What was the understanding of eastern Northern American natives peoples of the political variety and rivalry amongst Europeans settlers and their overseas homelands? How much did it factor for their own politics?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

After seceding from the Union in 1861, Alabama drafted a new state constitution that seems oddly progressive. It declared that the "The humane treatment of slaves shall be secured by law" and seems to have given the enslaved certain rights. Why did the Convention include these articles?

It just seems oddly progressive for the Convention of a State that was seceding to protect White Supremacy and Slavery to include provisions that seemed to grant certain rights to the enslaved. Here is the part of the 1861 Constitution that dealt with the enslaved, which I got from here:

SLAVERY

Section 1. No slave in this State shall be emancipated by any act done to take effect in this State, or any other country.

Section 2. The humane treatment of slaves shall be secured by law.

Section 3. Laws may be enacted to prohibit the introduction into this State, of slaves who have committed high crimes in other States or territories, and to regulate or prevent the introduction of slaves into this State as merchandise.

Section 4. In the prosecution of slaves for crimes, of a higher grade than petit larceny, the General Assembly shall have no power to deprive them of an impartial trial by a petiti jury.

Section 5. Any person who shall maliciously dismember or deprive a slave of life, shall suffer such punishment as would be inflicted in case the like offense had been committed on a free white person, and on the like proof, except in case of insurrection of such slave.

Note that it says that the "humane treatment shall be secured by law", instead of may or can, so it seems that the Constitution actually required the Legislature to create the law. It also grants them a trial by a jury that's required to be impartial, and makes murdering a slave equal to murdering a white person. I looked up the constitutions of other Confederate states and they have nothing like this. In fact, many times their provisions are the opposite, such as allowing jury trials of slaves just in very specific cases. Why did Alabama, of all places, enact these provisions? Note that I'm aware that these provisions can't be called truly progressive because they still protected slavery and at most allowed a degree of paternalistic protection as the burden of the "superior race", but still, it's weird when compared with other Confederate states.

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Yalta, Tehran, these conferences would not just decide the fate of ww2, but even the world after. But, more importantly, what was the catering like? What did the delegates eat?

At all of these big political meetings, I always wonder what people did for food. As someone with food allergies, that's always a top priority, especially in countries that use a lot of my allergies. Did everyone have Iranian cuisine? Did people chow down on borscht in Yalta?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

How common was it for non-native American settlers to learn Native American languages?

Today Spanish is considered a good second language to learn. Did settlers in the 19th century Dakotas for example consider learning the Lakota language instead?

2 Answers 2021-06-21

Were queen monarchs afforded less respect in European history than if they had been male?

I know the question is broad, and the timespan is large, but I’m fine with an answer which outlines how over history attitudes towards monarchs changed, if at all, and how such attitudes were affected by the different cultures that varied across Europe; and furthermore, how such attitudes might have been affected by characteristics like class, religion, ethnicity, etc.

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Native American tribes had a taboo against mouth breathing, believing it sapped spiritual and physical strength. Do we know the source/reasoning for this taboo, and how nose breathing was enforced/taught on a community level? How universal was this practice among Native Americans?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Did the Romans know of the formation of the Three Kingdoms in China and did the Romans have any trade with the far east?

I was wondering whether the Roman Empire knew about the events in China that led to the formation of the Three Kingdoms and they both would’ve coincided with each other and was there any trade between them?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Why did France emerge so early as a nation-state, compared to other European countries?

When we see maps of Europe of the late Medieval and the Renaissance era we usually see an assortment of smaller duchies, principalities and more rarely, some bigger state which encompasses many ethnicities and didn't really have a unified national identity. Then we see France, a comparatively massive blob of land, which had strong centralised rule (mostly) and where most people, apart from their local identity, saw themselves as culturally French. Why and how did France unite as a quasi nation-state so early?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Why was Napoleon allowed to live after defeat to the Seventh Coalition? Especially considering the high cost of his exile on St. Helena and his previous "escape" from exile on Elba?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

By 1947, Philippe Pétain had a serious dementia. Were there any signs of mental decline a few years before that, when he was a dictator?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Are there historical accounts of how universities responded to pandemics or plagues throughout history?

I'm mostly wondering about how a university or college responded to events such as the Spanish Flu, or other pandemics/epidemics/plagues. Did they remain open and bring the student body back or were universities closed until the disease had passed?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

How did the Soviet Union Beat Japan so fast in WW2?

The Japanese Soldiers in WW2 gave heavy resistance during the Pacific campaign in WW2. Russian troops swept through Japanese held Manchuria in a matter of weeks. I can't even fathom how an army could move through an area that large, that fast without any resistance. How did Russia pull off a victory so fast against the Japanese?

2 Answers 2021-06-21

How and why did institution of indentured servitude evolve into chattel slavery of Africans in the US?

This question sprung into my head after reading this source: https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/aug/14/slavery-in-america-1619-first-ships-jamestown. It talks about how the original Africans shipped over to Virginia in 1619 were indentured servants rather than chattel slaves, only through a series of laws in the late 1600 did enslaved Africans become property. How and why did this shift occur?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

How did Ukrainian/Ruthenian language and culture in Galicia survive centuries of foreign rule leading into Ukrainian nationalism?

