How do historians feel about Paradox Interactive historical games?

What do they get right/wrong, what narratives and myths do they perpetuate, how do you feel about how they use history as a setting for grand strategy?

3 Answers 2021-10-10

What type of leisure activities were there during the Middle Ages?

I'm wondering what people did to spend time during the Middle Ages, in Europe especially. We often hear about how the Middle Ages were a dark time, and I learned that this is mostly a misconception. So I'm wondering, what did people do to spend the time, for example were there proper restaurants (not like taverns but actual restaurants with waiters and menus etc), and did people go to the theatre to watch plays before the Renaissance?

Thanks for your answers!

1 Answers 2021-10-10

Henry VIII was consumed by his quest for a male heir. Why was there seemingly so little concern about Elizabeth I choosing not to marry and provide one?

1 Answers 2021-10-10

Did the UK consider keeping Hong Kong past the lease expiration date in 1997?

Side question. Did they consider handling over only the "new territories"? Since the 99 year lease dealt with only those parts of Hong Kong, unless I am misinformed.

1 Answers 2021-10-09

USSR ballerinas on TV?

what exactly happened, I heard when something bad happened they would put ballet on all channels. would someone be able to explain this please?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

How well known were the Vinland Sagas in 15th century Europe? Were they considered historical documents or mythology?

Specifically I'm wondering if as Columbus was casting about for funding of a Western passage to India that would've rebuffed him b/c those Sagas indicated that the passage might be blocked by another continent.

1 Answers 2021-10-09

How did the Soviets react to American advances in CPU design?

So, reading about the Intel 4004 CPU and this caught my attention:

Federico Faggin accomplished what no one had achieved before: to fit a general-purpose CPU into a small, commercial silicon chip

Which seems like a huge leap! This in turn brought Intel to the forefront of CPU technology and put them on the path to become what they are today.

But given that this was at the height of the cold war...what were the Soviets doing while all this happened?

Did Soviet leadership recognize how important this was or they dismissed it?

What was the reaction inside the Soviet scientific community? As far as I know, around these years cybernetics was a huge topic in the Soviet Union.

Why did the Soviets (and for that matter, the rest of Europe too...) fell behind so fast compared to the Americans when it came to CPU research?

2 Answers 2021-10-09

Did Winston Churchill like James Bond?

By the time Churchill died in 1965, 12 of Ian Flemings' novels and 3 of the films had been released. As one of the founders of the British intelligence services during both World Wars, did Winston Churchill ever read a Bond story or watch one of the Connery films? If so, did he like them?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

One day I plan to make an biopic epic about lord Horatio Nelson. I’m looking for facts about his early life. I mean do you know anything about what he was doing on a certain day?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

What were the changes between French Fourth and Fifth republic to deserve such a rename

Current French state is often called the Fifth Republic. What were the changes made in 1958 to deserve considering it a new form of government?

It was also preceded by a republic, unlike other times when a republic was re-established after periods of monarchy or foreign ocupation.

1 Answers 2021-10-09

French [Canadians] and native costume work

am doing research on the dress that was generally worn in new france until the 7 years war and I noticed something interesting about the Canadians, Metis and Acadians, in many historical books of travel stories, such as Alexander Henry's Travels and adventures in the years 1760-1776 it is mentioned that he had to dress as a French Canadian so that the natives do not want to assassinate him, because of the hatred that there was towards the English in the Pontiac war, also in several films and illustrations these appear dressed from the waist down in 100% native clothing and weapons, as I show in the following examples:

Last of the mohicans excerpt:

https://preview.redd.it/z24uoywv6ee61.png?width=590&format=png&auto=webp&s=a523fac7e058c8bc7a4093b3312ab9efc55932ba

excerpt from The War That Made America documentary series:

https://preview.redd.it/xbhtskt46ee61.png?width=850&format=png&auto=webp&s=046eba5a6b28efbe272a3aa986659cd40edb2117

Books illustrations:

https://preview.redd.it/68yd1ldc6ee61.jpg?width=1081&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=70dacb81a50f4b97478262524641569b172f31b7

ask to consult the community if this is real or is a historical error, I await your answers.

1 Answers 2021-10-09

As I understand it, feudalism/vassalage was used to manage lands without investing in a massive administrative organization; as far as I can tell, however, it just gives authority away without making anything simpler. How did feudalism actually minimize bureaucracy?

I'm clearly misunderstanding something here; I'd love help figuring out what.

Here's the basic reasoning behind feudalism and vassalage, as far as I understand it. You've conquered a lot of lands, but you don't have the bureaucracy to effectively manage it. To make it easier, you break up your land and give most of it to some of your generals to administer. You no longer have as much control, but you can now extract taxes without as much hassle. However, as far as I can tell, your lands still have just as many administrators---you just don't have as much authority.

Here's my math for a fictional, simplified kingdom. Some part of this logic must be where I'm going wrong.

  • You're a king with five provinces. Each province needs a reeve to collect taxes, a bailiff to resolve disputes, and a steward to coordinate everything else. That's a total of 15 administrators, though 10 of those report to you through your stewards. (I know I'm making some extremely simplified roles, but it's the numbers that matter.)
  • You decide that that's too much, so you make your stewards into barons. Each baron rules a province, but still needs a bailiff and reeve. So that's still 15 administrators total, and still 5 direct reports, but you've told your direct reports that they don't have to listen to you as much. The bureaucracy is still the same, but you've lost quite a bit of authority.

So, since the numbers are still the same, why give up some of your ability to control your subjects? I assume that the numbers are where I'm going wrong, or maybe the numbers are the same but the costs behind each role are less. Regardless, I'd love to understand better.

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2021-10-09

Why is Stettin part of Poland and not Germany ?

