How far could I travel back in America's history and get away with?

If I wanted to travel back in time in America, how far back in time could I go, if I wanted to still be able to understand their English?

2 Answers 2014-07-01

Why has the scientific development seen in Alexandria's Library suddenly stop?

I've heard the theory that says that it was because of the economy based on slavery (which made people think that working with your hands (ie experiments) was for slaves only so they didn't experiment anything) but was it just because of that? In Alexandria and during that time period there are records of big ideas that were proved in the 20th century and all that. So why did all that stop? Why did we enter the "dark ages" if we had such a history of at least looking and theorizing?

1 Answers 2014-07-01

Why has switzerland always be neutral and almost every nation has respected that?

Specially has surprised me this map of Europe during WWII, where switzerland was right ni the middle of germany, and yet still they were untouched, while all east Europe was overrun

2 Answers 2014-07-01

How far in advance were the USSR wary of a potential German invasion before Operation Barbarossa commenced?

1 Answers 2014-07-01

Were horns usually used to sound alarm in war camps, or is it just movies and books?

Was this an universal tool throughout medieval Europe, or were there many alternatives by country-to-country basis? Say, drums?

1 Answers 2014-07-01

Was the fall of Vietnam after the withdrawal of American troops similar collapse of N. Iraq to the ISIS?

1 Answers 2014-07-01

do historians, anthropologists and archeologists have any major disagreements about the past?

are there big conventions for all three professions? when you write a history thesis or dissertation, do you anxiously watch the news for new archeology finds that might invalidate your theories? When do theories graduate into generally accepted knowledge?

Edit: Thank you, this is fascinating stuff. Big thanks to mods for an awesome subreddit.

4 Answers 2014-07-01

How did the idea and practice of democracy develop in Athens? How did the other Greek states look upon this new form of government

Saw 300: rise of an empire today and would like to know the real history of Greek democracy

1 Answers 2014-07-01

How did the Reformation affect the Orthodox world? Was there any push for an Orthodox Reformation?

1 Answers 2014-07-01

At the Roman Empire's height under Trajan, how much of it was actually under the control of the government?

With that much territory, it seems like a lot of it would only be nominally controlled or maybe some kind of frontier area. Was there actual roman presence throughout the whole empire? And if so, how much?

1 Answers 2014-07-01

How did social democratic states become predominant among Nordic countries?

Why were labor and social democratic movements more successful in Sweden, Norway, Denmark, Iceland and Finland than elsewhere in Europe? Why has the "Nordic model" been limited to Nordic countries?

3 Answers 2014-07-01

When is the earliest record of the door as we know it (solid with hinges on the side)? What did people use before its invention?

2 Answers 2014-07-01

Was the Six Days War a preemptive strike or an act of aggression?

I always thought that Israel was invaded by the Arabs and we're forced to fight to repel the attack, but today I learned it was the other way around. I also read that the Israeli government admitted that it attacked first, for self defense.

This is new to me, but I'm sure it's not new to historians. However if Israel attacked preemptively I understand why they'd do it of it means survival. If they didn't then does this mean they were the aggressors and had an intention to take land from the Arabs?

I know this is a sensitive subject and I'm not pro or negative toward either side. In fact I'm just curious from a strictly historical perspective. Does one side have the upper hand over the other or is this not worth bothering to look into because it's too controversial and too many contradicting sources?

4 Answers 2014-07-01

What is the meaning and origin of the "blue blood" phrase used about nobles?

I've often wondered what this was about. I've had the idea that it's a form metaphor for how the blood never is shed from a noble, but instead keeps running in the veins, looking blue from the outside. Or maybe it's an actual misconception. What does the phrase come from? Was it used by nobles or about nobles? Why is "blue blood" a noble thing?

1 Answers 2014-07-01

What were the most important events that led to Hitler's rise to power in Germany?

1 Answers 2014-07-01

Why has England always been more powerful than Scotland.

