Alabama and Florida state flags, evidence that they were modeled after the CSA battle flag, or the Spanish Burgundy Cross, or?

I have the impression that there is debate over the state flags of Alabama and Florida, which were both created in the 1890s (at least the red St. Andrew's cross was added then). Some say they are based on the Spanish Burgundy Cross. Others say the Confederate battle flag. And there are other theories, I think.

In this book, The Confederate Battle Flag, which seems decently scholarly, the author John Coski seems to say the two state flags were based on the CSA battle flag, but then doesn't make a particularly strong argument about it.

This letter, from the Attorney General of Alabama, states bluntly that the flag is based on a Confederate battle flag. But I'm not sure how good a source it is.

I've read that in the 1910s the United Daughters of the Confederacy said that Alabama's flag was based on the battle flag. Do claims about the Spanish Burgundy Cross go back that far? Or is that an idea that came up later?

It is curious that both states adopted the same basic design at the same time. As far as I can tell Alabama was first and Florida essentially copied the idea? The flag laws they passed don't say anything about the meaning of the red St. Andrew's cross. Do we have correspondences between the states, their governors, legislatures, etc, about the flags?

Basically I'm wondering if there are real historical sources that back up one or another theory. Do historians agree in general one way or another, or it is a matter of debate and conjecture?

EDIT, to add one more observation/question: The Spanish-American War happened around the time Alabama and Florida added the red St. Andrew's cross. Today is seems totally reasonable that Florida, and maybe Alabama, would honor their Spanish history. But in the 1890s?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

What were Ancient and Medieval peoples' attitudes towards "underage" drinking?

In ancient and medieval times, could a 12-year old kid buy a bottle of wine, and if his mother saw him drinking it would he be chastised?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

How was it decided what soldiers went to the front in battle?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

Common ancestors of stuttering/stammering.

Hello, r/askhistorians!

I am a long time lurker of this sub and finally decided to post something. I hope you guys and gals can assist me in my current quest for understanding.

I do apologize if this is the wrong sub. If it is kindly point me in the right direction.

I have a stutter. I've been reading scientific research into this and it says that stuttering more than likely stemmed from a common ancestor, as a mutation in the genes.

I am here to inquire about who this common ancestor may be.

Historians, to your knowledge who is the first person who may have had this?

Thank you for your time and assistance. I do truly appreciate it.

1 Answers 2015-06-26

Why were so many Jews in the Netherlands deported and murdered during World War II and the Holocaust as compared to other Western European countries?

About two thirds of Jews in the Netherlands were deported East to their death, whereas much lower percentages of Jews were deported from other Western European countries. Why?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

How was maritime justice handled during the age of sail?

I'm curious how crime and discipline were handled aboard ships (All different answers, I expect) during the age of sail. I believe military officers were empowered to summarily execute members of the crew in extreme situations/offenses, but what about merchant or pirate vessels? Did it vary vastly from ship to ship (I expect this is the answer for pirates) or was the an agreed upon charter/law for Captains to follow?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

You know those sci-fi stripbooks about the year 2000, with flying cars and stuff. But are there more sources in history on what people thought how the year 2000 would look like?

What are the differences between time(medieval age, the industrial revolution, etc.) people(Europeans/Americans for example) and culture (Islamic, Christian culture)? Who was (partly) right and who was totally wrong? Can these thoughts be explained based on events in history?

2 Answers 2015-06-26

What would victory for the Confederacy have looked like?

2 Answers 2015-06-26

Why do we trace Modern radical Islamic thought to Qutb instead of the Mahdi/the Mahdi state in Sudan?

how did the Mahdi's political islam impact future currents of thought and events in the islamic world that would have touched on

On some level i'm pretty sure i understand why Qutb is seen as the originator but i'm always a little bit bothered how this narrative seems to place him outside of the events of the late long 19th century. Did they just not have a big impact?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

The Celts in Gual had Road Systems, Cities with Large Populations and so On, What do we Know About Urbanization There Before Caeser?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

Was Anthony Johnson the first man in America to own a black slave?

