What kind of wine was Jesus talking about?

Did Israel in the ~0000s cultivate grapes for wine? Or was it a different type of wine

1 Answers 2015-10-16

A stereotypical Western depiction of African women has them carrying objects on their heads (jars, water jugs, food bags). Did this practice exist in Europe prior to industrialisation?

4 Answers 2015-10-16

What were the roles and duties of "political officers" in Soviet military units and ships?

I watched a documentary about a 1975 incident in Riga in which several Soviet officers on a new Navy ship mutinied (Basically the political officer felt the soviet leadership was corrupt, so he imprisoned the captain, and convinced about half of the ship's leadership to commandeer the ship and take it to Leningrad where they would use radio and loudspeaker messages to inspire the people to revolt--he wasn't anti-communist, he was actually super-communist and was railing against corruption).

The whole incident helped inspire Tom Clancy to write The Hunt for Red October.

My question is the role of "Political Officers" in the Soviet Military. I know very little about this, but my impression is that pretty much every ship, for instance, had a "political officer." I assume their role is to make sure everything comports to the Socialist ideals... but I don't really know.

What WAS their role? Were they technically part of the military or the Party? Or both? Did they have an entirely separate promotion track? Were they highly integrated into the crews of the ships, or viewed warily? What power did they hold? Whom did they report to? Did they report to the captain of the ship, someone in the party, or both?

My recollection is that the Nazis had something similar in their U-boats during the Second World War... is that true? Is there anything even remotely comparable in the United States Military?

1 Answers 2015-10-16

How communitarian were neolithic tribes and what major structural changes occurred during the transition from neolithic groups to agrarian civilizations?

Frequently I see pre-civilization tribespeoples' lives being romanticized as a sort of ideal communist society, but to what extent was this the case? It seems that they were probably much more communal out of necessity but were there really no social hierarchies? Looking at other animal societies they appear to have basic social structures with upper and lower classes.

Then, the second half of the question, what sorts of societal shifts occurred during the transition from the neolithic to agrarian cultures and why did these shifts occur?

2 Answers 2015-10-16

In most societies today, women live longer than men on average. Was this true before modern medicine (i.e. pre 1800)?

Just wondering if this is only because few people die of infection or malnutrition now, and women simply have less chance of old age diseases.

1 Answers 2015-10-16

Why did Canada not join the American Revolution?

Seeing as they were also under British rule during this period, why did Canadian territories not unite with the American colonies?

1 Answers 2015-10-16

Why did the Soviet Union lose in Afghanistan?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-10-16

Was the Holomodor a genocide?

I used to think so, now I just view it like Mao's agricultural disasters. As far as I can tell, the Holomodor was an accident that Soviet paranoia and incompetence just multiplied.

Is this true? What's the consensus?

3 Answers 2015-10-16

Did people have bad skin (acne) as often as they do now before this century? Why do I never notice it in old photographs from the 1800s?

Did people suffer from acne less frequently? I never notice it in daguerreotypes, for example, which are pretty clear and sharp. I also never see it depicted in paintings, although I figure that's because most flaws like that weren't included. Can someone explain this to me?

1 Answers 2015-10-16

Friday Free-for-All | October 16, 2015

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

24 Answers 2015-10-16

How did Romania emerge from the Slavic Migrations as a non-Slavic country? Were attempts at settlement/conquest made by the tribes, or did they simply bypass it for other areas?

1 Answers 2015-10-16

What are some good books I can read about horses used for warfare during the medieval ages?

Hi,

I really want to learn more about horses and how they were used in war. Things like how they were bred, trained, and all that jazz. Do you know of any good books?

Thanks.

1 Answers 2015-10-16

Is there historical evidence for why there would be lots of staircases in woods? Or a typical decay pattern that leaves this sign elsewhere in the world?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-10-16

What is the earliest record or reference to music that we know of? Is there some sort of consensus of when humans picked up music? Did Neanderthals or other close relatives of humans have music?

3 Answers 2015-10-16

What was life during the French Revolution like for the middle classes?

