In the Medieval era, What exactly contributed to GDP growth? Was the nation with the most farms and tax collections the "richest"?

2 Answers 2015-10-06

When did african countries get firearms and which countries did?

I'm pretty sure some african tribes (or countries) had firearms BEFORE the colonisation of africa. (Why? Because firearms were invented in China in the 14th century!)

Can anyone give me a source of which firearms they had and who had it? IF they even had any, before the "Scramble for Africa". - Accoring to "CrashCourse" (which is made of a team of historians) africans had firearms, but what does that mean? Does he mean that they used the europeans weapons or that they had firearms of their own?

Africa is a big continent, so it's not enough to say "Africa had firearms!", i need to know which countries/tribes.

EDIT: Pardon my grammar

2 Answers 2015-10-06

How were Roman numerals pronounced out loud?

I like the decimal system because I find it easier to work with. Take the number 1992. I can say "One Thousand and Nine Hundreds and Ninety and Two" out loud, and you know which number I mean. All I need to do is count the total number of digits, to know that I am starting from Thousands rather than Ten thousands or whatever. But in roman numerals, the same number is written (I believe) as MCMXCII. I'm sure a Roman would have been able to answer questions about this number, but how would they say this number out loud. Would it be (translated into english) something like : "A Thousand and A Hundred less than a Thousand and Ten less than a Hundred and One and another One"? That's how I read it - is that what romans had to do as well?

2 Answers 2015-10-06

What was the international drug trade like before the second world war?

2 Answers 2015-10-06

Before alarm clocks, how did people regulate when they woke up?

1 Answers 2015-10-06

How were the conditions in Bomber planes in World War II?

My grandfather was a navigator in the Lancaster Bomber towards the end of World War II, and I have recently been getting interested in aviation history. Therefore, I have been wondering what the conditions were in inside the bombers during raids. Such as:

  • If they needed to go to the toilet, how did they go?
  • What food did they eat?
  • How did they stay awake during raids?

3 Answers 2015-10-06

Were swords/bows/etc.. controlled from general masses in any given periods?

It's a general broad question sorry. I was just wondering if various time periods had control issues with weapons and how it was handled?

1 Answers 2015-10-06

There are many stories of U.S. POW's held captive in Southeast Asia following the conclusion of the Vietnam War. To what degree is this true and what are some cases in which POW/MIA's were found later?

1 Answers 2015-10-06

The last lunch menu on the Titanic has just been auctioned, and it lists a few vegetables. How would vegetables have been kept fresh on a long trans-ocean voyage back then?

Here's the story for those interested: http://time.com/4060037/titanics-last-lunch-menu-sells-at-auction/

There's lettuce and tomatoes and a few other things listed. This was obviously within a couple of days of leaving the US. But how would they have been able to supply vegetables over the rest of the journey later on?

1 Answers 2015-10-06

How did U.S. soldiers get the nickname "Doughboys" in WW1?

1 Answers 2015-10-06

How rich did whalers actually get in the age of sail?

You hear about these whaling expeditions where the sailing ships would be gone from home for two or three years as a matter of course.

Would the men on board really make that much more than if they stayed and worked at home?

How much could the officers expect to come home with? How would the ordinary crew members actually make out with at the end of so long a cruise? How about the actual owners/investors?

3 Answers 2015-10-06

Why did China lose the 1895 Sino-Japanese War?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-10-06

The validity of claims of multiculturalism in Japan

I read an article on an online publication a while back (I forget which) that claimed that Japan had a history of multiculturalism and the idea of a monolithic "Japanese" identity is just a myth. I know that in the modern era, only around 1% of Japan's population is immigrant, but I was wondering if there was any historical basis to this claim. To my knowledge, prior to the Meiji restoration, foreigners were only allowed into the port of Nagasaki, and that during the Imperialist era, Koreans and Taiwanese would be brought to Japan as labor, but I'm not aware of much regarding immigration to Japan in other timer periods.

1 Answers 2015-10-06

Of what unnatural offense was Giovanni Battista Ribera guilty?

In reading biographical information about St. Charles Borromeo, I've found many sources that said he attacked his confessor, Fr. Giovanni Battista Ribera, for unnatural offenses. What exactly is meant by an unnatural offense?

1 Answers 2015-10-06

Flint stone what is it used for

This was found by my dad in the desert where I live and we have found more of them around arrow heads and stuff like that just wondering what this would have been used for. It has a sharp round edge and a place to put your thumb.

1 Answers 2015-10-06

What's the history behind the Arch of Triumph at Palmyra?

