Did people lose their minds about getting vaccines (mandated or otherwise) at any point in history as much as today?

This is a question regarding Covid-19 specifically, but in my lifetime I've seen the "anti-vax" movement grow. Is being "anti-vax" a historically frequent occurrence or is it an anomaly?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

[META] Is there a list of specialists within this sub that we can search by topic and direct our questions to?

If knowledgeable users were made aware of questions that they can answer, we might see a greater number of questions answered.

For example, I'm sure there is someone knowledgeable here who can answer my question regarding Catholicism in England, but may not have seen or been made aware of my post.

Maybe this is unjustiable to implement, just an idea.

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Why didn't knights paint their armor black

Wouldn't it make them harder to see in battle or at night

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Swedish medieval armor

Looking for swedish armor/uniforms from between the swedish viking age and late middle age. cant find what soldiers and knights in sweden wore during battle.

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Why didn't Prussia annex Alsace-Lorraine?

After the Franco-Prussian war, the Imperial Territory of Alsace-Lorraine was annexed into the German Empire as a new federal territory, legally separate from all the others.

My question is, why wasn't it annexed directly into the Kingdom of Prussia as a province?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Bertrand Russell said that, "The doctrines of Buddhism are profound; they are almost reasonable, and historically they have been the least harmful and the least cruel." Is there any reason to suspect that Buddhist societies have ben less cruel or harmful than others?

3 Answers 2021-10-15

Any good introductory texts about Mesoamerican ceramics, books, articles?

Looking for a beginner’s guide to different types and styles of Mesoamerican ceramics. The field looks a little complicated and daunting just diving in with zero context.

1 Answers 2021-10-15

How did people explain and treat identical twins before science explained the phenomenon?

2 Answers 2021-10-15

Why did America's Founding Fathers create a Congress and not an American Parliament?

The British Parliament had already been around for centuries by their time. I don't recall hearing them (in the history I do know) complain about Parliament itself, just that they had no representation in it. Did they find a parliamentary system lacking in some way?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Were there other Jewish Messiah claimants around the time of Jesus? Why were they not as popular as Jesus?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

At what point did Native American groups acquire some kind of immunity to western diseases?

Was it not until modern medicine? Or is it still an ongoing issue?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Medieval-era overland traders - What kind of preparations needed to be made? How did they tackle rough terrain and/or unpaved roads? What kind of speed could they manage?

(rephrased from an earlier question)

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Mature student looking to learn

I am wanting to explore my interest in history from palaeolithic to late Bronze Age. I simply cannot ignore how giddy I get learning about our ancestors. Especially interested in Mesopotamia; Sumer and Akkad, etc… l. My Question is: since my local university only offers courses back to 1600 AD. What do you all suggest for distance learning?

I don’t plan on swapping careers or anything. I just want to learn.

Thanks in advance

2 Answers 2021-10-15

How do educators teach "both sides" of a historical controversy when the modern mainstream has completely rejected one side?

History is full of leaders who are now widely perceived by the public as villains, such as Hitler and Pol Pot, and social institutions that are now widely perceived as immoral, such as slavery and colonialism. But in their own time, these people and ideas enjoyed support from substantial segments of the population.

How do history educators, at the university level or in primary and secondary schools, teach the perspective of the side that is now considered repugnant by the modern mainstream? What does that lesson plan look like - do you assign texts arguing a point of view that the students will find objectionable? Can you take a neutral stance and withhold value judgments so the students form their own opinions from the given facts? Is there a risk that empathizing with the reasons why people at the time held those beliefs might actually sway some students into agreeing with them?

For example, this question is prompted by two controversies about history education and discourse in the US this week: the annual Columbus Day / Indigenous Peoples' Day debate about how to contextualize Christopher Columbus's achievements as an explorer vs. his subjugation of Hispaniola, and a news report that a Texas school district interprets the state's new education law as requiring teachers to present "other perspectives" about the Holocaust. How do you teach the perspectives of enslavers or Nazis?

4 Answers 2021-10-15

How far did Scientists/Inventors/Scholars advance thinking during the Islamic golden age ? Who were the key figures ?

I want to understand how critical this period was in advancing human understanding and what went wrong.

3 Answers 2021-10-15

The role of caesar in the first triumvirate

Why did Pompey and Crassus allow Caesar an equal share of the power.

Crassus had money, Pompey was popular and had a lot of conquests already, but what did Caesar bring that was so special for them?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

What did the Nazi have to say about The Protocols of the Elders of Zion being exposed as a fraud?

