What was ancient Canaanite religion and culture actually like?

I go to a christian university, and my Bible professor was lecturing about how terrible the canaanite religions were in the time of the Israelite conquest, around 1750 B.C. Specifically, he mentioned child sacrifice to gods like El and Baal. He also said that it was commonly accepted as fact that the canaanite religion was the most evil in the ancient near east. Is there any supporting evidence for these statements apart from Biblical records?

1 Answers 2015-10-11

What was to the west of the 2nd century BCE Qin dynasty in china?

The Qin dynasty is often said to be the first empire to unify China, but when I love at a map there is a very large amount of land to the west of what is accepted as the borders of the Qin dynasty. What lands and civilizations were to the west of the 2nd century BCE Qin Dynasty?

Please Note, I understand the boundaries of modern china are disputed due to the state of Tibet, but for academic argument in my question please use what the Country of China defines as its modern borders for comparison.

map for reference - http://imgur.com/VAJpYOS

1 Answers 2015-10-11

During World War 2, did people call it "World War 2?" If not, what did they call it, and how did they understand the war they were fighting?

Also, if it was not referred to as "world war 2" during the actual war, when was that name agreed on?

2 Answers 2015-10-11

AMA: Why Was the United States So Afraid of Radicalism? (Loyalty and Liberty: American Countersubversion from World War I to the McCarthy Era)

Hi there! My name’s Alex Goodall, and I’m a historian at University College London, where I teach twentieth-century US history. I have a particular interest in the history of radicalism, antiradicalism and countersubversion in the United States. My book, [Loyalty and Liberty] (http://www.press.uillinois.edu/books/catalog/62hst7ka9780252038037.html), explored the politics of countersubversion in the United States in the decades before the McCarthy era. It explored subjects including:

  • political repression during World War One
  • the post-war Red Scare and the Palmer Raids of 1919-1920
  • popular antiradical groups in the 1920s, including ultrapatriotic organizations, the Ku Klux Klan and the American Legion
  • early (and mostly unsuccessful) efforts at communist spy-hunting
  • fascism and antifascism in the 1930s, and
  • the growth of anticommunism in the 1930s and 1940s, including the creation of the House Committee on un-American Activities (HUAC), which played such an important role in fuelling Cold War McCarthyism.

My aim was to pull together a wide variety of different subjects in order to chart the deeper origins of countersubversive politics in American life. Among other things, I hoped to challenge the popular understanding of “McCarthyism” as being associated with just a short period in the early Cold War years, and showing instead its deeper roots.

As a result, the book looks at lots of different groups and figures, including antiradical businessmen like Henry Ford, anticommunist figures in the labor movement, antiradical elements in various religious denominations, and counter-subversive political factions in both the major political parties.

Rather than there being a singular counter-subversive movement, these different groups and individuals constantly argued about the nature of the threat that they believed was out there, and over the best ways of responding to it. More generally, American countersubversives struggled to balance their desire to engineer national loyalty with longstanding US commitments to constitutional liberties such as the freedom of speech and assembly. Indeed, I argue it was the tension between these two goals that gave the debate over “subversives” in American life such fury.

I’d be happy to field questions about any of these subjects, so please fire away!

Hi everybody. I'm going to log off now as it's nearing my bedtime (in the UK)! I just wanted to say thanks to you all for asking some great questions, and for being so friendly and polite all the way. This is a great community you have here. I'll try and have a look in again tomorrow in case there's any straggler questions that come in overnight, but otherwise I hope that you've found this discussion interesting and look forward to engaging with AskHistorians more in the future.

If anybody wants to know more about my book or related subjects, you're very welcome to email me at alex.goodall@ucl.ac.uk, or my twitter address is @dralexgoodall

25 Answers 2015-10-11

If Hitler believed the Enigma machine to be unbreakable, why did high-level communications use the more sophisticated Lorenz cipher?

I recently visited Bletchley Park and was fascinated by the whole experience. This is one question that niggled at me however. I may have missed any such explanation at the museum as it was extremely busy!

