What did Winston Churchill think of Oswald Mosley and vice versa?

1 Answers 2014-08-29

The AskHistorians Podcast - Episode 18 Discussion Thread - A (Brief) Textual History of the Hebrew Bible

Episode 018 is up!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make/r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forum on the internet. You can subscribe to us via iTunes, Stitcher, or RSS. If there is another index you'd like the cast listed on, let me know!

This Episode:

/u/Husky54 speaks to /u/400-Rabbits about the Hebrew Bible. They cover what exactly the "Hebrew Bible" really is, when it was written, who was doing the writing, the historical precursors, corresponding epigraphy, textual intricacies, and, of course, Richard Dawkins.

If you want more specific recommendations for sources or have any follow-up questions, feel free to ask them here! Also feel free to leave any feedback on the format and so on. If you like the podcast, please rate & review us on iTunes.

Thanks all!

Coming up next fortnight: /u/Daeres palavers with /u/400-Rabbits about the Assyrian State Archives, a collection of Neo-Assyrian cuneiform documents covering topics as varied as state level diplomacy to the price of one man's new house. The significance of the documents and the particulars of several texts are discussed.

Previous Episodes and Discussion

5 Answers 2014-08-29

In the early days or air travel, was there any race segregation for travelling minorities (like Rosa Parks)? Did it reignite under apartheid? How did the system work?

1 Answers 2014-08-29

Did other ancient peoples start a lot of colonies like the Greeks?

I've been studying ancient Greek history and found their constant colonizing of Italy, Sicily, Ionia, North Africa, Scythia, etc. to be fascinating. Did other ancient cultures also do this, or was this unique to the Greeks. Also, what was the cause behind this extensive colonization? Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-08-29

What makes the legend of Troy so enticing to ancient European writers such as Geoffrey of Monmouth, Snorri Sturluson and Virgil that they attribute the origins of their respective nations to people fleeing from Troy after its downfall?

1 Answers 2014-08-29

Out of all the wars America has been involved in, which war would give me the lowest odds of survival? (In terms of the total number of military personnel who served throughout the war, and the percentage of those who were killed in action)

Sorry if this is worded poorly, but I believe the question makes sense. In my mind, I always imagine Vietnam as being the most brutal, but I don't know any numbers.

Also, if it's not too much trouble I'm also curious which war would have been most likely to kill me as a civilian. I understand most of America's wars have been fought overseas, but the Revolution, the War of 1812, and the Civil War obviously caused casualties on our own soil, and my odds of survival could be calculated by taking the total civilian population at the time and finding the fraction of those who were killed as a direct consequence of military action.

For any answers regarding the Civil War, let's assume I'm serving on the Union side.

1 Answers 2014-08-29

What were the roles of ancient Roman women and what roles were not open to them?

3 Answers 2014-08-29

Was Germany far ahead technologically in World War 2?

I have heard that their advancement is over hyped so to speak. I am just seeking more information. Were they actually ahead of the allies, or only in limited areas?

1 Answers 2014-08-29

How well did the Finnish speaking soldiers integrate with the Swedish army during the times when Sweden and Finland was the same kingdom?

When Sweden and Finland was the same kingdom, how well did Finnish speaking soldiers and, by extension, officers integrate in the army?

  • Individually, were they treated the same as Swedish speaking soldiers? If not, how?
  • Were there officers who spoke Finnish as first language, how far could they climb? Did they have equal opportunity to Swedes (or Swedish speakers from todays Finland)?
  • Would the commanders of said units, if not Finnish speakers themselves, have to learn Finnish? Or was it the other way around?
  • How were the general feelings from Finnish speaking soldiers on serving under Swedish speaking officers?
  • On a regimental level, were the Finnish ones and Swedish ones handled differently?

Since the Aristocracy was (mainly?) Swedish speaking in what is today Finland, I know of several notable officers from this era from that population. Mind, these are not the people I am interested in. They should have had Finnish as a first language (Swedish as a Second Language is acceptable though). I am especially interested in the period of 1500s to 1750s, with events such as The Thirty Years' Wars, March across the Belts, Great Nordic War, etc.

If you have answers to the questions but about sailors rather than soldiers, I am just as happy to hear it!

Looking forward to reading, if any, answers! Thank you.

3 Answers 2014-08-29

Were there any hunter-gatherer societies in Europe that survived into the historical era? If so, do we have written records of contact with any of them?

1 Answers 2014-08-29

Culd somebody explain Roman Imperium during the Republic to me?

I understand that Imperium refers not just military command, but also to political rule as well. What I'm wondering is who was allowed to command armies in the field. I'm assuming the two consuls would, but other offices of the Cursus Honorum hold Imperium. Would a Quaestor or a Praetor be able to command an army in the field? Or was it just the Consuls? And if that is the case, what happened when there were more than two armies to command?

