How do Modern historians and history professionals view Jared Diamond's book Guns, Germs, and Steel?

2 Answers 2014-11-17

Is there a historical reason for the rise of Islamic extremism as opposed to, say, Christian or Jewish extremism?

I was wondering why it is that the majority of the terrorist groups you hear about on the news are all connected with Islam. I feel like extremist leaders have an easy time interpreting the religious texts and teachings of Islam in a way that makes extremism sound like the duty of any good Muslim. You have non-extremist leaders condemning their practices, and yet followers still trickle over to the dark side of this "peaceful" religion. I would think that other religions that apparently have similarly peaceful teachings would have the same problems, yet you dont see Christian, or Jewish extremist groups in the news (maybe we just dont hear about them?). Is this merely a compounded result of the hard times the Middle East region has faced in the last century, or is something else at work?

I guess what I'm really asking is whether there is something in particular about the history of this religion or those who practice it, that makes it prone to the formation of extremists.

2 Answers 2014-11-17

With the political, cultural, and economic giant of China right next door, how did Korea manage to remain independent for the vast majority of its history?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

So... what was porn like in the Soviet Union?

I mean, every country has some sort of porn industry. How did this work in the USSR?

3 Answers 2014-11-17

Why did the Cold War happen? Why did the US and USSR care so much about what form of government the other had?

Every time I try to read about the start of the Cold War the sources I find always say "tensions increased" between the US and USSR after WW2, but they never say why tensions increased. Yes, the US was a capitalist republic and the USSR was communist, but so what? Why couldn't the governments at the time put on their big boy pants and just live and let live?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

What was the plague that eventually killed Pericles and many Athenian citizens during the Peloponnesian War?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

Were the ancient Assyrians as brutal and violent as many people make them out to be?

I have often heard that the ancient Assyrians were very brutal and committed many acts of violence when dealing with other peoples, much more so than many other empires. They seem to be remembered for their brutality and their methods when doing war and diplomacy.

How much of this is true? Where the Assyrians truly anymore brutal than other empires? Or is it all just some sort of bias against them?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

How accurate are the accounts on Drunk History?

Can it be considered a (somewhat) reliable source of surface level information on the depicted events?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

Is it true that a group of colonists somewhere during the American Revolution took down a public statue of King George and turned it into 40,000 bullets?

I thought I remembered this from somewhere.

1 Answers 2014-11-17

Did the dime novel have any real effect on view of American culture outside the country?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

When the Euro was first created, how was its value established? Who decided how many euros goods and services would be worth?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

What was the courtship and eventual marriage process between two peasants in the Medieval eta?

Was it a long drawn out process, or a relatively quick one? Did the parents arrange the marriage, or did a male simply choose a female in the village of the same serf/peasant status, say "I want you" ask the father/guardian, and that was that?

And were the ceremonies extravagant, or relatively small affairs?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

Are there any examples of successful opposition to Jim Crow in the segregated South before Brown v. Board?

I was reading through 100 Years of Lynchings by Ralph Ginzburg, and was wondering if there were any accounts of people standing up to that culture from within the Jim Crow South. Does anyone know of any?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

Did Napoleon Make a Largely Positive or Negative Impact on History?

I appreciate answers both on an international scale and a domestic scale.

1 Answers 2014-11-17

When and why did the concept of "Mother Earth" and "Father Time" emerge?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

How did the first humans realize how to conceive?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

What was the process for dealing with the 1916 Berlin Olympics?

I just saw it took until around this day in 1914 for the committee to get around to discussing what to do with the games. Were there just busy or were there hopes the games could be salvaged?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

Why did historical rulers grant monopolies?

I often read of rulers granting some person or corporation a monopoly on the production or trade of some good or another. Why would the rulers do this? How did the monopolist go about getting and maintaining their monopoly?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

How did the first two different races to meet react after they learned of the other's existence?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

What board games and games of chance were played in Ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia?

2 Answers 2014-11-17

Has there ever been a female with a cult of personality?

5 Answers 2014-11-17

What problems do academics usually encounter when measuring the Atlantic Slave Trade?

2 Answers 2014-11-17

I am an ordinary person in the middle of England in the mid 14th Century. What is the closest modern flavour of cheese to the cheese I would usually eat?

What about elsewhere? I'm just curious, really.

3 Answers 2014-11-17

The Jacksonian Period was celebrated as the era of the common man, but to what extent did the period live up to its characterization?

1 Answers 2014-11-17

In the Peaky Blinders, why are the victim's names called out before they are shot? Is this a English culture thing?

So my first line of evidence is within in the question. Throughout the TV series, Peaky Blinders, before a victim is shot, the victim's name is often called out by the attacker.

Ex. 1: An assassination attempt on Thomas Shelby after he wins a bid on a racehorse. The assassin cries "Thomas Shelby!" before shooting at him. The assassin obviously knows who Thomas is, so I know it isn't for the purpose of verifying his target's identity.

Ex. 2: When Thomas has to kill some dude, a blacksmith, Thomas calls out the blacksmith's name before blowing his brains out.

My second line of evidence is more vague. I remember years ago, when studying Shakespeare, a historian explained a bit of English culture to clarify the story. In Hamlet, a man is stabbed through a curtain, but his victim's name wasn't called out or something, and so it was shameful. Again, this memory is vague and may be inaccurate.

I had completely forgotten about that Shakespeare historian until I watched (with unbridled addiction) the Peaky Blinders. I noticed that before men are shot their names are called out.

So, is this just a random coincidence to raise drama for the viewers? Or is this a little or well known trait in historic or modern English culture? If it is of historical significance, is it a matter of honor? Professional courtesy?

I looked all over the internet, and used up all the vocabulary variations I could think of in searching Google. I've found nothing. I'm dying to know. And yes, I need to get out more.

Thanks,

  • Future Mrs. Shelby

2 Answers 2014-11-17

6096 / 7255

Back to start