Did any Spanish Republicans who fled Spain after Franco’s victory, fight for the allies against the axis during World War 2?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

What caused the Mujahideen to schism into Al-Qaeda and the Taliban? Was it philosophical differences or otherwise?

With the situation in Afghanistan being what it is there is a popular post on another subreddit that shows an infamous picture or Reagan meeting with the Mujahideen. This got me thinking as to what actually fractured this group, and what relations between the two groups are like now.

1 Answers 2021-08-16

What is the level of continuity between the Soviet invasion-era mujahideen and the Taliban of the 1990s?

Congresswoman Rashida Tlaib had this tweet today, in which she drew a direct line between the mujahideen that the US backed against the Soviets and the Taliban now taking over Afganistan. As counterpoint, someone on Twitter said that the Taliban were founded "five years after the Soviets left Afghanistan" and linked to this article, in response to what they saw as an exaggeration of how the US' backing for the mujahideen empowered and armed the Taliban.

Is one or the other side closer to reality here? What happened within the anti-PDPA camp during the gap between the Soviet withdrawal and the Taliban coming to power? Which of the active mujahideen groups during the Soviet period actually became Taliban?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

GOP and Democratic Party - When and how did the political position shift happen?

This will be my first time posting on this subreddit, so if this post is too short or relatively shallow compared to the other discussions, sorry in advance.

I have a simple question: When and under which circumstances did Republicans and Democrats changed places politically? Considering how Republicans positioned themselves during Civil War and regarding the abolishment of slavery, they can be regarded as the progressive party back then, unlike Democrats, who were rather pro-slavery and held a conservative stance. Today, on the other hand, as we all know, Republicans are more conservative compared to the Democrats, and progressives, liberals, and even social democrats do have a wing under Democratic Party. How did such a radical shift happen?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

What exactly would I be learning or doing in Moscow in the '30s if I were a Spanish Communist party member.

1 Answers 2021-08-16

U.S. Civil War Historians, are there any Confederate songs with explicitly racist lyrics, or have they all been censored in modern times because people might find them "triggering"? Alternatively, did the South at the time ironically not write any explicitly racist songs? (I elaborate more below)

So, to phrase my question better and give more background to this, I've heard songs from the Civil War Era like "Dixie", "Bonny Blue Flag", and others, but none of them have explicitly racist lyrics from what I can tell. Now, as someone who's half Italian-American and Queer, let me state that I do not endorse racism or bigotry of any kind, this is just a question of curiosity. What I want to know is, did the explicitly racist songs written by the Confederacy:
(A) Get censored in modern times because of modern racial sensitivities.
Or...
(B) Never get written in the first place because the South wanted to focus on the message of "States' Rights" and possibly because they knew the racism made them look bad so they wanted to cover it up.

Personally, given what I know about racial attitudes at the time, I think it's VERY unlikely the confederacy would try to cover up their racism for posterity or to make themselves look more admirable. (I mean during the war, not later when the apologists came out with the whole "States' Rights" argument that's more "popular" with certain kinds of people today.) I mean, the Confederate constitution even explicitly stated how they believed Black people were inferior to White people, and it was the "White man's burden" to teach the other "underdeveloped" races how to be "civilized". Or at least it said something to that effect. One thing that is plainly clear is that they thought Black people were basically savage animals.
So where are all the racist songs? And if I can find them on YouTube (which given YouTube's current policies I probably can't), I'll be sure to cleanse my ears with a good dose of "Union Dixie" afterwards. Haha.

(Also I have a Bachelor's Degree in History yet somehow can't find a job. Please validate my existence and tell me I didn't waste my life getting a "useless" degree. 😅😅😅)

1 Answers 2021-08-16

Where there instances were eastern christians joining crusader orders?

Did Eastern Christians during the crusade joining the templars or hospitallers ever happen? Where there well known crusaders of eastern christian origin?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

How was Leon Trotsky viewed in the post-Stalin Soviet Union?

During the Stalinist Era, Leon Trotsky was one of the biggest targets for Stalin’s paranoia. It even got to the point where people were getting purged merely for having formerly associated with him. With Stalin’s death and Khrushchev’s destalinization program, was Trotsky rehabilitated like many of Stalin’s victims? If so, would he have been talked about in Soviet history classes or would they just not mention him?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

Did any of Hitler's contemporaries point out that he wasn't "Aryan"?

It's been pointed out a lot in the present day that Hitler was awfully short, brown haired, and brown eyed for someone championing a race of tall, blonde haired, blue eyed "Aryans." Did this ever come up while he was in power? Did his enemies poke fun like we do today? Did his allies express confusion? Did he have an answer ready? Is my understanding of his understanding of race excruciatingly simplistic?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

Shields with a Λ

Is there any archaeological evidence to support the idea that Spartan hoplites had a Λ for Λακεδαίμων on their shields?