I’ve been doing a lot of research on Ukrainians in Galicia for personal family history, and after the downfall of Kievan Rus the general timeline is that Galicia was taken and incorporated into Poland, then Poland-Lithuania, and eventually Austria-Hungary before Ukrainian nationalism + independence happened followed by multiple relocations after ww2.

My great grandparents are Ukrainian from Galicia area that’s now part of Poland, with the men serving for the Austrian army in ww1 and eventually being relocated into northern Poland during Operation Vistula.

My general question is how did Ukrainian culture + Eastern Orthodox religion and specifically language survive in this area that wasn’t in “ruthenian” control for almost 700 years? Before the relocations and ww2 a good chunk of Galicia was Polish speaking and cultural at this point which makes sense after 400+ years of Polish control, but still almost 40% of the region was Ukrainian identity even though Ukraine/Ruthenia didn’t exist for so long?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Why is the 19th century Russian Empire described as being "autocratic", while other similar 19th century states, such as the Austrian Empire, are not described as such, despite also being very illiberal? Why is "autocratic" a description only used for the Russian Empire? What was unique about it?

2 Answers 2021-06-21

Ergotism effect on society and religion.

Hello all I have a question what’s been on my mind for years and I hope I can get some good perspective on my views.

So as we all know ergotism was a big thing in the Middle Ages and beyond.

Really my question is what is the effect it had on society? (In you’re view)

From what I can tell it effected a lot of people and I truly believe people tripping out during the Middle Ages would of definitely had a effect on peoples beliefs I. Religion as there was no other explanation.

I’ve also heard of mass hysteria outbreaks and the Salem witch trials where all due to ergotism.

Would I be right in saying that ergot had a profound effect on society and peoples religious beliefs

Thank you :)

1 Answers 2021-06-21

What was the relationship like between William the conqueror and Philip I of France?

I understand that kings can’t be subservient to other kings, and given that Normandy was part of France, how did Philip react to having essentially a part of his kingdom just leave and join another kingdom? Was William still a vassal of Philip or did he declare independence? Did Philip know of Williams plans before the invasion took place and if so what did he do and was he ok with it?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Did ancient peoples talk about how beautiful other civilizations' lands were? Like today we look at scenic pictures of the Italian countryside or beaches in Greece... Was this a big thing in the past?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Did Ancient Roman cities have their own distinct cultures and attitudes like cities do today?

For example, New Yorkers are seen as tough and loud and people from Seattle are seen as compassionate liberals. Would people from Pompeii be seen as drunkards due to their city's history as a major figure in the wine industry? Would citizens of the city of Rome be seen as rich snobs due to it being full of wealthy politicians?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Were there any pre-columbian civilizations in the America that knew how to forge iron?

I'm aware that civilizations like the Inca and Aztec knew how to work precious metals like gold and silver, and from what I understand many civilizations knew how to forge copper going back to 5000BCE. But do we have any evidence showing that pre-columbian civilizations used iron in any fashion, be it even just for jewelry or tools? And I would ask (though I'm sure I know the answer is yes) is it likely that, were foreign arrival delayed for a significant period of time, would Native American civilizations have learned to forge iron weapons and armor?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

What were hitlers views about Germanic and Aryan races outside of Germany?

What was Hitler’s racist views toward anglosaxons, Danes, Norwegians, and Indian aryans?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Why did the last absolute monarchs resist constitutional monarchy?

Nicholas II rejected any ideas of constitutional monarchy in Russia until after the 1905 Revolution and the adoption of a constitution in 1906, but even then he did his best to maintain as much personal power as possible. Sultan Abdulhamid II revoked the Ottoman constitution and parliament established in 1876. Kaiser Wilhelm II, while nominally a constitutional monarch, still wielded considerable power over the German Empire and (at least to my understanding) he was blamed for being personally responsible for starting the war. Why did they all reject a constitutional system more like the British monarchy's, despite obvious growing support for one? Or is it more complicated than that? It seems to me that under a constitutional system, they'd still enjoy all the perks and priveleges of being royalty without having to deal with the messy business of playing politics and appeasing supporters in government.

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Before California created the US's first no-fault divorce law, someone wanting a divorce would have to have (or fabricate) a reason why their partner had violated marriage norms. Did divorce involve a lot of slander? Did people make up reasons to get divorced?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

What were the borders of the Incan empire like? Did their leaders practice diplomacy with smaller tribes or were those conquered until there was none around?

What I really want to know is that if there was any kind of "buffer culture" between the large, expansive Incan empire and the smaller Amazonian tribes (let's say, east of the Andes in modern day Peru and Ecuador).

1 Answers 2021-06-21

Were most vikings also famers? If so why were they so much better warriors than the saxons

As a fan of the viking age I have frequently read that when the viking invaded anglo saxon England, there raiding parties were composed of warriors that were trained and simply too much for the saxon militias to handle.

It is often emphasised that the saxon militias were composed of farmers who did not stand a chance against the vikings.

But this does not quite make sense to me, as werent these vikings themselves also a militia of sorts? ie were they not farmers for most of the year who only raided during the summer? If so why were they such better fighters and warriors to the saxons?

1 Answers 2021-06-21

647 / 7255

Back to start