Would a WW2 U-boat have been able to contact a US destroyer via the Talk-Between-Ships (“TBS”) system?

I’m doing some historical research about the sinking of the U-550 on 4/16/1944 for a book that I’m writing (two publishing offers so far!) The USS Gandy, one of three US destroyers engaging the surfaced & largely defenseless U-boat, reported hearing “a Germanic accent” over their TBS system during the engagement. The words were not understood but it was believed to be an attempt to surrender. The U-550’s crew was indeed trying very badly to surrender at that moment, as they were crippled and under withering fire from three directions.

This claim, accurate or not, made it into the USS Gandy’s official reporting of the engagement. I’m not familiar enough with how the TBS system worked to know offhand how likely this claim is. There is no record from the German side of any such attempt, but the majority of the crew did not survive the battle so it’s possible the funker or someone other than the captain (who survived) made the attempt and subsequently died.

Several other things in the destroyers’ reports- such as the sub firing on them with its conning tower guns- are patently untrue and can be attributed to the stress and chaos of the brief but intense encounter. This claim could very well be another result of the Fog of War.

1 Answers 2021-09-08

How accurate is this map in my history textbook?

The map in question is here (https://www.reddit.com/user/Divorcefrenchodad/comments/pkjf21/questionable/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf) your specially the part about the US is questionable

2 Answers 2021-09-08

Was there any kind of signal that something big would happen in the months prior the 9/11 terrorist attacks?

Any credible threads or ultimatums? Any odd noticeable increase or decrease in islamic terrorist activity?

The only thing I've found into explaining the motivation for the attack before it happened, are the fatwas from Al-Qaeda from 1996 and 1998, but they are really just a denouncement of the US and a call to arms for muslims.

1 Answers 2021-09-08

The Continental Army is portrayed as fighting a guerilla war against the British, but Washington trained his troops for European-style set-piece battles. Did the army manage to switch between both combat styles? Did it ever excel at either style?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Since gay people weren’t allowed to serve in the military until pretty recently did draft dodgers pretend to be gay during the Vietnam war? What were the repercussions or roadblocks to doing so?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Was there superstitious beliefs about witches in early 1900s?

Did the belief of witches ever cease to exist? If someone thought a girl was a witch, how might she be treated? Would someone hold their breath around a "witch" for example or do any other sort of weird behaviors?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Why aren't these cities the capitals of these states?

I have no clue as to why cities such as LA and NYC aren't the capital of there respective states. so i've made a list of cities I think should be the capital of their states

Florida: Miami

California: Los Angeles

New York: New York City

Illinois: Chicago

Ohio: Cleveland

Pennsylvania: Philadelphia

Washington: Seattle

and finally Louisiana: New Orleans

2 Answers 2021-09-08

Where to start reading about the history of the CIA?

I recently watched the 2019 film The Report, and also listened to a brief podcast series on Operation: Midnight Climax, and I'm interested in learning more about the history of the CIA, and, essentially, how we got from "intelligence and spycraft during WWII" to "an agency which has undeniably committed numerous severe human rights violations over decades both at home and abroad". My knowledge of the agency is currently limited to "they did MKUltra, which was a grotesque violation of human rights," "they have facilitated the overthrow of democratically elected governments in a bunch of different countries," and "they tortured a bunch of people as part of our 'War on Terror'."

Obviously I'm bringing my own biases, and I'm not exactly looking for a defense of the agency, but I would like to read some things that at least attempt a neutral perspective. Most of my normal reading tends to skew very heavily left, where the narrative is (perhaps rightly) that the CIA is deeply, deeply troubling as an agency. I'm interested in a more nuanced look at the agency, from it's inception. What books and articles would you recommend?

2 Answers 2021-09-08

What did the Romans think of Stonehenge? Did they ever wonder who built it and what it was made for?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Where to start when reading Greek Tales

I have been a big fan of Greek mythology as long as I can remember, but my first exposure to Greek mythology in literature, like most people, was the Percy Jackson series. I love pretty much anything to do with Greek mythology, whether it be games, or mentions of the gods in stories and film/TV, but I'm never certain where to look for accurate stories about the deities of Olympus (or the underworld) due to oral tradition spreading misinformation which then gets documented down in literature.

