Why don't the British speak a Romance language?

Britain (or most of it), Spain and France (Gaul) were all Roman provinces that were later conquered by Germanic tribes. Yet the French and Spanish speak Romance languages, but the English/British a Germanic language (with the exception of the Celtic minorities). What happened in the case of Britain that caused them to adopt a Germanic dialect?

1 Answers 2014-08-28

What food would people give their pets before commercialized pet food?

1 Answers 2014-08-28

What is the reason for the peculiar shape of the Austro-Hungarian border?

Currently I am in the beautiful town of Gussing in Austria. Today, I had the chance to visit the Austro-Hungarian border (Iron Curtain etc.) I noted the rather unnatural(?) border lines of Austria and Hungary. Some parts look quite artificial. I guess all borders are artificial but what I mean is that rather than following any natural features like most of the borders in Europe, the Austro-Hungarian border has straight lines and incursions in random areas. It seems that this may have an interesting history so I am here posting this on AskHistorians! Can anyone help?

http://imgur.com/r7zgfsJ

1 Answers 2014-08-28

How did the British Royal Family keep all their stuff but give up all of their power?

I understand revolutions like France or Russia where you come in and take everything. But how and when did the British Royal family say, "Okay well we're not going to make any more decisions but we're keeping our cool house"

1 Answers 2014-08-28

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in August 28 2014:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

3 Answers 2014-08-28

What hair styles were common for men with curly hair in the 18th century?

I always see paintings of men with long straight hair or military men with short combed, but still straight, hair.

1 Answers 2014-08-28

What was the Japanese strategy behind its invasion & subsequent massacre of Nanjing?

Was there any reasoning at all from Imperial Japan's perspective? I know that seeking a reasoning for genocide is generally a fruitless endeavor, but for a nation that was just a decade or two away from its shift from a feudal state ruled by Shogun to an industrial one, it has always baffled me why Nanjing was brutalized in such a grotesque manner.

2 Answers 2014-08-28

How accurate is the movie Gandhi (1982)? I read some articles slamming Gandhi (the actual person), and I don't know what to make of them.

Especially the first one seems very exaggerated:

3 Answers 2014-08-28

Was it known or suspected that the Treaty of Versailles would lead to the economic collapse of post WWI Germany?

Reading about the constant defaults, bank collapses, political unrest, and reconstruction required, it looks like it was doomed to failure from the beginning. France and the UK also seem to have been at least somewhat reasonable later on, allowing Germany to default many times and only reluctantly occupying portions of Germany to force compliance. There does not appear to be a malicious intent to destroy Germany, just to humiliate and humble.

2 Answers 2014-08-28

Did any Native American tribes have pet wolves or dogs?

2 Answers 2014-08-28

What street food was sold in cities in Renaissance Italy and Eastern Europe?

2 Answers 2014-08-28

Question about Spanish History - is there any truth to Franco's support of Real Madrid? How much did Real Madrid's success actually benefit Spain?

OK, so i have football sources that say that Franco used Real Madrid to restart diplomatic relations and it gave a huge boost to economy. But are there any hard historical sources which suggest any of this. Was his support of Real Madrid even true or an exaggerated rumour

2 Answers 2014-08-28

I'd like to ask whether or not Flandern still utilize pilgrimage, the Camino de Santiago, as penance in their punitive system. If it is a legitimate way of seeking redemption, how far back does this tradition go?

I found [this] (http://caminodesantiagoguide.org/history/penance) while looking for information about the Camino for a friend. It is also repeated in almost the same wording on wikipedia. [In english] (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Camino_de_Santiago#As_penance) and atleast [in danish] (http://da.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jakobsvejen#Middelalderen) too. The only source I can find is [this] (http://www.flandes.net/descubre-flandes/index/huellas-espanolas/), given on the english wiki, which seems inadequate at best. I couldn't find mention on Google of such a system, but then again I can't write flemish.

1 Answers 2014-08-28

Medieval Crossbow Attachments & Assassinations?

So I'm a Medieval reenactor (time period 1066-1485, area Europe - mainly England) looking to make my Crossbow somewhat more interesting.

Small ones are easy to set up, hide under a cloak and walk up to someone, fire a shot at point blank and walk away fluidly. Likewise, large ones are optimal for sniping from massive distances, my brother estimates some of the most powerful ones might be able to travel 200-300 metres with very little bullet drop.

So I'd like to become a Medieval assassin, but I'm not too well-informed on the subject, so may I ask:

  • Are there records for Crossbows being used for assassination methods?
  • Are there records for Crossbows having attachments (i.e a Bipod, Bolt Rack for quicker reload etc)?
  • I know poison is a big one, but what other tools/techniques would hired killers use at the time for their assassination methods?

1 Answers 2014-08-28

What could have been done differently in WW1?

1 Answers 2014-08-28

Why did no Norse sailors return to America after the early 11th century?

2 Answers 2014-08-28

What did composers from the classical period [Mozart, Haydn, even Beethoven] think of the United States? Do we know? [crosspost from r/classicalmusic]

Mozart and Beethoven were both alive during the American Revolutionary War and the birth of the United States. You would think that people with strong republican sympathies would have been inspired by these events, but instead we see Beethoven writing music for Napoleon and Dutch independence but nothing for the U.S. Do we have any idea how classical-era composers felt about the U.S.?

2 Answers 2014-08-28

Why and how did religion become so widespread that it's still prevalent today?

1 Answers 2014-08-28

Roman Historains -- Officially, Republican Rome's subject cities were titled "allies". For what reason?

First off, is it more accurate to refer to them as vassal or subject states, seeing as though in reality, that's what they were? They had no choice in their "alliance" with Rome (as Capua would prove in the Second Punic War) and were obligated to provide Rome with soldiers for their armies. Is it correct to, nowadays, refer to those cities as Rome's subjects?

As a second question, and the one posed in the title, why were they called allies? Obviously, the term is much friendlier than "subject" or "vassal", but was it really fooling anyone? Also, it wasn't like the idea of conquering cities via war and annexing them into your empire was completely unheard of. Or perhaps it was because of the previous rulers of the Italian peninsula; the leagues of Etruscans and Latins, or the various isolated Greek city-states, or the united (is it correct to call them united?) bands of nomads.

1 Answers 2014-08-28

What is the longest running government in terms of not having a revolution or other overthrowing of power?

2 Answers 2014-08-28

We know that invading Russia was never a good idea, but why did the Mongols succeed?

2 Answers 2014-08-28

Has there ever been anything like the modern drug epidemics in ancient civilizations?

Heroin, meth, pills. Was there anything like the modern drug epidemics of today in the ancient civilizations?

1 Answers 2014-08-28

At what point did Germany realize the war was lost? (WWII)

And why didn't they try to negotiate a peace treaty if they knew defeat was inevitable?

1 Answers 2014-08-28

Profit margins of armament companies in total wars?

During total wars, like the later stages of WW2 in Germany, what kind of profit margins did the big armament companies (in this example, Krupp and Messerschmidt and the like) have? How did they justify their profit (if any) in a time of such scarcity?

1 Answers 2014-08-28

How were colors defined before hexadecimal or RGB values came into use?

Today, the hexadecimal color scale (ranging from 000000-FFFFFF) covers every color visible to the human eye. It allows standardization in graphic designs around the world. Before this system came into effect, how did people collaborate on color schemes?

2 Answers 2014-08-28

6372 / 7255

Back to start