What are some laws or things that are only "recently" accepted in our society but was completely normal during ancient times?

1 Answers 2015-05-10

Are Christian and Anglo-Saxon sources reliable on Vikings?

IMO these sources usually considers Vikings as savages and cruel murderers. Do historians usually consider these sources (usually written by monks and other religious figures) reliable at all? I just read some history "nonfictions" and I can see some bias towards blaming them as murderers and uncivilised warrior-tribes.

1 Answers 2015-05-10

Are there any major disagreements between historians?

I'm not talking specifically about what happens, but are there disagreements when it comes to interpreting those events? What are some of the more interesting disagreements?

1 Answers 2015-05-10

French WWI / Holzminden camp medal found in my yard, anyone have background info on this?

Found this medal in my front yard this morning (in Kentucky if that makes any difference). Who were these given to? How many were given out? What was the Holzminden internment camp? Here are some pictures of the medal in question: http://imgur.com/oytzuef http://imgur.com/qFrFJNF

1 Answers 2015-05-10

Why are these British soldiers marching to certain death?

I came across this video of a battle reenactment, where the British soldiers just keep marching towards the enemy, even after they start firing. What's the point of it?

4 Answers 2015-05-10

How did the conversion of pagans to monotheism come about?

2 Answers 2015-05-10

Are American government and corporate interests mixed at unprecedented levels, or are we only just now noticing it due to increased information availability? (X-post from /r/AskReddit)

2 Answers 2015-05-10

Were communist regimes often maintained by force by the Soviet Union?

I've looked at the cases of the Hungarian Revolution and the invasion of Czechoslovakia and was just wondering if force was the primary/only way in which the Soviets maintained power or control over Eastern European satellite states?

2 Answers 2015-05-10

Did indians or indian tribes participate at all in the American civil war? Did they fight on both sides? What reasons would they have to fight?

The question was prompted by this painting posted over in /r/battlepaintings which shows a person in the bottom left who is dressed in traditional native american garb fighting on the side of the confederacy. It struck me as really odd that a native american would fight for either side in the civil war as they were such a mistreated class by Americans in general. Is it possible they fought for the confederacy in order to stop the US government expansion and hostility towards indians in the west? Did they fight as mercenaries? Was there ever a formal alliance or agreement between belligerents in the civil war and whole indian tribes or was it more individual? What would the indians seek to gain from such an agreement? And finally how were native american soldiers/mercenaries incorporated into the armies, both in how they were treated by soldiers and officers and in what role they served in the fighting? Edit: upon viewing the painting again it seems there a larger number of indian cavalrymen charging in the background as well although it is hard to tell

1 Answers 2015-05-10

Numerically speaking, did more executions occur before, during or after the Jacobin "Reign of Terror"?

Did somebody do the count? I heard the affirmation that if we stick to pure numbers more executions occurred in the periods before and after the Reign of Terror that during it, but that this period has been vilified because the people killed were higher class instead of lower class.

Does this hold at all or is it just revisionism?

1 Answers 2015-05-10

What kinds of agricultural technology did Gorbachev want from the USA?

I've seen it referenced here and elsewhere that Gorbachev didn't trust Reagan would share missile shield technology because the US had not shared ag tech with the USSR. What kinds of ag tech was he hoping for?

1 Answers 2015-05-10

I am an Aztec captive selected to sacrificed. What would my last days be like?

I'm curious about things like: How would I be treated? How much familiarity would I have with Aztec rituals? What stages of preparation would I have to go through? Are there any known cases of sacrifices being freed or escaping before the big day?

1 Answers 2015-05-10

Can anyone explain exactly how wrong CW's series "Reign" is when describing the life of Mary, Queen of Scots?

I know it is wrong. I just am curious HOW wrong.

1 Answers 2015-05-10

Civil war causes & slavery

Hey everyone, northerner here in the Deep South. I've been taught my whole life that the civil war was mainly about slavery. However, obviously people here have a different opinion.

I know the war was too complex to narrow it down to one issue, but I'm fairly certain slavery was the driving cause. Does anyone have any academic resources to back that up? Or any input is appreciated. Thanks

3 Answers 2015-05-10

How did the siege warfare in medieval era work?