If anyone knows original stories to read to get an accurate understanding of these Greek Tales, it would be greatly appreciated.

PS. If anyone also plays games, can you tell me the accuracy of zagreus' story in the game Hades?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Did they have flat tops (hair style) in Ancient Rome?

I am doing a research project on hair styles worn by the Ancient Romans. There seems to a be a lot written about hairstyles worn by women, and some descriptions of how hair changed amongst men in the imperial period (e.g. curls in the era of Nero progressing to shorter cropped hair with bangs in the time of Trajan). But what about flat tops?

Having recent come across the classic film Spartacus (1960), the titular character is graced with a "flat top." This film is very highly regarded, and still a classic, but is this hairstyle appropriate? If not found with Romans, perhaps it was a Thracian haircut (per the ethnicity of Spartacus)? A renowned film critic Dr. Cifaretto poignantly commented on this (trying to find the exact source, I will try to return with one later). Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Why was salt so valuable when it could be easily produced anywhere with access to the sea?

From the Roman period where the world "salary" came from "salt", all the way upto the 20th century, when the Indian independence movement was characterized by protests against British salt taxes; what made common salt such a valuable commodity?

Why couldn't anyone with a coastline produce it? And what made it so cheap today, as compared to a century ago?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Why do collectivized farms fail?

I am sorry if this has been asked repeatedly, but I'm curious. I know that the collective farming in both the Great Leap Forward and the Holodomor caused an actual reduction in grain production. But why was that so? What was happening, on the ground, for it to fail? Why didn't other Soviet plans like the production of concrete and steel fail in the same way? After the failure, what steps were taken to correct the issues present in collective farms?

2 Answers 2021-09-08

Short Answers to Simple Questions | September 08, 2021

Previous weeks!

Please Be Aware: We expect everyone to read the rules and guidelines of this thread. Mods will remove questions which we deem to be too involved for the theme in place here. We will remove answers which don't include a source. These removals will be without notice. Please follow the rules.

Some questions people have just don't require depth. This thread is a recurring feature intended to provide a space for those simple, straight forward questions that are otherwise unsuited for the format of the subreddit.

Here are the ground rules:

  • Top Level Posts should be questions in their own right.
  • Questions should be clear and specific in the information that they are asking for.
  • Questions which ask about broader concepts may be removed at the discretion of the Mod Team and redirected to post as a standalone question.
  • We realize that in some cases, users may pose questions that they don't realize are more complicated than they think. In these cases, we will suggest reposting as a stand-alone question.
  • Answers MUST be properly sourced to respectable literature. Unlike regular questions in the sub where sources are only required upon request, the lack of a source will result in removal of the answer.
  • Academic secondary sources are prefered. Tertiary sources are acceptable if they are of academic rigor (such as a book from the 'Oxford Companion' series, or a reference work from an academic press).
  • The only rule being relaxed here is with regard to depth, insofar as the anticipated questions are ones which do not require it. All other rules of the subreddit are in force.

42 Answers 2021-09-08

How did the public think about wealth requirement to vote in the early US?

I watched a series of videos by a content creator called Mr Beat where he talks about presidential election and in the end he says how high percentage of the population voted in each election. For the first few is is very low, less than 5% in 1812, and on wikipedia (link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_turnout_in_United_States_presidential_elections#History_of_voter_turnout ) it says that for decades voting rights were tied with owning property or paying a certain amount of taxes.

This makes me wonder three things:

  1. What did the general public think about these wealth requirements for voting when they so recently fought the war of independence?
  2. Was such a low voter participation the intention of the founders? One can often hear about how much they worried about the general public and "mob rule", so this seems to support the idea that only the "elite" should vote.
  3. Why did the requirements for voting change and why did the (possible) sentiment that only the elite should vote change?

Thanks in advance for any help!

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Which side did the Romans walk on?

An image was recently posted in r/ArtefactPorn of a mosaic at the entrance to a Roman-era (1st-2nd century AD) bathhouse in Timgad, Algeria. The mosaic depicts two messages, one of which was "BENE LAVA" (Have a Good Bath) and the other presumably "SALUM LAVISSE" (Hope You Had a Nice Bath), forming a welcome and goodbye sign, as each was flipped to read correctly for readers in either direction along the long edge. Essentially it looked like a modern bathmat.