3 Answers 2015-10-11

Did early Christians believe that the Roman gods existed, but should not be worshiped, or did they deny their existence altogether?

8 Answers 2015-10-11

In a one-sentence aside, Hannah Arendt writes that Hitler never had any intention of killing the ~2000 Finnish Jews because of his deep respect for the Finnish people. Why the respect and why would it matter if he wouldn't have considered the Jews Finns?

From Eichmann in Jerusalem, which I know is not a work of historical scholarship per se, but certainly the product of significant research.

Sweden was never occupied, and Finland, though in the war on the side of the Axis, was the one country the Nazis hardly ever even approached on the Jewish question. This surprising exception of Finland, with some two thousand Jews, may have been due to Hitler's great esteem for the Finns, whom perhaps he did not want to submit to blackmail.

5 Answers 2015-10-11

When did we realize there are (what we now know as) time zones? ie, it's night in the East when it's daytime in the West?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-10-11

In WW2, how exactly did technological transfer from Germany to Japan take place and how did Japan pay for it?

For all I know the Japanese received a lot of technology from the third Reich like plans to build their Nakajima Kikka jet plane. No doubt - there has been military and industrial cooperation before the war, but when WW2 broke out the technological transfer continued. How did Japan actually receive all the construction plans, parts and sample machinery and how did they pay for it? All transportation routes led through enemy territory and the axis powers probably had limited access to the international financial system...

1 Answers 2015-10-11

Why was it the bolsheviks and not the Russian socialist revolutionaries (who had double the supporters) who started the communist revolution in russia?

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Constituent_Assembly source on numbers

2 Answers 2015-10-11

How did the Muslim world view the Crusades?

The history of the crusades is usually sold as the titanic clash of religions and civilizations, however I've recently read a different view that, since the Islamic powers had broken down in the decades leading up to the first Crusade, there was not much for Islamic unity. Therefore, when the Europeans came to conquer Jerusalem, the Muslims largely saw it as some barbarians who came over the frontier. Dangerous, but not a threat to their religion or culture. So my question is, is this true? Is the story we've been told of a mighty clash between the crescent and the cross solely how the Christian west has viewed it?

1 Answers 2015-10-11

How do we know what the spoken form of ancient Egyptian sounded like, based on hieroglyphics?

Recently I visited the Field Museum and wondered how we knew the pronunciation of things, e.g. people's names, based on the hieroglyphics found.

2 Answers 2015-10-11

Did Germany have to comply with the terms of the Geneva conventions with the Soviet Union, even though the Soviet Union did not sign it?

I'm getting some mixed information here. A source on google books states that "the signatories were still bound to the Convention even when one of the parties to a conflict was not among the signatories."(294)

However, when I'm reading a different source, a General Reinecke defends himself in front of a court, stating the since Germany and the Soviet Union were not binded by the Geneva Convention, "War captivity was solely protective custody, and to prevent prisoners from further participating in war," which was only the normal international law.

The main problem is that the author of the second source states that General Reinecke's argument was legally true, but that contrasts with what the first author said about the Geneva Convention, which was that even though the Soviet Union didn't sign, Germany still had to comply.

Thank you for all your help!

1 Answers 2015-10-11

Apart from the invention of the Cotton Gin, what led to the consolidation of slavery in the U.S.?

Regarding my history essay "What factors lead to the consolidation of slavery as a labour system in the United States?"

1 Answers 2015-10-11

Was classical music by German composers less popular after World War II?

If more specifics are required to give a reasonable answer, this is how I would ideally narrow down the question, but outside information would be neat as well:

Did American symphony orchestras program fewer pieces by Richard Strauss, Richard Wagner, Gustav Mahler, or Johannes Brahms after 1942 explicitly because of Germany's involvement in WWII?

