Was Soviet rocketry ever more capable than US rocketry? If so, what made it so? Tangential: When did it become common knowledge that many of the top US rocket scientists were German expats?

My understanding is that the reason the US was slow to put something in orbit was the fragmentation of rocketry programs, not lack of know-how; that the reason the R-7 was so much more powerful than its US counterparts was that Soviet warheads were much heavier and that it still couldn't strike the US mainland; and that the reason the US was behind for much of the Space Race is that NASA was being relatively conservative with risks. And the Soviets never had a rocket suitable for a manned moon mission. Is that correct? Thanks.

3 Answers 2015-11-04

Why were brass knuckles made of brass?

I imagine that steel or even iron would be cheaper and more effective, and less prone to damage or wear.

1 Answers 2015-11-04

I understand that back carrying a sword is commonly understood as rubbish, but are there any examples in history of people doing this during war?

Question is not bound to a certain time period.

The reason I ask is because people who oppose this idea in an argument mostly prove their point more with common sense (as in "swords are to long to be drawn from the back" for example) as with hard facts.

I too don't think it is very useful to carry a sword on the back (maybe for long marchs it could be), but I want to know if anybody did that in history or if it is solely limited to Hollywood and fantasy games.

2 Answers 2015-11-04

During Alexander the Great's conquest of Persia, the Persian Empire used Greek mercenaries as elite troops. Did mercenaries from the time have loyalties to things other than money? It seems that the Persians trusted them to not simply defect to the highest bidder.

It just seems strange that the Persians would trust Greek mercenaries to be elite, loyal troops when a "mercenary" can in theory be bought quite easily by someone wealthier, as Alexander eventually came to be. Yet according to Richard Freeman's biography, these Greek mercenaries fought for Persia until the end.

2 Answers 2015-11-04

How hard was it to learn a new language in pre-modern times?

I can imagine there were learning books for languages close to the borders (eg. I'm Dutch, so I imagine there was plentiful material to learn French, English and German properly). I'm learning Japanese now, and I feel like without all the modern spaced repetition learning systems on the web I wouldn't have gotten so far (so quick).

How did the average scholar (I'm assuming only scholars would do this) go about learning a language that was not particularly close to their border? How long did it take to learn a language? Was this something someone ever did as hobby, even?

I'm not sure in what time frame to place my question, but definitely before electricity existed, I suppose.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2015-11-04

What were the socio-economics of fashion in early modern royal courts?

How many dresses would queens and high-ranking duchesses have owned? Did kings and elite lords re-wear their best garments on state occasions, or was it uncouth to be seen in the same clothes? Were clothes worn until they wore out, or handed down? To whom? Was there competition to make e.g. the future queen's wedding dress?

tl;dr I know nothing and I am curious.

1 Answers 2015-11-04

When did most of the crusader holy orders cease to exist?

When did groups like the Templars, Hospitallers, and other holy military orders cease to exist and why?

2 Answers 2015-11-04

[Fashion] Are there discernible big picture trends in the use of colors? For the color photography era, I haven't noticed any (though I'm not very conscious of these things).

1 Answers 2015-11-04

Was there a double standard regarding extra-marital sex in Rome?

Question is inspired by the Spartacus TV show, and yes, I do realize it's hardly something to go off from.

In it, the owner of the gladiator gym would sometimes have sex with slaves while the wife was just around him. She would get pleasured by another female slave or be involved in a threesome with her husband and a female friend.

Her affair with a gladiator was a secret though, and she knew that her husband wouldn't accept it.

So, did Romans think that a husband or a wife sleeping with other women was fine but sex with a man that wasn't your husband was wrong?

1 Answers 2015-11-04

During late 19th - early 20th century Western Europe, was behaviour we would now call homosexual generally dismissed as simply 'boys being boys'?

On more than one occasion I've heard the claim that Western European society was often apathetic (as opposed to actively hostile) towards expressions of male/male sexuality during the late 19th and early 20th centuries, with such contact being viewed as 'boys will be boys,' - provided that contact was limited and the males involved went on to have 'straight' relationships. The same claims have said that this attitude disappeared around the early 30s, and was replaced with far greater hostility towards male/male sexual relationships.

Would anyone be able to elaborate on whether this was the case? If so, what factors lead to the changes in public perceptions of male/male sexuality in the 30s?

1 Answers 2015-11-04

I'm a tavern-owner in Ephesus in mid-first century (before Paul comes through). What do I care about in life? What are my worries/hopes/dreams? Why do these things matter to me?

Sorry if the question is impossible to answer, I appreciate that tavern-keepers didn't leave extensive diaries, let alone ones that have survived for 2,000 years.

I'm less concerned with the exact example of tavern-keeper, that was just the example that I picked of a mid-ranking citizen in order to get a concrete picture of the concerns that a citizen might have had.