I've read that it was mostly a waiting game (starving out the opponent), but what if the sieger attacked? How did he conquer a castle?

2 Answers 2015-05-10

What was Britain's Naval strength during the wars with Napoleon and France?

I've been reading up a little on the war with Napoleon, and I keep reading that it was Britain's mastery of the seas that allowed them to prevent invasion, as well as fund their allies in mainland Europe. So now Im curious as to their naval strength, both from a merchant/commerce perspective, as well as a military perspective. How many various types of ships did they have, how many personnel served, how many officers, Etc.

Thanks in advance for the answers!

2 Answers 2015-05-10

Does having a strong sense of nationalism have a bad effect on the growth of economy and education?

1 Answers 2015-05-10

How did Japan revitalized its economy after WW2? What about their concept of nationalism? Were they changed?

I've read that Japan was absolutely devastated from WW2 after firebombing major cities, and the dropping of atomic bombs. I've also read that Japan, during the time of war, have a strong sense of nationalism. So how were they able to let US help them when they were the enemies in the eyes of the Japanese? What were the comprised or changes in their Japanese nationalism concept? Does having no official military helped?

2 Answers 2015-05-10

[Methodology] How will historians deal with primary sources on computers?

So my question is more about the methodology of History than actual fact. I hope it's not going to be deleted because it aims just a little bit about the present and the future. I'm really asking about the methodology and the way historians work. Note that I will talk using future tense but what I'm talking about might be already happening.

So, I'm used to seeing records on papers of archives, letters written by thinkers and authors, and so on. I have myself a book of Nietzsche with his first letters and his first written texts. Historians deal with a lot of primary sources written on paper.

But now that we have come to an electronic era... are you still going to work the same way? How will you collect the equivalent of letters written between people (e-mails, Facebook conversations perhaps) ? Isn't there any risk of false authenticity (could be easily modified), or any risk that the amount of records we have decreases with time because documents and sources are easier to lose on computers because they can be deleted?

I guess what I'm asking is how will historians deal with primary sources that were written directly on computers. Letters, texts, even art, all that made on computer today. How do you deal (or will you) with documents or sources made by the geniuses of today considering they are on computer and might not be as "fancy" as paper material (considering the slang words of the Internet and the fact that communications on Facebook or Skype will not be as fancy as 19th century hand written letters) ?

Do you think the fact that we're moving into a more virtual and technological era will change the methodology and the approach of historians on today's sources?

Thank you in advance, and sorry if the question is a bit off timeline.

3 Answers 2015-05-10

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | May 04, 2015–May 10, 2015

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2015-05-10

War Journals and Campaign studies?

Are there any War Journal and Campaign studies that anyone could suggest to me? Aside from Clausewitz & Wellingtons as well as Shermans Memoires. I'm looking for officers who would have had insight into the strategy, Logistics and tactics utilized during the war rather than a common soldiers. I don't have much preference for the time period, however Marian Reformed Rome, anything from the three kingdoms era china, and Seven Years War or Napoleonic are my main interests but I'd like to read anything to be honest.

(EDIT: Guerilla Warfare and/or revolutionary warfare studies suggestions are also appreciated)

2 Answers 2015-05-10

Why are headstones from the late 19th and early 20th century much more elaborate than today?

Whenever I drive by a very old cemetery, I'm amazed at the size and detail of headstones. In today's money those would cost a small fortune. Did people spend exorbitant amounts of money on headstones at that time or is there another explanation?

1 Answers 2015-05-10

How would Britain tell the story of the American Revolution?

What were the effects of the American Revolution on the British? How would a British historian tell the story?

1 Answers 2015-05-10

Want to go for a MA in Classics/Ancient History, is this the smart route?

I want to get my MA in Ancient History. From my understanding most programs require you to have knowledge of ancient languages. I have found this program at Rutgers, a post-bacc in Ancient Languages. Does this make sense to get this cert then apply for a classics MA? Or should I just go for a MA in "History"? Also, are there any books in English on Ancient history you would recommend? I was thinking of starting with the Decline and Fall. Thanks

http://classics.rutgers.edu/about-the-program http://classics.rutgers.edu/program-description

2 Answers 2015-05-10

The Popular Front in the Spanish Civil War help?

1 Answers 2015-05-10

5425 / 7255

Back to start