If so, when did the German classical music tradition come back to be the standard in the U.S.? Did United States orchestras try to program more American classical composers (Copland?) in an attempt to be nationalistic? Did anything similar happen during the Cold War to Russian composers (Stravinsky, Tchaikovsky, Rimsky-Korsakov, Mussorgsky)?

1 Answers 2015-10-11

Approximately how long would it have taken to build a fleet of 100 warships in the Ancient World?

1 Answers 2015-10-11

Columbus Day is tomorrow. Why did people start hating Columbus so much?

I've heard a lot of people criticizing the death of Native Americans, but that happened after Columbus. Rather, his successors and other colonizers are to blame.

Yes, I know he wasn't the first human, nor European in America. But he did discover America for all intent and purposes. Yes, i know he was going for Catai and America was a mistake, but that doesn't take away the fact he connected Europe and America. Many discoveries in History (and in Science) were mistakes, but that doesn't make it less relevant. Yes, I know that he had some low points as governor, but no one is perfect. The "smallpox blankets" were decades after his last visit to the American continent.

I just feel that he is held to a level of scrutiny much more severe than anyone else (namely, the Founding Fathers or so many other in American History).

1 Answers 2015-10-11

At any point in time, did the History Channel actually treat historical topics?

Seriously, I'm curious to know what happened and why today it's junk. Does it have to do with commercialization of TV?

2 Answers 2015-10-11

Was Christopher Columbus a bad explorer? What is an explorer, anyway?

My question is ultimately about what it means to be an "explorer". Do historians use that term, and if so, what do they mean by it? I am particularly motivated by the example of Christopher Columbus. Based on my understanding of the term, I would say he was not a good explorer, but maybe I'm being completely unfair.

I'm sure he was a competent sailor, and he knew how to use the Trade Winds, and that thing with the eclipse was pretty clever, so I grant all that. But I always figured, to count as an explorer, you can't just go to a place. You have to actually notice something about it, and come away knowing more about the world than when you started. Columbus seemed to completely disregard any evidence that contradicted his preconceived notions about the world.

I'm particularly struck by how he concluded that Cuba was part of China. Obviously we have the benefit of hindsight, and Columbus was only able to work with what he knew about China, so I could easily forgive the mistake if the major features matched up, but as far as I can tell none of the features matched up.

China was the largest empire in the world, with 120,000,000 people, and a vast army and navy. Traders would often return from there with spices, silk, and opium. Gunpowder, paper, and the printing press were invented there. Meanwhile, Cuba was an island of 300,000 people living in small villages. No silk, opium, iron, written language, or wheeled vehicles. They grew tobacco, cotton, and maize instead. Other than approximate latitude, they seem to share nothing in common.

There are more examples, like when he decided that South America was the Garden of Eden and the world was not round but pear-shaped. But you get the idea.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2015-10-11

Was there anyone within the USSR Stalin couldn't have killed?

Or somebody/group of people that Stalin would have been afraid to get involved with or was literally everyone in the Soviet Union a potential target for the man?

1 Answers 2015-10-11

Does the bible have any historical basis?

2 Answers 2015-10-11

Salting the earth has been used to punish losers of wars. But have invasive species ever been used as a weapon of war or revenge after a war? I do not mean things like plague rats to spread disease, I mean the introduction of animals or plans to play havoc with the local ecosystem.

2 Answers 2015-10-11

Was Bohemond of Taranto's 1107-1108 expedition against Byzantium a crusade?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-10-11

How's many calories did our ancestors get from animal fat on a daily basis?

By ancestors I mean pre-agrarian peoples from 200,000 to 12,000 years ago. If I had to guess, fat would be the most abundant source of calories for people prior to the advent of agriculture.

1 Answers 2015-10-11

Did ancient China know about the fall of the Roman Empire?

The faq says that the ancient Chinese and Roman empires had a vague awareness of eachothers existence. When/how did the Chinese learn of the Roman empire's fall/decline? What was the Chinese reaction? Was trade along the Silk Road disrupted?

3 Answers 2015-10-11

4900 / 7255

Back to start