If it helps you could pretend that the tavern is near the docks, that I grew up in Ephesus (maybe my Dad owned the tavern before me?). I'm not a Roman citizen. I have no slaves, but a wife and two surviving young adult sons (praise Artemis after the four that we miscarried or died in infancy). My sons work in the tavern with me.

Perhaps the question is not verifiable enough? I'm trying to understand life as a citizen back then and that's fairly hard to fact-check!

2 Answers 2015-11-04

According to Anthony Beevor's "The Second World War", the Japanese Military had an officer led policy of eating prisoners. Is this true, and if so why aren't people mad as hell about it?

He mentions it several times, and claims that Americans, Indians, Indo-Chinese and Chinese people among many others were eaten.

He also claims

  • that these acts of cannibalism were not by hungry and desperate individuals, but were an act of conscious and organized policy led by officers in the Japanese Military.
  • that prisoners of war as well as civilians were eaten
  • that Japanese units would raid civilian population centers for more people to eat
  • that some people who were eaten were first raped
  • that some people were kept (and treated) as human cattle
  • and that the allied powers chose to keep the cannibalism quiet as it was considered too distressing for the families of those who were eaten and the public at large

These are some serious -- and seriously fucked up -- allegations, so I'd love more info from historians.

Edit: More info on allegations here https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3ribf6/according_to_anthony_beevors_the_second_world_war/cwoadyo

Edit2 a clearer question with help from /u/jschooltiger

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3ribf6/according_to_anthony_beevors_the_second_world_war/cwof05n

"Why were reports of Japanese soldiers cannibalizing American POWs suppressed by the allies after WWII? And what reaction was there when the information was released?"

3 Answers 2015-11-04

Who were Napoleon's heroes?

Or heroines. I am curious which historical figures he had tremendous respect for. Thanks for your responses in advance!

5 Answers 2015-11-04

How did the Roman Empire develop when Hadrian was emperor?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-11-04

Some people claim that the Bible depicts the Earth as flat. Considering what we know about the context in which the Bible was written, is it probable that its creators held that belief?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-11-04

Wednesday What's New in History

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

1 Answers 2015-11-04

Why do biologists and historians put so much emphasis on the HMS Beagle when discussing Darwin?

Whenever I read about Darwin and his journeys and discoveries the first sentence always includes the reference to the HMS Beagle. While this is very interesting when studying the story of Darwin himself, but even in Biology textbooks the HMS Beagle is mentioned. What is the importance of which ship Darwin sailed to Biologists or to the overall story of Darwin? I understand that it is a historical detail so it should/could be noted, but it is noted in EVERY article on Darwin or evolution in EVERY discipline. Made me wonder whether something interesting was going on with it.

2 Answers 2015-11-04

Why are Roman gods considered myths while religions like Christianity aren't?

Not looking to bash religion, as I'm Catholic, but I've always wondered this.

1 Answers 2015-11-04

Exactly how heavily were the Japanese influenced by China?

I know that the Japanese eventually adopted the Chinese system of writing, but my professor mentioned that they were influenced by the Chinese in many different ways. I'd always thought the Japnese had a pretty distinct society compared to the Chinese. Can someone elaborate?

5 Answers 2015-11-04

[INFO REQUEST] I'm looking for a website that lists artifacts from Ancient Greece with information on each artifact (how it was made, what materials were used, etc.)

This is for my girlfriend's 5th grade class. They're currently learning about the subject. Does an online resource like this exist?

3 Answers 2015-11-04

In several hadith (in Islam) the Antichrist is expected to come from the region around Persia. Why Persia? What historical context that makes this narrative possible?

I remember another few more hadith saying about evil coming from Persia.

Sahih Bukhari and Sunah Ibn Majah, which both contain information about the dajjal, are compiled around 9th century. What was the historical context making this kind of narrative possible?

6 Answers 2015-11-04

Did the founding fathers ever recognize the disconnect between their words and the reality?

By that I mean they say in the opening lines of the Declaration Of Independence that all men are entitled to the pursuit of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. But what about slavery, lack of women's rights, and the fact you had to be a wealthy land owning male to vote? I don't expect them to have 21st century morals but I'd be interested to hear there logic for creating a system the said it was for freedom but kept telling door to citizen participation pretty tight.

1 Answers 2015-11-04

The USSR was never a threat to the USA, they were out matched in everything. How did the cold war go on so long? Does this show the inadequacy of the US Congress?

1 Answers 2015-11-04

Mongol Podcasts?

Hi,

After listening to the wrath of the khans, I became interested in the mongols. Any podcasts that discuss the mongols in more detail? I'm mostly interested in the rise and fall of the mongol empire and it's successors (I will take successors of successors too).

3 Answers 2015-11-04

Légion d'Honneur Records

My great uncle received the Légion d'Honneur during his service as an American soldier in WWII. However, he spoke very little about his time in the war, which I'm sure is the case for most veterans, so my family has no idea why he received this honor.

Where could one find this information? Other family members have traveled to France a tried without any luck.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2015-11-04

4829 / 7255

Back to start