In the centre are two sandals similarly oriented, suggesting that they guided viewers in the direction of travel (coming and going). On either side, the sandals on the left represented the viewer's direction (the straps are to the front).

What do we know about directing pedestrian traffic in the Roman Empire? Could it just have been an accident that the sandals were oriented this way in the mosaic or was it practice that Roman society preferred to walk on the left? How does this square with driving on either side of the road in the Roman Empire, given that over the years there have been two (rather than one) dominant systems in the world?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

What are the cultural and theological predecessors of Islam?

Jesus was a Jew, but he started a movement that became something else entirely. Muhammad similarly started a "new" religion, but what was his "original" religion? Was he a Jew? Was he a Christian? To my understanding, these religious traditions existed in his milieu, but the relationship is unclear to me.

I know that Islam claims to be the ideological descendant of Abraham's pure religion through Ishmael, but that seems rather vague. Is there a textual tradition or remnants of an oral tradition that describes why the Israelite branch eventually became apostate?

I also understand that Islam recognizes Jesus as a great prophet, but why? Surely by Muhammad's time the Christian tradition was well established, and Jesus was firmly believed to be god himself come to earth as the Jewish messiah. What tradition of Jesus did Mohamed adhere to, and what was the basis for that tradition?

I know there's several questions here, but I guess the overall question could be rephrased as, what "scriptures" did Muhammad and his contemporaries hold sacred that provided the backdrop for why people started following him and his message?

3 Answers 2021-09-08

Active Service Pocket Book - What now?

Apologies if this is the wrong subreddit for this question. If anyone has advice of where else to post it, I appreciate it.

An old book was given to me down the family line (pics). It’s an Active Service Pocket Book, Fifth Edition, Enlarged, by Bertrand Stewart. The best I can find online dates the book around 1915.

I’ve had the book for a decade now. A few random friends have asked to read or borrow it. It’s super old but the binding is not in the worst shape. The pages feel very delicate like an old bible.

Obviously I’m skeptical of lending it out, let alone even reading it myself, for fear of damaging it. What’s my best course of action here? Is there a way to have it nicely and safely digitized so I can share it with anyone interested in reading it? It’s 950+ pages also, which feels like an insane number of pages to scan on my little all in one printer.

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Looking for Books on the English Civil War.

Hello, I am looking to learn more about the English Civil War(s) (17th century) and would love any book/audiobook recommendations. Any recommendations on Cromwell biographies would also be appreciated. Thanks!

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Why did Jewish and Italian immigrants to the United States stay so close to New York City, relative to other European immigrant groups?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Was the Spanish flu ever as politicized and divisive as COVID is?

Did people wear masks back then and social distance? Did they argue and bicker and refuse to wear a mask? Was it as tense in public and did they open carry like in the beginning of covid? Did the president endorse mask wearing?

3 Answers 2021-09-08

The first day of the battle of Gettysburg included thousands of dismounted cavalry. How did this work logistically? Where did all the horses go? Who took care of them during the fighting?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

Was there a specific uniform the World War 1 Stormtroopers used

Did they have a specific uniform or did they use what evet they had

1 Answers 2021-09-08

The Treaty of Westphalia broke up the Holy Roman Empire??

So, I was looking at this map (link below) of the Treaty of Westphalia and, if I’m interpreting it correctly, the Treaty of Westphalia reshaped Central Europe’s borders by breaking down the Holy Roman Empire into little nations, yes?

And it also gave sovereignty to individual nations so they have each have a seat in future conflict peace resolutions, yes? It’s not just the dominating power deciding everything after the Treaty of Westphalia, right?

Link to map: https://espace-mondial-atlas.sciencespo.fr/media/map-3C17-EN-large-3x.jpeg

So, “borders of the Holy Roman Empire” (the red line on the map) marks where the H.R.E. used to be?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

What did Hitler and the Nazis think of Asian people more specifically about Chinese people?

1 Answers 2021-09-08

542 / 7255

Back to start