Was the bill of rights only meant to apply to the federal government and not states?

Was the bill of rights really only meant to apply to federal government?

I’ve heard an argument stating that “the bill of rights was only designed to apply to the federal government!”. I could not find any info on this so I decided to ask historians.

1 Answers 2022-11-05

Is the "call and response" present in gospel and spirituals an exclusive feature of sub-Saharan African music? How much did traditional European music impact/influence American music then and now as a whole?

1 Answers 2022-11-05

It is ancient Persia and India. Can I find Ahriman worshippers?

Analogous to Satan worshippers.

1 Answers 2022-11-05

Why did people in Medieval Europe write Chronicles/Annals? Who was interested in reading them?

Mostly the title.

Why was there an interest in writing a chronicle at this time? Was the past analysed in a similar way to today or were there political/religious reasons?

1 Answers 2022-11-05

Why were mentally ill people stereotyped as believing themselves to be Napoleon?

Perhaps it's less common now, but one of the stereotypical depictions of the mentally ill person in cartoons, comics, sketches, caricatures etc. as late as the 90s was the guy with his right hand tucked into his shirt, wearing a bicorne, possibly made of a folded newspaper.

What is the history of this stereotype? Where did it originate and why did it gain traction?

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Was the Grand Duchy of Finland the only sub-national entity of the Russian Empire to have the semiautonomous rights and privileges that it enjoyed? Or were there other parts of the empire which also had such an arrangement under the tsardom?

Copy-pasted question from a post 7 months ago that received no answer.

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Alexander Hamilton had great success and helped build the United States, but by the end of the 1790s he told a friend that there is no place in this country for me. Why did he feel this way?

2 Answers 2022-11-04

How would a film critic writing in 1961 know what a film released in 1934 was like?

In his 1961 review of Disney's Babes in Toyland, John L. Scott writes:

This "Babes" represents an expensive translation of Victor Herbert's operetta with typical Disney effects It's considerably more showy than either Herberts stage original or the first film version done in the middle 30s; and older patrons may re sent a loss of quaintness ana a surplus of fantasy-whimsy.

How would Scott have seen the [1934 adaptation](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babes_in_Toyland_(1934_film))? How would critics of this era in general amass knowledge about the content of films from previous generations? Nowadays a critic has access to a huge proportion of twentieth century cinema through archive prints, DVD, streaming services, digital piracy, and even VHS.

Wikipedia mentions that Babes in Toyland was broadcast in the holiday period on local TV stations across America, but presumably most three decade-old films were not regularly screened on television. Would a film this old still be doing the rounds as part of repertory programming in theatres? Or would critics just build up their own personal memories of films over the decades and draw on those, with little opportunity to ever re-watch most of them?

2 Answers 2022-11-04

Were the french nearing a collapse in 1918? WW1

I'm trying to understand if the Germans, instead of forcing the British out of France, would have had more of a chance focusing on the French lines; I'm obviously then ignoring all the other aspects going poorly for the Germans.

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Why was Islam permitted in the Soviet Union when other religions were repressed?

Hi all,

Recently I've been reading about different schools of socialist thought for some research, and I came across some interesting information surrounding Islam in the Soviet Union. Russian Orthodox Christianity was actively suppressed but in the six majority Islamic ASSRs, Islam was permitted (if not outright encouraged) to be continued as a practise, with Muslims in the Soviet Union developing strains of thought such as National Communism and Islamic Socialism.

Why was Islam allowed to continue relatively unimpeded (until certain actions under Stalin) in comparison to the repression of other faiths such as Judaism and Orthodoxy? What was the reasoning of the Bolsheviks in permitting this whilst atheism was promoted elsewhere in the USSR?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Were there people of color in Medieval Europe?

Were there people of color in the Middle Ages of Europe? If so, what were the rough population numbers? Were they generally only found in certain areas, or were they widespread? What are the sources we have today, if any, that shed some light on this topic?

There is a common sentiment that Medieval Europe was almost entirely white. I find this hard to believe. There have been quite a few discussions recently online regarding diversity in certain fantasy media modeled after this time period. I often see this sentiment shared in defense of a lack of diversity. I would like to get a little more understanding of the topic to determine if this myth is actually a myth, or if there is any truth to the claim.

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Trustworthy books on Freemasons and Freemasonry? (i.e. without conspiracy theory)

What are some trustworthy books/references on the Freemasons and Freemasonry?

I am interested in the way they (likely have) influenced history, the symbolism, rituals and the grade system, but without the conspiracy nonsense.

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Best of October Voting Thread!

13 Answers 2022-11-04

How did armies of veterans make such a practical difference in ancient battles even when outnumbered?

Hannibal, Caesar, Alexander, there are a lot of examples where great generals won battles seamingly against the odds because they relied on armies of veterans.

What did veterans do during preparation and in battle that made them so valuable assets. Can the difference between a recruit and a veteran be quantified?

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Did Jewish people participate in the transatlantic slave trade, either in Europe or North/South America, at any point throughout the 16th-19th centuries?

There have been many claims flying around social media resulting from the tirades of certain public figures. I just want to be pointed in the right direction in terms of reading.