If the border was going to be drawn by the river why did they left the city and surrounding outside ?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

It’s England, approximately 1605. All my mainstream friends are busy raving about the latest cash in from the Shakespeare Theatrical Universe. I just wish they’d look beyond the blockbusters and expand their horizons to some alternative indie plays. What shall I take them to?

Slightly facetious title aside, what was the theatrical culture in England towards the end of the Elizabethan/beginning of the Stewart era? We’ve all heard of Shakespeare (and Marlowe, to an extent) and know his plays were popular, but to what extent did they dominate the theatrical scene? Were other playwrights as prolific during that time?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

I am looking to find some introductory books on European medieval arms and armour. Could you suggest something?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

Why did anti-mainland sentiments not arise in Macao similar to Hong Kong? Or do we not just hear about them?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

Was Julius Caesar what we of today would consider a fascist?

While attempting to apply modern terms to historical figures and peoples can be sometimes reductive, I find looking back with new understanding can help us as a species identify what problems seem to repeat over and over, making them stand out as "human problems" rather than just the product of one time or culture.

I've often felt that Julius Caesar's rise to power using military might and a strong-man mentality to enact control over a representative democracy as being noticeably similar to the rise of fascism and dictatorships in the modern age.

More specific questions: In what ways was Julius Caesar fascist and in what ways was he not? Did fascist leaders draw inspiration from Caesar, and could this be the reason for the parallels? In what ways is fascism of the 20th century different from other populist/dictatorial movements from history? Are there other historical leaders that fit into our understanding of conservative populism and/or fascism? What readings do you recommend for study on populism/facism throughout history?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

How many soldiers returned from WWI and WWII with severe hearing damage?

I've shot contemporary shotguns and rifles (very stupidly) without hearing protection. One time I shot skeet for an hour, my right ear had substantial hearing loss for 4-5 days following, it was like I had water in my ear for 4 days.

I was just watching a documentary about WWI and it showed a clip of a soldier firing a belt fed machine gun with no hearing protection, and all I could think about were his ears.

I know they didn't have much in the way of hearing protection in WWI and WWII. The majority of soldiers who returned must have had some pretty serious damage to their hearing with the continuous machine gun and rifle fire.

1 Answers 2021-10-09

Announcing the Best of September Award Winners

The time has come once again to crown the Best Answers, and announce the September Awardees!

This month's pick for the "Flairs' Choice Award" goes to /u/Trevor_Culley for their work on Alexander the Great's invasion of India gets no mention in Indian sources, all our knowledge of it comes from Greek sources. Are records lost or did Indian historians consider it unimportant?

Next up we have the "Users' Choice Award" going to the magnificent /u/YourlocalTitanicguy for What would the odds be of Dua Lipa actually surviving the sinking of the Titanic?

The "Dark Horse Award" was a very close fought race this month, with /u/TremulousHand narrowly taking the victory with Do we have knowledge if Beowulf was considered 'special' at it's time or was it one of many but it's the one that survived to us?

For this month's 'Greatest Question', voted on by the mods, goes to During the early 1500s, the Indian ocean was contested by the Portuguese and the Muslim powers. How did the sailing practices and traditions of the Portuguese, Ottomans, Mamluks and Gujaratis differ? by /u/thePhantom_Warlock! Still hoping for that special answer.

Finally, we come to Septembers "Excellent in Flairdom Award". A hard-working contributor, who’s written quite a number of fantastic multipart & extensive posts. Never afraid to throw themselves into a tough thread, congratulations go to /u/Kelpie-Cat! Thank you for your fantastic answers!

As always, congrats to our very worthy winners, and thank you to everyone else who has contributed here, whether with thought-provoking questions or fascinating answers. And if this month you want to flag some stand-out posts that you read here for potential nomination, don't forget to post them in our Sunday Digest!

For a list of past winners, check them out here!

6 Answers 2021-10-09

Where did Nazi Germany find the workforce in 1941 for the holocaust, an astonishing logistical achievement in mass murder, when operation Barbossa was happening?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

What was the support like for leftist organizations in the early 20th century by communities of color in the United States? Did African-Americans get any noticeable involvement in the Communist Party? Did Mexican or Chinese immigrants latch onto progressive organizations to help them in America?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

Why did Norway and Denmark join NATO whereas Sweden prefer to stay neutral despite the obvious danger of its neighbor, the Soviet Union?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

What precisely was the American-Liberian relationship like once the U.S. helped set up the colony? Was there a massive amount of support going from the U.S. to Liberia? Was Liberia seen as a "child" to the United States leadership?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

How much did the Holocaust cost the German state? Did the Nazis gain more from plundering Jewish assets than expending state resources from exterminating them?

Sorry for the grim question but it's something that I am curious of. However, I can't find any online resources that touches on this specific topic. What the search results yield to me is how much the Nazis plundered from Jewish assets, but nothing on how much the genocide cost the German state. I'm curious about this because intuitively, it would be a huge waste of resources to be persecuting millions of people. Aside from the loss of talent (Jewish scientists fled Germany along with their know-how on creating the atom bomb), I imagine that setting up death camps would also take up valuable manpower that could have instead been sent to the frontline, along with the finances that could have instead been used somewhere else.

1 Answers 2021-10-09

How accessible and affordable to lower classes was beer in Medieval Europe?

Although water was cheaper (free?) and easy to access, beer was a common drink during the Middle Ages, especially in northern and eastern Europe where the climate did not favor grape cultivation and wine production.

I know that abbeys became centers of beer production during this time. However, were monasteries and other Christian institutions actual production breweries? Did the industrialization of brewing emerge in the Middle Ages or a later period? Were there secular production facilities reserved for making beer? Where did the average peasant of, say, the duchy of Brabant get his pint from?

1 Answers 2021-10-09

503 / 7255

Back to start