Before ISIS destroyed this monument I have never heard of it, I tried Googling and could find much of the history. Why was it built? By whom? What year? So to honour this lost piece of history I would like to learn about it.

1 Answers 2015-10-06

Best of September Winners!

The Votes Are In!

/u/retarredroof's answer to "Did Native Americans use the bow and arrow prior to Europeans arriving in the New World?" takes the "Flair's Choice" Award.

/u/Elm11's response to "ELI5 - Holocaust Denial" takes the "User's Choice" Award.

Congratulations to both winners, and a "Thank You" to everyone who wrote great answers during the past month! You can find the list of past awardees here!

5 Answers 2015-10-05

My CLST Roman Army professor claims that ancient Roman soldiers employed slingshots as missile weapons. I have never seen a source which references this, despite searching. Is there any evidence for this that I'm missing?

Long story short: I am taking a 300-level classical studies class on the Roman Army at university. Our professor has repeatedly mentioned "slingshots" as a missile weapon used in addition to slings (note: I am not confusing these with references to the projectile). I was dubious, because everything I've read claimed that material of sufficient elasticity to make a hand-held slingshot did not exist until the 19th century.

My professor, when asked, claimed that the same materials used for ballista and other artillery weapons were employed to create handheld slingshots. She further says both slings and slingshots were used by missile troops.

I found a couple other answers on this subreddit addressing this, which seemed to make the answer out as an unequivocal 'no'. I don't want to ask my professor again, but this is driving me crazy!

Is there anything I'm missing that she could be basing this on?

1 Answers 2015-10-05

How exactly did the Union victory at the siege of Vicksburg "split the confederacy in two"?

The quote is from Wikipedia but I've seen the battle described that way before. Was Vicksburg the last major crossing point of the Mississippi that the Confederacy controlled? Also I would think that if there were enough soldiers west of the Mississippi to make this a serious blow, then there would be enough soldiers to try and retake one of the other crossing points. I'm just looking for a little context on this battle.

2 Answers 2015-10-05

Did pre-modern empires feel any need to "justify" conquest/enslavement/etc.?

Lately I've become interested in the intellectual hoops that early modern Europeans were jumping through to justify their colonial expansion. Specifically I'm thinking about how rationalism and the scientific method were central to theories of racial essentialism and, by extension, racism in the modern sense. (I'm mostly getting these ideas from having read "A Genealogy of Modern Racism," so I guess my first implicit question is whether most historians accept that Dr. West was onto something...)

Based purely on depictions in popular culture, it seems like ancient Egyptians or classical Romans or medieval Scandinavians would have felt no need to justify conquest or enslavement of people beyond "because we can." Is this accurate? Or is there any literature suggesting that Romans or Vikings felt some need to defend the practice of slavery?

3 Answers 2015-10-05

As Americans, we use the names World War 2, The Korean War, the Gulf war, etc. Did different countries use alternate names, such as "The American War" for these same major events?

This question isn't limited to the events mentioned in the title, but counties tend to name wars after who they see as the enemy or the location of the fighting. Are there any cases were the same exact event is named something entirely different relative to a country's point of view? (example: The USA calls it the Korean War, does Korea call it the American War?)

Sorry if I sound ignorant asking this question.

8 Answers 2015-10-05

Did divine right kings really believe that their god wanted them to rule?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-10-05

It's there any account on how Yuri Gagarin was effected by the death of Vladimir Komarov?

Or perhaps how Yuri Gagarin delt with the cccp space program after the soyuz 1 failure.

1 Answers 2015-10-05

What exactly is "Marxian Historiography?" What are some good examples?

Hey guys, I've overheard some of my professors speaking about a school of historiography they specify as Marxian, but for everything I can tell about it, it seems more like social history than anything. Can anybody with a better grasp of things clarify this for me, and possibly supply some sources?

1 Answers 2015-10-05

Who was Japan's Hitler/Mussolini/Churchil/Roosevelt?

Basically the opening question. WW2 is generally described in terms of its leaders. Hitler wanted control, he allied with Mussolini and Stalin, Churchill saw it so he teamed up with Roosevelt etc.

The exception to this is always Japan. Japan is always Japan. "Japan allied with Germany, Japan attacked Pearl Harbor, etc." There never seems to be any prominent figure associated with leading Japan's militarism and aggressive expansion. There is, of course, Emperor Hirohito, but my impression was always that he more or less remained aloof from political matters.

Japan's aggressiveness seems to have been a cultural trend that was a long time building, but surely that could be said of many nations in WWII. Who might be considered the most instrumental figure in terms of 'leading' Japan's military expansionist agenda?

1 Answers 2015-10-05

4916 / 7255

Back to start