That being said, whatever the truth may be, historical events do not justify current prejudice.

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Is there an agreed-upon reasoning for why certain women were accused of witchcraft in Late Medieval Europe, and is there merit to the theory that these were just "wise women" and "folk healers"?

There has been a trend I've noticed in the past decade to correlate "witches" (as the concept is understood from medieval times) with women who were considered wise and knowledgeable of healing. This theory generally follows certain patterns, such as the proposition that the traditional "witch's broom" relates to how these women understood cleanliness was important to health and would therefore keep brooms for cleaning, or the proposition that these wise women would keep cats for hunting mice as they understood mice to spread diseases. Very often, the theory also follows the pattern of stating the reason for witch hunts was primarily based on fear from a male-dominated catholic church, which sought to exterminate these women as a threat.

The theory seems a little flimsy to me, and I wanted to know if it is recognized in serious academic circles. The notion that these women were the only ones with brooms seems a bit far-fetched to me, as does the idea that cats would be found more prominently around certain single women's houses rather than spread more generally. It also appears to leverage the trope that Medieval Europe was entirely absent of hygiene, which I believe is known to be false across almost the entire Medieval period in almost all the European continent. Also, my understanding of witch hunts is that they were largely perpetrated by common people as a sort of "excuse" or "catharsis" from particularly hard times, such as years of poor harvest; they did not necessarily have an organized aspect to them which would directly connect it to the catholic church (with the exception of the inquisition). What's more, there have been several other theories regarding the origin and reality of witchcraft and witches in the past century (such as that it was an offshoot of old paganism) and my understanding is that most of those theories have since been dismissed as speculation.

So the question is: Is there evidence to support the theory of witches being primarily a misunderstanding towards wise women of medicine? And if not, is there a more widely accepted theory of what would cause certain women to be targeted in witch hunts? I also understand that witch hunts occurred differently in certain locations and time periods, my question is mostly restricted to the traditional witch hunts of Late Medieval Europe. I also apologize for casting a wide blanket over the "Medieval period", but I believe for the purposes of this question the generalization should be admissible.

2 Answers 2022-11-04

How often did medieval jousts or tournaments take place?

I’m a big history nerd, as well as a huge fantasy nerd too, but after relistening to Blood and Fire by George RR Martin, as well as A Knight of The Seven Kingdoms (same author), I realized that tournaments seemed to be a fairly common thing for lords to do at least within the fantasy world. Is this an accurate reflection of the real world?

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Friday Free-for-All | November 04, 2022

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

5 Answers 2022-11-04

I'm interested in ancient and not-so-long-ago persian history,where should I start?

Schools social studies is no where near enough for me and I don't want to learn history cause I have to,I like it as a hobby,something like Philosophy,not exactly a hobby but ig

Iranian Historical series and movies always catch my attention, stuff I can never ignore or left unnoticed,let's add that I absolutely love farsi literature and poems

Where and how should I start my historian journey?

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Why did the nazis adopt the word “aryan” to describe themselves? And how did it come to mean “blonde white”?

The word Aryan is related to the region that now is Iran. Why did the nazis claimed it? Also, taking into account it refers to Persia/Iran, WHY was it changed to “blonde and/or white” instead of brown-ish or middle eastern?

I am not denying there are white Iranians, but how did the word get “whitewashed” during WWII?

2 Answers 2022-11-04

The best book on English history?

Hello fellow enthusiasts, I'm looking for a captivating look on English history, but there's simply too much to choose from. I would be interested for instance (but not exclusively) in the War of the Roses or the rule of Henry VIII, so I'd like to ask you for a recommendations of some gripping, hard-to-put-down narrative. Thank you very much!

2 Answers 2022-11-04

Why does France have so many well-preserved Medieval/Renaissance palaces despite them going through multiple periods of conflicts and internal strife like England, whose number of historical palaces are less than in France?

In England, a lot of the old Medieval/Renaissance palaces have either been desecrated during the Reformation or the English Civil War. There was a similar situation in France, with the French Wars of Religion, War of the Spanish Succession, and the French Wars of Coalition, so how did France still end up with so many well preserved palaces and castles. Also, what kind of preservation efforts are being done in France in regards to the upkeep of these historical big residences?

1 Answers 2022-11-04

Why are the historic'Russians' now divided into Russians, Ukrainians, Belarusians, etc?

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskEasternEurope/comments/yj4ns2/are_belarusians_and_ukrainians_a_kind_of_russian/

As you can see from this, in the past, Ukrainians and Belarussians were also considered Russian.

But now only the 'great Russians(grande russie)' are using the name Russia exclusively. What is the reason for this?

1 Answers 2022-11-04

What were the positive and negative consequences of Italy invading Ethiopia(1935-1936) from 1936-1939?

1 Answers 2022-11-04

I've been googling stuff out of boredom and I can't believe this to be true. Did we invent the Lighter 3 years before we invented Matches?

matches invented 1826, and lighter invented 1823.

Kinda seems like the joke form Hitchhiker's Guide about inventing aerosol deodorant before the wheel.

1 Answers 2022-11-04

65 / 7255

Back to start