How significant were Gluck's 1760 "reform" operas and why did he dislike opera seria?

(paging /u/cafarelli)

1 Answers 2014-06-26

Which Supreme Court Justice has had the most dissents? Are there any justices who have been particularly well-known for frequently disagreeing with the majority?

Specifically asking about SCOTUS, but would be interested if there are judges in other countries who fit this description.

5 Answers 2014-06-26

How did Nazi officers know they were going to be in trouble after the war?

I've read about several instances where Nazi officers knew that if they lost the war, they would be tried and executed for what they did. Sometimes trying to cover up their crimes or help someone out to get an alibi.

So how did they know they would be in trouble? Was there a precedent that had been set before the war that they would be tried and punished for what they did?

3 Answers 2014-06-26

Have there ever been any republics that voted for the same 'president'?

Note: I'm not asking about monarchical personal unions. I seem to recall this happening a bit in Italy, but can't recall any specifics.

1 Answers 2014-06-26

Can anyone tell me about these numbers on the side of a WW1 German Mauser? (X-post from r/Guns)

I'm cross posting this question because I can't determine which sub is the best sub. The sub r/guns didn't seem to have a lot in the way of historic content. I'm trying to trace the history of this gun and hopefully learn a little bit about it. Sorry if this is too specific a question for this sub.

Here are the pictures.

I'm interested in learning anything worth knowing about this gun but I'm mainly curious about the numbers and initials on the side. I'm guessing it might be the serial and initials of the original owner. My googling didn't any sites that would allow me to search and find who it originally belonged to though.

Here's its history as far as we know: Basically it was brought back from WW1 by my great-uncle. Its been in our family for awhile. He fought in WW1 in France. He most likely got in there and brought it back with him to the US.

My mom is big into genealogy, so I'm sure she'd appreciate finding out a little bit about where it came from and who owned it before it came into our family.

Edit: To add, the initials are not my great Uncles.

2 Answers 2014-06-26

What was life like for Tezcatlipoca's ixiptla during the year leading up to his sacrifice?

Where did he live? What did he wear? What privileges did he enjoy? What obligations was he expected to perform? Was he guarded or otherwise prevented from escaping (was that even a concern)?

1 Answers 2014-06-26

Roman persecution of Christians. How bad was it?

Just as the title says, was the persecution of Christians in the Roman Empire really as bad as it's made out to be, or has it been romanticized a bit? Were they actually hunted down and fed to lions in the Coliseum and things like that? Trying to solve a debate with someone, and I realize I don't really know the answer to this.

3 Answers 2014-06-26

What unified the Austrian-Hungary Empire - Religion, Culture, etc.?

It certainly wasn't linguistics, and I'm suspecting that it was religion. The Austrians and Hungarians were Catholic, and so were the Croats who were part of the Empire. Bits of Italy and other Catholic nations were as well.

2 Answers 2014-06-26

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in June 26th, 2014:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2014-06-26

Has specialized production of war materials for a country ever been its downfall or key to power

Essentially, is a nation better off specializing in war material production and trading for with allies for its deficit materials? Are there any historical examples showing failures and successes?

1 Answers 2014-06-26

In Montreal, there is a major boulevard and metro station named after Pope Pius IX, supposedly because many Quebecois Catholics joined the Papal army under his reign. How true is this claim? If so, how many Quebecers actually joined?

1 Answers 2014-06-26

How peaceful was sub-Saharan Africa prior to the re-drawing of borders by Europeans?

Has there always been strong inter-ethnic/tribal violence of the level seen for the last century or so?

2 Answers 2014-06-26

What is the importance of the Coptic church? And why did it maintain such a strong presence in Egypt?

1 Answers 2014-06-26

How did lost works from the ancient world generally become lost and is there -any- hope of any being recovered?

Hello!

