Why is Anne, Princess Royal not 5th in line for the throne?

2 Answers 2014-10-13

Are major archaeological discoveries becoming more common or less common?

Here's what I'm trying to understand: On one hand, it seems like large discoveries could be increasing due to more people looking, more earth-moving projects, more development, etc. On the other hand, I could see the big finds decreasing if we had already found most of the big ones (just like there are few large oil fields left undiscovered and so the rate of discovery slows). And on the third hand (?), we're paving over and building on top of a lot of potential sites, meaning nobody in our era is likely to find them, but perhaps some future archaeologist studying our epoch will.

I'm trying to understand what the future might have in store, specifically, a slow down of big finds, or an increase. If the latter, at what point can we confidently conclude that there really are no more major finds left to discover? Implicit in this question is A) the assumption that the potential discoveries are finite, and B) we'll never find them all, but we will approach some asymptotic maximum percentage.

Sorry if this question is inappropriate; I couldn't really tell from the rules whether the current state of historical research is fair game. (Is this a historiography question? I'm often a bit fuzzy on the boundaries of that term.)

2 Answers 2014-10-13

Hayden White argues that history is more a study in literary genres than a science. Do you agree? If so, how has that affected your research?

As medievalist, I've had to straddle both literature and history -- both in terms of discipline and in terms of evidence. Exposure to White, and then Foucault and Barthes, in graduate school really shook up the way I interpreted the act of composing/analyzing history. I would like to read more about how these critiques of historiography have influenced your thoughts about historical inquiry, as well as your work.

2 Answers 2014-10-13

Precisely how high was the deathrate in Stalin's Gulags?

This seems to be a point of some contention to me. It's obvious that a shit tonne of people died in the Gulags, but at the same time the more "extravagant" numbers tossed around seem to originate from Western critics, who obviously had a motive to attack the USSR.

From the official statistics from the Soviets, the death rates varied from 3-20%(With 20% being at the height of the German invasion) - though similarly to their Western critics, they would have plenty of reason to fudge the numbers, even in the period of De-Stalinisation.

Do we know how accurate estimates of the death tolls are? Is there a broad consensus amongst the global community? Or are the statistics just lost to time?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

In 1832 Joseph Smith prophesied that a civil war would start in South Carolina. Was this commonly assumed or was it an impressive guess?

Here is the official prophecy in Mormon scripture: https://www.lds.org/scriptures/dc-testament/dc/87

Was civil war pretty much inevitable at this time (1832)? Was it commonly assumed that South Carolina was going to be the location where war would break out?

3 Answers 2014-10-13

When did amphorae fall out of favor in the Mediterranean?

Would an eighth century Umayyad ship bringing grain from Tunis to Alexandria use amphorae? What about an 11th century Neapolitan trade ship going from southern Italy to Spain?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

When I and a lot of modern people look back at the common beliefs & attitudes of 100 years ago we see them as extremely conservative and reactionary. Would someone (from Europe or North America) in 1814 think the same thing when they look back on 1714?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

How did the Romans justify their conquests?

What i'm asking is if there was a particular ideology behind their wars, and if so what was it.

3 Answers 2014-10-13

Was iron used at all during early bronze age societies?

I know that the iron age came after the bronze age and that it is called the iron age because it saw the widespread use of iron. What I would like to know is whether there was any forged iron at all before it became a common metal?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

Has there ever been an Islamic Inquisition?

The Catholic Inquisition (primarily the Spanish Inquisition) are infamous for the brutality and dogma that drove them.

Nonetheless it's an interesting field of study. However, it has me wondering was there ever an Islamic Inquisition that hunted down heretics or witch's? In addition has there ever been a Jewish Inquisition or Eastern religion Inquisition?

Tldr; Is the "Inquisiton" a Catholic only event or has it been conducted by other religious groups?

4 Answers 2014-10-13

Didn't the Protestant electors of the Holy Roman Empire have a problem with the Emperor being Catholic?

