Are there massive events, like battles or the existence of some city, that historians debate whether or not they happened

1 Answers 2015-07-16

What was the Vandal administration of North Africa like?

When the Vandals occupied parts of Spain and North Africa, how did they handle going from a migratory tribal confederacy to controlling a number of cities and their administrations?

2 Answers 2015-07-16

Confusing Calligraphy

is there anyone on here who can translate Japanese Iconography? I am trying to translate an inscription n a sword, but I can't seem to post it here, and I have no clue how to decipher it. The local University has next to nothing on this.

1 Answers 2015-07-16

How did the Romans do engineering?

This is questions that has always fascinated me, how the Romans engineered things.

Did they have engineering standards, material specifications, uniform factors of safety? How did they calculate the load bearing requirements of an arch for a bridge or aqueduct and how did they then use these requirements to design the structure itself.

Where did they get their education? Did a Roman engineer go to school or was it an apprentice program?

Have any engineering documents from Roman times survived? Architectural sketches, blueprints, calculations, etcetera.

If the Romans did calculate things like loads and stresses, would this mean they developed mathematical techniques and like concrete many of these were only rediscoveries?

I’d be interested to see some kind of analysis of Roman structures and see what margins exist in them and if these margins are uniform. Uniform margins would indicate some kind of standard.

De architectura hints at some of these answers, but I would like to know if there is more out there.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2015-07-16

[WW1] Was there any military protocol for dealing with the Spanish Flu among soldiers towards the end of WW1?

It's clear from the material I've read that people were aware of the Spanish Flu (sometimes referred to as "La Grippe" in Europe). Given that the flu's transmission was perhaps helped spread by troop movements, I'm wondering whether or not any of the militaries participating in WW1 had any protocol for helping the minimize infection among their troops. Certainly, there are photos of large wards set up among the civilian population in old gymnasiums and the like. Given that the flu attacked younger adults with stronger immune systems, I imagine it would be a big concern for any army.

1 Answers 2015-07-16

Did Stalin, Churchill, and other world leaders know that Franklin Roosevelt needed a wheelchair to get around? What about members of congress and other government officials not in Roosevelt's inner circle?

I know that Roosevelt's condition was hid from the American public. But how well kept of secret was it? Did most politicians know that FDR couldn't walk? I imagine that at conferences with world leaders it would be obvious to foreign heads of state. Thinking about it, I feel most photos of FDR, Churchill, and Stalin are shown with all three sitting down.

3 Answers 2015-07-16

What happened to U.S. (non-CSA aligned) troops who were stationed in the southern states at the outbreak of the civil war?

3 Answers 2015-07-16

I was told in a college class once that the American slave trade was unique in history because it was the only one based on ethnicity, and not economy or war. Is this true?

I did hear this in my ancient China course, but approximately ¼ of that course was about the American Civil War, so I was never too sure on the accuracy.

By economy, I mean slavery based on contracts or debt.

EDIT: Thank you to everyone for some enlightening answers, especially /u/Tundur and /u/anthropology_nerd.

9 Answers 2015-07-16

Were there any internal problems with Protestant rebels in Spain during the Thirty Years War?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

How was early Rome able to lose so many battles but form new legions to keep fighting?

From the early Gallic invasion, through the Samnite wars, and up to the second Punic War) the history of Rome is full of losing battles and sometimes wars. They seem to win just by being indomitable; they just keep coming. Everytime they lose, they just form up new legions and try again. How did they keep forming new legions? Was Roman success a result of a massive population that other areas lacked? Did they have a denser population? Were they able to draw recruits from a wider area than just local areas like other city states? Or were casualties usually quite low, and there was lots of survivors to just put into new legions?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

What is the purpose of the investigation of History? Can we really "learn from history?"

Should we investigate history to know our place in it? To learn from it? Is it a goal worth pursuing in itself?

2 Answers 2015-07-16

Did volkswagen have difficulty distancing itself from Hitler's Germany after WWII?

They went from being hitler's solution to transport to being a hippy's dream car pretty quickly. How did they do this?