So it is known as that The Protocols of the Elders of Zion has been exposed as a fabricated antisemitic text by the British newspaper The Times in 1921 and the German Frankfurter Zeitung in 1924. Yet, when the Nazis came into power in 1933, it is taught in German schools as if factual. What did the Nazi have to say about their antiseptic text being exposed as a fraud? Do they just shrug it off as just some left wing or Jewish newspaper trying to dispel the myth that Jews aren’t a dangerous race in their propaganda? Or are there more reasons behind the fact that it was used in schools and even neofascist, fundamentalist and antisemitic groups to this day?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

THE LAST DUEL claims charges of rape in 14th century France were a species of property crime made against the husband or father of the woman. What was the legal nature of sexual assault in the high middle ages?

Eric Jager's book, which provides the source, is slightly more confusing than the screenplay, saying:

The prosecution and punishment of rape often depended on the victim’s social class and political clout. In France women convicted of lesser crimes like theft were often put to death, while many males guilty of rape escaped with a mere fine—compensation that was often paid not to the victim herself but to her father or husband, since rape counted less as sexual violence against a woman than as a property crime against her male guardian. Legal records show that clerics, men holding church office, numbered disproportionately among those accused of rape and that they often escaped serious punishment by claiming “benefit of clergy,” which entitled them to have their cases tried by the church rather than by the secular courts.

The circumstances of the crime, including the frequent absence of any witnesses, often made a charge of rape hard to prove in a court of law. And in France the female victim, no matter what her social standing, high or low, could not bring charges in the first place without the cooperation of her husband, father, or male guardian. Many rape victims, threatened afterward by their attackers with shame and dishonor, chose to keep silent rather than risk ruining their reputation, or that of their family, by making the crime public. So if in theory rape was a serious crime for which the law provided heavy penalties, in practice it often went unpunished, unprosecuted, and even unreported.

What work is Jager's "in theory" doing here? What is the nominal attitude on the books? Was it the case that it was de jure a crime against the woman but de facto treated as a crime against the man? Or was it de jure also a crime against the man for "violation of property"?

Moreover, was rape unique in that a woman was required to have her male guardian as a sponsor to bring the charge before the court, or was this a case with all criminal (or civil?) charges?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Today I learned the root of "gargoyle" is likely the same as "gargle", because gargoyles were originally just decorative gutter spouts on stone buildings. How on earth did we go from gutter spouts to magical stone monsters?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Did ancient civilizations cut their nails?

Do we know if in ancient times in Egypts, greeks, Romans or even Aztecs cut their nails? Do we know at what time in our history we started to cut them?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

When the American Civil War started, there were not nearly enough free states to amend the US Constitution and lawfully end slavery. So why exactly did the slave states secede?

In 1861, there were 19 free states and 15 slave states. The US Constitution requires that amendments be passed with two thirds support from the Senate and House, and three quarters of the state legislatures. I know the basic history — the slave states were concerned that the free states would admit more and more free states to the US, and eventually there would be enough to amend the Constitution. Hence, there was Bleeding Kansas, the caning of Charles Sumner, etc. But in order for three quarters of the states to be free states, the US would have had to admit 26 free states, giving it a total of 60 states, which the U.S. doesn't even have in 2021. Was this at all plausible? Even if the border states changed their positions — and I suspect that's a big assumption — the US would still have to admit 10 free states, which would be a long way to go. It doesn't seem like the abolitionists were remotely close to amending the Constitution in 1861. What lawful threat to slavery were the slave states anticipating when they seceded? Why exactly did they secede?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Friday Free-for-All | October 15, 2021

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

9 Answers 2021-10-15

How did succession work in the Byzantine Empire?

If I remember correctly many Roman emperors were actually adopted by the emperor some time before his death to ensure a succession. Did the Byzantine Empire operate in a similar fashion?

1 Answers 2021-10-15

Why didn't mathmatics develop in the same way languages did?

Why don't we have different "dialects" of math? I'm sure math popped up everywhere and was "invented" by many different people around the world, each of these people would have assigned a different symbol to represent 1, 2, 3, etc. As well as symbols to represent things like times and division.

When and how did we all agree on how mathmatics was written? Why does X mean times and why does 1 mean one? Who decided these things?

It'd all ultimately be describing the exact same thing, but same for spoken languages. You can translate between languages and keep the same meaning.

So why didn't mathmatics develop the way language has? Or maybe the better question is why hasn't language developed the way mathmatics has?

2 Answers 2021-10-15

The AskHistorians 2021 Digital Conference kicks off next week! All events are free to attend, but live events have limited slots available! Don't miss your chance to attend our live keynote, roundtable Q&A, or networking events! Sign up here!

3 Answers 2021-10-15

495 / 7255

Back to start