Is there any chance that the Indigenous Australians actually 'stole' the land from another race before them?

What if there was another race of humans that inhabited Australia before the Aboriginals and had their land stolen by them?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

Did anyone ever 'discover'/think of Evolution before Darwin?

As in, anyone ever think of or something and not tell it to anyone?

1 Answers 2015-06-10

Recently rewatching Band of Brothers and I have a question about the medics.

When soilders get injured the soilders round them put this white powder all over the wound until the medics come. Can someone tell me what exactly this is? Is it some sort of antiseptic or something to slow the blood flow?

1 Answers 2015-06-09

How much time and preparation would be required to pass the Imperial Examinations during the Song Dynasty?

1 Answers 2015-06-09

In the Roman Empire what was stopping a Subject claiming to be a citizen to gain more rights? How could this be confirmed if one moved to a different region?

There was obviously no ID card or computer database to check. What was stopping say, somebody in Nazareth in the year 1CE, moving from Judea to Gaul and assuming citizenship?

1 Answers 2015-06-09

What are some accurate and in depth podcasts over a broad range of historical topics?

I'm just finishing out Dan Carlin's Hardcore History (at least the free ones), and I really enjoyed them. I did some looking around, and a lot of the history podcasts I found feel pretty ... Superficial. I figured you guys would be the ones to ask. Thanks in advance!

6 Answers 2015-06-09

How related to the citizens of Rome are the modern citizens of Italy and Italians in general?

In the Sopranos there was a scene where Tony and his gang are torturing a Jewish guy who owes them money or something. The Jewish guy says something about how hateful people will always get their downfall and says something like "Look at the Roman Empire. Where are the mighty Romans today?" And then Tony says something badass like, "You're looking at them, motherfucker." And then they drill his kneecaps or whatever.

So, how true is that statement? Are modern Italians direct descendants of the citizens of Rome? Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2015-06-09

Has the US really been at war 222 out of 239 years since 1776?

I've seen this image being posted on social media claiming that the US has been at war 222 out of 239 years since 1776. Is this true or just some made-up fact?

3 Answers 2015-06-09

In medieval warfare, how difficult would it have been for twenty good men to sneak into an enemy's wilderness camp and set fire to the siege weapons and supplies without getting caught?

1 Answers 2015-06-09

At the time of Waterloo, where were the forces of the other members of the Seventh Coalition?

Where were the forces of Austria, Russia, Sweden, Spain, and Portugal located? How ready were they to carry on a war with Napoleon, should the campaign in the low countries go badly for the coalition?

In comparison, what about France?

1 Answers 2015-06-09

Why did the early Christians style themselves as a new religion as opposed to considering themselves the true followers of Judaism?

1 Answers 2015-06-09

How did Vichy France find any soldiers to fight the allies in World War Two?

The Vichy French fought the allies in Africa, Syria, and even Madagascar. Considering how explosive anti-Nazi sentiment was after their liberation (rape and humiliation of Nazi sympathizers), it blows my mind how the puppet government could find troops to essentially fight FOR their historical rivals that had just destroyed their country.

Did they have problems maintaining discipline? Was desertion a serious issue?

EDIT: I realize similar questions have been asked before. To emphasize distinction. This thread concerns the legal impacts of Vichy France. This one wasn't really answered.

1 Answers 2015-06-09

How long would the average melee battle (pre gunpowder) last between armies?

Although "throughout history" questions are to be avoided, I must ask because I assume the answer would change with time period, culture, arms, armor, tactics, and battle formations.

1 Answers 2015-06-09

Resources On Crusades Armies

I'm looking for a book or books that have information regarding the militaries that fought in the Crusades, or even the medieval ages more generally, but with a more detailed focus on the arms, armor, orders of battle and actual fighting formations being used.

I've got a stack of booms that talk about medieval warfare more generally but I can't find any that talk about how knights might have fought on the battlefield or how spearwalls would be employed or other specific tactical information. Thanks ahead of time.

1 Answers 2015-06-09

When discussing Axis troops in WW2, the Italians and Romanians are often seen as weaker or inferior forces. The facts do seem to indicate that they were less effective than the German troops. Why?