Throughout the Protestant Reformation, the Habsburgers remained mostly Catholic, did they not? Also, did the Emperor have a problem with his subjects turning Protestant, or even go to outright war?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

How did the word of Columbus's "discovery" spread through Europe?

I've always wondered how other countries and rulers came to know about the new world. Columbus and Spain knew they were on to something big, even if they didn't know exactly what. Why didn't they keep it quiet? Why spread the knowledge rather than take everything for themselves?

2 Answers 2014-10-13

How does a language "die"?

It seems like people would continue speaking Latin even if the Roman Empire was gone. I can understand fairly foreign lands such as England and Africa, but why did Italy continue speaking Latin?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

How can I check on a history books credibility?

I'm interested in reading history books so far I mostly listen to history podcasts and maybe look at a few wikipedia pages but I want to get into reading so how I can I find out if a book is credible? Is there any site that you can use or do I just have to google and trust sources and reviews of the book?

2 Answers 2014-10-13

Were any cheap dishes invented during The Great Depression that are still eaten today?

For example, I've heard that Sloppy Joes were invented during the Great Depression when people tried to stretch their ground beef by adding ketchup or tomato sauce to it. Is there any truth to this? Are there any other examples?

2 Answers 2014-10-13

During the 20th Century did the Democrats and Republicans actively work to prevent the emergence of a third party?

If so, how?

2 Answers 2014-10-13

"When the first dinosaur bones were found in the 1820s-30s, scientists explained them as belonging to some oversize variant of a modern species. This was because it was believed that no species could ever become extinct, since God would now allow one of His creations to die." Is this true?

This quote is a slight paraphrase from the novel Jurassic Park, right after their first encounter with raptors.

Was this is a common view? Rare(r) view? Completely false idea by the author, Michael Crichton?

If this statement is true (or true-ish), then...

  • Was the view mostly held by scientists or non-scientist Christians (or both or others)?

  • If the latter, which denomination(s) mainly held the belief?

  • Finally, what was the Christian reaction to the realization that species did become extinct over time?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

What would be the most suited economic system to colonialize a new planet?!

1 Answers 2014-10-13

How did members of the Confessing Church congregate in Nazi Germany?

I am reading some sermons and letters written by Niemoller and Bonhoeffer while they were incarcerated, but I was wondering how members of the Confessing Church practiced Christianity outside of prison. Did members meet secretly? How did they avoid being caught? Can you suggest any further reading?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

Who were the most wealthy and powerful individuals in 1775 Boston?

How did John Adams, John Hancock, Samuel Adams, and Robert Treat Paine fit into the socioeconomic hierarchy of Colonial Boston?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

Were there instances of colonization during Antiquity that resembled English/American colonization of North America i.e. displacement/replacement/eradication of native populations?

Colonization in Antiquity to me is Phoenicians or Greeks landing somewhere and establishing a city to expand their trade routes, but any conflict with natives is incidental. Or with Romans conquering an area (and killing some natives, true) and settling some former soldiers, but otherwise not systematically removing the native population.

Were there ever instances in Antiquity where the natives were completely destroyed or removed and replaced with a colonizing population?

2 Answers 2014-10-13

I've been devouring history books recently, and am looking for more. So what's your area of expertise, and if I was going to read one book about that time, place, or event, which one should it be?

I just finished Death of a King by Tavis Smiley over the weekend. I never realized how little I knew about Dr. King until I picked up that book. So much detail that I had no idea about.

Now I'm looking for something new. So make your suggestions, please...

4 Answers 2014-10-13

During WWI and WWII did nations see a drop in crime rates?

After seeing pictures from the London blackout I was wondering if people abused that and committed more crime or was it sort of a known fact that people had more important stuff to worry about?

6 Answers 2014-10-13

How many % of Germany's forces were on the Western front in wwii

I have been told 80 were on the eastern, but how many on the Western?

2 Answers 2014-10-13

What caused the collapse of the Federalist party?

1 Answers 2014-10-13

6212 / 7255

Back to start