What does AskHistorians think of Dinesh D'Souza?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

At the end of the French and Indian War (Or Seven Years War), why did France still control Haiti when they lost all other territories?

I was in my introductory history class, and I asked my professor why the map showed that Haiti was still a French colony after the war, and she didn't know the answer. It just seems kind of weird to let them have it when the British could have easily squashed any remaining resistance and wipe out France in the Americas completely.

1 Answers 2014-10-12

Comedians & comedy from dominant cultures of today seem to regularly self-deprecate. What's the history of a dominant culture having self-awareness of its flaws and going so far as to make fun of itself, especially in mainstream venues?

I'm talking about such examples as a white, American male comedian making jokes about how white culture is deeply flawed, Americans are deeply flawed, being male is deeply flawed. Comedians like Louis C.K. have become immensely popular and successful while making jokes that hold a mirror up to the face of the dominant race, culture and gender to point out its legitimate flaws (though that's not the sum total of C.K.'s work by any means). This type of self-awareness and self-deprecation by a member of a dominant culture in a society seems relatively historically new to me, especially the major mainstream success of it. Throughout history many rulers have suppressed satire and comedy as being a form of dissent.

Through my (very) basic undergraduate studies in Theatre history, I've read that satire and criticism of the dominant culture through comedic performance has had a long way to go before becoming mainstream. Roman comedy actors were barred from politics and persecuted. Mummers and traveling actors during medieval times were persecuted as well. Shakespeare and his contemporary dramatists kept their satire deeply hidden, or satirized more general subjects. Molière was allowed more flexibility, but still kept under watch by the patronage of the aristocracy.

I hypothesize that the mainstream rise of comedy and comedians from oppressed cultures allowed more space for dominant cultures to do some soul searching and self-criticism, especially given the rise of self-awareness by the dominant. In the United States I'd mark that by the rise of black comedians talking more frankly about race after the Civil Rights Movement. In history before you might have things like Yiddish theatre making fun of dominant cultures, but they were nowhere near mainstream.

In any case, I'd be interested to know about the history of this type of comedy where the dominant culture openly criticizes itself, and where not only is the artist not censored or marginalized but instead becomes mainstream and successful. Furthermore, have there be exceptions throughout history where a dominant culture had condoned or even enjoyed self-critical humor on a mainstream scale?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

My "uncle" served in World War II, when he died we found these. Can someone tell me what they are?

My great grandfather's brother was in the 82nd Airborne Division during World War 2. I don't know much about where he was deployed and when, but I do know he jumped into Normandy on D-Day. When he died, we found these things in his hat, and I have no idea what any of them are, it'd be great if someone could help me figure out what they are, and if this is the wrong subreddit I apologize, and please direct me in the right way.

This medal is really weird. It looks like a medal that would be worn on a uniform but it has a swastika on it. It says 1939 on the bottom. The edge of the ribbon looks like it was either ripped or cut. Picture: http://i.imgur.com/tq730ge.jpg Close up: http://i.imgur.com/Fvb4qFM.jpg Back: http://i.imgur.com/wZ7tyvq.jpg

This one is kind of similar. The ribbon on this one also looks like it was cut or torn. The back of the medal says 1939 on it. Picture: http://i.imgur.com/nkeUjio.jpg Another picture: http://i.imgur.com/pCndAjb.jpg Back: http://i.imgur.com/7J1YAx8.jpg

He also has two pins, they look exactly the same, they just aged differently. I don't know what they are. Pin 1: http://i.imgur.com/xQnSoAg.jpg Pin 2: http://i.imgur.com/v9zTKre.jpg

I think these are striped that would be worn on a uniform but if anyone has any information on what they mean that'd be great. He has two, and one of them has these badges on them. Stripe 1: http://i.imgur.com/ycNoJDK.jpg Stripe 2: http://i.imgur.com/ZSm4zuX.jpg Stripe 2 Closeups: 1: http://i.imgur.com/v5JNYm3.jpg 2: http://i.imgur.com/p5oUaQa.jpg

I'm almost positive this is just an Airborne thing you'd wear on your uniform but if anyone has any other info that'd be great: http://i.imgur.com/wiLrVor.jpg

And lastly, this doesn't look relevant to anything else, but there was this thing in his hat too. It looks like a fake key, and I think it's made out of tin: http://i.imgur.com/1TIVb46.jpg

16 Answers 2014-10-12

How long did it take for America to liberate the USSR and Great Britain after they were conquered by the Nazis in WW2? And why do Britons claim they won the war when they were just liberated by the USA?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

Ancient historians, LF Book about Rome. In Eng.

