhelmed Grenier's brigade. These would be the only two French eagles captured by the British during the battle.

Likewise from what I gleaned Napoleon remained tight-lipped on these losses while underreporting troop casualties. Were these Imperial Eagles prized by opposing forces for their rarity, monetary value, or as a psychological tool of conquest against Napoleon? If a psychological tool, do we have any evidence of leadership directing forces to concentrate on seizing these eagles above all else?

1 Answers 2021-10-26

How did breast feeding work before the invention of formula?

As I await the arrival of my first child I'm learning a lot about breast feeding and the challenges that many women face with it. Either they have a baby that's bad at latching or their supply never comes in adequately or any number of other issues come up that prevent feeding properly. How did society deal with this problem before the invention of other foods for babies? I can't imagine the baby was just left to die. What did a widowed dad do if his wife died in childbirth?

1 Answers 2021-10-26

What is the cultural/historical background of sentient pink blobs in Japanese media (think Chansey, Clefairy, Jigglypuff, Kirby, Majin Buu)?

2 Answers 2021-10-26

I am gladiator in ancient Rome. How do i look? How much freedom I have? How much I earn. How not to die fast?

1 Answers 2021-10-26

When did the animosity between Protestants and Catholics in the United States die down? Are there any identifiable root causes for this decline?

1 Answers 2021-10-26

What factors led to Azerbaijan, a Muslim nation having generally good relations with Israel?

Azerbaijan is unique in that it's one of the few Middle Eastern countries that has friendly relations with Israel. Is this due to being a part of the Soviet Union which de emphasized religious beliefs, or because of economic relations?

1 Answers 2021-10-26

Best English translation of The Alexiad

Hi, doing a history paper on Anne of comnena and I was gathering resources. I was wondering which translation is the best or most accurate. Also any other resources would be greatly appreciated :) thanks in advanced!

1 Answers 2021-10-26

How true is the common argument that the introduction of gunpowder weapons in medieval Europe slowly shifted the balance of power away from the nobility towards the non-noble classes, as now anyone with 2 weeks of training could defeat a heavily armoured knight?

Whereas previously armies depended a lot on warriors from the nobility, which trained hard for years with the sword and lance and wore heavy armour, now any common peasant could defeat said armour, training and sword with just two weeks of training and a well placed shot. This in turn shifted the power balance slowly in favour of the non-noble classes.

How true is that statement?

And did the crossbow have a similar effect?

1 Answers 2021-10-26

Can one account by a biased ancient historian be taken as legitimate proof that an artifact existed? Alternative title: Zosimus' Necklace Legend

I have been really into Ancient civilizations since I was very little but recently I started reading about Rome. I grew interested in the Vestal Virgins and began to read about them. During that, I found an account by a Greek historian (Zosimus) concerning the last vestal virgin, an artifact I had never heard of in an academic source before, and the niece of Theodosius I (named Serena). The legend is recounted here 0490-0510,_Zosimus,_Historia_Nova_(Green_and_Chaplin_AD_1814),_EN.pdf (documentacatholicaomnia.eu) on page 69, 2nd paragraph. Essentially, Serena steals an artifact known as Rhea Silvia’s necklace from a statue inside a temple. I can find no other mention of this artifact (except the claims of this Robin Rivers person who says it can be found in The Sibylline Chronicles but I looked and couldn’t find it), which I find odd as Rhea was the mother of Romulus, the legendary founder.

The questions in bold are the ones I really would like answered if anyone doesn't have the time to do them all. I know these are a lot of questions and I've posted them previously without any answers, but I really am curious. Thank you.

1) Do historians believe the artifact existed based on Zosimus’ account?

  1. Are there other sources on this- either academic or mythological?

  2. Is Zosimus' account considered too biased against Christians to accept it as proof the necklace existed? That after the downfall of Serena and her family, he formed a tale to explain it as the actions of pagan gods on "impious" Christians?

4)If an artifact is lost to time (or hasn't been found), how do historians determine if it likely existed?

And what is the "threshold" historians have when it comes

1 Answers 2021-10-26

Are there any good cultural/social histories of Greater Yankeedom (the Puritans and their descendants throughout the Northern USA)? Especially interested in the 19th century.