1 Answers 2014-08-29

What does the Middle East call the Middle East?

Maybe not the most history-focused question here, but I couldn't figure out a better place to ask.

I'm assuming the Middle East is known as the Middle East to discern it from the Far East. The Near East then, would be Turkey/the Levant (or perhaps even the Balkans/Eastern Europe) - this all being from the perspective of Western Europeans.

I'm wondering how other regions have referred to the Middle East? Does the Middle East distinct itself as a geo-political region? What would say, China, call the Middle East?

3 Answers 2014-08-29

Why did Mesopotamia develop complex civilization before Egypt?

From what I've gathered Egypt's settlers and resources were very similar to those in Mesopotamia. So how come Egypt didn't develop a complex society until almost 500 years after Mesopotamia did?

1 Answers 2014-08-29

Given the massive loss of male population by the end of World War II, were there changes to the dating culture in Europe as a result of the gender imbalance? What happened to the widows and "surplus" women?

2 Answers 2014-08-29

What is the significance of the Iliad and the Odyssey?

I've been reading these, and I'm not sure what to gain from them besides a great story

1 Answers 2014-08-29

Where did the concept of flags come from and why are there certain set designs that so many countries choose to follow?

Just a wondering thought that I was interested in finding the answer too. And find questions are answered with more variety and depth than If I were to take this to Google. edit: grammar

1 Answers 2014-08-29

Who actually brought slaves to the United States?

Was it a corporation? A country? Has that corporation continued on post abolishment? I feel like it became BP or Halliburton.

1 Answers 2014-08-29

Everyone here always has great sources, can you please give me tips on how to do better online research?

3 Answers 2014-08-29

Was Napoleon a "bad person" beyond being a conqueror?

I guess what I want to know is if he was a cruel person in an age where war and expansionism was more common? Did he condone torture, treat prisoners poorly, or have "dishonorable" practices? How is he viewed now by most Europeans, and particularly French people?

3 Answers 2014-08-29

Flag Color Origin

I was just browsing flag colors and was curious if there was any correllation between colors in flags, and noticed a (very surface level, admittedly) correlation, that more wealthy countries typically had blue in their flags (Sweden, Finland, US, UK, Australia, albeit North Korea, Venezuela, and Chad) and was curious if there was a common agreement towards what colors go into flags or maybe better stated, if alliances between countries is brought into consideration with flag designs?

I'd like to apologize if this is a very naive question, but I'd appreciate if this could possibly start as a general discussion of flag design or if that's a topic that has a subreddit, I'd love to hear where to go.

Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-08-29

Which royal name (i.e. William, Louis, Henry, Elizabeth, etc.) would you say has the best legacy based on rulers of that name?

1 Answers 2014-08-29

When did the term Chirurgeon give way to surgeon?

This is just a quick question, I hope. Just research for a story.

1 Answers 2014-08-29

What exactly are the rings the Norse sagas mention?

In the saga of the People of Laxardal, its mentioned that King Hakon of Norway gave Hoskuld a gold ring, by "drawing [it] from his arm". Was this ring actually drawn from the arm like an armlet/brassard, a ring from one's finger, or something else? What size would it be? Do we have any surviving examples?

1 Answers 2014-08-29

Over the hundreds of years of wars between France and England why didn't one side or the other ever finish it's opponent off once and for all?

Sorry this is a big question I'm just curious why there was never just a single total crushing victory over one nation or the other. Maybe there was and I just don't know it.. Please enlighten me.

2 Answers 2014-08-29

Is It Worth It?

I'm just going to say this bit first if this isn't the right place to put this post I will take it down.

I am currently looking into going to college to get a degree in a field in or related to history. I know this isn't the field that you would enter for money or fame, but the number of people who do get degrees in history and struggle to get a job in the field makes me wonder if I am better of putting history as side project rather than a main focus. I see quite a few people in every field who struggle to get into the field of their choice, but it seems that history is basically limited to either becoming a teacher on some level or park guide, and not that I would be disinterested in doing those, but there's a oversupply of people for both of those jobs and aiming for them seems to be a risk for the amount of money and time necessary to do qualify for them.

My main questions would be -

  1. If you are employed in the history field in any area do you feel like you have any accomplishments or skills that put you over others for your job?

  2. If you are not employed in the field and have a degree in history do you feel that you in retrospect would of chosen a different career path?

  3. Do you feel that furthering study in history is itself worth it even if it means that you may not get a job in field?

2 Answers 2014-08-29

6369 / 7255

Back to start