Was the loss considered a big deal in European politics of the day, or was the American Revolutionary War considered more of a proxy war between other European powers, and the loss simply a minor event of a larger European political environment?
3 Answers 2014-07-01
The idea of wanting to destroy the Kaaba has a long and interesting precedent. Throughout history, Arabs who have traditionally hated Muhammad have expressed their desire of doing so, probably out of spite of what Muhammad represents.
Was a top comment in the news post, and I was curious as to it's veracity.
1 Answers 2014-07-01
I've been trying to research it and from what I have found it basically says that shia's want Muhammad's bloodline to rule and the sunni's want elected leaders. I can understand this disagreement - but how does it go from this to ISIS saying that they want to destroy the Kaaba? Shouldn't they all we worshipping the same things but just have a disagreement about who's in charge? Are they effectively two different religions now?
1 Answers 2014-07-01
I mean come on. Were they represented by the British? France was represented and they got knocked out six weeks after Germany attacked. SIX WEEKS. Canadians even participated in the Normandy invasions. What's up with that?
3 Answers 2014-07-01
1 Answers 2014-07-01
1 Answers 2014-07-01
I know that the Roman republic effectively wiped Carthage from history and that very little remains for us to study. So how is it that artists have drawn images like this?
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-y1p4fpX9F3Q/UPivyMrYIlI/AAAAAAAAN9Y/SiIiHdBtCN4/s1600/carthage.jpg
Is it all speculation or based on accounts? If so what accounts/sources should I read?
1 Answers 2014-07-01
The idea of prehistoric garments is typically highly utilitarian, and I usually see patchworks sewn together as the depiction of such. Clearly, fashion existed in Ancient Egypt, and from there on, it served as an important piece of culture. So at what stage was humanity prosperous enough to invest time in ornamentation en masse? Am I wrong in entirety, and did ornamentation arise long into prehistory?
EDIT: I have posted this question to /r/AskAnthropology as well. Link here
3 Answers 2014-07-01
I heard today that ISIS has vowed to "Destroy Mecca’s Kaaba, 'Kill Those Who Worship Stones.'" A friendly redditor suggested that:
"The idea of wanting to destroy the Kaaba has a long and interesting precedent. Throughout history, Arabs who have traditionally hated Muhammad have expressed their desire of doing so, probably out of spite of what Muhammad represents. Yazid bin Muawiya of the opposing clan of the Ummayads, who massacred Muhammad's family including Muhammad's grandson Hussein at Karbala, also attacked the Kaaba with catapults. Previously, Muhammad's grandfather Abdul Muttalib organized the defense of the Kaaba against another attacker named Abraha. In the current incarnation, ISIS represents Wahabi'ism, a cult that wishes to erase Muhammad's heritage and establish the supremacy of the rival, non-Hashemite clans descended from Ummaya and Abd Shams(translated as slave of the Sun). Wahabis have already destroyed many heritage buildings belonging to Muhammad and his family and friends in Saudi Arabia, under the same guise. So why the enmity stretching over centuries? At its core was the ideology of Muhammad. Muhammad belonged to the poor, the downtrodden, the disenfranchised. The opposing clans represented elitism, money, power and Arab imperialism. It was the selfless vs the selfish. They tried to persuade, bribe, cajole, armtwist him to their side. He refused. They massacred most of his family. The survivors refused to budge, citing egalitarianism and condemning the trappings of concentrated power and wealth. And so it continues to this day."
How accurate is this assessment? It seems biased, but I know very little about the subject.
3 Answers 2014-07-01
I've been reading about Yassa and I stumbled across this law
I know we have no primary sources for the Yassa code, and many Muslim writers didn't like the Mongols. Is this rule definitely BS or is it possible that Mongols really were executing people unless they brutally temple of doomed their livestock?
1 Answers 2014-07-01
I recently watched this movie. I'm wondering how much was fiction and fact. I know this film was made during the war so I'm thinking there might have been propaganda reasons to twist the facts a little.
1 Answers 2014-07-01
I'm familiar with the Pontic hypothesis, but don't know what evidence suggests an Anatolian origin. Is there significant linguistic and archeological evidence to support an origin in modern Turkey?
1 Answers 2014-07-01
I'm asking as my History education focused largely on isolated periods and locations with little focus on any other subjects. I only found out about the English Anarchy last week through chance!
How do I find out about the larger narrative so that I can use other sources to fill in the specifics?
2 Answers 2014-07-01
I was recently listening to a portion of a TED talk where the speaker claimed that due to a combination of coffee houses being a place where intellectuals gathered and shared ideas, and that they had coffee to drink rather than the ubiquitous alcohol of the day, they greatly accelerated the enlightenment. Is there any truth to this claim?
