How was Brandenburg under Frederick William I part of both the Holy Roman Empire and Brandenburg-Prussia?

To clarify, the territory of Bradenburg was part of the HRE, but Prussia was not. Frederick William (Grandfather of Frederick William I), the Great Elector, helped to unify these territories. How did this situation play out politically and economically?

For example, did Brandenburg have to take certain orders from the Holy Roman Emperor, when Prussia did not? Furthermore, if so, how could Brandenburg-Prussia be unified when the territories are under the authority of different people?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

Mississippi's two college-based companies in the Civil War suffered insane casualty rates. Was that level of attrition normal in Civil War units?

The University Grays reportedly got the farthest on Cemetery Hill and literally none of them weren't wounded or dead. Likewise, while I was a student at Mississippi College, the monument there to the MC Rifles reported that only 8 of the original 104 students who had enlisted returned to Mississippi.

I know that a ton of people died in the Civil War, obviously, but those levels of losses seem kind of insane. Was this typical? Or is this a reflection of the fact that maybe sending a bunch of rich college kids to shoot muskets was a bad idea or what?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

What did the Arabic world look like pre-Islam?

I think we tend to associate Arab and Islam together often, so my question is. What did 'Arabized' pre 6th century?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

Was Alexander the Great Albanian?

I have heard people say that he from a part of Macedonia that was actually part of Albania. I want to know if this is the truth.

2 Answers 2015-10-27

I'm a Victorian-era housewife whose husband is, say, a doctor. What's my usual day like?

Literally any information on the topic would be great. Recently became fascinated with the whole Victorian era but I'm not sure what's reliable, where to start, etc.

Greater specificity:

  1. Based in London, just for simplicity's sake.

  2. How do I spend leisure time and how much do I have?

  3. How big is the house?

  4. What sort of societal pressures do I have? What's my culture's equivalent to Cosmopolitan, etc.?

  5. What level of education am I likely to have?

  6. What's expected of me? When will people start badgering me about my ticking biological clock and having kids?

2 Answers 2015-10-27

What is the earliest documentation of a government providing a social safety net for the poor/elderly/disabled?

For example, were ancient Egyptian laborers still given a food allowance once they were too old to carry pyramid blocks? Were Roman soldiers who lost a limb given the equivalent of a "pension?" Etc.

The oldest laws mentioned in my Poverty Law textbook are the English "Poor Laws" from the 16th century. Are there any examples from the Ancient World of societies taking measures to care for members of society who were considered "deserving" of support?

2 Answers 2015-10-27

Why is the country "Bosnia and Herzegovina" not called something like "Bosnia, Herzegovina and Republika Srpska"?

I understand that Bosnia and Herzegovina has two internal entities to reflect its ethnic groups: Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina (for Bosniaks and Croats) and Republika Srpska which means Serb Republic (for Serbians). So why does the country's name only reflect one region?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

Is World War I propaganda the first instance of viewing the enemy as a pests?

I just finished reading War and Nature: Fighting Humans and Insects with Chemicals from World War I to Silent Spring by Edmund Russel.

In his book he suggests the it wasn't until World War I that humans started using derogatory terms for enemies, often comparing them to vermin, pests, etc.

Is this true? Are their instances of enemies being compared to insects, pests, etc before World War I?

2 Answers 2015-10-27

[META] Do questions about current attitudes and views towards events that happened more than 20 years ago break the 20 year rule?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

Why were so many important figures in Tudor England named Thomas?

2 Answers 2015-10-27

Does the Greek word "Zeus" have anything to do with Latin "Deus"?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

Would it have been difficult to enter Alexandria as a merchant during the Middle-Ages around the 1300s?

Would there be requirements? Would there be fees?

While specify Alexandria in the 1300s, feel free to post about cities in the Islamic world in the Middle-Ages.

1 Answers 2015-10-27

Were the allies considered heroes for ending the WW1?

I meant WW2 sorry was distracted by cats

1 Answers 2015-10-27

Were grain mills built by specialists, or could a noble commission his own tradesmen to build one once the principle was known?

I've read that in antiquity some windmills required royal consent in order to be built.
Given the strategic and revenue value, were there specialist teams that would travel to build these?