I am an undergrad History student currently on leave and I have some familiarity with the ancient world however I am a terrible ignoramus when it comes to manuscript transmission. One thing that fascinates me is the assortment of 'lost works' from the ancient and medieval periods which we know of via references or fragments but which are not preserved extant or in any significant form. All the lost works of Suetonius and Porphyry are eye-watering to consider in terms of source material if they could be re-discovered or reconstructed. I'd like to find out about how these works became 'lost' and what the odds are of recovering any of them? Any authors or periods will do for examples - I know getting hold of classical Greek texts is highly unlikely but are there chances of some later works being found buried out in the wilderness like Nag Hammadi or the Dead Sea Scrolls?

To what extent is the medieval Church to be held responsible for the present situation? It's often claimed that Christianity kept civilisation alive during the Dark Ages and that manuscript transmission by monks preserved ancient learning. However, I'm aware of the preservation of much Greek wisdom by Arabic and Persian libraries and I've read accusations of deliberate destruction or neglect of manuscripts containing heretical teachings, 'pagan learning' deemed unworthy of preservation or anything that put the Church in a bad light. And of course Eusebius forever ruining our understanding of Josephus, among other things. Did the Church destroy many ancient texts deliberately? How much was lost as a result of the prioritization of Scripture transmission and the discarding of pagan texts?

Thank you for any help!

1 Answers 2014-06-26

Why is it that Newspaper Articles are accepted as credible sources when they are often opinionated or biased?

I understand that an essay would not only accept newspaper articles as sources.

6 Answers 2014-06-26

Were there any other episodes of witchcraft hysteria in America or Canada to rival that of Salem, in 1692-93?

3 Answers 2014-06-26

Were the ancestors of today's Arabs Jewish before the spread of Islam?

Sorry if there is an obvious misunderstanding in the title but I was just curious as to the religious make-up of the Middle East before Islam. For example: What would the people of e.g. modern-day Yemen have been in the years before Islam? Jewish? Pagan?

2 Answers 2014-06-26

How did Lithuania hold out against christianization for so long?

Edit: Very informative, thankyou for your detailed responses.

5 Answers 2014-06-26

Did the Greek philosophers e.g Socrates and Aristotle believe in the typical Greek Gods?

I'm just beginning to look into the Ancient Greek civilization and the like in preparation for the start of my BA in Ancient and Medieval History which I should (hopefully) be starting in September. I was watching Andrew Marr's History of the World documentary for the BBC to ease myself in a little and from it I have the understanding that part of the reason for the persecution of Socrates was due to him not honouring the Gods? Could anyone go into a little more detail such as what he did that led to this conviction and also how typical was this of other famous Greek philosophers? Did they disbelieve completely and actively try to convince/convert people to their way of thinking or was it more of a passive disbelief?

I may be thinking of 2 completely different time periods here or have gotten things muddled but now that the idea of atheist people living in Ancient Greece has entered my head it has made me quite curious. So thanks for any answers.

4 Answers 2014-06-26

Were their any royal families that failed to produce an heir or were wiped out?

And what happened to their land holdings? Are there any castles or palaces left abandoned without the family to maintain them?

Just wondering if there are any lost kingdoms out there.

3 Answers 2014-06-26

During the Unification of Germany how much of an issue was the religous split between Catholics and Protestants and did Bismarck make any provisions to try and deal with it?

1 Answers 2014-06-26

When did the devil become red?

So in Croatian traditional literature and fairy tales devil is always black. But in all the modern western cartoons devil is red. Why is this so? Do other European tend to portray it in red?

2 Answers 2014-06-26

Why were muskets adopted over bows?

Wouldn't a hail of arrows be better than a horizontal firing of the muskets? Wouldn't the better accuracy and MUCH faster nocking speed of the bow be better than the less accurate long-reload time of a musket? Even crossbows would be better than muskets wouldn't they?

2 Answers 2014-06-26

Is there any way I can listen to radio broadcasts that were broadcasted just after WW2 ended? If possible the first one that states the war has ended.

I'm from England so it would be cool to hear an English broadcast but an American or German one would be just as cool!

2 Answers 2014-06-26

How did the U.S. expedition team communicate with the Japanese people?

I am talking in context of when Japan closed their borders and U.S. ships came and forced Japan to open their borders again.

My assumptions are that no one in the U.S. expedition knew Japanese and the Japanese knew little to no English before this event.

1 Answers 2014-06-26

6586 / 7255

Back to start