Im referring to before the formation of the UK. Im talking about the ages of the Picts-Gaels-and Vikings to the last Anglo-Scottish war. Is it England just had more (and better) resources? Is it because Scotland was divided in cultures? Is it both?

3 Answers 2014-07-01

Roman Legion

In your opinion what made the Roman legion such a juggernaut post republic era

2 Answers 2014-07-01

What was the reason for the rules in Leviticus 19:19?

I mean other than the "God Says So" thing, what were the earthly reasons for rules like "Do not mate different kinds of animals. Do not plant your field with two kinds of seed. Do not wear clothing woven of two kinds of material."?

What exactly were examples of people doing that sort of thing in the era, and why did Moses/Jews think it was bad?

Also from Leviticus: "When you reap the harvest of your land, do not reap to the very edges of your field or gather the gleanings of your harvest."

1 Answers 2014-07-01

In Shakespeare's day, did audiences know who he was?

If the average person went to go see Hamlet, would they know who wrote it? I guess this applies to all medieval/renaissance theatre in general.

2 Answers 2014-07-01

Why did Polish Hussars wear wings?

Polish Hussars are well known for the famed "wings" on their armor. Why did they wear them? Did the wings serve a practical purpose? If not, did they bring any disadvantage to the rider?

2 Answers 2014-07-01

What if the USSR fought with the axis powers in WWII?

1 Answers 2014-07-01

How can a student best study history to understand the full scope of its different aspects?

I'm sorry my title isn't the clearest. I did my best, but will elaborate here.

When we study history, it is often a collection of isolated matters - this battle, that agricultural advancement, here an explorer, then a shipwreck, etc. What ways are there to really pull it together and develop a deep understanding of all the different aspects and how they interplay? Something like this is great for giving some relation to areas we don't tend to learn in context of each other, but how can a student create this sort of reference when learning?

I'm interested in the broader spread, and I think this applies at many different levels, but my particular area of interest is the Canadian Rockies.
When I study historical events in the Canadian Rockies, I find three different ways of connecting individual bits:

  • I can study by place - who saw the Highwood Pass when, then who came after, then what event next occurred there, etc.
  • I can study by time - what happened across the region in the 1840s, where was each figure in 1910, etc.
  • I can study by persons - What trips did David Thompson take, when were they, what did he visit on each trip, and what did he do after, etc. This could also be topical outside of a person, in the vein of a company's expeditions, or where silver mining happened over the years. I think they're still within this general concept.

I have stored in my memory several unrelated individual stories.
Where I am struggling is how to connect them all. How can I put together these various angles with different people in different places at different times, doing different things, and develop a comprehensive big-picture view?

I'm sure this is a common problem for studying anything not completely specific, and I'm hoping you brilliant Historians will have some ideas to help me understand how I can go from remembering unrelated events, to understanding history in its full scope, within my area of study, or more broadly.


I believe this falls under the "Questions may also be about historical method or the “world of history” more generally", and I did not find a similar question when searching. If I am incorrect and it should have gone elsewhere, or I missed the question already answered, I would appreciate being redirected.

1 Answers 2014-07-01

During the Wars of the Roses did soldiers paint or customise their helmets?

On a painting of the battle of Tewkesbury there is a soldier with what looks like stars on it. Could soldiers actually do this or is this just the artists interpretation of the battle?

http://imgur.com/bLy3oZM

2 Answers 2014-07-01

When did the traditional squared boxing stand with palms up change to the modern turned stance that boxers utilize today?

As the title asks.

edit: I wasn't sure how to tag the title.

1 Answers 2014-07-01

What prevalence and style was leather armor the western old world?

It seems like there's a lot of conflicting information, some from video games or other wholly unreliable sources, and not much with a lot of background. All I know is that it was used in things like lamellar, holding to wood/metal lamellae, and was used as the structure for brigandine. And I've heard some ideas that it was probably used as boiled plates or coats on its own, but nothing definite. That's what I'd most like to know about.

1 Answers 2014-07-01

6571 / 7255

Back to start