Was the royal permission requirement confined to only a small area, or was it a widespread practise, allowing anyone with the finances to build his own?

2 Answers 2015-10-27

Why is New Years Eve/Day not on the Winter Solstice?

Why does the Winter Solstice occur on December 21st, and not Dec 31st or Jan 1st?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

Why are historic Italians often referred to by just their first names? Why is Leonardo da Vinci referred to by his first name AND place of birth?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

How were Norwegians who joined the SS and other nazi affiliated organizations treated after the war?

I have been curious about how Norwegians who joined the SS, and alternatively other occupied nazi supporters from european countries, were treated after the war. Did they hide their past, were they treated as POWs, or maybe even flee somewhere?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

What did women wear when they had to travel long distance on foot in the past or when they had to do laborious tasks?

I'm interested to see how it has changed over time, how practical/impractical. I think of the "fitness clothing" that people wear now, stretchy yoga pants and stylish tank top things with a variety of shoulder straps and it obviously hasn't always been like that. Were women just not as active in the past and just wearing large cumbersome dresses all the time?

Edit: How about during the renaissance, but across a few different cultures that you historians are specialized in?

3 Answers 2015-10-27

In need of some recomendations.

Recomend anything- books (accessible ones please, hold back on the academia), documentaries, blogs, articles and whatever you can think of on the subject of Ancient Greece from the Minoian Period to the Roman Conquest. I am perticularly interested in the culture of Ancient Greece so emphasize on that. Looking to amass a huge reading list for the following 6-7 months, so don't stint on the titles.

1 Answers 2015-10-27

Why is Mongolia almost unheard of in todays world?

Most large empires that still exist as a country:

For Example:
-------------------------
- England
- Russia
- Spain
- Iran
- The Umayyad Caliphate (Divided into independent arabian countries)
- China
- France
- Japan
- Turkey
- Ect.

Are still very major world players, are both heard of all the time (i.e. in the news and such) and have a very big hand in world economics, war, the UN and so on, even if said country has been conquered since having been an empire.

Mongolia, however, is almost silent on a global scale, despite having been the second largest (by land area) empire ever.

What caused this decline in Mongolia's influence over world events?

Edit: Actually if you look at the first 20 or so of these: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_empires, Mongolia is the only one that isn't still a large influence.

4 Answers 2015-10-27

Was there a big demand for specific "gigging" musicians before the advent of recorded music?

I know that musicians often traveled around to wherever they could (traveling minstrels) but would say, a saloon/pub in Georgia be like "I want john Smith from NYC!" Did patrons ever request specific musicians to their local bar owner?

Edit: As pointed out by a mod, I want to narrow is down to specifically the post Civil War period to the rough period when radio was introduced and widely used.

2 Answers 2015-10-27

why is a "Cockpit" on a airplane called that?

Why? What is the first recorded use of "cockpit" in relation to airplanes and which plane? Is it related to looking like cock fighting arenas?

3 Answers 2015-10-27

The Moors influence on Europe

[deleted]

2 Answers 2015-10-27

Did Americans help Europe as much as they did Japan after/during WWII?

I see all the time in old WWII films Americans doing good deeds to random victims or deserters of the Nazi regime and I was curious if there are accounts or recorded non-fictional stories of them.

2 Answers 2015-10-27

Did the "live and let live" attitude that was sometimes present in WWI disappear for WWII?

In WWI you have stories like the Christmas Truce of 1914 and other anecdotes where soldiers had a mutual sympathy for each other. Dan Carlin's podcast has an account where two armies have their trenches flooded and they both come out so as not to drown and no one shoots at each other.

Yet in WWII there are a lot of stories about killing German POWs and civilians and few about non-aggression or kindness towards the enemy. The TX State dissertation that was posted not too long ago here had a story about an American shooting a German boy for Sieg Heiling, and another where an American chased a naked German prisoner with his bayonet for sport until finally killing him.

Did WWII have these same acts of "live and let live" but they're just overshadowed by other acts of cruelty? Or was that attitude largely gone by WWII and if so, why?

1 Answers 2015-10-27

4851 / 7255

Back to start