1 Answers 2014-07-01
It wasn't connected to the rest of their country by land and it wasn't even connected to a sea.
1 Answers 2014-07-01
Previous weeks' Tuesday Trivias and the complete upcoming schedule.
Today’s theme comes from /u/Bobicka!
Ahh, youth. It’s silly and doesn’t get much done. Let’s talk about age and wisdom today. Please share either general knowledge about how a society treated their oldest members, or specific people who did their best work when they were at an advanced age.
/u/Bobicka has a slightly more specific question if you can answer it - in movies of today, a society’s elders are often portrayed as in their 70s or older, but is this accurate? In various societies, what age was worthy of “elder?”
Next week on Tuesday Trivia: A Tuesday of contrasts: you can share either events when we know precisely when they happened, down to the hour and minute, or events when we have only a vague idea of when it happened, like a month or year.
2 Answers 2014-07-01
For example, I have recently read several books on WWI, and they all have called Romania 'Rumania.'
1 Answers 2014-07-01
I think we all grew up with the importance of the food pyramid, but previous to this, was there any precedence for the importance of variety in diet?
1 Answers 2014-07-01
In many works of fiction, particularly video games, Dwarves usually have a Scottish accent. Is there any reason for this? I'd have thought since a lot of fantasy worlds are inspired by Tolkien that the Dwarves would be equally inspired by Norse mythology and by the Jewish people, as are Tolkien's.
If there's a better place to ask this, could you please point me in that direction?
1 Answers 2014-07-01
If so, why aren't they as well known as the Pacific campaign? If not, why wasn't it as important?
2 Answers 2014-07-01
1 Answers 2014-07-01
I'm looking for information on how a murder trial would have proceeded in Scotland in the early 1600s. Beyond the Justice of the Peace/Magistrate, would there have been prosecutors or an equivalent? Would there be defence/prosecution arguments etc? In short, how would it have differed from trials as they're conducted these days?
Facts or directions to further reading would be majorly appreciated. Thanks!
1 Answers 2014-07-01
Happy Canada Day /r/AskHistorians! Or if you are in Quebec, maybe Bon Déménagement!. For those of you who are not Canadian, we extend our warmest greetings.
July 1 is Canada's national holiday when we celebrate the creation of the Dominion of Canada in 1867 (even though only Prince Edward Island actually joined on July 1). Like so many constructed traditions, the historical accuracy isn't as important so much as having a good time - after all July 1 has only been "Canada Day" since the relatively recent 1982! So today we are hosting a Canadian History AMA and first and foremost, let's have fun. I plan to at least.
Please ask us anything about Canadian history and we will try our best to answer. With us today are:
/u/AC_7
My main area of focus is Canada during World War Two and the governments of William Lyon Mackenzie King, but I do dabble in many post confederation (post 1867) topics. I'll be around for pretty much the entire day.
/u/CanadianHistorian
My name is Geoff Keelan and I am a University of Waterloo PhD student who focuses on First World War history, Quebec history, and political history. I co-write a blog, Clio's Current, which tries to provide historical perspective to contemporary issues. I will be here all day answering your questions.
/u/Respectfullyyours
I'm starting my PhD in Art History this fall and have been focusing on Canadian art throughout my BA and MA. I'm most comfortable answering questions about art in Canada during the late 1800s and early 1900s (particularly in Montreal and Toronto), but I can answer more general Canadian art questions as well. I also know a lot about Montreal social history in general (from the 1800s - 1950s) so I'd be happy to answer any questions related to that period. I'll be working likely till around 5pm EDT on Canada Day but I may be able to check in very briefly throughout the day.
/u/TheRGL
I have completed a Bachelor of Arts from Memorial University of Newfoundland, with a Major in History. I have focused specifically on Newfoundland history from the 1800's on. July 1st in Newfoundland was Memorial Day before we joined Canada and today the morning is considered Memorial Day with the afternoon being Canada day. The day is also my Father's birthday so I will be back and forth through the day. Any question regarding Newfoundland and Labrador I will answer as best I can
/u/WhiteRastaJ
Nova Scotian history for me, with a specialty in the Mi'kmaw people and their relationship with the government and the Acadia expulsion.
And for the mods, we are hoping /u/constantandtrue adds some much needed knowledge about Indigenous history, but was uncertain if they would have the time to answer any questions. If they pop up though, please consider them part of the AMA!
Ask away!
33 Answers 2014-07-01