I've often heard from others that the first man in the British colonies of North America to possess as permanent property a black African was a black planter named Anthony Johnson. Is there any validity to this claim?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

In medieval Japan, during the time of the Samurai, was honor and tradition as binding as shown in films and other pop culture mediums?

Asking whether or not the Bushido code was truly supreme in culture and society, if detractors from the traditions were as common as , let's say, those who ignored chivalry in medieval Europe.

3 Answers 2015-06-26

In World War One, why did the Allies agree to an armistice in 1918, if they were finally winning?

In November of 1918, the Allied Powers ended World War One by signing an Armistice agreement with the remaining belligerents. At this point, the German army was loosing territory at a rate of miles a day, and the Americans were finally beginning to devote their full industrial and demographic resources to the war effort. Despite the collapse of the Eastern Front and the withdrawal of the Russian Empire in March of 1918, the Italians had the Austrians on the rope and the British were successfully chasing the Ottomans out of the Levant and Mesopotamia.

So why did the Allies agree to an armistice that left their enemies intact at the very time when they were finally in a position to crush them once and for all?

Reading Hew Strathan's The First World War, I couldn't help but feel that by agreeing to an armistice, the French and British were literally snatching defeat from the Jaws of victory. But clearly the Allied leadership of had different priorities back in 1918. I suspect that my reading of events is influenced by the knowledge that Germany would start another massive war 20 years later, but I don't quite understand why agreeing to an armistice seemed like a good idea to the Allied leadership in late 1918.

Why did the Allies not want push on to forcibly take Berlin and like the Germans had taken Paris back in 1871?

3 Answers 2015-06-26

Why are there seemingly so few really old buildings in North America?

I remember reading a quotation by Bill Bryson stating that there were more 17th century building in the Yorkshire village he was living in than the whole of the US. Now north America saw European settlers from the late 15th century, and they presumably build buildings the same way they did in Europe, so why are there seemingly so few around still? There are rather few Tutor buildings in Britain still, and I guess similarly in the rest of Europe, but even relatively fewer still in the Americas. Am I imagining this or it true and why?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

What are some lesser known origins of wedding traditions?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

What rifles / muskets did the British army use after the brown bess and baker rifle were decommissioned and before the Enfield snider was introduced? there appears to be a gap.

What rifles / muskets did the British army use after the brown bess and baker rifle were decommissioned and before the Enfield snider was introduced? there appears to be a gap.

Also, why did it seem to take Britain far longer than say e.g. France to adopt a percussion rifle?

(or am I just incorrect?) thanks for your responses.

1 Answers 2015-06-26

Reading Casanova's memoirs have given me some questions about 18th century chocolate consumption

I noticed that Casanova is consuming chocolate often and that many friends he makes invite him to "take chocolate with them" in the mornings. What was chocolate like in 18th century Italy and how prevalent was it? Was it really that normal to invite over guests to eat chocolate with you and hold a conversation? Also chocolate isn't really known as something you would eat in the morning but was it consumed early in the day often?

2 Answers 2015-06-26

What are some lesser known origins of wedding traditions?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

Where does "man of the cloth" come from?

Title. What is "the cloth", specifically? Why are priests, nuns, and the like referred to as such? When did this title come about?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

A question about bombing campaigns.

I keep having debated with people about the effectiveness of a bombs only campaign to end a war/conflict. The only one I can think of is the Pacific theatre of WWII. Are there any wars that have been won only with an air campaign?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

During the attack on Pearl Harbor, how long did it take American forces to figure out it was Japan that was attacking?

2 Answers 2015-06-26

Why were certain peoples, i.e.; Sorbians and Polabians, able to be very effectively Germanised, while others, like Czechs and Poles, only offered partial successes at best?

I'm aware that there were efforts to Germanise various races, mostly Slavic, first in the HRE and then in Austria and the German Empire. Why were certain peoples like those mentioned above much more successfully assimilated into German society/culture?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

reasons for british in the subcontinent

1 Answers 2015-06-26

[WW2] German tanks and tank destroyers. If tank destroyers were so much more plentiful than thanks, and easier to produce, why not use tank destroyers instead of tanks?

1 Answers 2015-06-26

One Man-stands

2 Answers 2015-06-26

5252 / 7255

Back to start