The common perception/stereotype of the French Revolution is that essentially nobody existed in it except the aristocrats (executed or fleeing), the peasantry (angry, vengeful, vicious), and the revolutionary leaders (generally nonexistent apart from Robespierre), which is of course wrong for a number of reasons. But lately I've been translating issues of the periodical Journal de la mode et du gout from 1790 which are very clearly not aimed at aristocrats (given how insulting it is about them), and it occurred to me that not only are the stereotypes inaccurate, they ignore a broad swath of society.

What was happening among the upper and lower middle classes, in Paris or in the provinces? I'm interested in the whole range, but in particular was wondering about the wealthier/more affluent members of the Third Estate - did many of them not involved in the National Assembly face suspicion or persecution due to their position, or did they kind of quietly skate through? Did many emigrate, or is the stereotype of the émigré(e) being of noble birth mainly accurate?

1 Answers 2015-10-16

Why is Korea influenced by China's Ming dynasty but Japan by Tang dynasty?

It seems that the Ming dynasty has had the greatest influence on Korea in terms of various cultural aspects like dressing, rigid confucianist family/social structure, hanja etc.

On the other hand, Japan seems to have been influenced disproportionatedly by China's tang dynasty. Many of its famous cultural symbols descended directly from thr Tangs. For e.g. the kimono, the makeup of geishas (painting face white and strange lipstick), bonsai,, the entire city of kyoto which was a copy of tangs capital.

What caused this difference in influence?

1 Answers 2015-10-16

What did Alexander Hamilton when he said "A national debt, if it is not excessive, will be to us a national blessing."

I saw this on a coworker's quote-of-the-day and can't make sense of it. How is debt a blessing?

2 Answers 2015-10-16

How did a cavalry charge evolve and what were the most common tactics?

Seeing a post today about a horse race accident-NSFW it made me wonder about how cavalry was used in the past.

How often was a cavalry charge used? Was it often to simply rush and hit the infantry head on or is this something made up recently by the movie industry? I am asking this because all that I could think of is that if you charge head on, for example, and you eventually hit the infantry line, the most of them would either fall down or get crushed etc. This would make it even more of an impediment for the soldiers behind, probably falling also while their horses would trip on the bodies.

Thank you.

1 Answers 2015-10-16

Are there examples of one man armies from the Axis side during WW2? I only read about the Allied heroes, was there a real life Fredrik Zoller?

5 Answers 2015-10-16

With its comparable range and much higher rate of fire over smoothbore muskets, why weren't crossbows ever reintroduced in European battlefields after the disappearance of armor?

I would think they would be especially desirable for defenders during sieges.

9 Answers 2015-10-16

How similar were the kingdoms of Israel and Judah to their neighbors in the ancient Near East?

Any info would be great, but I'm thinking in terms of things like culture, politics, and religion.

1 Answers 2015-10-16

Why did Sweden place the Barsebäck nuclear power plant so close to Copenhagen?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-10-16

Why did the American colonies turn so anti-British in the space of about two decades in the run up to 1776

First off some background. I'm British, living in England, but my wife is American. I've been reading history narratives of the US to try and get a fuller understanding of, er, American History.

I read Alan Taylor's brilliant American Colonies which gives an excellent overview of events up to about the 1750s/1760s. After this I picked American Creation by Joseph J Ellis which while brilliant, and thoroughly engaging, I get frustrated not by what he writes but by the bits he doesn't write. For example he tells half the story of the revolutionary war before skipping ahead to the constitutional convention, and after the ratifying conventions he skips ahead to after Washington is already president without getting into that process at all.

Anyway, my real question is basically about the gaps between the two books. What turned the tide toward revolution and independence?

Of course I know the over-arching theme is having rule and laws and more specifically tax imposed on them from far across the Atlantic without representation. But up until the 1750s I get the impression from my readings that everyone was quite happy to be under British rule and protection and the trade laws that helped their economies.

What events am I missing in this 20 year period that turned opinion so drastically?

Thanks

2 Answers 2015-10-16

did Benito Mussolini have any plans for changing the name of Italy to Rome?

1 Answers 2015-10-16

When did the socialdemocrats start moving away from the revolutionary left in the 20th century?

2 Answers 2015-10-16

4886 / 7255

Back to start