I am looking for a academic book about the history of Rome, the city, or the ancient Roman world. It will be my first read on the subject. So I need something introductory and wide. Something of a good book to start your leaning from. I just started studying Classical Philology. I need a good authority on the above mentioned subject to set a respectable standard for future learning. And it has to be available in English. So: -a history on the ancient city of Rome, -or on the ancient Roman world. Thank you!

3 Answers 2014-10-12

How fast could the chasquis (Incan messengers) deliver goods or messages across the empire? Do we have any reliable sources about this?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

How could Arminius defeat the Roman legion at Teutoburg Forest?

How could a bunch of "uncivilized barbarians" defeat one of history's most organized and well trained armys?

2 Answers 2014-10-12

Which societies in history faced growing economic separation between upper and lower classes in the way we do today? What was the end result?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

When was the first time Vlad Tepes was tied to the vampire myth?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

Day of Reflection | October 06, 2014–October 12, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2014-10-12

Do we know any of the great war captains of mesoamerica?

The Aztecs, Zapotecs, Mixtecs, etc. seemed pretty aggressive---do we have narratives of any of their great war captains? If we need a narrower range, then Mixtecs in 1100--1300.

2 Answers 2014-10-12

I am a pirate and board a ship. Someone pulls out a blunderbuss and aims it at me at close range. What type of damage would be inflicted?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

[Meta] British museum's world history in 100 objects - how faithful a representation is it?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

Why has the Suit remained the standard for men's smart wear for so long when other area's of fashion are constantly changing?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

Horse training in Middle Ages?

How was horse training done in the Middle ages? Was it anything like training we do today, and is modern horse riding based upon medieval horse riding?

2 Answers 2014-10-12

Do you think that Cleopatra had a chance to achieve her goals?

1 Answers 2014-10-12

Do we have any idea about whether or not people have gotten relatively happier throughout history, as the "standard of living" rises?

So for example, people in the 1500's were dirty all the time and didn't have electricity, but were they actually less happy than someone from modern day because of that? Is there any research on that?

2 Answers 2014-10-12

Has there been any writing about Transgender people in the past? Or is it some type of newer phenomenon brought on by the availability of hormones?

2 Answers 2014-10-12

Was the use of "Fatherland" and "Motherland" exclusive to Germany and Russia during the World War 1 time period?

How about for the other empires of the time period such as Britain, France, the Austro Hungarian Empire, and the Ottomans? Specifically how so in propaganda? (I'll admit this is for a history project sorry)

2 Answers 2014-10-12

Can you recommend any books about the history/ideology/politics of communism and socialism

Hi,this is my first post on this sub and if this in not appropriate to this sub please let me know.I am interested in learning more about socialism/communism(i live in Romania and i won't get a lot of objective information in school.The curriculum focuses more on the ussr,the cold war and communist romania and i'm more interested in other aspects of socialism.) The reason i am posting it here is because i believe that you will recommend books that will be objective and will not fall into the category of "socialism is the devil and has never ever done anything slightly positive and everything that has to do with socialism is objectively evil" or "Marx was like a god of economics etc and he was never wrong".I asked something similar on /r/communism[1] and i got a lot of book written by communists,I would like something more"third party". Thanks in advance and sorry if this post breaks any rules of this sub

3 Answers 2014-10-12

Are there any archeological or written (outside the bible) evidence of the jewish exodus from Egypt?

Such as jews being mentioned in Egyptian texts, or other sources placing them in Egypt, or perhaps evidence of jewish burials? Any mention outside of the bible of the jews leaving Egypt (with or withouth the nile turning into blood and locusts...).

If not, are there any theories about the factual basis of the enslavment in Egypt or is it just a story?

2 Answers 2014-10-12

Did those rulers of the ancient world who were seen to be Divine God-Kings really believe they were deities? (E.g. Pharaohs in their belief that they were incarnations of Horus).

Is there any evidence of any monarch questioning this 'Imperial Cult'?

Growing up in such a tradition would make a ruler inclined to believe such claims, but their obvious human frailty would have made them question this, no?

6 Answers 2014-10-12

We call him Augustus, but what would Romans have called him during his rule?

2 Answers 2014-10-12

If you were to devise a new way of separating human history, replacing B.C. and A.D. but serving the same function, how would you do it?

3 Answers 2014-10-12

6218 / 7255

Back to start