My own perception is that they were poorly equipped, not as well trained, and also less motivated. Hitler was a great leader. Mussolini less so, and the puppet Romanian government was... well... a puppet government. If I were conscripted in Italy or Romania, I doubt that I'd give 100% and I would probably surrender the first chance I got.

But are my perceptions typical of those involved or am I talking out of my extremities?

And why did German troops care so much more? Culture? Indoctrination? Shame of defeat in WW1? Other?

4 Answers 2015-06-09

The US spent 26 billion dollars on the failed Iraqi Army. What are the best and worst historical examples of local armies propped up by foreign powers?

1 Answers 2015-06-09

How are we able to understand how mesoamerican languages (Nahuatl, for example) work (phonetics and grammar wise) if the Spanish destroyed nearly all mesoamerican documentation?

2 Answers 2015-06-09

What was the significance of beating Russia to the moon?

Or the moon landing in general. It obviously inspired patriotism, but what other effects did it have?

1 Answers 2015-06-09

I am a 5'4" tall woman, which is the average height of a woman in the modern US. Was there ever a time/place in European history when I would have been considered tall (or edging towards tallness) for a woman?

2 Answers 2015-06-09

Were the atomic bombings of Japan necessary to facilitate a Japanese surrender?

The conventional wisdom is that, as horrible as the bombings were, they were necessary to avoid a US invasion of mainland Japan which would have led to significantly more deaths on both sides.

I never really considered a reason to doubt this, but as I read more about the history of nuclear weapons, I find myself asking some surprising questions. In Kai Bird & Martin Sherwin's American Prometheus: The Triumph and Tragedy of J. Robert Oppenheimer, there's a full chapter dedicated to where the bombings took place, and why. They refer to a series of meetings in Washington after the Trinity test where the top brass made all the pertinent strategic decisions of using the bombs. Bird & Sherwin attempt to illustrate (in their book about Oppenheimer: a fairly pacifistic and diplomatic personality) that the meetings basically fell into two camps: Oppenheimer and the Los Alamos scientists on the one side, and the military brass on the other side. Apparently Oppenheimer argued for a detonation over the sea, to demonstrate power without taking lives. The military retort that they have to show what the bomb can do to a population centre, and they have to use both to show Stalin that they have an arsenal (so they can keep him in check after the war). They feature excerpts from the diaries of high-ranking Truman aides which suggest that the Japanese Empire might have been willing to surrender even before a bombing or an invasion, as long as some conditions are met (chiefly, that the office/title of Emperor won't just disappear after reconstruction).

So I thought that was interesting, and it put the bombings in a whole new light for me. Then I read Command & Control by Eric Schlosser, and he references historical arguments like Bird & Sherwin's and basically waves his hand and says that it's just conjecture and that the bombings were not only inevitable, but necessary to facilitate a surrender.

So, my question is what the historical consensus says about this issue, beyond the basic pop history books that introduced me to these ideas.

edit: I'm also shamefully ignorant of what exactly was happening between Japan and the USSR after German surrender, and if this could have influenced the decision at all.

1 Answers 2015-06-09

Lineage of Confucius?

I've read in several places that the family line of Confucius can be traced back a ridiculous number of generations, and that he has known descendants today. Is this family line historically verified, or is it just tradition?

1 Answers 2015-06-09

No Such Thing As A Stupid Question: How Could A Time Traveller Take Over The Premodern World, "Pasta God" Style?

2 Answers 2015-06-09

Why does the Amazon rainforest fall mostly within the borders of Brazil, when the line of demarcation set by the Treaty of Tordesillas gave Spain most of control over the Amazon?

2 Answers 2015-06-09

How many different versions of the Persians did the Romans fight with over its 2000 year existence (inc Byzantine Empire)

In just the Republic years it had dealings with the Seleucids & Parthians. Were there any Roman mercenaries fighting with Xenophon? How many Persian Governments fell while Constantinople watched the bodies of its enemies float downstream?

2 Answers 2015-06-09

I'm a citizen of the Roman Empire in 150CE and I want to buy a home. How does the home buying process in Rome work? Mortgages? Paperwork? Realtors?

2 Answers 2015-06-09

5313 / 7255

Back to start