What are the arguments for Shi'i Islam arising as a distinct movement during the Safavid period?

I studied International Studies and Religious Studies in uni where most of my research was focused on Islamic militant groups in the present day. Consequently my education was very Sunni focused and given that my professors weren't incredibly familiar with the Shi'a the limited forays I made into Shi'i Islam and Iranian Twelver Shi'ism in particular were basically independent affairs.

For my education the theological history was less important than more recent developments and doctrine (mid 1800s to the present) and so while I have knowledge of the broad strokes of early Islamic history and more specialised knowledge of recent history there are some gaps in the middle.

Essentially I had been taught that the Sunni-Shi'a division dated back to early Islamic history but I've heard a few different places that there are suggestions that Shi'i Islam as a distinct entity doesn't really arise until the Safavid establishment of a distinctly Shi'a Persian state. I was wondering what the specific arguments are for this view and some reading material if anybody has any.

1 Answers 2014-12-28

Why are Port of Geese and It's Pain so culturally different despite being neighboring countries?

1 Answers 2014-12-28

How did Japan's war industry in World War II differ than America's war industry?

I know for the fact why we bombed Japanese cities because Curtis LeMay found out that the Japanese had utilized cottage industry (i.e., making war parts in homes rather than factories) in order to produce weapons of war and it was also because Japan was an island nation filled with mountains terrains, leaving them no room to build munitions factories outside cities.

However, I could not find any data whatsoever about the way our war industry was situated at the same time. Is it the same as Japan? Or that it was entirely different? Were factories situated near residential homes or something like that? What about today? Thanks.

1 Answers 2014-12-28

It is January 1944, What military/economic/political decisions could Hitler have made to extend the war into 1946?

2 Answers 2014-12-28

The Sherman M4 105mm variant: To what extent was it used in anti-tank operation?

I would love to know how much this tank was actually used for anti-tank combat vs anti-infantry? I am having a hard time finding any primary resources regarding combat actions involving this tank.

1 Answers 2014-12-28

What happened to older servants in the 19th century? Did they just get thrown out or did they get pensions?

1 Answers 2014-12-28

How do pitched battles occur? Is there communication between the armies beforehand?

1 Answers 2014-12-28

Vassal's and Puppet States-How are they seen in the world?

1 Answers 2014-12-28

Can someone recommend me some good medieval books?

Books to do with the medieval period and the kind. My personal areas of interest:

Chivalry, cathedrals/churches, knights, everyday life, hunting.

4 Answers 2014-12-27

Why is there a city named Thebes in Greece and a city with the exact same name in Egypt?

Is there some sort of relationship between the cities? Does the name Thebes mean something? Were there different name for the cities in the respective languages of Egyptian and Ancient Greek?

1 Answers 2014-12-27

Why didn't the United States annex Cuba or Bahamas or similar along with Florida?

The Bahamas especially are so close and similar to the Florida keys and Cuba was Spanish and surely ripe for the picking.

Why didn't America take it?

1 Answers 2014-12-27

Why are horses not eaten to the extent that something like cows are? Specifically in the US?

3 Answers 2014-12-27

Documentation on Native Americans breaking treaties?

We get such a one-sided view in every discussion, but honestly - human nature being what it is, there must have been many times that Indian tribes decided to just disregard treaties. Maybe a new chief felt he was not bound by the agreements of his predecessor, maybe some young braves simply decided to attack a settlement or a homestead on their own, maybe a tribe just thought the treaty had run its course and no longer applied. But this is seldom addressed in history books.

1 Answers 2014-12-27

Cavarly charging first

How rare was it for cavarly to just rush ahead of everyone elsee and still mostly survive. We see in movies that the cavarly just charged and kept charging until the battle was won. Wouldn't that be extremely dangerous if you were surrounded by enemy soldiers even when on horseback?

2 Answers 2014-12-27

Has there ever been a three way war in history?

1 Answers 2014-12-27

Why did Greek city states create colonies? Why not just make new cities controlled by them?

2 Answers 2014-12-27

Why did the population of the United States expand so much greater than that of Canada's?

This was a question I asked my grade 7 history teacher and he was never able to give me a great answer. I understand there is more habitable space in the US, but there are a number of geographically smaller countries than Canada with a much larger population.

2 Answers 2014-12-27

When, how, why did every military on the planet adopt a more or less identical hierarchy of ranks?

2 Answers 2014-12-27

Why/How did Basketball become so popular in China of all places?

It's always struck me as odd that an American sport could become so popular in China. How did this come about?

1 Answers 2014-12-27

Why has the land that is currently Israel, been so coveted?

I've heard a number of reasons - religious, geographical, etc.

Is there an agreed on 'most-likely' answer, or is it simply just a combination of many.

1 Answers 2014-12-27

Why was Korean paper so famous?

Reading through Genghis Khan and the Making of the Modern World and it says, "Mongol officials sent their Korean subjects a demand for one hundred thousand sheets of their famous paper." This is the first I've heard about Korean paper being special. What made it so famous?

1 Answers 2014-12-27

Were early muskets more accurate than later ones?

Basically the argument I heard was that many early matchlocks were extremely expensive, hand crafted weapons commissioned by nobles for target shooting and so were far more accurate than the cheap, mass produced muskets given to troops in the 18th century.

2 Answers 2014-12-27

Why did some cultures never advance past the "tribal" stage?

1 Answers 2014-12-27

Reddit's fun fact of the day is that the government of West Germany absorbed East Germany and continued on. Is this an accurate assessment of what happened?

Obviously, East Germany didn't take over, but I'm thinking there may have been a referendum that created an essentially new universal German government instead.

2 Answers 2014-12-27

Historians of Reddit: Can you help identify the man in this painting?

My dad has been trying to figure out who the man in this painting is for years. The painting is by Carlo Schellemann. He was a German painter in the mid 20th century. The back of the painting says "Munchen Akadem".

Here's the link to the picture: http://imgur.com/cHpGEZR

1 Answers 2014-12-27

5962 / 7255

Back to start