I can't remember reading any such description in Herodotus or Xenophon, but it seems quite wide spread in popular culture.

2 Answers 2021-08-16

Question About British Redcoat Uniforms

I've seen British Officers wearing a gold plate around their neck in a few shows I've watched. The plate is a sort of crescent shape facing upwards. It is worn by higher ranking individuals. I wanted to learn a bit about them, but was unable to find what they were called from google. Captain Chesterfield from Frontier is one character that wears one. Can someone tell me exactly what they are?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

My German grandfather smuggled letters for the resistance against Francisco Franco in the 50s and 60s. I would love to earn more about this, so what are the best ways to research about it?

Hello everyone,

My father told me that my German grandfather smuggled letters for the resistance against Francisco Franco in the 50s and 60s. He even got caught once and was in a Spanish prison for four weeks. My father did not have a lot of contact with him, and he must have been very secretive about these jobs, so I don't know much more than his name Otto Axtmann and that he was an architect, who worked for the French in their South-German occupation zone because he was one of the few German architects who wasn't member of the Nazi party

I would love to find out more about him, and the Spanish prison might be a good starting point. Do you have any tips on how to approach this? I hope that there are any digitalized archives available.

And since this is a history sub: can you tell me a bit about post WWII fascistic Spain and how the resistance worked during this time?

I am happy about anything you have for me.

EDIT: I just found the privacy rule of this sub. My grandfather died before I was born in 1988.

1 Answers 2021-08-16

I've been taught that when Europeans found the new world, they brought with them many diseases that wiped out the native American population. but- wouldn't this work both ways? wouldnt the colonists encounter new diseases in America that they had no immunity to?

And yet, I've only ever heard the description of how European diseases effected the natives, and not the other way around. Even though- from what I've been told- the Europeans had worse hygiene and would rarely bathe, while native americans were cleaner and bathed often. what gives?

5 Answers 2021-08-16

Did humans have fleas most of the time before the modern era? Did battling fleas require constant effort?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

Spartan Law

Hello,

So right off the bat the reason why I’m asking this is because the movie 300 has made this kinda difficult for me to figure out.

But was the saying “No retreat no surrender” an actual Spartan law or is this an entire things made up from the 300 movie?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

By 1776, the thirteen colonies had claerly defined borders. How did these borders come about?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

How did South Vietnam hold on for 2 years after the US pulled out all of it's troops?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

How was ancient gold coins worth determined?

I am talking about within one empire. Was it all about the size, bigger coin > bigger money?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

Historians, what are your book / documentary recommendations in regards to the Middle East / Afghanistan conflict?

I feel this would be a better question for you historians who know more than the average Redditor over at the book suggestion sub.

I am interested to learn more about how Russia, Saudi Arabia (& other middle Eastern countries), Pakistan, USA, UK (etc) all played a role in what's happening to Afghanistan today.

I'd like books:

  • what it was like during the time of the conflict. History about the Taliban etc.
  • what it's like now, 21st century, how America and other countries are partly at fault for what happened

Thank you.

2 Answers 2021-08-16

What is the history behind the expression 'The King is dead, long live The King'? Do the words have any more significance than just literally describing the process of a coronation?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

Khmer is culturally influenced by India while Vietnamese is culturally closer to East Asia, but why are both languages (Khmer and Vietnamese) considered to be in the same language family?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

Do the collapse of soviet union having direct impact with the rise of the talibans?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

What was the crisis in American democracy that nearly destroyed the federal government in 1879?

In a recent interview with Heather Cox Richardson, she mentioned a governmental crisis in 1879 during which "people who fundamentally did not believe in democracy" nearly managed to dismantle the federal government of the United States, but they failed and now nobody ever learns about it -- and then she completely failed to elaborate. I count myself among that nobody: I had never heard of this, and internet searches for that period only discuss the Long Depression and the beginning of the Gilded Age, neither of which seem to rise to the level of what she alluded to. What happened in 1879?

2 Answers 2021-08-16

Ancient Scottish/Celtic Mythology

Hello, I’ve been wanting to learn some more about the Celtic Mythologies as well as the religion of Ancient Scotland. Does anyone have any suggestions for books to read on these subjects(which potentially overlap if I understand correctly)

1 Answers 2021-08-16

A question regarding the use of soap

I saw a post saying soap was created 2800 years ago and im just wondering, how did they have the knowledge to create it and what were the ingrudients?

1 Answers 2021-08-16

571 / 7255

Back to start