I recently read Howe's What Hath God Wrought and was struck by the amazing cultural dynamism of this region c. 1815 - 1848. It produced so many inventors, innovators, reformers, writers, and zealots while largely maintaining a coherence within a greater nation. I am curious if there are any works which focus on the culture (institutional, religious, educational, political, and literary) of this region (New England + those areas settled by New Englanders, which I believe this map of Liberty Party voters in 1844 does a good job of approximating). I find the early period (c. 1620 - 1820) interesting, and I find it later subsumption into the general US culture (c. 1877 - present?) interesting too, but I really find the Golden Age of Yankee democracy, expansion, and "improvement" (in Howe's phrase) utterly fascinating. This is the period where they formed thousands of self-organized groups to fight slavery, to spread the gospel, and to make heaven on earth, even as many also had a deeply contradictory relationship in their treatment of Catholic immigration and capitalist industrialization. I know these dates are completely arbitrary, but I figure including them is better than not.

There are a couple of books which I already have read and enjoyed which cover aspects of this period:

  • Howe's What Hath God Wrought has great sections on this period (inspiring the question)
  • Nancy Cott's Bonds of Womanhood does a good job covering the role of women in this region during the early republican period.
  • David Hackett Fischer's Albion's Seed covers the legacy of England on New England.

The aspects I am most interested in are:

  • Development and contestation of post-Puritan religion (c. 1800 - 1900)
  • The role of voluntary organizations
  • The tensions of industrialization in one of the most equal societies of its scale
  • The role of elites (the Adamses, the Beechers, the Brahmins, Harvard) within said society which valued equality so highly
  • The landscape of literature, from the remembered (Thoreau), to the important (Beecher-Stowe), to what people actually read (I am sure much of it I have never heard of)
  • The dissolving of the sense of a coherent "Yankeedom" in the later 19th and 20th centuries.

Thank you for anyone with any recommendations

1 Answers 2021-10-26

City of Bergen in the Hanseatic League

I am interested about the history of the Norwegian City of Bergen during the Hanseatic League time. Anyone has a bibliography to shere (in English)?

Thank you!

2 Answers 2021-10-26

AskHistorians Podcast 185 - Jinn and Streaming History with Laura Castro-Royo

AskHistorians Podcast Episode 185 is live!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. If there is another index you'd like the podcast listed on, let us know!

This Episode

I talk to Laura Castro-Royo about her research on Jinn, the source of Hollywood's "genie" trope. She also talks about presenting history in non-traditional spaces, including streaming on Twitch as Las Plumas De Simurgh.

You can check Laura out on all kinds of platforms here:

Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/lasplumasdesimurgh

Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/lasplumasdesimurgh

Twitter: https://twitter.com/PlumasDeSimurgh

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/plumasdesimurgh/?hl=es

Or see all her links compiled here: https://linktr.ee/lasplumasdesimurgh

1 Answers 2021-10-26

When did the concept of dueling with guns become a thing and why

As the title says because it seems rather strange that people were suddenly taking offense with each other and heading out into the field to just shoot one another to determine who the winner was. Like did some guy just propose it one day and everyone just went with it. Or was it a natural development from sword fighting and the like.

Honestly this is just an interesting concept that popped into my head while watching something that involved a duel. Because it just seems weird that everyone in high society would agree that the best way to deal with a problem is to walk 10-20 paces from it and then fire a very inaccurate gun at it.

1 Answers 2021-10-26

Why didn't the Marathas abolish the Mughal throne?

After the Marathas had defeated the Mughals, why didn't they abolish the throne? They instead continued the throne even though the Mughal emperors were just Maratha puppets. They continued pledging allegiance and minting coins in the name of the Mughals? Why was this?

1 Answers 2021-10-26

Who bore the brunt of fighting the Japanese during the Second Sino-Japanese War? What were the prolonging impacts to the eventual Civil War?

With regards to the fighting against the Japanese by both the Communists and Nationalists in China, who did most of the fighting and dying? I’ve read arguments that the Nationalists actually did most of the fighting and it took a heavy toll on the number of soldiers and morale once the Chinese Civil War had restarted-the CCP was in a better condition than the nationalists. On the other hand, there are claims that the Communists actually fought the Japanese on a greater scale than the Nationalists had, thus pinning more support behind the CCP once the Japanese surrender and the civil war resumed. I’m curious as to what generally historians agree or think on this topic. Thank you and have a great day.

1 Answers 2021-10-26

Was the 1996 Russian election fair?

I've heard that Yeltsin was languishing below 5% in the polls before, at a summit at Davos, Russian oligarchs agreed to do all they could to prop him up over frontrunner, communist Zyuganov. With their power behind him, Yeltsin climbed steadily and ultimately won the election. But was it all because of the increase in money and messaging thanks to oligarch power? Or were less fair, more foul means known to have been employed?

1 Answers 2021-10-26

482 / 7255

Back to start