3 Answers 2015-07-16

What caused the difference in culture between the southern states and the northern states in the US?

There were differences during the civil war and the southern states continue to be more republican than the northern states at present. What caused these differences?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in July 16 2015:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

4 Answers 2015-07-16

Did Hispanics play a significant role in the Civil Rights Movement?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

Yesterday I visited the National Museum of Denmark, and was intrigued by the many people who'd been sacrificed in bogs. Are there any good books on human sacrifice in northern Europe?

2 Answers 2015-07-16

Was Arab slave trade worse than the atlantic slave trade? If so, why are we not taught about it?

Hi,

Arab slave trade was never even mentioned in my history class - yet after a little bit of research, it seems it was much more impactful than the slave trade done by the West, lasted for longer and led to more people dying. Is this the case, and if so, why are we not taught this in history class and why is that never part of the conversation in modern, politically correct Europe/US?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

How Russian is Lenin?

Hello! The question might be a bit wierd, but i'm intersted how much russian is Lenin? I'm asking because i know that his mother is non-russian (if Wikipedia hasn't lied to me) and i'm intersted in what cultural sphere did he grow up, how did he identify himself and what nationality can we give him today knowing his roots (Russian or other)? Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2015-07-16

Information about Medieval robberies and heists?

I'm wanting to do some research into Medieval robberies and heists, but having no look trying to find information. Google is just giving crap about modern day ones.

Any help?

2 Answers 2015-07-16

What impact did the Protestant Reformation have on the Orthodox Church? Were there any reformation attempts tried outside Catholicism?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

Why did Caesar overthrow the Republic?

I've realised that while I of course know Caesar ended the Roman Republic and laid the foundations for the Empire, I've never really wondered why he did this. Was it a selfish quest for power - was he that sort of person? Did he believe he was reforming Rome for the better - and did others?

3 Answers 2015-07-16

What is the cause of the cultural differences between northern and southern Europe?

Some people say it is a myth, but most people who have friends from different countries in Europe would agree there is at least some truth to the idea there is a cultural difference between places like the UK, Germany and Sweden and places like southern Italy, Spain and Greece. This particularly manifests itself in things like punctuality, attitudes to following rules, open emotional warmth in conversation etc.

So what was the historical cause of this difference? When did it first emerge?

1 Answers 2015-07-16

Teotihuacan v. the Mayan World

I am listening to this fantastic lecture series and one of the things that keeps coming up as the lecturer discusses the histories of various specific Mayan cities in the Early Classic period, in the histories of several of these cities we hear about the warlord Siya Kak from Teotihucan. He likely killed the king of Tikal and the entire royal family of Washaktun and then winds up as the overlord of a whole bunch of cities after installing himself and other Teotihucan nobles as Mayan style kings.

This sounds like a fantastic story from history and I have a bunch of questions about it. How much do we know about how this actually went down? Are there attestations of these people and events from any other sources than the relevant Mayan royal inscriptions? Looking at the map it looks like quite far between Teotihucan and the area where these cities are. Is the any evidence of the rulers of Teotihucan doing this same kind of thing to the people in between them and the Maya? Are these historical persons from Teotihucan actually Mayan as well, or do we just know them by Mayan names because that is the language our sources are in? Was this projection of power limited to the one generation and these specific people, or was it more lasting?

3 Answers 2015-07-16

Were there any signs of the native American tribes moving towards unification before the arrival of Europeans?

From what I understand, the native American tribes were often at war with each other. As with most continents, somebody starts winning and before you know it there's a unified civilisation (the Roman Empire, Chinese empires throughout the different dynasties).

Is there any historical proof that the native Americans of what is now the US, were starting to become one nation? Which tribes were the "masters" then, that conquered?

3 Answers 2015-07-16

How accepted is Jacques R. Pauwels' "The Myth of the Good War: America in the Second World War" by the historical community?

Pauwels has some rather strong claims about the Allies' schemes towards Germany in WW2. I ask how accepted Pauwels' book is.

1 Answers 2015-07-16

5180 / 7255

Back to start